The Son of Neptune
discussion
Piper or Reyna ? Who should Jason choose?
reyna.you have all changed my mind.i've spent agonizing weeks trying to decide so RR better be spending 1000x more agony over it than me!but it must be stressful to know that the whole world is depending on you.
REYNA! she is the best choice and piper is freaking annoying and clingy
hmm... well i like them both. and i don't really know what may have been between Reyna and Jason, maybe they where just good friends, and that Reyna wanted them to be more... who knows??? we haven't gotten much info on that... and as with Piper, yes her memory's of being a couple with Jason may have been fake, but the quest they went on, and the feelings that they grew for each other were not.
and i also believe that Reyna should end up with Leo, because like im sure many others have said... he like the pretty girls out of his league. and inst that what Reyna is??? a smart, pretty girl who is WAY out of his league???
Marisa wrote: "REYNA! she is the best choice and piper is freaking annoying and clingy"i yes i agree that Piper is clingy, but i still find he the batter choice...
Sabrina wrote: "Reyna, those 2 have an actual history and besides, if you like percabeth imagine that instead of Jason wondering who it will be, it was Percy. Then you'd all choose Annabeth, because those 2 actual..."How dare you say that about Percy and Annabeth????!!
1.Annabeth and Percy have a serious relationship and have CHARACTER!Reyna/Jason are too, you know, quiet.They don't love each other that much.
2.I don't think they've gone through all the stages yet.I mean Percy and Annabeth have fought, and have done all this stuff together, went through the awkward stage, and fighting over each other(in this case,annabeth vs. rachel).with Jason /Reyna, reyna never shows a trace of what she's done with jason and you can't have a relationship that deep w/o showing it.
3.Percy doesn't find any1 else to fall in love with and annabeth keeps trying to find him so he's pretty much safe.
4.You know they have closer relationship because Annabeth goes personally looking for Percy.Reyna doesn't.
5.The gorgons' blood helped Percy remember so he keeps away from other girls.
6.He found people/things to remind him of Annabeth(that monument,remember?and nico and tyson)
7.His case wasn't as serious as Jason's so he REMEMBERED liking a girl called Annabeth whom he was real close to.
Sonia wrote: "Sabrina wrote: "Reyna, those 2 have an actual history and besides, if you like percabeth imagine that instead of Jason wondering who it will be, it was Percy. Then you'd all choose Annabeth, becaus..."I AGREE ALL THE WAY!!! with the Percy Annabeth thing...
ARGGGGGGGHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDKIDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDKIDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDKIDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDKIDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDKIDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDKIDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDKIDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK IDK
RR,I HATE YOU FOR PUTTING ME IN THIS MESS! OTHER PEOPLE FRET,TOO,OKAY!!!
Cathryn wrote: "Sonia wrote: "Sabrina wrote: "Reyna, those 2 have an actual history and besides, if you like percabeth imagine that instead of Jason wondering who it will be, it was Percy. Then you'd all choose An..."FINALLY,someone gets my point!
Cathryn wrote: "hmm... well i like them both. and i don't really know what may have been between Reyna and Jason, maybe they where just good friends, and that Reyna wanted them to be more... who knows??? we haven'..."If she's WAY out of his league, she won't go for him.But they'd be a good match cause Reyna's so blunt/serious and Leo is the exact opposite.I heard somewhere two people who are alike don't go together well.
Sonia wrote: "Cathryn wrote: "hmm... well i like them both. and i don't really know what may have been between Reyna and Jason, maybe they where just good friends, and that Reyna wanted them to be more... who kn..."yes they would :)
i would say piper cuz i know her better, but then again, reyna is kinda like annabeth's equivalent and, well, percabeth is the cutest thing so i guess jeyna would be too
He'll probably pick rayna (sadly) because they already dated....but..... I wish I could say he would pick piper but.....
yeah, i mean, i think piper is way more awesomer...but, jason could have different opinions...
@Pjrox:Reyna is NOT the equivalent of Annabeth!We have too little info on Reyna so I'm not sure I want to make a judgement.
i pretty sure she is, she's mature and territorial just like annabeth and her boyfriend is the leader of the roman camp and annabeths boyfriend is the leader of the greek camp...they're literally the same thing
Okay, they have some similarities, but annabeth's personality is waaay different and you can't find the - the- the WONDERFULNESS that you find in annabeth in reyna.(reyna is a bit tooo territorial.if jason agreed to go on the quest, she'd stay back and say she couldn't leave the roman camp unattended.Not annabeth.)
ya, your rite...but, i mean, we can only see the WONDERFULNESS in annabeth cuz we've read about her in 6 books
Sonia wrote: "How dare you say that about Percy and Annabeth????!! 1.Annabeth and Percy have a serious relationship and have CHARACTER!Reyna/Jason are too, you know, quiet.They don't love each other that much...."
