The House of Hades
discussion
NICO… YOU KNOW WHAT I'M TALKING ABOUT O.o

And there are apparently people younger than that who understand there's no problem with people of the same gender liking each other romantically. Don't use kids as an excuse for your prejudice and bigotry. If you don't like it, then own up to that, but don't use others as an excuse.
Besides, who are you to judge what other people's kids should and shouldn't be reading at what age? Dumbledore was gay. Should kids not read Harry Potter?
Why don't you let kids make up their own minds? So you can teach them one book's (the bible) perspective, but not another? Let them decide for themselves what's right and what's wrong when it comes to who to love.
Matthews 5:28 also says "But I say to you that everyone who looks at a woman with lustful intent has already committed adultery with her in his heart.". So technically speaking, it's sinful and immoral of Percy to look at Annabeth and think about how hot she is. I don't see you complaining about that. Where exactly are you willing to draw the line?
Take a page from Jason's book, and don't judge Nico based on one single trait. Don't you think it's far more sinful in God's eyes to judge someone like that? What happened to "love thy neighbors"? Nico is a hero. I think that's resonating with kids far more than the idea that he was crushing on Percy.

I know Nico has issues, and that's perfectly okay. But I'm sure there are other issues that can be discussed.


Also, you forget that Nico was brought up in the 1940s (before the _sexual revolution of 1960s_ - and that was just hetero) so he was understandably mortified about his feelings. So he could not just blurt it out to people he did not even consider his friends fully. Remember, he spent much of the books brooding away from them and trying to bring his sister back.

I didn't see any thread by Chayse...lol.
I am aware that Nico was brought up in the 1940s until he was 9! I highly doubt he would be highly educated or aware of his own sexuality at that age.
Nico's greif for his sister is one of the primary reasons that I don't think it was appropriate to bring him out of the closet now. I mean, I would've thought Nico would have other things to be upset about other than his crush on Percy.


As for children not being ready to read stuff like that. So they're ready to read about murder, demons, death, incest, bestiality, love, kissing and even talk about having children, but not a crush on another boy? Seriously? If you're old enough to have a crush, you're old enough to know that not everyone crushes on people who are the opposite gender.

Yeah, sometimes it's hard to keep track of the ages. I think most people get tripped up by the time different between Lost Hero and Son of Neptune. Remember, when Percy's arguing with Hera, he makes mention that it's at least 8 months since he went missing from Camp. There's 2/3 of another year right there. Also, Nico is 10 at his introduction, but it's not as though it's his birthday. He could have been a month away from his next birthday.
So I agree with you. If his most recent age is stated to be 14, then that's what the readers have to go with.

Alright, you guys have convinced me of Nico's age :)
However, I feel that Nico's sexuality really isn't the most relevant thing to the storyline so far. There are so many other themes Rick could have explored with Nico, given Nico's unique background and tragic upbringing, and yet Rick did not choose those things. Yes, it is important to educate people at a young age about these sorts of issues. However, I simply feel that not in this book because it impedes with the flow .

Sheechiibii wrote: "He stated as ten years old in Titan's. Yes, there is a discrepancy with Nico's age. He was stated to be 14 in the House of Hades, however less than 3 years have passed since he was ten. I understan..."
I am not homophobic, but I simply do not think " Nico coming out" should be incorporated as part of the storyline because it does not contribute to the current plot at all. It simply directs the reader's attention away from Nico and to his sexuality. IT is a little abrupt and impedes with the flow of the book, that is all.

It might not be majorly relevant to the story, but it's extremely relevant to the character. His crush on Percy is the reason it hurt twice as much to lose Bianca. Someone he had feelings for promised to protect and bring back alive the only family he has in the entire world. Add to that, Percy was the one who told him about Camp, and how much he'd like it there, and formed that bond with Nico right after Bianca decided to leave him to join the Hunters. Essentially Percy replaced Bianca as the only person in Nico's life. Then Percy comes back from the quest and says "I let your sister die". Wouldn't you be a little crazed by all the conflicting feelings?
Grief, for Bianca.
Anger, at Percy for breaking his promise.
Confusion, because Nico likes Percy but now he's that guy who let Bianca die.
Abandonment, because now he feels alone in the world at 10 years old.
Loneliness, because he doesn't think he belongs anywhere.
Fear, because he doesn't know what he is and there's no one to show him.
Nico had a lot going on. If he hadn't been crushing on Percy, it's possible he might have still stuck around Camp and just avoided Percy. That one single moment in his life is catalytic to his character. (It's why I want so badly for him to find happiness by the end of the next book. >_<)
You all can think what you want about how his orientation changes (or not) his character.
I love Nico. Not because he's gay or not gay, but because he's Nico, and he's deserving of love.

Very well said mate!!! I also hope that Nico will have a good ending and get the love he deserve, whether its romantic or companionate...

