The Son of Neptune
discussion
Piper or Reyna ? Who should Jason choose?
message 701:
by
Nancy
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Aug 08, 2012 03:23PM
I don't get the part she's the only one fighting for him? Jason felt guilty for liking Piper we still don't know how much he likes Reyna we only know that he likes her.
reply
|
flag
Lauren wrote: "I think he will totally choose Reyna because most of Jason and Piper's relationship was made up by Hera(Juno)"sorry but your wrong hera olny put jason on that bus with leo and piper cause they had a quest to rescue her and jason and pipers relationship was caused by the MIST!!!!! duhhh remember wat u read .....but dont u remeber aphrodite said that piper could make the possibilittes true so she ment that piper had a chance to be with jason
Nancy wrote: "I don't get the part she's the only one fighting for him? Jason felt guilty for liking Piper we still don't know how much he likes Reyna we only know that he likes her."well ya but wen piper was tell ing the story she wanted jason to be with her and she was fighting for him but reynas and jasons relationship wasnt deep so maybe piper and jason will be together thats wat im hoping for
Elisa wrote: "Nancy wrote: "I don't get the part she's the only one fighting for him? Jason felt guilty for liking Piper we still don't know how much he likes Reyna we only know that he likes her."well ya but ..."
Why? Are you Reyna? Is that why you know how she feels? Please answer.
Elisa wrote: "Lauren wrote: "I think he will totally choose Reyna because most of Jason and Piper's relationship was made up by Hera(Juno)"sorry but your wrong hera olny put jason on that bus with leo and pipe..."
had a chance but not necessarily end up with him.
Elisa wrote: "Sabrina *The REAL Princess* wrote: "Reyna, those 2 have an actual history and besides, if you like percabeth imagine that instead of Jason wondering who it will be, it was Percy. Then you'd all cho..."That's because Reyna didn't even if Jason is even alive (yet she kept the position open for him). Piper, on the other hand, knew that Jason had a past, with or without some other girl.
Mercedes wrote: "Elisa wrote: "Nancy wrote: "I don't get the part she's the only one fighting for him? Jason felt guilty for liking Piper we still don't know how much he likes Reyna we only know that he likes her."..."Was that meant for me? Or for the other girl?
Nancy wrote: "Mercedes wrote: "Elisa wrote: "Nancy wrote: "I don't get the part she's the only one fighting for him? Jason felt guilty for liking Piper we still don't know how much he likes Reyna we only know th..."Sorry... =(( It wasn't meant for you. I was just curious about what the one who commented on your post has to say...
Nancy wrote: "Mercedes wrote: "Elisa wrote: "Nancy wrote: "I don't get the part she's the only one fighting for him? Jason felt guilty for liking Piper we still don't know how much he likes Reyna we only know th..."Sorry... =(( It wasn't meant for you. I was just curious about what the one who commented on your post has to say...
PIPER 4EVER! REYNA IS SUCH A JERK AND I HATE HER SO MUCH!
Emilee wrote: "PIPER 4EVER! REYNA IS SUCH A JERK AND I HATE HER SO MUCH!"
Why is Reyna a jerk? Why do you hate her it's not like your Piper?
whoa...what the heck did Reyna ever do to you? LOL calm down...Im more of a Jeyna fan but I don't hate Piper, I just dislike her (but thats only cuz shes Aphrodites kid and I find her to be a bit stuck up)
Emilee wrote: "PIPER 4EVER! REYNA IS SUCH A JERK AND I HATE HER SO MUCH!"
If there is someone who is a jerk here, it is someone who can hate a character that does not even exist because you are actually insulting Rick Riordan who made her.
Hey! I'm sorry guys! I don't hate Reyna! My friend, Katy knows my password to goodreads and she usually answers these convorsations! She does hate Reyna and I am totally a Jeyna fan. Sorry for the confusion!
Emilee wrote: "Hey! I'm sorry guys! I don't hate Reyna! My friend, Katy knows my password to goodreads and she usually answers these convorsations! She does hate Reyna and I am totally a Jeyna fan. Sorry for the ..."It's okay. =) This is a forum to express your thoughts. The answer that I gave earlier was meant to anyone who thought of it that way as a personal opinion to what that person posted not because she ships what. XD
I guess we're going through this again.... let's just not have it get out of hand.
hm...i think of all the forums, this one has to be the most entertaining.... :D
Ummmmmm. Its Piper obviously, she helped Jason when he had no one, while Reyna just sat their, she didn't even look for him.
Hahahahha this forum is hilarious
either one. i donnt like one more than the other
I have nothing against Piper and all. Reyna is just my personal preference.
