The Son of Neptune
discussion
Piper or Reyna ? Who should Jason choose?
message 1201:
by
Breanna
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Dec 27, 2012 09:12AM
personally I don't really care for either of them but if I had to choose one it would be Piper....... Reyna had her chance and Hera took it away from her..... That is fate right??
reply
|
flag
Breanna wrote: "personally I don't really care for either of them but if I had to choose one it would be Piper....... Reyna had her chance and Hera took it away from her..... That is fate right??"good point it's her fate to be with someone else
Ok, this is just a guess, but I bet most HoO fans dislike Piper/Jason.There are a few who like Jason and not Piper.
There are a few who like Piper but not Jason.
And there are a slim few who like them both. (like me)
Since I like them both (and Reyna, who most people like, I think), I probably have the most unbiased opinion. And other people who feel the same way about all three of them have an unbiased opinion, too, like people who like all three of them or hate all three of them.
So, I think that Piper is Jason's first choice.
(and yes, I'm going by what JASON would want, not who I would pick)
He has no romantic feeling for Reyna, he said so himself.
CASE CLOSED
Jeez! I'd rather choose Piper than Reyna. Because of what huh ?!? SHE IS ONE OF THE SEVEN DEMIGODS
Ok, I answerd this awhile ago so I'm not going to again. I originally dis-liked Reyna, but I was willing t give her another Chance in MoA. AT the beginning of it i like her. By the end my opinion of her, and the Roman camp was worse than it had been in SoN. The Romans, especially Octavian and Reyna, came across as proud, hypocritical, unfriendly, and overly stubborn. They were very unwelcoming to the Greeks, even though the Greeks came asking for friendship and help. By going after Camp Half-Blood, they are too proud and stubborn to admit that maybe they were wrong about the Greeks. The Romans say they are about duty, doing the right thing for their camp no matter what, but they are too blinded by an old grudge to see that unless they make nice with the Greeks it is not only their camp that is at stake, it is the whole world.
Hannah wrote: "Okay Piper or Reyna? Who should Jason choose? At the end of the Lost Hero we were left hanging."definetly piper because Reyna tryed to flirt with percy said in mark of athena she is a back stabber
Kimber~!! wrote: "Piper disgusts & annoys me"how is that possible piper is sooo cool
piper is awesome no doubt piper!!!
Piper can be annoying.....but she is one of the Seven.. If it came down to a fight though, do you think the daughter of the goddess of war or love would win? Reyna had Jason first!!!!!
Sophia wrote: "Hannah wrote: "Okay Piper or Reyna? Who should Jason choose? At the end of the Lost Hero we were left hanging."definetly piper because Reyna tryed to flirt with percy said in mark of athena she i..."
I'm tired of people saying this, because it makes no sense. Why would Reyna flirt with a guy who ruined her home? Percy didn't do anything in that time that would make her suddenly stop disliking him to making her actually like him.
But because she flirted with him, I believe it wasn't out of attraction, but that she was willing to give up her love life so that Percy would become Praetor before Octavian seized the chance.
GreatScottland wrote: "Sophia wrote: "Hannah wrote: "Okay Piper or Reyna? Who should Jason choose? At the end of the Lost Hero we were left hanging."definetly piper because Reyna tryed to flirt with percy said in mark ..."
hm... I know that she's in a critical condition... knowing there's an octavian trailing behind her... but did she has to seduce percy to become a praetor? Can't she just ask him or telling him her problem about the praetorship?
why did she have to seduce him?
I'm not sure why she had to, It's just very unlikely she was actually flirting with him because she liked him.And if I remember correctly, she did tell him the situation. I think she realized that Percy was still kinda unsure and did everything she could to get him to be praetor with her.
(hopefully this helped)
PIPER! He didn't even have feelings for Reyna.
GreatScottland wrote: "I'm not sure why she had to, It's just very unlikely she was actually flirting with him because she liked him.
And if I remember correctly, she did tell him the situation. I think she realized that..."
In MoA, it mentioned *spoiler* that Reyna did, and that Annabeth could read from Reyna's face that she was hitting on Percy. Even after that, Reyna showed some signs of jealousy for Percy's constant attention on Annabeth.
And if I remember correctly, she did tell him the situation. I think she realized that..."
In MoA, it mentioned *spoiler* that Reyna did, and that Annabeth could read from Reyna's face that she was hitting on Percy. Even after that, Reyna showed some signs of jealousy for Percy's constant attention on Annabeth.
PIPER DESPITE THE FACT SHE IS ANNOYING THEY ARE PERFECT FOR EACH OTHER
Ro wrote: "GreatScottland wrote: "I'm not sure why she had to, It's just very unlikely she was actually flirting with him because she liked him.And if I remember correctly, she did tell him the situation. I ..."
I know, it just doesn't make any sense why she would like someone who destroyed her home.
Plus who says Annabeth is right? Maybe Reyna didn't like her because she helped destroy her home too.
Piper. Reyna just needs to get over it. lol. sorry, but its true. Life doesn't always go the way you want it to.
GreatScottland wrote: "Ro wrote: "GreatScottland wrote: "I'm not sure why she had to, It's just very unlikely she was actually flirting with him because she liked him.
And if I remember correctly, she did tell him the si..."
