The Son of Neptune
discussion
Piper or Reyna ? Who should Jason choose?
why don't we wait for the next book to see how Jason really feels towards Piper/Reyna?too many theories will complicate the story even more...
Echizen_kirino wrote: "why don't we wait for the next book to see how Jason really feels towards Piper/Reyna?too many theories will complicate the story even more..."
True, but it makes the story a whole lot more interesting.
Leah wrote: "Nancy wrote: "Leah wrote: "Nancy wrote: "Has anyone noticed Piper seems different from THL and from the MoA?In TLH Piper said she was willing to let Jason go if he had a girlfriend. Reyna was his..."
Percy has troubles because he's Percy. That's invalid.
But still Piper still knows mythology! Or used to, I guess.
Annabeth usually talks about the monster, why can't Piper?
GreatScottland wrote: "Leah wrote: "Reyna. And. Jason. Were. Never. Dating. There was no 'relationship' you speak of."Just because Annabeth and Percy weren't dating, didn't mean Annabeth wouldn't get upset when Rachel ..."
*Applause* I couldn't have said it anyway better.
I'm still wishing Jason choose Piper over Reyna till the end of the series
Valerie wrote: "rawr the dinosaur wrote: "btw...open question again.
i've seen this many times, not just in leah's post, but alot of ppl say that piper's flaw is that she can't make decisions.
could someone expla..."
sorry, should have clarified. i was referring to the fatal flaws, which the siblings of the same god/goddess will have in common. eg: all the children of athena have pride as their fatal flaw, children of hades would be holding grudges. percy's is his loyalty,and it was inferred that to the children of zeus, power is tyheir fatal flaw. hope you understand what i mean now.
i've seen this many times, not just in leah's post, but alot of ppl say that piper's flaw is that she can't make decisions.
could someone expla..."
sorry, should have clarified. i was referring to the fatal flaws, which the siblings of the same god/goddess will have in common. eg: all the children of athena have pride as their fatal flaw, children of hades would be holding grudges. percy's is his loyalty,and it was inferred that to the children of zeus, power is tyheir fatal flaw. hope you understand what i mean now.
Leah wrote: "GreatScottland wrote: "Leah wrote: "Angeline wrote: "It's gotta be Piper. Reyna is SO sulky!"I refuse to hate any characters, but I have to agree with you. Piper is a great character."
um, she is..."
I probably would have it too, but that doesn't mean we should. Drew was mean, but that doesn't mean we should be mean back, so I'm just saying her reaction's to drew aren't as likable.
In MoA, I thought Piper interpreted things differently.Jason PROMISED no break up. It was a promise not an oath. Also when Jason promised they would all survive. Those were promises. A promise can easily be broken.
A oath is BEYOND a promise. A oath can't be broken. A oath is when they swear on the River of Styx. Jason didn't swear on the River of Styx.
I thought it was a bit low of Piper's intelligence to think like that, but she was in love mode with Jason.
Piper knows about beauty and how universal it is. Therefore, as a child of Aphrodite, it would be the best for her to lead them.And Drew is the one who uses her power for bad attention. And she is a ****h so Piper needs to act and also if you guys said Piper was meant to her, maybe Drew needs to taste her own action or an eye for an eye.
Urgh, how else would Drew realize her mistakes if she herself does not know what's the feeling to be humiliated or threaten. And Piper did it because of Drew's fault; if she's nice to Piper, none of this would happen.
IMO I actually think Drew is better than Piper in some ways
.......................................
.................................................................................................................................................................._____________________________________________
How, exactly, is Drew better than anyone?
Ok maybe she's better than Gaea or Kronos but you know what I mean
i really wanted him to choose Reyna:(
Piper. Reyna makes my eye twitch. =.=
Rylie wrote: "Piper. Reyna makes my eye twitch. =.="Reyna is way too serious for Jason. He's already a serious person, and he needs someone to balance him out.
