Debate discussion
Fun Debates!
>
Twilight (good reviews) vs. Twilight (harsh critisism)
Proof to what?That SM writes like a kid who got left back in 3rd grade or something else that i said?
I honestly would have more willingly read frigin Junie B Jones, than Breaking Dawn.
There are PLENTY of wayyyy better, and less nauseating vampire books besides Twilight.
that your sister could write betterbut really, twilight (im pretty sure) was the mother of what i like to call 'The Literary Vampire Movement'
so we have to give it credit
Honestly, I've tried a lot of other vampire series, and I didn't think any of them were as good as Twilight.Oh, except I like the Peeps books by Scott Westerfeld. But those are really different, so I wouldn't really compare the two.
And I agree; the whole vampire craze is all owed to Twilight. Totally.
Soo yeah. Twilight is not the best book in the entire world. But it is totally not even close to being the WORST. It's really not that bad! People are so harsh about it.
And how come so many Twilight haters are so rude? Not ALL of them of course; there are some perfectly decent twilight haters out there. But for some reason, most of the Twilight haters I've encountered couldn't just say: "I don't like Twilight. That's my opinion. Moving on." It's always: "I HATE TWILIGHT AND EVERYONE WHO LIKES TWILIGHT IS A CONFORMING IDIOT!!!" And then they all try to change my mind ... and I'm like, "Uhhh. No. Can't we all just have our own opinions and leave it at that for crying out loud?"
Hey, i never called ANYONE on here an Idiot. I was insulting SM before but i dont really understand how that would offend you...
well either waysm did start the movement of vampire series
her life was not in vain even if her writing style wasn't the best
but im not a picky reader so i don't notice grammar problems
only plot problems :)
Im still not sure if she started the wave, or if other tird grade-esque writers paved the way of stupidity for her.
TWILIGHT! AWESOME!! New Moon, in the middle it's boring. But im beginning eclipse, and its good so far.
well after twilight was when all the vampire books started to come outso id say twilight started it
No i read a BUNCH of vampire books before twilight. And they were all better. Eclipse sucked. Bella is such an annoying and whiny melodramatic...urgh. But it was 10000 times beter than BD.
Im reading Eclipse..dont spoil it for me...
Im not, just keep ur expectations loww...like really lowwww
okwhen they all started to get popular
w/ the general audience i mean
Well i dunno. There are a lot of peple who hate Twilight.
Ok. I dunno , i just really dont like the series. its just not good. maybe some people think that ist fun bu tits not good.just my opinion
ya, well my opinion is that the more creative ppl like Twilight, especially ppls who like to write...or are obsessed wit Vampires...
Hey im plenty creative, i love to write and read and im about to take an english course at NYU. I dont like twilight at all.HAHA I DISSPROVED YOUR THEROY!
No. i know tonz of people who are very very creative artists and such, who hate twilight.
Chandani, I think you'd like Midnight Sun better. Its in Edward's head, not Bella's. And OMG you go to NYU?? How old are you?? and my friend's sister goes to either NYU or the arts school over there, I'm not sure...
Its a college course at Piolytechnic NYU, its for kids in 7th grade-12th grade. I get to sit in on an English course and get 4 college credits!!im 12!
oh, thatz awesome!!! I wish UF would do that XD
You can!! Do u live in NYC? its this thing called teh YES program. U just take a test, pay 200 dollars (vs 4000 dollars) and you get college credits!
Nope, I live near the University of Florida.
Yeah, the coasts are. but in Northern Florida its not that great..but its better than like say..Greenland or Iceland.
???? I go lost when you said School.
ITS A BLONDE JOKE!! I'M BLONDE!!!!!
lol"Blonde jokes are short so men can remember them"
this restaurant has placards with funny quotes on them and that was one of them"Cat and Husband missing. Reward for Cat."
"I'm not sure if Life is passing me by, or running me over."
I LOVE TWILIGHT SOOOOOOOOO MUCH!!!!!!!!!!!
I actually like it too! The movie doesn't look like it will be too good (cuz it's so different from what people imagined), but I am still taking my GF to it.I don't know about Breaking Dawn. I actually kinda liked the ending, but I think there should have been more sadness, and perhaps an actual fight btw. *someone* and *someone else thats kinda furry*, where no one got hurt.
I dunno i hated BD so frigin much, its crazy. The rest were bad but not as bad.
Wow Kenny we just disagreed on something...
that suxbut kenny's right
a little sadness never ruined a story as long as the character actually learned from it (no one learned anything in that series i might add)
Yeah, it could have had a WAY WAY better ending. I dunno i just really hate that series.
the ending of breaking dawn was kinda abrupt. i expected there to be something bigger.but it was still good i think.
I just didnt really like the book in general.BRIGID OMG I JUST READ INJECTION AND ITS AMAZZAZING!!!!!
ITS SOOO GOOD!!!!
ITS AMMAZZZIZIING!!!!OMG I CANT WAIT FOR THE 18TH CHAPTER!! GAHHJ ITS SOOO FRIKIN GOOD I CANT GET OVER IT!! YOU HAVE TO GET IT PUBLISHED BRIGID!!!!
AM I ALLOWED TO TELL MY FRIENDS ABOUT HOW GOOD IT IS??
ITS SOO GOOD! EVERYONE GO READ IT NOWW!!!
Books mentioned in this topic
Nightlight: A Parody (other topics)Control Freak (other topics)
New Moon (other topics)
Breaking Dawn (other topics)
The Book Thief (other topics)
getting too harsh isn't fair either
yeah the book wasn't the best
but i don't think it was a pile of dog shit either
(not to mention im pretty sure twilight was the mother of the vampire craze for YA)