And you buffoon, I meant that Chayse had posted in this thread itself, as you would have known if you had been following it. Also, Nico's "coming out" explains the whole reason why he leads the 7 to the House of Hades even though he had no reason to (being ostracized his whole life) and of course everything else Catherine said. It makes the character as a whole much more interesting. Books are plot + _characterization_, not just the storyline.
Love you for putting up that post Catherine! Just excellent.

For one, these books are about the Greek myths, which feature many, many stories of homosexuality.
Secondly, it's part of the character, and as Rick has said, it would be wrong for him to write Nico's character in a way that isn't natural to him.
Thirdly, it tells us an awful lot about Nico's character that we didn't understand before, it explains pretty much all of his odd behaviour, praising Percy all the time but trying to keep his distance from him whenever possible.
Fourthly, Rick writes about characters that are going to be relate-able to kids like them - he writes about ADHD, dyslexia, mixed race and now homosexuality because these are issues many kids struggle with and often suffer bullying from. He's trying to show them they're not alone, that they're just like anybody else, and that they can be amazing too. No matter who tells them they can't.

A..."
Wow, getting old fashioned around here. Haven't seen the word " buffoon" in awhile.
I agree with Catherine when she said Nico was struck with grief and everything when he lost Bianca. However, I think he first saw Percy as a big brother instead of a potential love match. The crush probably happened much later.
Nico have plenty of reason to lead the others to the House of Hades. He owed much to Percy to this point of his life, and perhaps, have done it out of the goodness of his heart( for a change?)
I feel that the outing Nico's love for percy takes away the complexity of his character. Now we know he did what he did because of love. If he have done something, we can say he did it because of love. If he hadn't done something, we again say he did it because of love. I feel that Rick could have made Nico a far more interesting character if his motives were something other than love. Let it be vengeance, guilt, greed...etc anything. Love in a children's book is a cure-for-all.
I'll admit it's a smart way to put in a plot-twister, but not a nice way to set up a good character.
Besides your last point does not make any sense. Plot+ characterization is the storyline.

please read my reply to Aditya :)


Romans 1:24-27
New International Version (NIV)
24 "Therefore God gave them over in the sinful desires of their hearts to sexual impurity for the degrading of their bodies with one another. 25 They exchanged the truth about God for a lie, and worshiped and served created things rather than the Creator—who is forever praised. Amen.
26 Because of this, God gave them over to shameful lusts. Even their women exchanged natural sexual relations for unnatural ones. 27 In the same way the men also abandoned natural relations with women and were inflamed with lust for one another. Men committed shameful acts with other men, and received in themselves the due penalty for their error."
The Bible says it all. it says that homosexuality is an error. another word for error is WRONG.

I will read the last book, but only because I've read all the other Kane and Olympus book and liked then. I was disgusted and disappointed that he had done this. And to others this is on topic. We are talking about Nico being gay.

jason says they will all support him and the author decides everything

Romans 1:24-27
New International Version (NIV)
24 "Therefore God gave them over in the sinful desires of their hearts to sexual impurity for the degrading of their bodies with one ano..."
So what? You're the one who chooses to believe that, nobody else has to live by your theories. It's a personal thing. Please keep it to yourself instead of forcing it on other people. The bible is not a book of facts. It's no more factually correct than the myths Rick Riordan bases this series on.
You're telling people who are gay (something that is a fact) that they are wrong based on what? A book documenting other people's theories about life? A book that also says eating ham or seafood is wrong, as is cutting your hair, working on a Sunday or wearing two different types of fabric. I'm guessing you don't do any of those things either? Or do you just pick and choose which parts of the bible you want to follow and which you don't?
Religion has no place in a discussion about human nature. Sexuality is something people are born with, something that has been around long before religious theories were ever made up.



If you think religion has more meaning than theories and ideals about things that can't be proven, then it's you who are misinformed. Religion can 'say' whatever it wants, it has no baring in the real world, since it is entirely based on people's beliefs and absolutely nothing of substance.
As for bestiality and incest, they both involve non-consent or abuse, which makes them an entirely different thing to homosexuality or heterosexuality, both of which involves two consenting adults. It's ridiculous to compare them. Of course they choose whether to have sex or not, just like straight people choose to have sex or not. It's absolutely no different.
And there were no sexual feelings mentioned in the book. Rick Riordan writes for kids, he's never mentioned anything sexual or explicit in any of his books. A crush is not sexual. Rick has always written for kids to show them they're accepted no matter what society says. That's why he had ADHD, dyslexia, mixed races etc having a gay character is exactly the same thing. Rick's doing what he can to tell those children that they don't have to hate themselves, because they can be heroes too. Do you think he cares about the bigots and the bullies? No. He has always written for the kids who feel left out and different, and he has always tried to show them they're perfect the way they are. Personally I think that's totally admirable.

Some come to find acceptable truth 'to them' others just seek Truth. I don't deny that children should feel accepted, but there are things in society that are unacceptable....should we accept a thief? a murderer? a liar? a cheater? Someone who is irresponsible? We put lists of "Character Qualities" on our kids all the time, but they are just lists. How do PROVE to them that these things are WRONG or RIGHT? We make value judgments all the time on BEHAVIOR and CHOICES....Why this topic to defend??? ....If we can tell our children that being a liar, cheat, murderer or lazy bum is wrong, why do we stop at sexual behavior and throw up are hands and say anything goes? Just wonderin .

