(Note: if the author is not Japanese, the book is not Japanese. Edit: This has generally been interpreted to exclude also authors of Japanese descent who have grown up elsewhere, so please vote for them on other lists instead.)
2182 likes · Like
Lists are re-scored approximately every 5 minutes.
Mitu
89 books
3 friends
3 friends
Jessica
10479 books
1461 friends
1461 friends
Holly
527 books
109 friends
109 friends
Greyweather
2660 books
65 friends
65 friends
Joel
96 books
2 friends
2 friends
Zoe
568 books
53 friends
53 friends
Jenn
3857 books
45 friends
45 friends
Karen
2141 books
82 friends
82 friends
More voters…
Comments Showing 1-50 of 103 (103 new)
message 1:
by
Mofo
(new)
Nov 20, 2008 08:30AM
Why isn't Battle Royale on this list?
reply
|
flag
Russell wrote: "kazuo ishiguro writes in english."Correct, but The Unconsoled is on this list, and it is written by Ishiguro. :)
Kazuo Ishiguro not only writes in English, he IS English. 'The Unconsoled' shouldn't be on this list. It's not even set in Japan.
Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro deleted. (not a Japanese book)see Paul's comments above.
*Also have deleted Memoirs of a Geisha and another Kazuo Ishiguro book "Nocturnals etc.."
Same reason - Not Japanese. Geisha might be about Japan but it wasn't first written in Japanese or by a Japanese person.
Actually Ishiguro was born in Japan so I think that makes him Japanese regardless of which language he writes in.
(RESURRECTS THREAD)Yas, you are entirely correct that he was born in Japan, and I believe he still holds Japanese citizenship. But he moved from Nagasaki when he was 5, and he has talked extensively in interviews about his irritation at lazy lit-critics trying to peg his style as Japanese. When he does write about Japan, such as in his first two novels, it is always in a very self-consciously imaginary fashion. So even though you may lay some fair claim to his Japanese ethnicity, the books themselves don't really belong on this list in my humble opinion.
I agree Paul and while Ishiguro has Japanese heritage his books are written in English which don't make them "Japanese" books even if they are about Japan. (still haven't read any of them yet)
Hmmm Geisha, a life by Mineko Iwasaki isn't here either.
Ishiguro was born in Japan but move to england while he was 6 or 7 and he already have British citizenship. I think his works should not on be the lists
He became a British citizen when he was 22 years old. Since he is both British and Japanese, he should be included.
Kirei wrote: "He became a British citizen when he was 22 years old. Since he is both British and Japanese, he should be included."How can his books be included when he was English bred, identifies more with Britain and his books are not concerned about Japan?
Deleted "Never Let Me Go," "I Was Told There'd Be Cake," and "Catcher in the Rye." In each case, the author is not Japanese, the book was written in English, and the subject matter is not related to Japan. Nothing about these books are Japanese, so they are inappropriate to this list.
Incredible list! I have read several of these and saved even more to my "to read" list! I added several more that I thought might belong on this list including:So Sad to Fall in Battle
Something Like an Autobiography
20th Century Boys
Battle Angel Alita
Japan Atlas
Robot Ghosts and Wired Dreams
Mishima's Sword
The Rising Sun
A Modern History of Japan
A Hundred Years of Japanese Film
Dreaming Pachinko
The last five on the list are on Japan but not by Japanese authors so not sure which of those would fit best on this list (please delete if you feel necessary, it will not offend me). I own all those books and they are all really good. Great list!
Mofo wrote: "Why isn't Battle Royale on this list? "Because it is a list of "the best" Japanese books. Battle Royale is a classic and a great alternative to Hunger Games and Lord of the Flies. I was going to write how it should not be considered "the best" but as I am writing my thoughts I have started to see your point. I wouldn't put it on this list for its amateur craftsmanship and pulpy violence. But I wouldn't object if you put Battle Royale on the list.
Battle Royale is on the list, it's in 4th place and I would hardly call it an alternative to Hunger Games. Hunger Games pretty much ripped off Battle Royale, made it more YA and gave it a female lead to get more readers and it worked.
Thank you for the wonderful list! I would like you to include these next time: "Lonely Hearts Killer" by Tomoyuki Hoshino; "The Apprenticeship of Big Toe P" by Rieko Matsuura; "The Doctor's Wife" by Sawako Ariyoshi
Masanaka,Click "add books to this list" at the top of the page and then type in those three books. The list is made by everyone.
Hi Michael, thank you for letting me know how this space grow. I have just added the books above and more. Cheers.
Didn't see The Tattoo Murder Case on the list. Excellent locked-room mystery set in post-WWII Tokyo.
Livy wrote: "just out of curiosity, what is Catcher in the Rye doing on this list?"I wonder about it, too. And so many votes... What does that mean?
Matīss wrote: "Livy wrote: "just out of curiosity, what is Catcher in the Rye doing on this list?"I wonder about it, too. And so many votes... What does that mean?"
I wonder what that means too. I deleted it... again.
It is interesting that "Across The Nightingale Floor" is on the list. Although the "Tales of the Otori" books are set in a place fairly closely resembling feudal Japan, they are actually set in a fictional island nation, not any real place in Japan.
Mark wrote: "It is interesting that "Across The Nightingale Floor" is on the list. Although the "Tales of the Otori" books are set in a place fairly closely resembling feudal Japan, they are actually set in a f..."Where the books take place is irrelevant. The author is not Japanese though, so I'll remove the book.
Yep, just clarifying how the list works! Someone managed to remove the book before I got to it. Yay!
This seems a great list, and just what im looking for. Il be honest, ive only really read Haruki Murakami, but want to delve further into Japanese literature. Do any of you guys have any recommendations for the next books to read?
Not sure if I saw Revenge by Yoko Ogawa. Absolutely love that quiet little book of short stories that roll up on you in the most hauntingly beautiful way!
The Thousand Autumns of Jacob de Zoet (no. 104) is not a Japanese book. The story may be set in Japan (for the most part, anyway) but the author, David Mitchell, is British (Merseyside) and lives in Europe. Therefore, the book has been deleted.
Booklovinglady wrote: "The Thousand Autumns of Jacob de Zoet (no. 104) is not a Japanese book. The story may be set in Japan (for the most part, anyway) but the author, David Mitchell, is British (Merseyside) and lives i..."Agreed. Good book though.
Evan wrote: "Not sure if I saw Revenge by Yoko Ogawa. Absolutely love that quiet little book of short stories that roll up on you in the most hauntingly beautiful way!"I particularly liked the story about the girl who was in love with her diver stepbrother (the main story, unsurprisingly). And the Professor and Housekeeper novel she wrote was a gem too.
Didn't like Hotel Iris though.



















