The Son of Neptune
discussion
Piper or Reyna ? Who should Jason choose?
message 51:
by
Emily
(new)
Nov 26, 2011 10:16AM
Ehh I choose Reyna. Piper and Jason, they just have no history! I mean they went on one quest but that's like it.Reyna.. She may have trouble with showing her feelings but that's because she's a leader and she probably doesn't want to show weakness. But I can tell she misses and loves Jason <3 Piper's cool and all but seriously.. She can date Leo or someone else. And maybe if Jason shows any indication of choosing Reyna then Piper will probably turn all Aphrodite and like so something about it.. But if that doesn't work out and he chooses Piper (which I hope won't happen!) then Reyna and Leo should go out:) I mean Leo has to end up with someone!
reply
|
flag
reyna deffinetly jason knew her longer
whoever says something about piper cause reyna tried to date percy thats bull she wanted percy to take the position of praetor so octavian wouldn't even if it took any means necassari
reyna because i am sick of piper
i dont like piper that much in the first place
truebut dont listen to me
i read the lost hero before the percy jackson and the olympians seris
ive read anything rick riordan wrote
im having alot of conversations rite now i might take longer to respond
ya and i seen you in almost all of the ones im in
Kimber~!! wrote: "lol..I have read all of Riordan's work except the Kane Chronicles... I have read Percy Jackson & The Olympians, The Demigod Files, Heroes of Olympus, and even the 39 Clues books he wrote...but not ..."Why haven't you read the Kane Chronicles???? They're REALLY good... Though they are Egytian instead of Greek.
I am sorry but Piper just gets on my nerves she is such a BICH in my mind. Like how she thinks she can just have Jason when she doesn't even know if he has a girlfriend, it just makes me so mad!!!
I agree that Piper should be with Jason and Loe with Reyna.
i think jason should choose reyna and piper go with leo. makes sense to me. percy and annabeth. hazel and frank. leo and piper. jason and reyna.
Piper because she is nicer and seems to really like jason. reyna and jason are better off as friends than bf and gf
plus Reyna was mean to Percy when he arrived at camp jupiter
she did have good reason when you think about it... not that I'm defending her!!
Sandra wrote: "plus Reyna was mean to Percy when he arrived at camp jupiter"well, this is about jason, piper, and reyna. percy is not in this. plus, reyna was only mean to him because she is praetor, and some people considered him a threat. to make matters worse, he was greek.
Krystal wrote: "I agree that Piper should be with Jason and Loe with Reyna."i agree
people stop hating on Piper!!!! jeez!! oh and PIPER!!!! i really don't like Reyna very much... she's a good character but really she seems to think that because Jason was praetor with her that he should automatically "date" her. ya know what i mean??
I just wanted to say, I would like Jason and reyna to be together. Now before people start screaming at me, let me tell you why.
At first, I wanted Jason and piper to get together.
But now, that is different. True, Jason and reyna didn't have anything going on to suggest they were bf and gf. But have you thought about how lonely reyna was while Jason was away? She had to put up with Octavian and the entire twelfth legion by herself. I don't mean she's weak, but she's been through a lot. Piper doesn't deserve Jason. Why? She charm speaks people into doing what she wants them to do. She's not as bad as drew, but she mainly does it for attention. Have you thought about that?
PIPER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
reyna was unfaithful to jason, and piper would never move onto somebody like that!
Sophia wrote: "reyna was unfaithful to jason, and piper would never move onto somebody like that!"How was reyna unfaithful?
Reyna. The few above me have stated why. Plus, Piper is weak and unless and a strong character like Jason with someone like her is just clique disappointing.With that said, since those two were together in the first book, there's about 99% chance that it'll be Jason and Piper (Barf.) in the end.
Dani wrote: "Reyna. The few above me have stated why. Plus, Piper is weak and unless and a strong character like Jason with someone like her is just clique disappointing.With that said, since those two were..."
