The Son of Neptune
discussion
Piper or Reyna ? Who should Jason choose?
message 1351:
by
-Athina-
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jun 30, 2013 10:48AM
I think Piper is an interesting character as she isn't the typical demigod you would expect ! Her talents lie elsewhere and in my opinion this makes her a perfect match to Jason who is like the perfect hero !! Reyna and Jason are too much alike...(but Reyna still is one of my favourite characters)
reply
|
flag
Jason does not deserve Reyna. So all that leaves is Piper...
Piper and him are a better couple than him Reyna, though I do feel bad for Reyna. Hopefully she will get a boyfriend.
Sara-Daughter of Poseidon wrote: "Piper and him are a better couple than him Reyna, though I do feel bad for Reyna. Hopefully she will get a boyfriend."well that would mean a lot of couples !!
Sabrina *The REAL Princess* wrote: "Reyna, those 2 have an actual history and besides, if you like percabeth imagine that instead of Jason wondering who it will be, it was Percy. Then you'd all choose Annabeth, because those 2 actual..."I like Piper better because I KNOW her, and according to Son of Neptune, the Rena/Jason relationship was mostly Reyna, and Jason slightly. I see that you like Reyna better for Jason and I'm not trying to change your mind, but don't take it out on the character, she's still an awesome character. Hating Piper because you like Reyna better would be like hating Jason because Percy's more awesome. Not really fair right?
Kimber~!! wrote: "Piper disgusts & annoys me"Well that's...wonderful
Sabrina *The REAL Princess* wrote: "Reyna, those 2 have an actual history and besides, if you like percabeth imagine that instead of Jason wondering who it will be, it was Percy. Then you'd all choose Annabeth, because those 2 actual..."Klio wrote: "Sabrina *The REAL Princess* wrote: "Reyna, those 2 have an actual history and besides, if you like percabeth imagine that instead of Jason wondering who it will be, it was Percy. Then you'd all cho..."
:I like Piper because of her personality, she actually acts a lot like me in some ways. Our family isn't rich, that's for sure, and plenty of people are pretty without trying, you probably are to, she doesn't get all the guys, Percy's still with Annabeth, Travis still likes Katie, Nico didn't seem to take much interest in her, and LEO? He hits on every girl he sees, but wouldn't do it to Piper. She breaks the Aphrodite kid stereotypes, but she's still Aphrodite's daughter, so she's still pretty, Aphrodite isn't going to just *POOF*make her ugly because she doesn't like pink. She cares about more than her relationship with Jason, Percy and Annabeth are falling to their deaths right now and do you really think she's only thinking about Jason at this point? Probably NOT...
She was so insecure at the beginning, she didn't think she was pretty, she didn't like herself at all, so she was struggling with the whole, Jason lost his memory thingamadoohicky. She get's scared, she's gets lonely, just like a real person, and like all people, she has lots of flaws, even the whole insecure thing, I had that problem, but now, I'M OVER IT. Now, people really should stop fighting over Piper, because I KNOW, there is no way to change someone's opinion on something, on the internet.
Klio wrote: "Kimber~!! wrote: "Piper disgusts & annoys me":I like Piper because of her personality, she actually acts a lot like me in some ways. Our family isn't rich, that's for sure, and plenty of people are pretty without trying, you probably are to, she doesn't get all the guys, Percy's still with Annabeth, Travis still likes Katie, Nico didn't seem to take much interest in her, and LEO? He hits on every girl he sees, but wouldn't do it to Piper. She breaks the Aphrodite kid stereotypes, but she's still Aphrodite's daughter, so she's still pretty, Aphrodite isn't going to just *POOF*make her ugly because she doesn't like pink. She cares about more than her relationship with Jason, Percy and Annabeth are falling to their deaths right now and do you really think she's only thinking about Jason at this point? Probably NOT...
She was so insecure at the beginning, she didn't think she was pretty, she didn't like herself at all, so she was struggling with the whole, Jason lost his memory thingamadoohicky. She get's scared, she's gets lonely, just like a real person, and like all people, she has lots of flaws, even the whole insecure thing, I had that problem, but now, I'M OVER IT. Now, people really should stop fighting over Piper, because I KNOW, there is no way to change someone's opinion on something, on the internet.
Ok, I just have to know, please someone answer me!I recently read The Son of Neptune and now I'm terrified to buy The Mark of Athena, because do you not see how wrong everything can turn out? It ends with the romans on edge about this combat-ready flying ship, and it pretty much depends on Reyna, who has NO idea about Piper and thinks that Jason is gonna go running to her and just marry her or whatever. And I feel a storm coming in Percabeth's way also! The partial prophecy makes me feel like they're gonna have some serious bumps in the road of their relationship..
And don't even get me started on Frank and Hazel. I'm afraid for Frank's life and what's gonna happen when Hazel meets Leo, and what's even going on.. just ... phew *breathe!*
Who's chosing who and who's gonna die and am I going to cry and do I risk my emotional stability??
RISK IT OF COURSE !!!!! How could you not ??!! This book is worth it and don't be too worried about how everything is going to work out, just trust Rick to do it right :)
PIPER!!!! OBVIOUSY THEY CONNECT... ITS LIKE PERCY AND ANNABETH... COMPLICATED.
Kaila wrote: "PIPER!!!! OBVIOUSY THEY CONNECT... ITS LIKE PERCY AND ANNABETH... COMPLICATED."complicated is not always good.
true. But it's not always bad...
Piper... I love them together.
Peacerose wrote: "Piper... I love them together."They seem so at ease with each other unlike him and Reyna... It is kinda forced upon him, the way it is said that ALL the camp "group leaders" wind up together.
