The Son of Neptune
discussion
Piper or Reyna ? Who should Jason choose?
Marisa wrote: "Galini wrote: "Marisa wrote: "Galini wrote: "Marisa wrote: "Galini wrote: "Marisa wrote: "Is this really a discussion? He's probably not going to choose either because I guarantee one of them will ..."I really hope none of them has to die... It would be terrible if one will die and the others would be so depressed..
Mercedes wrote: "Marisa wrote: "Galini wrote: "Marisa wrote: "Galini wrote: "Marisa wrote: "Galini wrote: "Marisa wrote: "Is this really a discussion? He's probably not going to choose either because I guarantee on..."IKR?! WE would be so depressed :'(
Marisa wrote: "Galini wrote: "Marisa wrote: "Galini wrote: "Marisa wrote: "Galini wrote: "Marisa wrote: "Galini wrote: "Marisa wrote: "Is this really a discussion? He's probably not going to choose either because..."I have noticed so too, but there aren't many chances for it. Thalia, I don't know, was a very main character in the first book and loved by a lot of readers, so I don't think Rick would make her get killed or something.
Galini wrote: "♘ɢα'ѕ ɢυαrdιαɴ wolғ™ wrote: "Galini wrote: "PIPER ALL THE WAY
Yay! Finally, a fellow Piper supporter. :D"
Haha, always was and always will be :D We don't even know yet if Jason EVEN likes Reyna."
May I quote "The day he'd gotten his tattoo. The day he'd been raised on a shield and proclaimed praetor. His friend's faces: Dakota, Gwendolyn, Hazel, Bobby. And Reyna. DEFINITELY THERE'D BEEN A GIRL NAMED REYNA." you know what the rest of the lines. Guilty.
Yay! Finally, a fellow Piper supporter. :D"
Haha, always was and always will be :D We don't even know yet if Jason EVEN likes Reyna."
May I quote "The day he'd gotten his tattoo. The day he'd been raised on a shield and proclaimed praetor. His friend's faces: Dakota, Gwendolyn, Hazel, Bobby. And Reyna. DEFINITELY THERE'D BEEN A GIRL NAMED REYNA." you know what the rest of the lines. Guilty.
Watermelon (In side joke.) wrote: "Galini wrote: "♘ɢα'ѕ ɢυαrdιαɴ wolғ™ wrote: "Galini wrote: "PIPER ALL THE WAY Yay! Finally, a fellow Piper supporter. :D"
Haha, always was and always will be :D We don't even know yet if Jason EV..."
Umm... if you had read the next comments, you would have noticed I said that he has feelings for her, but stronger for Piper. .___.
Galini wrote: "Reneered wrote: "Galini wrote: "Reneered wrote: "Galini wrote: "Reneered wrote: "♘ɢα'ѕ ɢυαrdιαɴ wolғ™ wrote: "Well, I don't think so. Percy didn't really remember Camp until he drank the gorgon's b..."
OH, ok, sorry about insulting Piper. Anyways, yay, fight's over. OMG, I have to study for my Latin exam on Monday!!!! My parent's are trying to get me to stop reading the Heroes of Olympus AGAIN, but I'm showing them all the latin words in it. :D
OH, ok, sorry about insulting Piper. Anyways, yay, fight's over. OMG, I have to study for my Latin exam on Monday!!!! My parent's are trying to get me to stop reading the Heroes of Olympus AGAIN, but I'm showing them all the latin words in it. :D
Marisa wrote: "rawr? wrote: "Marisa wrote: "Is this really a discussion? He's probably not going to choose either because I guarantee one of them will die in the next book."
:O...ohh I was so wondering if anyone..."
I'm not sure which one would die...but considering that RR is writing with the greek myths as his guide...I do think it's possible one of them (Piper or Reyna...or even both) could die...but he is also adding his own to the myths (and he is the writer of the story) so its possible he could also not kill anyone...
:O...ohh I was so wondering if anyone..."
I'm not sure which one would die...but considering that RR is writing with the greek myths as his guide...I do think it's possible one of them (Piper or Reyna...or even both) could die...but he is also adding his own to the myths (and he is the writer of the story) so its possible he could also not kill anyone...
Reneered wrote: "Galini wrote: "Reneered wrote: "Galini wrote: "Reneered wrote: "Galini wrote: "Reneered wrote: "♘ɢα'ѕ ɢυαrdιαɴ wolғ™ wrote: "Well, I don't think so. Percy didn't really remember Camp until he drank..."OMG, LATIN IS FREAKIN' AWESOME!!! Muaha, take that, parents :P Though I'm not sure my parents would care less if I showed them PJO or anything :(. I'm Greek and no one at my school even knows Rick Riordan *gasp*!!!