I say Reyna. But I know it's gonna be Piper. :\
Ok I think that jason should be with piper even though ALOT of peopel want Piper want her to jump off a cliff :D but lets look at it this way Reyna TRIED TO MAKE A MOVE ON PERCY!!!!!!!!! I don't think anyone said that yet. If they were in a serious realationship she would of NEVER done that. Nobody should say that she was desprate because Annabeth was going through the SAME thing!!! but did she cheat on Percy? I DON"T THINK SO!!!!! So I think Piper fine and should be with Jason. But I also think that it would better if Jason dates someone else other than Piper and Reyna.
I personally prefer Reyna as a character but I think Piper.
reyna at least she knows how to fight piper is just good with words and piper whines a lot and reyna is fearless
Leah wrote: "Rylie wrote: "Piper. Reyna makes my eye twitch. =.="Reyna is way too serious for Jason. He's already a serious person, and he needs someone to balance him out."
How much do we know Reyna? Not enough to say she's serious. Sure, she is serious when she does her job, which is all we ever see of her, but she probably isn't as serious in the inside.
GreatScottland wrote: "Leah wrote: "Rylie wrote: "Piper. Reyna makes my eye twitch. =.="Reyna is way too serious for Jason. He's already a serious person, and he needs someone to balance him out."
How much do we know ..."
Well said
GreatScottland wrote: "Leah wrote: "Rylie wrote: "Piper. Reyna makes my eye twitch. =.="Reyna is way too serious for Jason. He's already a serious person, and he needs someone to balance him out."
How much do we know ..."
That's true... but it can work either way. How much do we really know about Reyna? She could be a total psycho. She could work for Gaea. We don't know much about her, she's been in about 5 chapters total.
Well lets just say I don't like Reyna but she defenttly isn't working for Gaea at least I don't think so. She is TOO serious and Jason is already a O MY GOD someone kill with a knife cause im dieing of boredom compared to Percy. Piper is ok... so I think he should "Choose" her. (She's alittle annoyying in my world though) Oh and Reyna tried ot make a move on Percy!!!! SOOOOOOO MAD!!!!! -____-
Piper is awesome he should chose her.
Julia wrote: "Well lets just say I don't like Reyna but she defenttly isn't working for Gaea at least I don't think so. She is TOO serious and Jason is already a O MY GOD someone kill with a knife cause im diein..."
She didn't know about Annabeth and she was lonely, OK? Stop bashing poor ol' Reyna, she's already upset!
She didn't know about Annabeth and she was lonely, OK? Stop bashing poor ol' Reyna, she's already upset!
Shahdia wrote: "Julia wrote: "Well lets just say I don't like Reyna but she defenttly isn't working for Gaea at least I don't think so. She is TOO serious and Jason is already a O MY GOD someone kill with a knife ..."yes! Reyna is a great character... so please stop bashing her
I personally like her character more than piper... but, since the discussion is about who will Jason choose as his girl... than I choose piper
because Reyna and Jason is not balancing each other... just imagining them as a couple makes me shudder...
Too serious!
While piper (even though a bit annoying) is perfect for Jason...
besides, they're sooooooooo cute as a couple!
Echizen_kirino wrote: "Shahdia wrote: "Julia wrote: "Well lets just say I don't like Reyna but she defenttly isn't working for Gaea at least I don't think so. She is TOO serious and Jason is already a O MY GOD someone ki..."Well sorry but I'm not bashing her its just that I love Percy soooo much I understand that you have your point of view and I have mine. I respect that. But you gotta admit Jason and Reyna are both serious people and sometimes oppisites arract. But just to get this clear I'm not a big fan of Reyna but I don't want her to "jump off a cliff" gosh people can be rude like how they want Piper to do it just because she's a bit annoyying. So yeah :)
Julia wrote: "Ok I think that jason should be with piper even though ALOT of peopel want Piper want her to jump off a cliff :D but lets look at it this way Reyna TRIED TO MAKE A MOVE ON PERCY!!!!!!!!! I don't th..."Reyna may have her reasons on why she supposably "made a move" on Percy. In the MoA, Jason still trusts her. Jason and Reyna weren't in a relationship YET. If they were given more time they would've had a relationship.
Annabeth was ALREADY in a relationship with Percy.