Eh...just kill off Jason. Problem solved!
*ducks as Jasper and Jayna fans throw knives at her*
*ducks as Jasper and Jayna fans throw knives at her*
Piper, what Jason feels for her is real now. Plus he left Reyna at the camp and went with Piper, granted he did it to save the world but if he loved Reyna and not Piper he would have brought Reyna along.
If Jason has to be with anybody, it should be Piper. Who needs Reyna. It would be hilarious if Reyna and Leo started going out.
Kayla wrote: "If Jason has to be with anybody, it should be Piper. Who needs Reyna. It would be hilarious if Reyna and Leo started going out."That would be funny but I would hate it, I like Leo best when he's free to stupidly flirt with girls, it makes him funnier!
Bookcrazed wrote: "Piper, what Jason feels for her is real now. Plus he left Reyna at the camp and went with Piper, granted he did it to save the world but if he loved Reyna and not Piper he would have brought Reyna ..."Yes! That's what I've been saying all along, but no one listens to a think I say so...
Kaila wrote: "Peacerose wrote: "Piper... I love them together."They seem so at ease with each other unlike him and Reyna... It is kinda forced upon him, the way it is said that ALL the camp "group leaders" win..."
Totally!
Ms. sHORT Tempered wrote: "just curious...how could it be forced upon him, when we really don't have his POV since getting his memory back?"Because, even if it isn't in his POV, you see the way he acted around Reyna, kind of restless, like he didn't know what to say, he seems more at ease with Piper, to me at least. Also, it was still forced on him before he lost his memory, he never says that he even really loved Reyna, but since they were both preator, he kind of had to be with her, right? At least, that's what I took from it... I love Reyna's character, and I sort of feel bad for her, losing Jason and all, but I think Jason should be with Piper. Reyna deserves someone who will make her happy and loves her as much as she loves them, and in this case, I'm not sure Jason does.
Emily Ann wrote: "Jason does not deserve Reyna. So all that leaves is Piper..."Well then...I guess you could put it that way if you really want to...
I think Piper because she does anything for Jason but I do feel really sorry for Reyna because Jason and Percy rejected her
Kimber~!! wrote: "Piper disgusts & annoys me"Shame on you!!!
PIPEEEEEEEEEEEER, but i still don't like her much
Piper, no questionIf reyna was better for him dont you think we would know more about her??
I think Piper all the way...who says him and Reyna even had a thing before he lost his memory?? And besides, I think that him and Piper would make a cute couple. Reyna seems to rule-bound and mean...evil roman
You know what really bothers me about these discussions? It's all about who Jason should choose, all about the love triangles, when it should be about the intricately woven, interesting characters that Rick created. He didn't make characters for us to argue about who they'd end up with. More people need to realize that.
Kimber~!! wrote: "Piper disgusts & annoys me"Yessssss
Kimber~!! wrote: "Reyna!! She is strong and obviously loves & misses Jason very much.Piper's just a selfish, whiny character who does nothing for anyone.
At least Reyna has some depth."
Exactly
i think piper and jason should be with each other. jason and reyna are too serious and they need someone less serious like the thing with percy and annabeth. now im not saying being alike is bad but when your too alike and roman-like it gets a little bland and boring. someone has to bring the fun to the relationship. OH and how is piper whiny. she complains but she definetely needs to be part of the quest. she does do things and judging her because she's a little insecure means you're also very shallow. besides those are all in her head not aloud so nobody on the quest knows that's how she thinks. anyway percy also complains a lot but i dont see anyone complaining about that
I love Reyna more than any of the other demigods and I want her to have all the happiness in the universe after everything she went through in HoH but I think it's pretty clear that Jeyna will never go canon ( Yay! Because Jason doesn't deserve Reyna). As much as I dislike Jiper, it's pretty obvious that Uncle Rick is sailing in this annoying ship.Anyway, idc because what matters to me is that Uncle Rick leaves Reyna alone and stops pairing her to any more guys because it's annoying and just cut her some slack. Reyna can make do without Jason. Heck she can be Praetor without help ( she already did it) although that wasn't the case by the end of HoH. My ultimate OTP right now is Reyna/ Happiness and I will ship it even if it ends up sailing in the Cocytus River or any other river in Tartarus.
Piper, because in
The House of Hades
Jason said he'd never loved Reyna, and Cupid suggested that Jason had found his true love in Piper. But I like that Jason and Reyna remained friends. :)
Drew wrote: "Piper, because in The House of Hades
Jason said he'd never loved Reyna, and Cupid suggested that Jason had found his true love in Piper. But I like that Jason and Reyna remained friends. :)"
Yep. It's pretty obvious Jiper is really canon with Cupid saying that and everything and Jason wanting to stay in CHB and be with Piper so yeah. Reyna/ Happiness 5ever!
as much as i dislike piper, i think jason and her are good together
I do like both Reyna and Piper, but I like Reyna so much more than Piper - a girl who is strong on her own and is so capable. Still, I'd like to see her with Jason - but let's be realistic, I knew Piper and Jason had to be together, because Riordan isn't good at actual plot twists and doesn't want to make any of his fanbase upset at him.So, Reyna, all the way. Even though I'd be shocked if it actually happened.
Piper all the way.
he should choose reyna but he will always choose piper. reality isnt always that fun
I was going to say Reyna, but I don't think so anymore. She deserves someone better.
I HATE PIPER!!! So, Reyna. (But I'm not really that much of a fan of Jason either, I'm kinda a Percy girl)
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
The Son of Neptune (other topics)
Books mentioned in this topic
The House of Hades (other topics)The Son of Neptune (other topics)
