Score

Once you vote...don't forget to slide down to the Friends Vote portion (on the right of the list) and invite your friends to vote too. It's super easy and it will help grow the list for everyone.

Mastering Toby and Geo's Dream I am nearly positive don't have cowboys in them! Physical Therpy, Sweet Toppings and Eye of the Beholder while set in Cattle Valley the MC in these books are not cowboys!

Perpetua wrote: "Mastering Toby and Geo's Dream I am nearly positive don't have cowboys in them! Physical Therpy, Sweet Toppings and Eye of the Beholder while set in Cattle Valley the MC in these books are not cow..."

I just noticed that someone added Mastering Toby. I will delete them since they obviously don't belong in this list.

It confuses me that Demon Moon is on the list - it's het isn't it? Is it maybe included because later ones in the series are m/m? Not that it matters, just wondering.

I was going to say the same thing as Karen, I was just making my ist for the May challenge, Demon Moon is m/f isn't it?

Hot Head shouldn't be on this list, though. :P

I've read Hot Head a while ago, but I remember it's about firefighters/amateur pornstars, not cowboys?

Exactly. No cowboys. :)

I've removed Hot Heads from the list. As fabulous as it is, it did not belong this THIS list.

I'd also like to point out that the book in the number one spot looks to have been artificially advanced to the top of the list through sock puppet accounts. The same thing has happened on other lists as well. It's very blatant and I just hope it's a misguided fan and not the author herself who has created all of these fake accounts to advance the book to the top of the M/M lists.

Moderatrix Lori wrote: "I've removed Hot Heads from the list. As fabulous as it is, it did not belong this THIS list.

I'd also like to point out that the book in the number one spot looks to have been artificially advan..."

Same thing for the best gay historical listopia :(

http://www.goodreads.com/list/show/25...

never even heard of this book

Sock puppets.

ETA: check the names who voted. Same pattern all the way through 0 friends, 1 or tweo books in their bio. All private. All created within a 2 day period or somehting.

Someone had a LOT of time to run that bullshit.

Just e-mailed support with a small list of accounts

They all live in GA, all joined in January 2012, all voted for this book and/or another book by the same author.

This defies the purpose of listopia, but we shouldn't be surprised. I was thinking of retaliating with the Worst Cover Listopia...

Damon wrote: "Someone had a LOT of time to run that bullshit."

And not to mention finding all those cool profile pictures!

:D LOL

Not to mention that some of the profile pics are DUPLICATES. LOLOL

Who the heck has that much time on their hands? Seriously!

Ah, this book. I was a bit suspicious of it to begin with. It's listed as THE top reader reviewed m/m book at ARE, but when I read the excerpt a few months ago, I didn't quite understand why.

I went to the page. It's like Ride of the Sockvalkyries over there.

I deleted the interloper book from the list. Anyone with a legitimate account that wants to vote for it again may do so.

Have to agree with 2 other posts from last year. Why is "Demon Moon" on this list for "Best Gay Cowboys" when the story is M/F, not M/M?

When I posted my comment last year I hadn't read the book, so I wasn't sure I was correct but since then I have and can safely say there is no m/m in this book, so I removed it from the list.