Leah wrote: "GreatScottland wrote: "Leah wrote: "Rylie wrote: "Piper. Reyna makes my eye twitch. =.="Reyna is way too serious for Jason. He's already a serious person, and he needs someone to balance him out...."
We do know that Jason trusts her.
Echizen_kirino wrote: "Shahdia wrote: "Julia wrote: "Well lets just say I don't like Reyna but she defenttly isn't working for Gaea at least I don't think so. She is TOO serious and Jason is already a O MY GOD someone ki..."A bit? Personally, I find her to be really annoying. She talks about Jason too much. She COMPARED Jason's and Percy's looks.
Jason might be getting manipulated by Aphrodite into loving Piper, who knows
TheEmoQueen wrote: "Jason might be getting manipulated by Aphrodite into loving Piper, who knows"Piper knows that her mom might be manipulating Jason's feelings but she doesn't care.
Nancy wrote: "Leah wrote: "GreatScottland wrote: "Leah wrote: "Rylie wrote: "Piper. Reyna makes my eye twitch. =.="Reyna is way too serious for Jason. He's already a serious person, and he needs someone to bal..."
They've known each other for a while, but trust isn't equal to romantic feelings
Leah wrote: "Nancy wrote: "Leah wrote: "GreatScottland wrote: "Leah wrote: "Rylie wrote: "Piper. Reyna makes my eye twitch. =.="Reyna is way too serious for Jason. He's already a serious person, and he needs ..."
That trust was leading to something more. Jason trusts Piper and it lead a romantic relationship thanks to her mom's help. Jason trusts Reyna but it didn't lead to romantic relationship that we know of thanks to Aphrodite/ Venus tampering it.
I would rather have piper with Leo he's so cute!
but it's still a contradiction whether it was true or not that Aphrodite really did something to Jason
Nancy wrote: "TheEmoQueen wrote: "Jason might be getting manipulated by Aphrodite into loving Piper, who knows"
Piper knows that her mom might be manipulating Jason's feelings but she doesn't care."
but thats just it, why doesnt she care, does she want Jason so bad she wouldnt care if he even cared about her or not
Piper knows that her mom might be manipulating Jason's feelings but she doesn't care."
but thats just it, why doesnt she care, does she want Jason so bad she wouldnt care if he even cared about her or not
he better, and must pick PIPER!
I think Piper would win. She could charm him too guys. Either he is willing or unwilling, but she ways of getting him.
Karla wrote: "he better, and must pick PIPER!"?
always and forever piper!
reynas cool but not as good plus i think she needs someone more powerful like a minor god
TheEmoQueen*I walk alone* wrote: "Nancy wrote: "TheEmoQueen wrote: "Jason might be getting manipulated by Aphrodite into loving Piper, who knows"Piper knows that her mom might be manipulating Jason's feelings but she doesn't care..."
She does care! She said a billion times that she doesn't want a fake relationship and she had a breakdown when she found out her relationship with Jason was fake. Since when is Aphrodite influencing the relationship?
Emily Danielle wrote: "I like Reyna more than Piper BUT Piper should be the one who would end up with Jason...they were so good together...I want Reyna to be with Leo...and besides, doesn't Leo like a girl which is ver..."
They are good together.
of course Piper! Reyna is so different from Jason.
hope Reyna and Annabeth become friends though-
Sabrina *The REAL Princess* wrote: "Reyna, those 2 have an actual history and besides, if you like percabeth imagine that instead of Jason wondering who it will be, it was Percy. Then you'd all choose Annabeth, because those 2 actualReyna, those 2 have an actually developed into a relationship. Not just BAM we're dating now. In these books they're constantly at war and going on quests so they have to form quick relationships usually.
Its not their fault that they met under hard circumstance(Jason with his memory wiped, Piper confused by the mist, and a storm spirits trying to kill you).
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
The Son of Neptune (other topics)
Books mentioned in this topic
The House of Hades (other topics)The Son of Neptune (other topics)
Just because Annabeth and Percy weren't dating, didn't mean Annabeth wouldn't get upset when Rachel came into the picture. Annabeth and Percy's relationship was there, it just wasn't boyfriend/girlfriend. So just because Reyna and Jason weren't dating doesn't mean there wasn't a relationship there.