Galini wrote: "Reneered wrote: "Galini wrote: "Reneered wrote: "Galini wrote: "Reneered wrote: "Galini wrote: "Reneered wrote: "♘ɢα'ѕ ɢυαrdιαɴ wolғ™ wrote: "Well, I don't think so. Percy didn't really remember Ca..."
O_o You're GREEK???? OMG, that's SOOOOO COOLIO!!!! (Did I just say coolio??? Oh well...:P) So do your parents and you like, believe in the Greek gods? Or is that question 2 personal?
-A very nosy Scarlett Rose
O_o You're GREEK???? OMG, that's SOOOOO COOLIO!!!! (Did I just say coolio??? Oh well...:P) So do your parents and you like, believe in the Greek gods? Or is that question 2 personal?
-A very nosy Scarlett Rose
Lol, I wish I lived in Rome. My aunt bouoght me this awesome greek purse. She lives in London and goes all over Europe.
No fair. She lives in London??? That is totally unfair ):
lol, guys, we were talking about who we thought would die, and who jason should choose (though being Greek and learning latin is WAY cool!!) Also, i dont see what the big deal is about London, to be honest, its not that nice... I would prefer living somewhere more open and less...crowded (and rainy!)
Yeah I don't like London that much but she gets to travel all over Europe.
that would be nice, i hardly ever travel D=
Annabanana wrote: "lol, guys, we were talking about who we thought would die, and who jason should choose (though being Greek and learning latin is WAY cool!!) Also, i dont see what the big deal is about London, to b..."I'd like to visit there, but when my dad went to Manchester, he told us the weather is horrible compared to Cali, and that the food wasn't very yummy. I would enjoy traveling there once though, to see the architecture of Big Ben. :)
Galini wrote: "Reneered wrote: "Galini wrote: "Reneered wrote: "Galini wrote: "Reneered wrote: "Galini wrote: "Reneered wrote: "♘ɢα'ѕ ɢυαrdιαɴ wolғ™ wrote: "Well, I don't think so. Percy didn't really remember Ca..."How is that possible???!!! How does EVERYONE at your school not know about PJO?
I think Piper.maybe Reyna could be with,like,Leo or something,he rocks!
I dunno about living in London, but anywhere in Europe sounds awesome... *sigh* Where I live it's not crowded at all. It's kinda nice... And the mountains! Wow...
I'd feel really bad for either of them no matter who he picked. If he picked Piper, I'd feel bad for Reyna because she knew him before. But, if Jason picked Reyna, I'd feel bad for Piper because she actually was thinking that maybe she will get another (or actually first REAL) shot at Jason.
Hadley ・I LOVE HARRY POTTER!!!・FLUTTERSHY wrote: "I dunno about living in London, but anywhere in Europe sounds awesome... *sigh* Where I live it's not crowded at all. It's kinda nice... And the mountains! Wow..."Yeah, like i love the scenery here and the weather is excellent, but id like to move out of the city and 'see the world' (i know, chiche, but its tru)
Yeah. I live in a neighborhood where it's really pretty and quiet, and I love it here, but I'd really like to move to Europe...
TRU! I live exactly on the edge [of glory...lol jk] of my city, and im one street away from this huge grassland with nothing beyond that. I love the quiet but Europe is always so active, i think it would be a nice change
Yeah, it would (: A nice house somewhere in France, in the country where there's no one to bug me...
that would be great...*sigh* i have this weird urge to go out amd buy the next plane ticket to france...if only i would follow it!
@galiniThere's actually a forum on fanfiction.net called "I hate Piper McLean...." a lot of valid arguments there, if you want to check it out.
Hannah wrote: "@galini
There's actually a forum on fanfiction.net called "I hate Piper McLean...." a lot of valid arguments there, if you want to check it out."
OMG!! I read some of those posts, and I was like, "WHOA!" They have AMAZING points. I swear, they're Ivy League professors in disguise.
-A very wow-ed Scarlett Rose
There's actually a forum on fanfiction.net called "I hate Piper McLean...." a lot of valid arguments there, if you want to check it out."
OMG!! I read some of those posts, and I was like, "WHOA!" They have AMAZING points. I swear, they're Ivy League professors in disguise.
-A very wow-ed Scarlett Rose
OMG! I just had a thought! Okay, so, you know how Piper's weapon is Helen's old looking glass? And you know how Helen and Paris kept on being mentioned? And you know how "History repeats itself?" Okay, so what if, Piper is Helen who chose to be born into another life and Jason is Paris? Cuz that would explain a lot. Or Jason could be Helen (can that happen?) and Piper could be Paris...WTH did I just say? Anyways, in the end Helen (Jason) would go back to where she/he belongs. OR, in my Helen is Piper thought, Helen would be freed from Aphrodite's spell and go back to her husband. Either way, history would repeat itself! :D Whaddya think?