I think you misunderstood me. I ship 'percabeth' all the way. I love Percy and Annabeth together. That's why I enjoy Reyna and Jason, because, like percabeth, they were together first and had a history with one another (were praetors together).
Piper and Jason had no actual history, it was fictual.
A made-up relationship fueled by the fake memories created by Hera. And to now adress your points:
1. I agree, Annabeth and Percy have a serious relationship. But what stops Jason and Reyna to have the same? We know very little about the dynamic of Jason's and Reyna's relationship. For all we know, they could have had their own secret kiss. Quiet people can love each other just as much as loud My boyfriend and I are quiet around others but does that mean I don't love him just the same? By ourselves, we are quite loud and I can envision the same with Reyna and Jason, having to put on a facade due to the formality of the camp. Also, who says their quiet?
2. Well actually, you can have a deep relationship. Need an example? My boyfriend and I broke up for a week. I allowed myself to cry in the walls of my home but I put on a strong face outside. Reyna cannot show her remorse, she is praetor but within the 8 months of his disapperance, Percy is still able to realize that Reyna talks about Jason differently. And again, we don't know if they've gone through all those stages. To turn the tables, Piper and Jason haven't gone through those stages. She was always in love with him, they didn't fight (this disregards her "memories" as they were fake).
3. No, Percy doesn't, because he remembers Annabeth. He remembered her kisses and just her so that allowed him to be consience to not fall in love with someone else. Jason didn't have that privilege. Instead, he had a pretty girl claim to be his girlfriend and with no recollection of his memories and feelings for Reyna, he went with it.
4. Tell me, what responsibilities does Annabeth have that she is neglecting? Oh yes, the redesigning of Mount Olympus. I love Annabeth but leaving everything to find Percy might be a decleration of her love but also, she has responsibilities. Reyna has the entire legion to take care of, she cannot simply abandon everything in a futile search for Jason. With so many lives depending on her, she puts them infront of herself. Someone has to take of Rome.
5. Thank you for giving me yet another reason to support Jason. Percy got gorgon blood, Jason didn't get that option. Without the gorgon blood, I rekon Percy wouldn't not remember unless Hera lets him remember.
6. I do remember, and I thought it was very sweet. Unfortunately, Jason did not. Why? I don't know. Perhaps because Percy bore the Achilles curse therefore he was linked to Annabeth.
7. Percy did remember liking Annabeth. Refer to point 6. Jason, nearing the end, remembered a girl named Reyna.
Regarding Reyna's "Wonderfulnes" the Reyna we are exposed to is told through Percy's opinion. He hasn't had the chance to know Reyna as a person, only as an individual who is the praetor. Perhaps in the later books we'll be exposed to her "wonderfulness"
As a side note, I shall "dare to say" whatever I feel. This is a public forum and everyone has their own opinion. I ship Jeyna, you like Jasper. We'll see what ship actually comes reality when the next book comes because we must remember that the choice is not up to us but to Rick Riordan.
I like Reyna, but she's a little distant and we don't really get to know her than well in SoN. Besides, (even though it was just Mist) Piper THOUGHT she and Jason had something. I think RR will put Piper and Jason together... Don't know why yet... Strange psychic feelings? I think Reyna will be the one who's left out... Don't know why either... I developed these feelings from the Lost Hero though, so I'm not sure if I'll still feel that way if I read the SoN again. (I own the Lost Hero, read it over ten times, so I guess I'm connected to Piper. I read about Reyna for about 10 minutes.)
ya, i agree...wait, u rated the book 3 stars?
Sabrina wrote: "Sonia wrote: "How dare you say that about Percy and Annabeth????!! 1.Annabeth and Percy have a serious relationship and have CHARACTER!Reyna/Jason are too, you know, quiet.They don't love each othe..."about the quietness thing, it might mean that Reyna and Jason don't talk enough to know each other well enough to say they really have feelings and know each other. I think Sabrina might have been referring to a different kind of quiet? i dunno, that's just me. (i won't bother writing a long list of reason why i like piper+jason. it'll just be a waste of time because i know whatever i say, it won't convince anyone in the end.)
Grace wrote: "Sabrina wrote: "Sonia wrote: "How dare you say that about Percy and Annabeth????!! 1.Annabeth and Percy have a serious relationship and have CHARACTER!Reyna/Jason are too, you know, quiet.They don'..."That's true, it might mean that. I was talking about a different quiet, I meant in the sense that they weren't so affectionate and talkative about their relationship in public but alone they are themselves.
