The House of Hades
discussion
NICO… YOU KNOW WHAT I'M TALKING ABOUT O.o

I wouldn't say it didn't have anything to do with the plot, I mean. Look, Nico needed so motivation as to why he'd willingly lead the seven to Epirus. Howcome he forgave Percy even though he blames him for his sisters death. And why he saved him that very scene he finds out. Yes I was just pulling out scenes from the book, but Rick put them there to explain why Nico having a crush on Percy was relevant.
I'd say Rick gave us reason to why this was relevant and also created a killer scene.
Remember what Cupid said? "But at least you've faced it now. That's the only way to conquer me." And that is absolutely true. Besides I don't understand why him being gay should matter so much. That wasn't the only part of the scene so I don't understand why everyone focus's on it.
Being gay is a thing that exists in the real world so why shouldn't exist in the PJO world? I get that some parents might disapprove of it, and that might create a hassle. But I'm willing to bet, that there are some kids out there reading it and silently praying thank you's to Rick Riordan for a character they can associate with.
So really while I can understand why you'd be upset with this. All your reasons are weak and who says you can't always just skim that part and ignore the fact that Nico may/or may not be [because it never said for certain] gay.

Thats the reading level. Not necessarily the age level the books are for, if you dont agree with it dont read the next book, and btw my friends and I are 16 and 17 and we LOVE these books so just because the cover says one thing it doesnt mean others cant read it and enjoy it.

If you're one of those prejudiced people who are homophobic and just don't like gay people, well, fine, I don't agree with you, but whatever, I can see why you would find it in appropriate. What I don't get are people who claim to be "okay" with gay people, but think that gay people should not be in a kids' book.
Why? There are straight people, and straight romances, in these books. The problem seems to be that people find being gay "inappropriate." Even people who claim to be pro-gay. Why? Look, I am straight, and I had my first crush on a boy when I was in the first grade. Did I have sexual feelings for him? Of course not, I was six. I didn't have sexual feelings at all. But I thought the boy was cute and I had a crush on him.
It's the same for gay people. That's probably how my gay friend knew he was gay, even at the age of 5 - like me, he probably had a crush on a cute boy. Again, were there sexual feelings involved? Of course not. He was 5.
So I really don't understand why people would be okay with, say, Nico having a crush on Annabeth, but think that him having a crush on Percy is not "appropriate" for children. It literally makes no sense to me.
Also, as others have pointed out, it's actually very "Greek." I also read Song of Achilles a few months ago (and totally loved it) and when Nico's feelings for Percy were shown to have been born out of this kind of hero-worship, I thought, wow, that's so Ancient Greek. It reminded me a lot of how Patroclus feels about Achilles in Song of Achilles. It seems totally natural to me that you start out admiring someone for being such a great hero, and then that admiration turning into romantic feelings.
I'm just so beyond happy that Rick included a gay character in his books. I didn't see it coming, but there was definitely a feeling of 'Wow, that makes total sense,' for me.
The only people that I think are maybe a little justified in being upset are the female fans who had crushes on Nico themselves! :P I have to admit, if Leo had turned out to be gay, I might've been a little sad. Cuz I love him :D



Hey being gay is not a bad thing. I dont care whether you find it bad or disturbing you chose to read the series and are negatively judging it because of Nico's sexuality? Really? You're kidding me right? If you hate gays please move on and dont negatively write about this book. I thought it was excellent even if it was a plot twist. Please do refrain from commenting negatively about this book and author. He doesnt have to believe in what you believe in. Overall shut the hell up and read another series where you WON'T complain about a characters sexuality. Good day to you.

I'm glad the book sympathized with him though Jason. We need to teach kids it's okay to be gay.

Please cry us all a river. You should realize how insensitive you are for shunning people of differing orientations.
Horrifying? LOL. "OMG THE EVIL AUTHOR IS RESPECTING PEOPLE FOR THEIR SEXUALITY. IT'S THE APOCALPSE"
You people are so weak,pathetic and fearful it's amazing.

It's important to teach kids that homosexuality is okay.
Marina wrote: "I was really suprised.... but I was more disapointed because I had this giant book character crush on him..."
for some reason in books, all the guys that i get book crushes on turn out to be gay. it sucks. lol
for some reason in books, all the guys that i get book crushes on turn out to be gay. it sucks. lol


1. Percy Jackson was born from the concept of being accepted. Rick wrote the books for his kids who had ADD and ADHD to assure them that there'd always be a place for them, always people who would support them. Since the first books, there have been signs of it elsewhere. Hazel's a good example. The school kids teased her because she was a minority race.
2. He likes to expose the issues of society. Nature, like how humans are polluting the air and deforesting our forests, and acceptance, so why not tackle the gay rights issue too?
3. He's recreating Ancient Greece. They were known for their homosexuality. It's only logical that he would put a Demi-God who's not entirely straight in a story based on Ancient Greece.
4. Nico is a character we know and love. He's so tortured and terribly confused, but he's changed a heck of a lot since book three. If we've grown to love this fictional character, why would we think of him as any different now that we know a small part of who he is?
5. This is a true test, I think. A challenge, a dare. Again, Rick Riordans smart. He knew this would cause controversy. If you stick with it, the more power to you because you accept his ideas as a writer, you respect his views, his opinions. You are a truly loyal fan.
This is why I plan to stick with it. I think it's great that he made Nico different, that he put that out there knowing he'd lose a few fans, not caring that he will because he did what he felt he had to do to continue this concept of acceptance and support.


