Score

Cardboard, Nimona, Hyperbole And A Half and several others were published long before 2018.

Zombieslayer/Alienhunter {good freaking grief} wrote: "Cardboard, Nimona, Hyperbole And A Half and several others were published long before 2018."

I removed the most obvious offenders. If anything else needs removing, call it out.

Thank you, Mitchell.

yes, should be removed

My Favorite Thing is Monsters Volume 2 has 4 votes and is not out yet and is not being serialized. Wishful thinking?

Amulet book 8 could be added

DONALD wrote: "Yes, instant remove Alex Letner books from a numerous lists is undoubted sample of dirty competition."

This is a list for graphic novels published in 2018. If there are Alex Letner graphic novels published in 2018 that you put on this list, really they should not be removed.

That said, I checked the Librarian log and saw that PARADOX: Super Indy had been removed. This book was published in 2016 so it should not have been on this list.

Forrest wrote: "DONALD wrote: "Mitchell wrote: "DONALD wrote: "Yes, instant remove Alex Letner books from a numerous lists is undoubted sample of dirty competition."

This is a list for graphic novels published in..."

There were a number of books removed according to the librarians log. That said, if Liberators: Super Indy was removed, I'm thinking that was done in error. Something volunteer librarians do make especially when dealing with user error. There is nothing in this list's criteria that says a 56 rating graphic novel published March 30th, 2018 should have been removed. I'd say feel free to put it back. But if you also put back other Alex Letner books that do not meet the graphic novel published in 2018 criteria, then a librarian will probably remove it again - and may make the same error and remove Letner books from 2018 as well.

On Jan 9, 2018 a volunteer librarian removed 8 Alex Letner books. They were for low rating books from 2016 - and generally this is what list spam looks like. And they were removed as they should have been.

1 - THE GREAT ACTION - 87 ratings, pub 2015
2 - The Techno Witch - 51 ratings, pub 2016
3 - FIRST HALF: Super Indy - 71 ratings, pub 2016
4 - THE GREAT ACTION - 87 ratings, pub 2015
5 - THE YOGA WITH NO PANTS: Super Indy-The Last Half - 50 ratings, pub 2016
6 - Yoga Time - 50 ratings, 2016
7 - The Fairway - 51 ratings, 2016
8 - PARADOX: Super Indy - 51 ratings 2016

In addition there was a 9th book that was also deleted.
9 - Liberators: Super Indy - 56 ratings 2018

so the user, presumably you and your friends, made 8 "mistakes". And the librarian made 1. Feel free to add that book back.

DONALD wrote: "Mitchell wrote: "On Jan 9, 2018 a volunteer librarian removed 8 Alex Letner books. They were for low rating books from 2016 - and generally this is what list spam looks like. And they were removed ..."

Are you calling me a liar? Because what I've done is read the librarian log and tell you what was in it.