Give me one good reason why being homosexual is wrong, a reason based on facts, not belief. There are factual reasons why murdering, cheating, stealing, lying etc are wrong - because they hurt other people. Being homosexual doesn't hurt anybody. Being homophobic does though.




Drug use, promiscuity, stds - these have nothing at all to do with sexuality. Heterosexuals have all these problems too.
I know many, many gay people. And most are so fun loving, happy with life people. Do you know when they weren't happy? When they were younger and they were pretending to be straight to fit in with what people like you preached about them being wrong or unnatural.
Do you know the one thing that makes most of my gay friends sad or unhappy (outside of issues relating to everyday life like any heterosexual person would have)? Homophobia.


You think I'm a humanist? Nope I'm not. And I don't worship anybody. Saying something is a fact doesn't make it so no matter how many times you repeat it. To be a fact you need proof, and you don't have it. I don't argue about religion, I've never told someone their religious beliefs are wrong. As for wanting to be right. I don't mind if I'm wrong. I have my beliefs, maybe they're right, maybe other people's are right. I don't mind, I'll find out when I'm dead :) until then I won't live my life according to any set of rules. I'll live my life based solely on what my own experiences have taught me is right or wrong.
And in my experience saying hateful things and forcing religion on others is definitely hurtful and wrong.

YEs, yes ,yes. this is great.
perfect



Pfloyd wrote: "If you don't have FAITH and BELIEF in something - then where do your MORALS come from?.....You say you don't need religion to have morals...Morals come from having some sort of religion - even if ..."
why so awesome? this is so perfect.
Stop quoting the damn bible and stop telling people all about your religion, all of you. No one gives a damn. What are we here for? To preach about your religion? No. So, stop it. It's really freaking annoying. If you don't like homosexuals then don't freaking comment on the damn thread! And you guys who support homosexuality: stop replying. It's becoming a stupid argument. No one cares about your god damn reasons. Just shut the hell up. I'm done.


@Yvenande OMG I agree with you. Like
I was really surprised at first. I'm a hardcore Percabeth shipper but now I feel like shipping Percico >_< I think it was adorable! I lurve ya, Rick :D
@Sheechiibii Okay I know this is a discussion for that. I'm just trying to say that you guys need to stop quoting stuff from the bible cause I don't want to keep going to this thread to see things from the bible. I'm an atheist, I don't like that. It's annoying to me. You guys can discuss the whole gay thing just, PLEASE, don't quote things from the bible. We shouldn't be religious here. Thank you.
I was really surprised at first. I'm a hardcore Percabeth shipper but now I feel like shipping Percico >_< I think it was adorable! I lurve ya, Rick :D
@Sheechiibii Okay I know this is a discussion for that. I'm just trying to say that you guys need to stop quoting stuff from the bible cause I don't want to keep going to this thread to see things from the bible. I'm an atheist, I don't like that. It's annoying to me. You guys can discuss the whole gay thing just, PLEASE, don't quote things from the bible. We shouldn't be religious here. Thank you.

I don't think I could ever ship Perico :( I like Percabeth too much. I want Nico to get with someone new. Possible a human XD just think how much trouble he'd be in with his father then.
Awwww yeah, preferably me. Rick should do a raffle where hardcore Nico lovers write all
About themselves in a paper and Rick just chooses one and that girl/boy gets to be Nico's lucky new gf/bf :D I would be so hype if it were me! Lol but he'd never do that xD Unfortunately
About themselves in a paper and Rick just chooses one and that girl/boy gets to be Nico's lucky new gf/bf :D I would be so hype if it were me! Lol but he'd never do that xD Unfortunately

I totally agree!!!!!

And there are apparently people younger than th..."
Sorry if this comes out rude, but don't pull out scripture to make it fit for you. For taking it out of context doesn't show much.

Romans 1:24-27
New International Version (NIV)
24 "Therefore God gave them over in the sinful desires of their hearts to sexual impurity for the degrading of their bodies with one ano..."
THANK YOU!

Yess!! Perfectly said!

Newsflash people: JUST CAUSE YOU AREN'T FOR HOMOSEXUALITY DOESN'T MAKE YOU A HOMOPHOBE CAUSE IT'S NOT LIKE YOU ARE AFRAID OF THEM!!!!!!
Sorry, just had to say that already.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
The Last Olympian (other topics)
The Iliad (other topics)
The Blood of Olympus (other topics)
The Mark of Athena (other topics)
More...
Books mentioned in this topic
The Sword of Summer (other topics)The Last Olympian (other topics)
The Iliad (other topics)
The Blood of Olympus (other topics)
The Mark of Athena (other topics)
More...
So long as you understand that he was gay/bi the whole time you liked his chara..."
No. Im mad at Rick cause you've got people as young as 9 reading these books. They don't need to read about that, sorry.