The Son of Neptune
discussion
Piper or Reyna ? Who should Jason choose?
message 201:
by
Andrea Mika
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Mar 23, 2012 06:38AM
Definitely Reyna! Piper just annoys me... agrees with Kimber~!!
reply
|
flag
I prefer Reyna because she is strong & brave like come on she held a camp for like 8 months. Piper would have the camp a mess. No one knows the real relationship between Reyna & Jason it could be like Annabeth & Percy they start out as friends. So Piper could just be a fling. I hope Reyna & Jason gt together like in a real relationship cuz they sort of seem alike loyal , brave, and the kind of ppl u want along side in a battle. So definetly Reyna.
Kimber~!! wrote: "Reyna!! She is strong and obviously loves & misses Jason very much.Piper's just a selfish, whiny character who does nothing for anyone.
At least Reyna has some depth."
Kimber~!! wrote: "Piper disgusts & annoys me"
I agree with you Piper seems very whiny.
Kimber~!! wrote: "Piper disgusts & annoys me"Agreed 100%
Sonia wrote: "Not really cold, more ....SHARP and attentive, I guess. Sharp like sorta quick to answer???...Oh, also, PJrox, what do you mean, put them together? Does this have anything to do with contemplating ..."no, well, if Jason chooses reyna then everyone would be together
Frank kind of bugs me with the fact that he's with Hazel and everything, but after seeing Leo, Hazel definitely does know that she's in trouble because he looks exactly like Sammy! Besides, Hazel and Leo are my two favorite characters, they need to have relationship! Frank could go with... his grandma! Not like that, just he needs her, really, just, oh he has plenty of time to find who's right for him! There are still three more books!
Robinnbastar wrote: "i really dont know and a lot of people here pick Piper.the thing is we dont get to know Reyna enough in the Son of Neptune.
I'm not so sure.
how about.....
Can he have both?
*take of sunglasses*
o..."
Hell to the Yeah!
Kimber~!! wrote: "Piper disgusts & annoys me"How come?
Samantha-J wrote: "Piper duh, I love Reyna, but I would always imagine her as a huntress of Artemis."I thought that about Reyna too.
Lena wrote: "Samantha-J wrote: "Piper duh, I love Reyna, but I would always imagine her as a huntress of Artemis."I thought that about Reyna too."
Well her sister is an Amazon
Yes, it just works. Also, she reminds me of someone I know who has vowed to give up sex for three years (long story). So that obviously doesn't help.
Yeah piper is so annoying! Go Reyna all the way! Piper is annoying, selfish, rude, and whiny! I think that it should be Hazel and Leo, frank and piper, Jason and Reyna, and percabbeth. Sorry if this was a private chat but yeah I don't like the sound of Piper and Jason. Go Jayna!!! But i did think Reyna kinda hated guys so you never know! maybe Reyna will join the hunters. Plus there is always a chance she will be the queen after Hylla.
I can't choose a side. I mean Reyna and Jason could have had a thing before Jason's memory got stolen. and in the book Reyna said she misses Jason. on the other hand Jason really likes piper and Piper really likes Jason.Piper is awesome and love the fact she cares a lot for her dad and Reyna is cool I love how her mom is Bellona and shes a warrior
@ PJrox:Ohhh,now I get it.
I don't really know much about Bellona so I'm not gonna judge Reyna on her. Plus, if you try to compare a demigod to his/her parents, you'll find only a few similar characteristics. I think.
I've never read son of neptune, but I've read the lost hero. So......... Well, unless Jason was already in a comitted relationship with Reyna then I say Piper! Or maybe still Reyna..... Piper can't just steal him away like that... Reyna was there first! But.... you know what, as long as it isn't Drew, I don't care all that much.
Sabrina wrote: "Reyna, those 2 have an actual history and besides, if you like percabeth imagine that instead of Jason wondering who it will be, it was Percy. Then you'd all choose Annabeth, because those 2 actual..."Yes, if it were Percy. By reading the comments I can tell that Reyna and Jason were never in a committed relationship, so why does it matter if Jason chooses Piper? Percy and Annabeth were actually in a relationship, and loved each other alot. He can't just all of a sudden back out of that.
Piper he aleady admitted at the end of the book that he 'liked her a lot' but I feel bad for Reyna
I dont understand that some poeple say Jason loves Piper that is false he admitted he LIKES Piper alot but he felt GUILTY for feeling that way about her. Yeah sure Piper likes him back but only because of the false memories Hera/Juno she put in her head. Unlike Piper, maybe Reyna and Jason were taking things slowly. Remember in The Son of Neptune Reyna said that if hadnt have left her and Reyna wouldve had a relationship. Proof right there that something was blossoming between. Also, Reyna admitted at the end that she missed Jason alot. Reyna also tried to keep Jason's spot as preator open waiting for Jason to return until she had to give the spot to Percy or eles Octavian was going to be preator which was a big no no. See also no one knows the real relationship between Reyna and Jason only that there was a spark between them. Sure Reyna seemed arrogant and chin held up high but only because she was preator she had to show no weakness. If I recall in The Lost Hero Jason had this cold stare when he was battling I think if I remember well. Reyna has known Jason for 4 years and Piper has known him for like what a couple of months and you poeple claiming Jason and Piper love each other like get real. Jason and Reyna had something. He remembered Reyna at the end of the quest that she ment something to him. But all you Jasper fan claim that the relationship between Reyna and him wasnt that deep like really at least he remembers her and she is IMPORTANT to him. Piper doesnt seem right for him Aphrodite can favor her daughter and give her Jason but do you think that is true love???? I thought so. So Jason and Reyna all the way. Jason seems attracted to Piper only by looks a pretty face doesnt work in this situation. I also believe that Jason was not attracted to Reyna because of her looks but because of her personality. Personality can go a long way no matter how you look.