Thanks for having the courage to say this online. You have just as much right to express your opinion as anyone else.
OMG This got me so surprised! I was so shocked. I really didn't see it coming. I think that it was nice of Rick to put it there and it completely made sense once I read it. How could Nico NOT have been gay? Now that I think about it, there were many clues here and there. My only problem is that I had a major HUGE book crush on Nico and now that I know he's gay, it makes me sad and crushes all dreams I had of Nico and myself (which would never come true anyway. Still, a girl can't dream?) I still think it was nice despite my massive crush. I'm as heartbroken as Nico :( Whats even more sad is the fact that Percy will never return his feelings. It makes me feel for Nico. I still love him <33 Also what makes me even MORE sad is that this might mean he's going to die. I don't think Rick is going to keep him in the story as a heartbroken person so maybe he'll just kill him? ARGHHH NOOO I DON'T WANT TO THINK ABOUT IT!! NOT MY NICO <333 Oh god, that's one character that I can't be with. At least Leo isn't gay, I don't think I would live anymore xD (Btw, Leo and Calypso? Nice!) Not that I have anything against gays its just that my dreams.. Crushed Dx Oh, Nico :(


Actually the selected age group I think is technically young adults so I don't see a problem with it.


...I feel your pain

Nico, aside from Percy, has always been my favorite! I just love his character. It is unpredictable and so mysterious. I loved how the others are scared of him, and how he has a past that they don't know about. (We as readers feel a little proud to the fact that we know more than them... at least I felt this way.);) Honestly, I wish he had remained that way. I didn't want to understand why he was the way he is. I pushed it off as simply the pain he feels from his loss and being an outcast. Also, it isn't that I hate gay people! I do not at all, but I don't support it either.... It is only that I am so attached to this character, Nico. As I said before, it was a shock to me. I did not see this coming. I love this character too much to see this happen to him...
On a completely different note. And I am biased. I wish Nico had more of a chance to show his awesome powers. He is just as powerful as Jason and Percy. I want him to be put on the pedestal with those two.


Then: "Wait, Nico? What?"

Well no, it kinda does. I don't disagree with you (that much) but I do think that Nico being gay suits his character and adds to the plot.
I don't see how "being gay" doesn't fit his character, anyways it not supposed to "fit" it, it's supposed to add to it. Nico's supposed to be the outcast kid. Son of Hades, from a different generation and all that jazz. Him being gay adds even more of the outcast sense. So it does "fit".
Then, in the actual scene itself we see Cupid taunting him and saying "Tell him the real reason you left Camp Half-Blood" In the Last Olympian we get the whole gist that Nico was finally getting accepted and he even had a cabin and all. So I don't really think the campers would start treating him like an misfit (again). But Nico still left, and him being gay was the reason why. That's pretty solid reasoning, and it lets us understand Nico's character a bit more. Plus it "fits".
Plot-wise I'd say Rick made it work very well, it went with the plot, they needed something to help defeat monsters, plus a spot where Reyna could find the note. He chose Diocletian's sphere. Then he needed a way to defeat Cupid, in a way it'd make sense. And having Nico admit his feelings was a good way to do it. Read what Cupid had said. "At least you've faced it. That's the only way to defeat me." Now tell me that doesn't make sense. Besides creating a killer scene and accomplishing many other plot-relevant things. He also created awareness about gays. Every scene doesn't have to be part of the sevens' story to be plot relevant.
Besides I don't see how he's in the midst of a love triangle. To have a love triangle you need one character to like two people or vice-versa. This to me seems more like a love angle, Nico harboring unrequited love for our Perseus Jackson, whereas he and Annabeth are deeply in-love, practically soulmates. It's not a love story, it's a schoolboy crush gone horribly wrong.
I'm sorry if this sounded rude or offended you in anyway but this is why I think Nico being gay and stuff added to the plot and his character, among other things *cough cough* love triangles.

for some reason in books, all the guys that i get book crushes on tur..."
Someone who understands my pain!



Nico does not have a boyfriend. He used to like Percy. Jason is not gay he has a girlfriend named Piper.

It's important to teach kids that homosexuality is okay."
Some parents don't want their kids being taught that.

It's important to teach kids that homosexuality is okay."
Some pa..."
Well that's their parent's problem for being bigots who support a society that shuns other individuals based on something that those said individuals have no control over, even when it doesn't affect them. smh.

Why does it matter if he's gay/bi? He's still the same person. Please do not judge others by their sexuality or you are just as bad as the homophobes that you claim not to be. Why can't a character with cool powers be gay/bi? It's not like it diminishes his power in any way, he's still awesome.
RR isn't telling everyone to be gay. He is trying to tell kids out there who ARE struggling with their sexuality that they are not alone. He is trying to help them accept themselves. Straight kids reading about someone not straight won't make them gay, just like gay/bi/etc kids reading about straight kids won't make them straight. So really, why is this such a big deal to you?