Definitely Piper I love them together they are so cute together!
kit kat wrote: "Ummmmmm. Its Piper obviously, she helped Jason when he had no one, while Reyna just sat their, she didn't even look for him."She had people looking for him for 6, maybe 8, months and was borderline unprofessional when she had his spot open for that long hoping he would come back or that they would find him.
kit kat wrote: "Ummmmmm. Its Piper obviously, she helped Jason when he had no one, while Reyna just sat their, she didn't even look for him."Umm...Reyna didn't just sat there. She ran Camp Jupiter & was in battle when the camp was being attacked. That's not sitting down. That's called getting your butt up & doing something.
Jasmine wrote: "kit kat wrote: "Ummmmmm. Its Piper obviously, she helped Jason when he had no one, while Reyna just sat their, she didn't even look for him."She had people looking for him for 6, maybe 8, months ..."
Agreed! 100%
Nancy wrote: "kit kat wrote: "Ummmmmm. Its Piper obviously, she helped Jason when he had no one, while Reyna just sat their, she didn't even look for him."Umm...Reyna didn't just sat there. She ran Camp Jupite..."
Exactly. She had a lot of responsibilities she couldn't just drop everything and leave like Annabeth was able to do.
Ah haha. Was looking back on the debates with Reneered and Galini and laughing. I seriously didn't realize how ridiculous and hotheaded all the stuff sounded 'till now. :)
kit kat wrote: "Ummmmmm. Its Piper obviously, she helped Jason when he had no one, while Reyna just sat their, she didn't even look for him."How is she going to look for him when she is Preator(spelling). She has to be a leader in New Rome, and she did have people searching for him. Romans train and Reyna probably knows thatbwherever he is he can take care of himself. He fought a Titan,
And was she going to leave Octavian to lead while she was gone searching?
Maddie wrote: "Arti wrote: "Sabrina wrote: "Reyna, those 2 have an actual history and besides, if you like percabeth imagine that instead of Jason wondering who it will be, it was Percy. Then you'd all choose Ann..."Jeyna knwon each other for like 4 years, assuming.
Percabeth knowns each other for like 1 or 2 years more than them
So Im not happy that Jaspers official(demigod diaries)So they came back from their quest on the winter solstice like december 22 or near that day.
The Demigod Diaries story take place on Christmas. They are dating.
..... really 3 days plus however long their quest took is not enough to start dating -.-
Wait, how did you get that from Demigod Diaries? The only way I found out was through the preview for MOA.
Piper piper piperpiperpiper forever and everPison or Japer
♘ɢα'ѕ ɢυαrdιαɴ wolғ™ wrote: "Ah haha. Was looking back on the debates with Reneered and Galini and laughing. I seriously didn't realize how ridiculous and hotheaded all the stuff sounded 'till now. :)"I know, right?! :D Still prefer Piper, though :P
Galini wrote: "♘ɢα'ѕ ɢυαrdιαɴ wolғ™ wrote: "Ah haha. Was looking back on the debates with Reneered and Galini and laughing. I seriously didn't realize how ridiculous and hotheaded all the stuff sounded 'till now...."XD Same here. :)
I don't Know who he should chose his best friend or the girl he felt an instant connection to> It's so hard*Pulls Hair Out* But Jasper/Jioer is Cannon right now...
And PIper isn't that bad i wish i could Charmspeak...
PIper isn't that bad i wish i could Charmspeak...
Honestly, I love both characters. But I would have to pick Piper, she's just increadibly funny and doesn't take any crap from anyone. For all of you who are saying that Piper and Leo should end up together, what the heck?! They have NO romantic feelings for eachother! Their relationship is sort of like a brother-sister relationship. There was no romance whatsoever! And for all of you who say that Jason and Reyna had "history", how do you know that for sure? Jason and Reyna BOTH said that there MIGHT have been something between them, but no "for sure" relationship. For those comparing Percy and Annabeth to Jason and Reyna, Percy and Annabeth have an official relationship. They are boyfriend and girlfriend, the term is used between them. Realize how both Reyna and Jason didn't say that? So they are not the same, which doesn't mean we will all be on Reyna's side down the road. Piper and Jason actually have real feelings for eachother. It is proven.That's all I have to say. I love all the characters, but Piper is just overall the best for Jason.
Kay wrote: "Honestly, I love both characters. But I would have to pick Piper, she's just increadibly funny and doesn't take any crap from anyone. For all of you who are saying that Piper and Leo should end u..."Agreed. Leo and Piper do NOT have romantic feelings whatsoever, Piper is more like his older sister. It's kinda like saying Thalia and Percy should get together.
Bubbles wrote: "Piper. I really don't like Reyna all that much."
Ikr?
Loved Pipes, disliked Reyna.
Loved Hylla though~! <3
Ikr?
