The Son of Neptune
discussion
Piper or Reyna ? Who should Jason choose?
Shahdia wrote: "Piper.Why? Because Reyna is strong. She is selfless. She is a leader. She is a fighter. She is a victor. She is a praetor. She deserves the best. Jason Grace, after how much he's hurt her, doesn'..."
Wow, I love your explanation. And I love Leyna. Honestly, to the one who started the shipping, I love him/her too! Piper, she's a Mary-Sue. Whereas Reyna is an ideal heroine.
Kirstin wrote: "Shahdia wrote: "Piper.
Why? Because Reyna is strong. She is selfless. She is a leader. She is a fighter. She is a victor. She is a praetor. She deserves the best. Jason Grace, after how much he's ..."
Thanks for the compliment on my explanation! Yes, Reyna is exactly what I like in a female character; strong, selfless, intelligent and as good as a boy...what's more, she runs all of Camp Jupiter by herself. Pretty impressive feat, huh? She should have a viewpoint in the House of Hades(view spoiler) and she should be a more major character.
Leyna would work out, because they have so many differences yet so many similarities. They are both like 'third wheels', but one is so serious and one is so immature. And I like to think that the relationship would be a lot like Percabeth.
Why? Because Reyna is strong. She is selfless. She is a leader. She is a fighter. She is a victor. She is a praetor. She deserves the best. Jason Grace, after how much he's ..."
Thanks for the compliment on my explanation! Yes, Reyna is exactly what I like in a female character; strong, selfless, intelligent and as good as a boy...what's more, she runs all of Camp Jupiter by herself. Pretty impressive feat, huh? She should have a viewpoint in the House of Hades(view spoiler) and she should be a more major character.
Leyna would work out, because they have so many differences yet so many similarities. They are both like 'third wheels', but one is so serious and one is so immature. And I like to think that the relationship would be a lot like Percabeth.
Shahdia wrote: "Kirstin wrote: "Shahdia wrote: "Piper.Why? Because Reyna is strong. She is selfless. She is a leader. She is a fighter. She is a victor. She is a praetor. She deserves the best. Jason Grace, afte..."
Me too. At first I was actually all JasPer. But when Reyna was introduced, I couldn't help but admire her. She's my favorite demigod now. And to be honest, I like her more than Annabeth. Make no mistake: I really like Annabeth. But Reyna, I just get her. And maybe because I'm kind of sorry for her.
Exactly! It's like Percabeth. I'd love to see Leyna happen. I hope RR reads... you know, the internet. Fanfic, if there's any. That would be awesome.
Agree with the major role. I'd like to have her narrate her own story, so we can have a glimpse of what's happening in the Greek-Roman demigod war. It wouldn't ruin the book at all.
Shahdia wrote: "Piper.Why? Because Reyna is strong. She is selfless. She is a leader. She is a fighter. She is a victor. She is a praetor. She deserves the best. Jason Grace, after how much he's hurt her, doesn'..."
That is very true, but I think Leo isn't right for her. I don't know who is though...
Well he kinda of ready choosed (cough cough jerk), Good too Reyna doesn't need him, Which is Awesome if in the Future she is going to be with Leo( maybe.)
Shahdia wrote: "Kirstin wrote: "Shahdia wrote: "Piper.Why? Because Reyna is strong. She is selfless. She is a leader. She is a fighter. She is a victor. She is a praetor. She deserves the best. Jason Grace, afte..."
That's a good point. Leyna is growing on me...
Piper all the way!!But when I hear somebody's comment on how RR could bring in another boy and leave Jason as a loner, I thought, what if they brought in a another girl and left piper single?!?!?!?
I hate that but it's just a thought
Hoping for the best with Jason and piper
No reyna or new character please!!
Piper!
Besides, Jason has been with CHB for a while now.
Reyna doesn't exactly trust the Greeks that much. I think with Piper, it works out better.
Besides, Jason has been with CHB for a while now.
Reyna doesn't exactly trust the Greeks that much. I think with Piper, it works out better.
Reyna needs support... why are you guys so mean to her?? --
Definitely Piper! They both are so cute together!
Seah Kim wrote: "Reyna needs support... why are you guys so mean to her?? --"It's okay. Jason didn't deserve Reyna anyway. But if I were to choose between Reyna and Piper, (let's erase Jason in the picture) definitely Reyna. SHE'S MUCH BETTER. 100x BETTER THAN PIPER COULD BE.
@kirstinThat's true, Jason doesn't deserve Reyna anyway. Piper is whiny and Jason is just kind of there, so they deserve each other.
Jason and Piper make a good couple since they are two of the worst-developed characters in HOO.
Reyna/Happiness for the win.
Reyna/Happiness for the win.
Jack's wrote: "Jason and Piper make a good couple since they are two of the worst-developed characters in HOO.Reyna/Happiness for the win."
I totally agree!! I think that Reyna deserves someone better than Jason.
I don't know the relationship that Jason has with both girls is confusing, but I feel that it should be Piper, she and Jason are
perfect for each other.
Jason should be with Reyna
Jack's wrote: "Jason and Piper make a good couple since they are two of the worst-developed characters in HOO.
Reyna/Happiness for the win."
Yeah. I've grown to love Reyna and I'm pretty sure she'd be my friend in real life. A few years ago, when we had to dress up as a book character for school, I wanted to be Reyna but we couldn't get her armor so I had to be Zoë Nightshade. No prob.
Reyna/Happiness for the win."
