The 100 Most Popular Fantasy Books on Goodreads

Posted by Sharon on July 13, 2020


Dragons, demons, kings, queens, and the occasional farm boy (with a special destiny, of course): Fantasy literature has it all! To celebrate our favorite fictional worlds and characters, we went on a quest for the 100 most popular fantasies of all time on Goodreads, as determined by your fellow members.

Of course, as fantasy readers know, the journey itself matters just as much as the destination. To create our list, we first sought out the most reviewed books on our site. Additionally, each title needed at least a 3.5-star rating to join our fellowship of titles. And, since fantasy is known for its epic sagas, in the case of multiple titles from the same series we chose the one with the most reviews.

Here are the top fantasy books on Goodreads, listed from 1 to 100.

How many have you read? Tell us in the comments below, and don’t forget to add titles that catch your eye to your Want to Read shelf!


#1

#2

#3

#4

#5

#6

#7

#8

#9

#10

#11

#12

#13

#14

#15

#16

#17

#18

#19

#20

#21

#22

#23

#24

#25

#26

#27

#28

#29

#30

#31

#32

#33

#34

#35

#36

#37

#38

#39

#40

#41

#42

#43

#44

#45

#46

#47

#48

#49

#50

#51

#52

#53

#54

#55

#56

#57

#58

#59

#60

#61

#62

#63

#64

#65

#66

#67

#68

#69

#70

#71

#72

#73

#74

#75

#76

#77

#78

#79

#80

#81

#82

#83

#84

#85

#86

#87

#88

#89

#90

#91

#92

#93

#94

#95

#96

#97

#98

#99

#100

 
How many of these books have you read? What’s your favorite fantasy novel of all time? Let’s talk books in the comments!
 

Comments Showing 201-250 of 289 (289 new)


message 201: by Steffi (new)

Steffi TheBohemianBookworm wrote: "Why isn't Harry Potter on here?"

Because J.K Rowling is a transphobic mess


message 202: by C. John (new)

C. John Kerry Rowling is not opposed to people being transgender but rather to an attitude that may be more prevalent in the UK than elsewhere that no one should reproduce via heterosexual intercourse.


message 203: by T.ScottReviews (new)

T.ScottReviews Lulu wrote: "this must exclude children’s and YA, but why not say that if it does??"
There's lots of children's and ya fantasy on this list.


message 204: by Hande (new)

Hande Hello. I could't see Michael Moorcock and Elric of Melnibone. There must be a mistake, right???


message 205: by Shrike58 (new)

Shrike58 ToniHiggsReviews wrote: "Lulu wrote: "this must exclude children’s and YA, but why not say that if it does??"
There's lots of children's and ya fantasy on this list."


That might be my biggest complaint about this list...a vague separation between YA and "adult."


message 206: by Shrike58 (new)

Shrike58 Hande wrote: "Hello. I could't see Michael Moorcock and Elric of Melnibone. There must be a mistake, right???"

This list is based only on how many reviews a book/series has gotten.

Otherwise I might be inclined to agree with you.


message 207: by C. John (new)

C. John Kerry Hande wrote: "Hello. I could't see Michael Moorcock and Elric of Melnibone. There must be a mistake, right???"

I suspect Elric suffers due to the number of times the stories have been repackaged. Nothing has had a chance to get sufficient number of reviews. I daresay the ratings should be up there, but them I could be wrong.


message 208: by C. John (new)

C. John Kerry I just checked and it is definitely the reviews. None of the Elric books have even a thousand reviews. Ratings are all over 3.5 however.


message 209: by Finas (new)

Finas K I need julius caesar's book. Is there available?


message 210: by Neil (new)

Neil Butler No Pullman, no Piers Anthony, no Julian May (maybe sci-fi/fantasy), No Donaldson, no Eddings and very little Pratchett. Doesn’t make sense.


message 211: by Maximus (new)

Maximus I think harry potter should have been first and then hobbit. but that is my opinion.


message 212: by Pat (new)

Pat Mullarkey The Daughter of Smoke and Bone series by Laini Taylor should be on this list. I have the series on my bookshelf because I plan to reread. (I only reread those books with enough depth and creativity that every time I revisit I discover something new.) She creates a truly brilliant, subverted reality to our world.


message 213: by Mrs F S Petersen (new)

Mrs F S Petersen I have read 30 of these, but like others, I wonder why "Harry Potter" and David Eddings are not included, when we seem to be overloaded with Neil Gaimen. Some of the best fantasy books at present are those for YA.


message 214: by Shrike58 (new)

Shrike58 C. John wrote: "I just checked and it is definitely the reviews. None of the Elric books have even a thousand reviews. Ratings are all over 3.5 however."