Loved Pipes, disliked Reyna.
Loved Hylla though~! <3
Ro wrote: "Bubbles wrote: "Piper. I really don't like Reyna all that much."
Ikr?
Loved Pipes, disliked Reyna.
Loved Hylla though~! <3"
I hated Piper who was hypocritial and annoying, loved Reyna.
Ikr?
Loved Pipes, disliked Reyna.
Loved Hylla though~! <3"
I hated Piper who was hypocritial and annoying, loved Reyna.
yeah I agree with Reneered, Piper is a bitch
TheEmoQueen wrote: "yeah I agree with Reneered, Piper is a bitch"
Yay!
I think Piper was shallow, hypocritical, and annoying. She became vegetarian because of a damn smell! I was a vegetarian when I read it and it really offended me.
Yay!
I think Piper was shallow, hypocritical, and annoying. She became vegetarian because of a damn smell! I was a vegetarian when I read it and it really offended me.
No she isn't u guys r assuming the Reyna is interested in Jason she said and I quote:"may have been something" plus she isn't one of the seven because the last one is a daughter of Athena and she isn't involved in the Nxt booksShe has nothing Rick riodan obviously isnt going to lead on rather same path as u guys r thinking
And BTW she probably didn't like the smell was ONE of her reasons wow u guys love to destroy good character
no offense!!!!¡
-A
A wrote: "No she isn't u guys r assuming the Reyna is interested in Jason she said and I quote:"may have been something" plus she isn't one of the seven because the last one is a daughter of Athena and she i..."She is interested in Jason. She spent anywhere from 6 to 8 months having people look for him while saving his spot as co-leader despite opposition. That was borderline unprofessional, which seems out of character for her, but she did it for him. She had a hopeful expression that Percy noticed when he was talking to her and when the ship came which was odd considering the ship was full of Greeks. We're not in her head like Piper so this is all we have to go on, but judging from the way Jason reacted as well it is clear that she has feelings for him. No offence A, but you are not Rick Riodan so you have absolutely no idea how the next book is going to go.
well sorry all u Piper fans, but Piper really is annoying, she was so obsessed about Jason & losing him, she barely knew him, at the end of the lost hero, when she says to Drew " dont go anywhere near Jason, he's mine" or something like that I swear I felt like punching her, not that I like Drew
TheEmoQueen wrote: "well sorry all u Piper fans, but Piper really is annoying, she was so obsessed about Jason & losing him, she barely knew him, at the end of the lost hero, when she says to Drew " dont go anywhere n..."
I love Drew, she has SO much more potential than Piper. I would've preferred it better if Drew was the daughter of Aphrodite in the prophecy. We could see great character development.
Because, honestly, at the end, when Piper dethroned her, she did NOT act like a high school queen bee. A high school queen bee would've fought back, hard. But she didn't, which leads me to believe that there was something in her past that made her feel like she needed power. Made her feel like she needed control. Maybe she knew that what she was doing was wrong but she continued being a bully for some reason. I would love to get to know Drew better.
I love Drew, she has SO much more potential than Piper. I would've preferred it better if Drew was the daughter of Aphrodite in the prophecy. We could see great character development.
Because, honestly, at the end, when Piper dethroned her, she did NOT act like a high school queen bee. A high school queen bee would've fought back, hard. But she didn't, which leads me to believe that there was something in her past that made her feel like she needed power. Made her feel like she needed control. Maybe she knew that what she was doing was wrong but she continued being a bully for some reason. I would love to get to know Drew better.
A wrote: "No she isn't u guys r assuming the Reyna is interested in Jason she said and I quote:"may have been something" plus she isn't one of the seven because the last one is a daughter of Athena and she i..."
Okay, first of all, where exactly in the book did it say that her becoming a vegetarian was ONE of her reasons? "Piper was vegetarian, for one thing. She had been ever since they‘d driven past that slaughterhouse in Chino and the smell had made her insides want to come outside." That is a direct reference from the Lost Hero. It did not say anything about her being a vegetarian for any reason besides that.
Wow, you just love to glorify a terrible character, don't you?
No offense, though.
-A very Piper-disliking Selene
Okay, first of all, where exactly in the book did it say that her becoming a vegetarian was ONE of her reasons? "Piper was vegetarian, for one thing. She had been ever since they‘d driven past that slaughterhouse in Chino and the smell had made her insides want to come outside." That is a direct reference from the Lost Hero. It did not say anything about her being a vegetarian for any reason besides that.
Wow, you just love to glorify a terrible character, don't you?
No offense, though.
-A very Piper-disliking Selene
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
The Son of Neptune (other topics)
Books mentioned in this topic
The House of Hades (other topics)The Son of Neptune (other topics)