Who knows. *Shrugs* I'm just sticking to what Annabeth and Percy said in MoA. Maybe RR missed that little detail, like he did when he made Annabeth and Percy surprised hearing from Piper and Jason that Hercules was a jerk, even though they should've KNOWN he WAS one already due to what he did to Zoe some books ago.
And if I remember correctly, she did tell him the si..."
Who knows. *Shrugs* I'm just sticking to what Annabeth and Percy said in MoA. Maybe RR missed that little detail, like he did when he made Annabeth and Percy surprised hearing from Piper and Jason that Hercules was a jerk, even though they should've KNOWN he WAS one already due to what he did to Zoe some books ago.
Ro wrote: "GreatScottland wrote: "Ro wrote: "GreatScottland wrote: "I'm not sure why she had to, It's just very unlikely she was actually flirting with him because she liked him.And if I remember correctly, ..."
agreed... heracles is a jerk!
piper wins!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Piper, but I feel bad for Reyna :( And then we find out that Jason's actually gay. That would solve a lot of problems :D HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
Calsi wrote: "Piper, but I feel bad for Reyna :( And then we find out that Jason's actually gay. That would solve a lot of problems :D HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA"Hahaha, yeah it would. Who should he be with then...? Anyone but Leo.
REYNA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ohmygods I soo want piper to die a super intense death and then jasons all NOOOO and then reyna is there to comfort him... and so then they end up together :)JEYNA!! love 'em, even tho I think they may kill each other before they remember their love... well, I hope that doesn't happen!!!
the probability is smalldoubting it will happen
Echizen_kirino wrote: "the probability is smalldoubting it will happen"
dang... yeah I know... :(
Piper. She's like the only daughter of Aphrodite in the series who doesn't put vanity first above everything else.
honestly I don't really care who he chooses as long as Percy stays with Annabeth ;) but if I had to I'd have to say Reyna cuz Jason and Piper went on ONE quest together and we don't know how long Reyna and Jason have known each other and I feel like it would be pretty horrible if Jason just decided to dump her for this girl he just met. Plus he's probably going to get his memory back in the end so I'm gonna say REYNA!! :)
Sabrina *The REAL Princess* wrote: "Reyna, those 2 have an actual history and besides, if you like percabeth imagine that instead of Jason wondering who it will be, it was Percy. Then you'd all choose Annabeth, because those 2 actual..."This!
well even though they have a history together... but as long as Jason didn't have any romantic feelings... it won't bloom into a romantic relationship...no offense though
well, there must be 'something' happened between Reyna and Jason before Jason went to Camp Half=Blood but since Reyna didn't tell more, we don't know what really happened. And Jason is too perfect to have Reyna by his side. I mean he's son of Jupiter and so on and if his girlfriend is the preator of Roman camp, it's just make him mooooore perfect than ever and it actually annoys me. (sorry guys, I kinda hate him lol)Although Piper is so insecure and her relationship with Jason is so boring I couldn't help my self smiling whenever Piper-Jason moments appeared on the books. So, I still choose Piper ;)
Echizen_kirino wrote: "well even though they have a history together... but as long as Jason didn't have any romantic feelings... it won't bloom into a romantic relationship...no offense though"
true, but how likely does that seem? He had to have had some feelings toward her, at least in the Lost Hero he seemed to...(though how strong these feelings were, I can't say)
yes... it's in the lost herobut in the mark of athena he obviously didn't have any romantic feelings towards her
Well why did those feelings sudden disappear?
GreatScottland wrote: "Well why did those feelings sudden disappear?"(Sorry if I sound mean)
hm?I don't know... but that seemed of what Jason feels towards her now...
maybe what he felt back then is just a fling since they did everything together?
Kimber~!! wrote: "Piper disgusts & annoys me"Not just me then?
I don't know how I feel about this, I mean Reyna and Jason's relationship didn't really seem like a legit thing, and Piper and Jason are obviously in a relationship now. I think Piper and Jason are cute together, but sometimes I dislike Piper a bit and I'm not sure why. I kinda want to see what it would be like if Jason and Reyna dated. Or maybe Rick Riordan could do like a flashback to when Reyna and Jason were priotors, and that might make it more clear.
I'm not really crazy about either of them
I'm a huge fan of Reyna's, she is so determined! And personally I kind of find Piper desperate, but based on the books I think Jason will probably go for Piper. Sigh.
Yeah, both are really annoying, especially Piper, but I think Jason and Piper are supposed to be together. The real question is Hazel....Frank or Leo. We'll just have to wait and see.
Kimber~!! wrote: "Piper disgusts & annoys me"I SO AGREE! Reyna is AWESOME with a capital A!
Go Reyna!
Piper!!!!! Definitely!!
REYNA!!!!! I hate Piper-she's really annoying and whiny. Reyna is awesome, a great leader, and a fighter. Plus, Piper's an idiot for not having warning bells go off in her head when Jason was totally rude to Reyna because he liked Piper better.
piper........ though if jason does pick piper most likely reyna will stab piper in the back then jason and then piper again. literally
Well If you read Mark of Athena you know who he picked
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
The Son of Neptune (other topics)
Books mentioned in this topic
The House of Hades (other topics)The Son of Neptune (other topics)