I find that sad
piper because after reading the son of neptune, you can tell reyna is a bit selfish and angry.
Susie wrote: "piper because after reading the son of neptune, you can tell reyna is a bit selfish and angry."
Lol, so true.
Deena Beena wrote: "Susie wrote: "piper because after reading the son of neptune, you can tell reyna is a bit selfish and angry."
Lol, so true."
How would you feel if someone you liked disappeared for eight months, and Octavian keeps on bugging you on becoming a preator?
I don't have an opinion on this yet, I think that Reyna will be very displeased with Piper, though. I want to say that he'll wind up with Piper, but I can't decide right now.
i like reyna better than piper. but i think piper and jason are a good match. reyna deserves someone more like percy... but not percy.
I don't think we got to know Reyna well enough in SoN to really get a feel for what she is like. We just know the stressed praetor Reyna and not the actual person Reyna. I'm holding off on deciding who I want Jason with, I think. :)
JEYNA!!! Why? I have a million reasons.
1. You've heard in the Son of Neptune about how Reyna frantically searched for Jason. Do you want her heart to break because Jason chose Piper? I've read the fanfics about Jason choosing Piper and they break your heart.
2. Reyna's known Jason for four years. Piper's known Jason for about 8 months. Plus, how much does Piper really know about Jason?
3. Venus/Aphrodite could be influencing Piper and Jason. Do you really think that Aphrodite would favor Reyna over her own daughter? That's not true love.
4. Also, for those who say, "Oh, Jason didn't remember Reyna like Percy remembered Annabeth." Oh really? What if Aphrodite made it like that? What if Juno couldn't wipe away Percy's memories but that was because Aphrodite was favoring him? Huh? So you can't say that Reyna meant little to Jason if he remembered part of her after his quest.
5. Next up, Reyna and Jason are so PERFECT for each other. Why? Because Piper glorifies Jason. She thinks he's perfect. Let's look at Percy and Annabeth. Does Annabeth think that Percy is perfect? No. But he's her seaweed brain. Piper, on the other hand, can only see his glory. Reyna sees everything about him clearly.
6. If you people are thinking that Piper and Jason have to be together to unite the two camps, then you're WRONG! That wouldn't be true love, now would it?
7. Rick Riordan, I hope you're reading this, because if you think that Jasper is the way to go, then you better be ready to face my WRATH!!!!!!!! X:(
Kelsi Calliari wrote: "Piper all the way. Reyna had her chance but didn't take it. So she can just date another random person."
That has to be the MOST INSENSITIVE COMMENT I HAVE EVER HEARD!!!!!! How DARE YOU just say that Reyna should date another person?!?!?!?!?!? Do you know how much Jason and Reyna have been through?!?!?!?!!? Piper, sure she's okay, but REYNA IS AMAZING!!!! Do you know how much pain Reyna would go through if Jasper or Jiper happened?!??!?!?!?!?!? AND YET YOU ACT AS IF IT DOESN'T MATTER!!! AND I DON'T CARE THAT I'M TALKING ABOUT FICTIONAL CHARACTERS!!!! HOW WOULD YOU FEEL IF YOU WERE REYNA?!?!?!?!?!?!?!??!!??!?!?!?!?! SO LEMME TELL YOU ONE MORE TIME, STOP BEING SO INSENSITIVE AND ACTUALLY FRICKING THINK FOR A FRICKING MINUTE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
1. You've heard in the Son of Neptune about how Reyna frantically searched for Jason. Do you want her heart to break because Jason chose Piper? I've read the fanfics about Jason choosing Piper and they break your heart.
2. Reyna's known Jason for four years. Piper's known Jason for about 8 months. Plus, how much does Piper really know about Jason?
3. Venus/Aphrodite could be influencing Piper and Jason. Do you really think that Aphrodite would favor Reyna over her own daughter? That's not true love.