The closest Disney movie with bestiality would probably be Beauty and the Beast...but the Beast is really a human placed under a curse so that doesn't really count.

OH MAN I really need Nico to have a happy ending!!!!!!! That would be awesome if he he found another guy, but, if he does, my guess is that it would be a new character Rick introduces. Maybe Nico meets him while returning the statue to Camp!
And hm… It would be really convenient for Nico and Reyna to fall for each other...

I think Nico really needs someone who will help him open up, and feel more sure about himself. Like (and I heard someone else say this first but I can't remember where or who, SORRY) the characters Alec and Magnus from Cassandra Clare's The Mortal Instruments. The character might not have to be so silly and outrageous, but he should be able to help Nico come out of his shell like the confident Magnus did for Alec.

I will still read the books. For I am a Percy Jackson fan.
I still like Nico. I don't care what you think
I don't really think this goes with his personality, but remember line above.
I will most likely ignore this in fan fiction stories that I write.
Don't be an idiot and stop reading the books, they are all amazing.


So, wait. You say you don't care, but it still bugs you? It sounds as if you're not okay with it at all.
And also, it's not like Rick even explained it in detail, all he did was mention it. He goes more into detail with his heterosexual relationships than with Nico and his homosexuality. It's just like saying a girl has a crush on a guy. Kids learn about girls and guys liking each other from a very young age. How is this different?
This is my opinion. I hope you respect it, and I do respect yours, I just wanted to get my point out.

It's important to teach kids that homosexuality is o..."
Indeed friend.

It's important to teach kids that homosexuality is okay."
Some pa..."
I know. But Rick can write about whatever he wants. Free expression.

Nico and Leo are hands down my favourite characters in this series. Nico especially. You could say, he's my favourite male character out of any book i've ever read.
Does being gay change anything or change how i think of him as a character? NO! In fact, if anything, i like his character even more. It developed sooo much in House of Hades.
But man, I'm glad RR decided to bring a character like him into the series. Oh, and people whining about how this not age appropriate....-.- Kids know 10 times more than you think. Plus, i don't know if anyone has MISSED these things but these books have some mature content in them.....(Just no graphic sex/violence or Language). I mean, they ARE in the young adult section at all the libraries i've be to.
OH AND WHY THE HELL WAS THERE NO POV FOR NICO??!!! *goes and slouches in the corner*


so do i, but i dont think he will. he's doing that norse myth series after this...

Why would you lose respect for an author who is actively trying to promote awareness for a cause that helps thousands of people a year and even saves lives?
And what does being Christian have to do with it? I know Christians that are perfectly fine with gay rights and support it. If it's because of the Bible, you would know that there are hundreds of different interpretations for the Bible.
As for my opinion, I loved how he included it; it makes me respect him even more, especially since he knew that it would cause controversy (like on this website) and did it anyways. Props to you, Rick Riordan, for having balls.

Note that what this person just said is pretty much-
"I will have nothing to do with an author who supports... rights." That's right. He's a bad guy for supporting equality, what America is founded on. ?????

I'm happy the way Rick addressed it, with Nico and Jason. Jason's all like 'okay, I'm cool with it, it's a little weird, but you're still my friend'.
Some people embrace the gay community, some pretend it doesn't exist, others fight against it. I'm happy that other people are cool with this thing. I know some people are going to hate it, I know personally people that are against it, I know there are going to be a lot of angry girls out there.
We all have our own opinions.
So thank you, Rick.
I tip my hat to you.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
The Last Olympian (other topics)
The Iliad (other topics)
The Blood of Olympus (other topics)
The Mark of Athena (other topics)
More...
Books mentioned in this topic
The Sword of Summer (other topics)The Last Olympian (other topics)
The Iliad (other topics)
The Blood of Olympus (other topics)
The Mark of Athena (other topics)
More...
I had been inlove with Nico since titan's curse and he had been my favorite PJ character evah! I named our dog after him and developed a crush to any guy with a name NICO bcoz that name had been essentially a part of my life. So, discovering he was *slightly gay shook the world out of me. I admit, i kinda lost like half of my enthusiasm in reading the book but then i wanted 2 read posts from fan's world-wide 2 know what r they're perceptions on Nico being homo n I FEEL SO ASHAMED that, just knowing he had turned homo made me lose like 1/3 of my devotion 2 him when here u are, all supporting n acknowledging him for what he is and that completely shamed me! I hav nothing against homo's , its just so disturbing 2 know Nico wud b 2 after not having any obvious hints that he is. But IM SO SOOOOORY NICO BBY, i misjudged you. Don't worry, through all these fans support, I STILL LOVE YOU FOREVER AND I ALWAYS WILL!! I'm so sooory too Mr. Riordan, i judged ur buk unfairly though i wish you could understand my perceptions. I love NIco toooo much 2 see him be...u know. But WTH, u still rock n I WILL FOREVER LOVE NICO DI ANGELO!! Mor power!