Debate discussion
Fun Debates!
>
Twilight (good reviews) vs. Twilight (harsh critisism)
message 101:
by
Kenny
(new)
Nov 17, 2008 07:46PM
I already have. It IS way good.
reply
|
flag
oh so it's brigid's storyokay, for a second i thought it was a published book
maybe ill check it
yeah eventuallyi won't promise because that wouldn't be good
i her books are ok i think thats the only thing that me and kenny agree on
I don't think that Twilight is the best book in the universe, but I think it's really good. And I like the fact that Meyer put in her own twist of vampires. I mean, how boring would it be if she just stuck to the original legend 100%? When she makes it up herself, she's being creative. There's nothing wrong with being creative. It's how you write.And yeah, Bella might be annoying sometimes, but just because the main character has flaws doesn't mean that the book is terrible. Actually, a character with flaws are what make books BETTER.
And I agree, the ending of Breaking Dawn was pretty abrupt...plus I sorta wished that the fight with the Volturri happened, she kinda cheated us out of that. But other than that, it was still really good.
I thought that Twilight was pretty bad. It had a sort of predictable plot, and the charecters were loathe worthy, but The Host was very well written and actually a compelling read.
hlakhjeklahhhkel.ahlwuiglskdkafkqyefqwuehjffkDGHASjFgqwh
i agree sellabut it would've been nice if SOME of Bella's flaws would've been fixed by the end
she literally learned nothing in the whole saga
oh and on the fight, i wish it happened. No offense, but the Edward vs. Victoria scene wasn't good.
It was just Edward moving step and step away while victoria lunged at him.
BORING
I know!"and Edward stepped to the left, Victoria lunged but missed Edward killed her and was completely fine, not a scratch on his purrrfect little head!"
yeah i was disappointedi think that stephenie just didn't try hard enough
really?i own it in paperback but haven't read it yet
I didnt even Buy it. I just read it at Barnes and Nobles
Chandani: Some wood say that just the characters/book making u feel any kind of "intense emotion" makes it good... I'm gonna read the Host :P
Yeah it was good. I dont really think that my intense hatred for the twilight characters would qualify as "good"
No, just that the book made u feel sumthing was good. Means they really got their character/story through..
you could read all that at a bookstore?what, did you sleepover?
Lol , no i read 500 pages in one day, then went back and read the last 3 hundred pages. It sucked. I swear i almost attacked the clerk i was so pissed
wait reading it sucked or the book itselfomg, ur killing me here...
Just the way it was written. It wasent as good as the others and the others werent that good themselves ya kno?
Twilight used to be my favorite book, but then I read The Host and realized how much better The Host was- and how worse Twilight compared to it.THE HOST IS AMAZING!!!!!!!!!! XD
i think after writing all of the Twilight ones she became a better writer ya know?
I just saw the twilight movie last night...
im going to see it on mondaybut it's probably going to suck
I'm either going to see it today or next Saturday.
i dont want to read it being a boy and all, but i just dont understand how emotional girls get over this book. Im in high school and when girls start talking about this some literaly start crying i mean its just stupid. I think some people forget that its JUST A BOOK.
(and now movie)
It's good, but seriously..to cry over it?? That's a bit extreme. You're only allowed to cry over The Host. Not Twilight. XD lol...I cried at the end of The Host, when I thought that Wanda __________. (don't wanna spoil anything for anyone who hasn't read it!!)
Girls cried over it???????? New Moon was sad but not like "omg-tear-jerker" the only book that made me cry was The Book Thief and thatz cuz like alot of people died..
Wow, I've never cried over a book. And New Moon was sooo stupid.
I cry over lots of books but I don't think Twilight was one of them. No, definitely not. I cried when I read Day of Tears though, how ironic right?
*sigh* I actually cried in New Moon. yes i was obsessed with Twilight at one point in my life and i cried when Edward left despite how much i hate him now. I also cried when bella got into an argument with Jacob.but im over that phase
ive never cried over a bookalmost with 'A Walk To Remember'
and I've cried with some Japanese tear-jerkers my mom loved (movies though)
but that's about it
OMIGOD WHO SAW THE TWILIGHT MOVIE???!!! :D I SAW IT LAST NIGHT AND IT WAS THE MOST AMAZING/HORRIBLE MOVIE EVER IF THAT MAKES ANY SENSE!!! HEEHEEEHEE I LOVED IT! XD
I haven't yet...I cried during ET...
And when Dumbledore _____________
and when Hedwig _____________
and when Fred ____________
and when Tonks and Lupin ________________
I cried a lot in the last Harry Potter.
I cried in the second to last one too.
I feel like crying whenever I see Chris Farley in Gap Girls. OMG what a waste...why did he have to start doing drugs?!
it's funny though since im a big crier...
I cried in a book where her dog ran away. And i want just crying, i was sobbing i had snot, and everything it was ridiculous.
Yep, HP 7 made me really sad too..
I just thought, Come on JK Rowling! I'm fine if you _________ Harry, but not Fred!
Books mentioned in this topic
Nightlight: A Parody (other topics)Control Freak (other topics)
New Moon (other topics)
Breaking Dawn (other topics)
The Book Thief (other topics)