4. Also, for those who say, "Oh, Jason didn't remember Reyna like Percy remembered Annabeth." Oh really? What if Aphrodite made it like that? What if Juno couldn't wipe away Percy's memories but that was because Aphrodite was favoring him? Huh? So you can't say that Reyna meant little to Jason if he remembered part of her after his quest.
5. Next up, Reyna and Jason are so PERFECT for each other. Why? Because Piper glorifies Jason. She thinks he's perfect. Let's look at Percy and Annabeth. Does Annabeth think that Percy is perfect? No. But he's her seaweed brain. Piper, on the other hand, can only see his glory. Reyna sees everything about him clearly.
6. If you people are thinking that Piper and Jason have to be together to unite the two camps, then you're WRONG! That wouldn't be true love, now would it?
7. Rick Riordan, I hope you're reading this, because if you think that Jasper is the way to go, then you better be ready to face my WRATH!!!!!!!! X:(
Kelsi Calliari wrote: "Piper all the way. Reyna had her chance but didn't take it. So she can just date another random person."
That has to be the MOST INSENSITIVE COMMENT I HAVE EVER HEARD!!!!!! How DARE YOU just say that Reyna should date another person?!?!?!?!?!? Do you know how much Jason and Reyna have been through?!?!?!?!!? Piper, sure she's okay, but REYNA IS AMAZING!!!! Do you know how much pain Reyna would go through if Jasper or Jiper happened?!??!?!?!?!?!? AND YET YOU ACT AS IF IT DOESN'T MATTER!!! AND I DON'T CARE THAT I'M TALKING ABOUT FICTIONAL CHARACTERS!!!! HOW WOULD YOU FEEL IF YOU WERE REYNA?!?!?!?!?!?!?!??!!??!?!?!?!?! SO LEMME TELL YOU ONE MORE TIME, STOP BEING SO INSENSITIVE AND ACTUALLY FRICKING THINK FOR A FRICKING MINUTE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Patricia Marie wrote: "Lλμπλ,thΣ wrote: "I agree with u....BUT ....wont Reyna stab her or something and then we would NEVER see Piper again....[CREEPY LAUGH]WA HA HA"
HAHAHA. Nice point! But I don't think so. I think Re..."
Uh, no. Reyna isn't stupid and shallow. If you've read the SON, then you would know how she would act.
HAHAHA. Nice point! But I don't think so. I think Re..."
Uh, no. Reyna isn't stupid and shallow. If you've read the SON, then you would know how she would act.
listen guys!! it doesnt really matter what WE think! what matters is what's going on in RR's head and what he puts down on the page!! so stop arguing and unite as fellow HoO & PJ fans!!!!!sorry, didn't mean to go all preachy on you... :)
I don't like either of them, but if I had to choose- piper, reyna had nothing on him, and she's too creepy
i agree, reyna is creepy....
i like them both but i like reyna better because piper is just so umm... annoying and stupid but she-s okay. reyna is more confident and smart and more kickass!!
i think he'll choose piper because she ,like,loves him.but Reyna has had the cute back story and stuff.
no,no,no i totaly agree with you,but all in all i like piper.
I like Piper and I think that piper and Jason are going to hook up and if you remember Aphrodite doesn't really like Percy so then why would she leave his memories of Annabeth? She won't and Hera was the only god or goddess who know about the switch. NO One know untell after it had happened. Plus like I've said before I think Leo and Reyna are going to hookup. it makes so much more scene for Leo and Reyna to be together scenic they both don't have Boy/girlfriend. Jason and Piper true has not known each other for long but with what they have been through how could something not happen between them?
PIPER!DUH!Reyna's is so,plain.A few days trying to decide and jasons gonna fall all over piper. DUH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Samantha-J wrote: "Piper duh, I love Reyna, but I would always imagine her as a huntress of Artemis."ya i can see that :)
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
The Son of Neptune (other topics)
Books mentioned in this topic
The House of Hades (other topics)The Son of Neptune (other topics)