There's also the small matter that they're relatively under the radar at this point having never been exploited for a visual treatment.


message 215: by Hester (new)

Hester I'm shocked that Janny Wurst is not on the list.
As for the rest, read almost all.


message 216: by Sherry (last edited Jul 21, 2020 06:44AM) (new)

Sherry Sharpnack I've read 13 of them, but several more are on my list.

I agree w/ those asking: Where is Harry?


message 217: by JasonNW (new)

JasonNW So many of these book I love. Makes me feel comfortable adding books to my Want To Read list. Best list I've seen so far. Thank you very much! 🤓


message 218: by Gerri (new)

Gerri Corrado Dikshita wrote: "Where is Harry Potter?"

Where is Alice in Wonderland?


message 219: by Raymond (new)

Raymond Thompson I read 19, mostly the older books. (Like me?)
Had The Sword in the Stone made the list, it would have been 20, a neat round number, but I guess it is too old for GR reviews.
I did read the first Harry Potter though . . . .


message 220: by Dave (new)

Dave Barron Watership Down counts as fantasy?


message 221: by Sara (new)

Sara I am currently reading The Belgarian series by David Eddings. Why isn't it on the list?They should do a list of series.


message 222: by C. John (new)

C. John Kerry I don't think a list of series is do-able. You can't simply add together the ratings as some series are longer than others. Same problem with adding number of reviews, as well since we are dealing with multiple reviews we have people with more than one review being included in the total. Maybe total each and divide by however many books in the series there are. Of course after all that we will still get arguments about rankings on the list and who isn't there.


message 223: by C. John (new)

C. John Kerry Raymond wrote: "I read 19, mostly the older books. (Like me?)
Had The Sword in the Stone made the list, it would have been 20, a neat round number, but I guess it is too old for GR reviews.
I did read the first ..."


Usually considered a fantasy.


message 224: by C. John (new)

C. John Kerry Raymond wrote: "I read 19, mostly the older books. (Like me?)
Had The Sword in the Stone made the list, it would have been 20, a neat round number, but I guess it is too old for GR reviews.
I did read the first ..."


914 reviews. That is not many compared to the the books on the list. The book also suffers in that most people these days are likely to read it as part of the omnibus volume The Once and Future King.


message 225: by Fougère (new)

Fougère Robertson So surprised to not see Robin Hobbs or Michael Sullivan on this list! They are both absolutely wonderful authors! Wonderful characters and plots! Please check them out. If you love Brandon Sanderson, then you will love these authors.


message 226: by Joshua atkinson (new)

Joshua atkinson I loooove to see that sooooo many Brandon Sanderson books made it on the list, I would have yo say that he is my number one favorite author.


message 227: by Kitty (new)

Kitty Liebhardt Did I see "Canticle for Leibowitz by Miller? A classic!


message 228: by Rob (new)

Rob Washam I've read 26 of these 100. Currently reading my 27th.


message 229: by C. John (new)

C. John Kerry Kitty wrote: "Did I see "Canticle for Leibowitz by Miller? A classic!"

over on the Sci Fi list (someone over there was very critical of the term Sci Fi so I am going to use it from now on.)


message 230: by Schuyler (new)

Schuyler 42, but plenty more on to read list


message 231: by Harry (new)

Harry Mack To the many comments asking about the "Harry Potter" books, I suspect that one reason may be that Potter is more popular in movies. So many young people lack the intelligence for reading, and instead, prefer being entertained by visual special effects. Promote literacy !!! Buy books for the young minds in your life !!!


message 232: by Barbara (new)

Barbara Wadman Where are the Outlander books! They are almost my favourite ever!! Author is Diana Gabaldon.


message 233: by Raymond (new)

Raymond Thompson C. John wrote: "Raymond wrote: "I read 19, mostly the older books. (Like me?)
Had The Sword in the Stone made the list, it would have been 20, a neat round number, but I guess it is too old for GR reviews.
I did..."