Yeah. I've grown to love Reyna and I'm pretty sure she'd be my friend in real life. A few years ago, when we had to dress up as a book character for school, I wanted to be Reyna but we couldn't get her armor so I had to be Zoë Nightshade. No prob.
PIPER! Reyna is too busy with the legion, and sometimes she can be heartless, like threatening to execute Annabeth.
Definitely Piper! I'm nearly vomiting just thinking about Jason being with Reyna.
Yes, Piper. Because Reyna deserved someone much better. Piper and Jason are for each other, since IMO their the least developed characters.
Piper, in the first book we mostly heard about Jason and Piper, there was one mention of Reyna ,but that was it.
I really dislike Piper and Jason, so I don't mind that their together, but I do feel bad for Reyna because she really seemed to like Jason. I almost would like it if Percy was with Reyna if I didn't like Annabeth so much. So I think I'm going to have to settle for Leo being with Reyna.
I think Jason should choose Piper,Because Piper has saved their lives plenty of times.
Piper annoys me very much (But still nor nearly as much as Bella Swan) so I will have to choose Reyna.
Entreri wrote: "... So I think I'm going to have to settle for Leo being with Reyna."wait, no. LEO? AND REYNA? TOGETHER??
Well, in my opinion Leo should end up with Hazel since Frank's gonna die anyway (not that i'm complaining - i hate him). And yeah, Jason should choose Piper - they already kinda act like a couple...
Piper. Why? Well, She obviously needs Jason in her life. With all of her rebellious spirit and all. Plus Jason sometimes is too responsible and that's where he needs Piper's rebellious spirit.
Faria wrote: "Entreri wrote: "... So I think I'm going to have to settle for Leo being with Reyna."wait, no. LEO? AND REYNA? TOGETHER??
Well, in my opinion Leo should end up with Hazel since Frank's gonna die..."
I LOVE YOU FRANK!!!!! He belongs with Hazel. Frank will NOT die!!!! Team Leo SUCKS!!! but I still like Leo himself, but like Frank better!
FRANK!!!<3
What?!!!! Definetly Piper.Reyna is too serious
Jack's wrote: "I'm pretty sure Piper and Jason's relationship is going to be torn up in HoH(I hope). Here's my really crazy theory...You know how Rick loves to use the Greek myths for PJO and HOO? Like how LT w..."
never seen a more mature post. I agree. This could be really good if this happens.
Either way, as most said, piper with Jason, since Reyna deserves better.
Please don't kill me for saying this but I have a feeling Rick will probably kill Reyna off in battle or something; like a true Roman soldier...
Nightlockiss wrote: "Piper annoys me very much (But still nor nearly as much as Bella Swan) so I will have to choose Reyna."Hahaha :) I agree! Bella is annoying -.-
Reyna, even though I hope she finds someone better than Jason. Although she probably will die or become possessed or something.
Piper. Because he loves her and Rick Riordan approves.
To be honestI think Jason would definitely pick Piper because Jason and Piper had been through more together.
(SPOILER)
In the MARK OF ATHENA Jason introduced Piper as his girlfriend to Reyna.
But I'm also a Jason and Piper fan so YEAAHH.
Reyna, the way I see it Jason and Piper have two personalities that do not go well in the relationship and in the mark of Athena Jason seemed kinda off even thought Piper was there. every alpha male needs an alpha female and lets face it Piper may be special but she is no alpha
reyna!!!! pipers memory about jason is not real. it was made by hera (or juno, whatever). reyna and jason will be a better couple with real memories and charmspeak-free. i wish they stayed a bit longer so they can have a relationship.
oh my gods Piper is perfect for Jason shes pretty awsom
Definitely Piper, she is perfect with Jason
Reyna...she is much more sensible. Piper is selfish I feel...
I think he should be with Piper. I respect Reyna and all, but I hate it when authors make the main character dump the first girl/boy when they meet the second girl/boy. That's just me. :)
PIPER!!!!!!!! I mean, duh... Obvious choice...
Piper!!Reyna seems to old for him
Honestly, I would choose Piper. Maybe back then before Jason lost his memory, he would have certainly been with Reyna and they would have been a perfect couple, but now with all the experiences he has had with Piper, it just seems obvious who he would be with.However,(view spoiler)
Piper, defiantly if Jason chooses Reyna i will want to through the book and scream. besides i think Piper is much nicer then Reyna anyway.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
The Son of Neptune (other topics)
Books mentioned in this topic
The House of Hades (other topics)The Son of Neptune (other topics)
Why? Because Reyna is strong. She is selfless. She is a leader. She is a fighter. She is a victor. She is a praetor. She deserves the best. Jason Grace, after how much he's hurt her, doesn't deserve Reyna.
Piper, on the other hand, hasn't done anything much to deserve the best. She gets what she wants from charmspeak. She's rich but she hates it, pretty but she hates it...does she have any idea what most people would give to be like her?
So Jasper. I am, anyway, among the minority who thinks that Leo/Reyna would be cute. Have since the Son of Neptune.
Besides, I'll have to call on one of Suzanne Collins's ideas. Reyna and Jason are really alike; sensible, serious praetors. I'm thinking Piper and Leo will level them up to be normal. Whereas Reyna and Jason would just clash, collide and end in sadness because they are too alike.
Piper and Jason all the way. Nothing you can say will sway me. Besides, it's the only pair left when I ship Leyna, Percabeth and Frazel way hard...and I wouldn't put Jason with Drew or Piper with *shudder* Octavian.