Score

Where's "Huntress"?

Well, the Earth 2 version of her is featured in Worlds' Finest with Power Girl, but I'm debating whether to include her solo miniseries or keep this list limited to collections of ongoing titles.

Omac and Hawk & Dove are both cancelled titles but they’re on the list.

Right, but they were part of the official roster of "52" titles whereas the miniseries like My Greatest Adventure, Huntress, The Shade, Penguin, etc. are all tangential to that core list.

NOTE 11/20/12: I have since decided to allow the miniseries despite this earlier comment. - Josh

Gotcha, I thought Huntress was part of the New 52 – my mistake. But a lot of those Vol 2s on the list haven’t been released yet, have they?

Right. Trying to think ahead.

I just don't see why people should vote on books that haven't been published yet. Maybe add them when they're published next year.

There are some miniseries within the New 52 as well, such as Penguin: Pain and Prejudice.

And I believe Huntress is a part of the Second Wave of the New 52, so Huntress Vol. 1 should come out about the time the second volumes of some of the other series do. A new "wave" occurs every time they cancel a couple of series like they did with Men of War, Static Shock and a few others and replace them wit others. Their goal is to keep the number of main series being published at 52 henceforth. I believe they are on the third wave already in the comics, but the collect editions are just wrapping up the publication on the first wave this month. Volume 2's start being released in January.

@Arron: That’s really interesting –is there a website where you’re getting this information?

Some of it I read on wikipedia's New 52 page, so take some of it with a grain of salt. I've also looked through DC Comics release schedule though, which backs up what I've read on wikipedia and there are no New 52 Collected Editions / Graphic Novels set to be released in December. However, there are some Vol. 2's scheduled to be released in January. For instance Green Lantern Vol. 2 and Justice League International Vol. 2 both release on January 2.

And to correct myself, Huntress has only had a miniseries in the New 52. It was written by Paul Levitz.

Titles being introduced in the second wave, replacing the cancelled titles (Men of War, OMAC, Static Shock, Hawk and Dove, Mister Terrific and Blackhawks) will be Batman Incorportated, Earth 2, World's Finest (featuring Huntress and Power Girl from Earth 2), The Ravagers, G.I. Combat and Dial H. New additions in the third wave include The Phantom Stranger, Sword of Sorcery, and Team 7.

Don't know why I didn't think to look up Wikipedia, it has a wealth of information. I think the ones that have been cancelled have deserved it for the most part. Really excited to see Constantine being part of the New 52 and a Superman title with Scott Snyder and Jim Lee helming. Also Dial H by China Mieville looks intriguing and glad to see Huntress getting her own series.

Oh, and the Court of Owls spin-off Talon is in the third wave as well.

Rumored titles for a 'Fourth wave' are Justice League of America, Katanna, Vibe, Threshold, Constantine, and an as yet untitled Superman spin-off.

So, the way I understand it, the graphic novels / collected editions are going to continuously be a wave or two behind the comics themselves. However, you can already read some of the graphic novels that are yet to be published by collecting all of the different comics that are grouped together and published in the volume sets listed here.

Yeah, I intend to read all of the sets that come out regardless, but some of them have been pretty bad. I really liked Hawk and Dove and Men of War, but I wasn't sad to see Static Shock or Mister Terrific go at all. OMAC was unique and at times was very good and at times was very bad. I haven't gotten a chance to read Blackhawks yet.

Stormwatch and the different Legion books (Legion of Super-Heroes, Legion Lost, etc.) have been boggy and boring thus far in my opinion.

Batwoman and Batwing weren't that great either.

I read 3 pages of Legion of Super Heroes and put it back on the shelf. Bad mojo. I don't get why people think Batwoman is so great either.

I toughed it out through both Legion Vol. 1's.

I also wasn't much of a fan of the Animal Man or Swamp Thing storylines in the New 52, nor Firestorm or Frankenstein, either.

Not sure why Penguin is on here if Huntress, and Legion: Secret Origin are being kept off. All three being mini-series started after New 52 started.