And I have come to respect other ships (no more throwing Piper off a cliff) and who knows - you might convince some people! I personally don't like Piper and Jason but everyone has their own opinions and you're free to express yours :)
Sonia wrote: "reyna.you have all changed my mind.i've spent agonizing weeks trying to decide so RR better be spending 1000x more agony over it than me!but it must be stressful to know that the whole world is dep..."Oh! Sorry, I must have misunderstood your misunderstanding (if that makes any sense). You ship Reyna and Jason! You just don't like the idea of Reyna being compared to Annabeth - correct? Well, we know too little of Reyna to judge but I apologize if I seemed rude to you in my previous post.
you people have changed my mind too, im rooting for reyna now... :)
Oooooo, Piper or Reyna! Well personally, I LOVE Piper's personality, but I like it also how strong Reyna is. Jason has definetly known Reyna longer BUT things felt WAY more romantic between Piper and JAson. Nothing with jeyna had never gone anyuwhere I felt. I don't know I love both!
piper annoys me i hope he picks Reyna. but what if Jason picks piper and Nico picks Reyna.
not likely, more like piper pix nico and jason pix reyna
ya, knowing rick, he might even bring some other guy into the picture and make it even more confusing
... I have been convinced and thoroughly confused...Okay, not really, I think RR will bring some other guy into the picture of maybe even just leave Jason a loner. Or someone is going to be a loner. This conversation/debate/whatever-this-is is really just focusing on Reyna and Piper, anyway, but since Piper and Jason's relationship was base on something false, and I agree with Maria that it feels like Jason and Reyna were just friends, Jason = Loner?
You never know...
Percyjacksonrox!!! wrote: "ya, i agree...wait, u rated the book 3 stars?"Yep, I did... Something wrong? Umm...? *shameful expression*
I just scanned through the comments by other people and realized they all rated either 4 or 5 stars. Oops?
total oops!!! ;) JK!! if that's you're opinion it's OK!!
Sabrina wrote: "Sonia wrote: "reyna.you have all changed my mind.i've spent agonizing weeks trying to decide so RR better be spending 1000x more agony over it than me!but it must be stressful to know that the whol..."s'okay...don't matter...i don't really understand what i wrote myself.but, yeah, i dont like reyna being compared to annabeth, thats the point.
esthermarie wrote: "Oooooo, Piper or Reyna! Well personally, I LOVE Piper's personality, but I like it also how strong Reyna is. Jason has definetly known Reyna longer BUT things felt WAY more romantic between Piper ..."no offense, but its kind funny thinking of reyna as STRONG(imagine muscles rippling across her chest, arm muscles tearing her shirt.)okay, i went a bit tooo overboard with that, but, LOL.
Percyjacksonrox!!! wrote: "not likely, more like piper pix nico and jason pix reyna"i dont think piper would pick the son of hades.her mom wouldnt like it, anyways.
Reyna+Jason>Piper+Jason?????RR......................................HURRY UP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
hmm...i thought leo wuz gnna be the loner of the 7 and the rest 6 would pair up...(sighs) u never no..
Okay:Hazel+Frank ; Percy+Annabeth ; Piper+Jason ; Leo/Nico/Reyna P.S.I said I WANTED Reyna+Jason not that it would be most likely.
If reyna's not going to b with Jason I'm pretty sure she'd end up single...
Reyna WOULD end up single....That's probably going to happen, especially since Piper IS one of the main characters AND a daughter of Aphrodite,so she'd probably have a role like that.*Sigh* It's too bad. She's a brat.
lol, yeah
Piper. Jason already admitted that he liked her and Reyna seems a little shallow and we don't know a whole lot about her. It's actually rather ironic. Most children of Aphrodite will be self centered but it's the other way around this time
Piper totally deserves Jason and Jason deserves Piper! There is just no question about it.
Piper is a total flunk. She's annoying, and a stupid daughter of Aphrodite. Now tell me again. Who is Aphrodite? Oh, right, the goddess of LOVE AND BEAUTY. I remember that one. Reyna, however, is a daughter of Bellona. The Roman goddess of war. She deserves Jason much more than Piper does. Leo suits Piper so much better. And Piper's so called ^relationship^ with Jason was a trick of the Mist! And Reyna deserves someone. She is a true leader and praetor of Camp Jupiter, a fierce fighter, only wanting the best for her camp and legionnaires.
Percy/Annabeth
Jason/Reyna
Hazel/Frank
Leo/Piper
Percy/Annabeth
Jason/Reyna
Hazel/Frank
Leo/Piper
i like the matches...then no one is single! and i think it's the most likely...
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
The Son of Neptune (other topics)
Books mentioned in this topic
The House of Hades (other topics)The Son of Neptune (other topics)
I want Reyna to be with Leo...and besides, doesn't Leo like a girl which is ver..."
Emily Danielle wrote: "I like Reyna more than Piper BUT Piper should be the one who would end up with Jason...they were so good together...
I want Reyna to be with Leo...and besides, doesn't Leo like a girl which is ver..."
oh ya i can so see that! lol