Unfortunately true, since The Once and Future King is good but not great . . . uneven? Whereas The Sword in the Stone is a gem. To make matters worse, most people encounter it only as the inferior Disney movie.


message 234: by Coffee (new)

Coffee I'm presently surprised that Tad Williams made it to this list. I didn't think that anyone would have read his books because he's an older author but I guess someone has to put him on this list.


message 235: by C. John (new)

C. John Kerry Alli wrote: "I'm presently surprised that Tad Williams made it to this list. I didn't think that anyone would have read his books because he's an older author but I guess someone has to put him on this list."

The book of his has north of 1,000 replies, which seems low but maybe isn't. I wish someone from Goodreads would come on here and explain the seeming discrepancies, but I suspect that is not going to happen. Ah well.


message 236: by C. John (new)

C. John Kerry Here's a thought, maybe the Goodreads computer was having a nervous breakdown the day it did this list.


message 237: by C. John (new)

C. John Kerry Harry wrote: "To the many comments asking about the "Harry Potter" books, I suspect that one reason may be that Potter is more popular in movies. So many young people lack the intelligence for reading, and inste..."

Here are the stats for Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone (to use the correct title, not the one used only in the US).

4.47 · 6,835,079 Ratings · 109,020 Reviews

I think those would have qualified it for this list if someone didn't have a bias against YA.


message 238: by Hester (new)

Hester Barbara wrote: "Where are the Outlander books! They are almost my favourite ever!! Author is Diana Gabaldon."

How indeed!! Loved them too.


message 239: by David (new)

David I'd add The Circus of Dr. Lao by Charles and Greenwillow by B. J. Chute. Both were written before J. K. Rowling was born. Of course, I'm not even sure that either of these are in print any longer. Too bad.


message 240: by Dan (new)

Dan Sinclair Jones I've read so many of these but I'm happy to be able to add a heap of titles to my TBR list! My fave fantasy writer of all time is still Anne Rice but I also love Sherri S Tepper (although I've heard her genre called speculative fiction - even though she's a fantasy award winner).

I agree that Harry Potter should be on the list. It crosses age categories and no matter JKR's recent extremely awful public statements it is still brilliant.


message 241: by Christine (new)

Christine I've read 20 of the books on this particular list. I, too, was surprised to not see Harry Potter on here.


message 242: by Karen (new)

Karen I've read 11 on this list and there are a few more I may get around to reading. N K Nemisin is one of the more recent authors I've got a lot of respect for.


message 243: by Rob (new)

Rob Raos Great list, can anyone tell a newb how to save this list somewhere in my goodreads account? It would be handy so I can finish all the books by the time I am 97.


message 244: by Lynee (new)

Lynee No Patricia McKillip at all? The Riddlemaster of Hed trilogy is one of the best series I've ever read. And I love how a reviewer references the "Dune" books, but none of those are on this list either. How about Michelle West's Sun Sword or House War books? There are far too many vampire bodiceripper type books on this list.


message 245: by Andrew Gilchrist (new)

Andrew Gilchrist @ veronica 'this list is a joke'.. yeah it struck me as wonky too. Steven Erikson is so far down for example. But then he wrote nine others the same quality and a few in a follow on series. So are votes spread across his books, hence his seminal offering isnt higher?


message 246: by Andrew Gilchrist (new)

Andrew Gilchrist I guess it's a book list and not an author list


message 247: by Sally (new)

Sally Haas Where is Steven Erickson his books are in a class of their own also r Scott Bakker. I have read very few of this list, have started them could not be bothered to read them


message 248: by C. John (new)

C. John Kerry Lynee wrote: "No Patricia McKillip at all? The Riddlemaster of Hed trilogy is one of the best series I've ever read. And I love how a reviewer references the "Dune" books, but none of those are on this list eith..."

I wouldn't expect Dune to he here. It is on the Science-Fiction list however.


message 249: by C. John (new)

C. John Kerry Andrew Gilchrist wrote: "I guess it's a book list and not an author list"

You guessed right. Not sure how they could do an author list anyway as we don't rate authors on this site, just their individual works.


message 250: by Pen&Quill (new)

Pen&Quill  Read What list has Harry Potter? Where do you go to recommend lists that goodreads should do? I can think of a few top 100s that I'd like to see.


back to top