Piper or Reyna that's tough because piper only knew him because of the mist at first and Reyna he knew since he was little
Stray wrote: "I don't know Reyna that well so... Piper"thats a good point
Hopefully Piper!!!
I agree I rather have someone eles new to be with Jason than Piper.
Okay, I read the beginning of The Throne of Fire and it says how Sadie liked Walt and he kept giving her guilty looks and I think he's gonna go for Jaz later on so I think it could be like that with Reyna is Jaz and Sadie is Piper and Jason is Walt. After all, they were both written by RR.And I don't literally mean pose Piper as Sadie.*Shudder*
@Nancy:I know I said someone new but I didn't really mean it like that but if that's what you're thinking okay but I meant I wanted Jason to go for Reyna but I wanted someone else to , well, I dunno, tip the balance, add to the confusion, you know.....
I guess I'm not making much sense.
jason and reyna...piper is a daugther of aphrodite (thats love and beauty people) she would look cute with anyone! reyna is the daughter of bellona,goddess of war,and would value traits like loyalty,strength and so she would not know how to express her emotions,but it doesn't means she doesn't have any...and come on..reyna and leo would never work... she lost her home on circe island, so in a way she needs someone who is stable and wouldn't run away...leo said it himself... he runs whenever things get tough...
@rawr?:Yeah,but that's in the mortal world, he probably wouldn't run away from the demigod world and all you people who are thinking 'but every DG hates the Demigod world wouldn't he want to run away?', I think if RR did something like that with Leo feeling all confused and all that sort of hero stuff that I laugh at sometimes he'll still probably choose the DG world authors make every hero do that, HP, PJ,plus RR wouldn't add something like that maybe in my opinion.
Reyna cause she was his first love and she loved him while Piper it was a vision that made her think that she was dating Jason, but they did seem to get to like each other, but Reyna was his first love soooo I think its her. :):)
Meh, Juno is screwing things up, but is it for a good reason, or is it on a whim? Or is it both?
Reyna, for sure.
Seriously, Reyna is in almost the same situation as Annabeth, except that she and Jason didn't have an official, public relationship the same way Percy and Annabeth did. The books are written so you'll kind of be biased toward Piper, but I definitely am rooting for Reyna. Reyna seems so much more real, and think of all the history she and Jason have together - to say that Piper and Jason have been "through so much together" might be true, but it's only a sliver compared to what he's been through with Reyna. He defeated the Titans with Reyna. I think that's got to amount to something. So to say that Piper and Jason have been through "so much together" is a very weak argument in this. And honestly, who do you expect him to pick? A girl who's been in his life forever, quite possibly loves him (as it is implied), and has fought side-by-side with him for years, or would he pick the girl who has just come into his life, and they've been forced together with fake memories?
Personally, I think Piper/Jason is much to cliche and very forced, even if their feelings at the end don't seem that way.
Seriously, Reyna is in almost the same situation as Annabeth, except that she and Jason didn't have an official, public relationship the same way Percy and Annabeth did. The books are written so you'll kind of be biased toward Piper, but I definitely am rooting for Reyna. Reyna seems so much more real, and think of all the history she and Jason have together - to say that Piper and Jason have been "through so much together" might be true, but it's only a sliver compared to what he's been through with Reyna. He defeated the Titans with Reyna. I think that's got to amount to something. So to say that Piper and Jason have been through "so much together" is a very weak argument in this. And honestly, who do you expect him to pick? A girl who's been in his life forever, quite possibly loves him (as it is implied), and has fought side-by-side with him for years, or would he pick the girl who has just come into his life, and they've been forced together with fake memories?
Personally, I think Piper/Jason is much to cliche and very forced, even if their feelings at the end don't seem that way.
I sooooo don't like Juno. Even if she is trying to help she is going about it the wrong way and is messing up all the demi-gods' lives. Plus, she acts sort of, like, well, she should be thanked and honored for her GREAT deeds and her role in screwing things up. Some goddess.
At first, I wanted Piper. Then I reread Son Of Neptune and realized that Reyna is awesome. I like Piper, but Reyna is the best person ever. She's strong, but she's still nice and, unlike Clarisse (I think that was her name), was able to feel emotions other than anger. I wish some chapters were from her perspective.
I do not know Reyna as well as Piper, or how she acts infromt of Jason. If she gets all war-like with Piper, i think Jason will try to protect Piper, but as Jason said in the Lost Hero, he liked Piper, a lot. If he chooses Piper, Reyna will feel bad, but she'll have other guys and well, if he chooses Reyn, Piper is kinda left hanging with Leo. I hope Jason chooses Piper because she's the daughter of Aphrodite (not that that matters XD) and she's nicer in my eyes.
piper all the way, and Jason didn't really like Reyna.Still a chance that later in the book when Jason receive his memory he might know Reyna better.
so even even
Very true. But still Reyna.
Piper. No competition
Reyna is okayPiper is also okay.....
Well their technically is because Jason is going to have to pick Piper or Reyna.
okay... maybe Reyna
Well I hope it's Reyna.
jason and hazel... are ganna datejust kidding
its going to be reyna
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
The Son of Neptune (other topics)
Books mentioned in this topic
The House of Hades (other topics)The Son of Neptune (other topics)