-A very curious to know what you think of my crazy (yet not crazy) thought Scarlett Rose
-A very curious to know what you think of my crazy (yet not crazy) thought Scarlett Rose
Reneered wrote: "OMG! I just had a thought! Okay, so, you know how Piper's weapon is Helen's old looking glass? And you know how Helen and Paris kept on being mentioned? And you know how "History repeats itself?" O..."
Well that is a possibility...But didn't Helen and Troy start a war?...And well since Piper and Jason(and the rest of the gang)are trying to unite 2 rival camps...well...it kind of doesn't leave much hope of defeating Gaea...which ultimately is the main point...
Well that is a possibility...But didn't Helen and Troy start a war?...And well since Piper and Jason(and the rest of the gang)are trying to unite 2 rival camps...well...it kind of doesn't leave much hope of defeating Gaea...which ultimately is the main point...
I don't really like the point of repeating history because I believe that people can change their destinies. Either ways, if they are the reincarnated version, I'd still pick Reyna over Piper.
rawr? wrote: "Reneered wrote: "OMG! I just had a thought! Okay, so, you know how Piper's weapon is Helen's old looking glass? And you know how Helen and Paris kept on being mentioned? And you know how "History r..."
I know, but it's obvious that the Roman and Greeks won't get along. The Trojan Horse could be symbolized as the Argo II without all the backstabbing. Plus, I was trying to find ways to prove that Jayna is possible.
-A Jayna-loving Scarlett Rose
I know, but it's obvious that the Roman and Greeks won't get along. The Trojan Horse could be symbolized as the Argo II without all the backstabbing. Plus, I was trying to find ways to prove that Jayna is possible.
-A Jayna-loving Scarlett Rose
Mercedes wrote: "I don't really like the point of repeating history because I believe that people can change their destinies. Either ways, if they are the reincarnated version, I'd still pick Reyna over Piper."
Yeah, I believe that you make your own choices and your path changes based on your choice. Like, with the Fates, the characters make their own choices and the Fates carve their destinies based on their choices. So, ultimately, you have the power to change your destiny.
-A very something Scarlett Rose (I couldn't think of something to put when I signed out)
Yeah, I believe that you make your own choices and your path changes based on your choice. Like, with the Fates, the characters make their own choices and the Fates carve their destinies based on their choices. So, ultimately, you have the power to change your destiny.
-A very something Scarlett Rose (I couldn't think of something to put when I signed out)
That 'history repeating itself' is a good point...Helen could finally be with her Paris! i love Jayna and all, but that would be a lovely twist,to add on to that, is it possible that Reyna might have been Helen?.
No. I hope its not going to happen that way but , *bite lip*, I have thought about that:
Jason: Paris (Eww I hate Paris)
Piper: Helen
Frank: Odysseus
Leo: Achilles (Or Hector)
Hazel: Cassandra
Percy: Hector (Or Achilles)
I hope not. I don't know what version you've heard, but the one I've heard Odysseus, Achilles, and Hector all die in battle, Cassandra tries to warn the people but dies, Helen was under a spell and died, Paris was a git and died.
Jason: Paris (Eww I hate Paris)
Piper: Helen
Frank: Odysseus
Leo: Achilles (Or Hector)
Hazel: Cassandra
Percy: Hector (Or Achilles)
I hope not. I don't know what version you've heard, but the one I've heard Odysseus, Achilles, and Hector all die in battle, Cassandra tries to warn the people but dies, Helen was under a spell and died, Paris was a git and died.
Kind of confusing but...isn't Jason sorta like Odysseus? And Piper could be his Calypso since the two of them meet when Jason's lost from Camp Jupiter. And Reyna is like Penelope.
Penelope? I don't know that myth, but if its better than the Trojan war I'm all for it!
Hannah wrote: "Kind of confusing but...isn't Jason sorta like Odysseus? And Piper could be his Calypso since the two of them meet when Jason's lost from Camp Jupiter. And Reyna is like Penelope."You've got a point. XD I always loved the "Penelope waiting for Odysseus to come home" story. XD
Amm...But doesn't Calypso already exist? Remember in Battle of the Labyrinth, when Percy went to visit her?
So, it would kind of be, er, confusing (for lack of a better word) to have Piper (or Reyna for that matter) reborn as Calypso when Calypso already exist?
So, it would kind of be, er, confusing (for lack of a better word) to have Piper (or Reyna for that matter) reborn as Calypso when Calypso already exist?
rawr? wrote: "Amm...But doesn't Calypso already exist? Remember in Battle of the Labyrinth, when Percy went to visit her?So, it would kind of be, er, confusing (for lack of a better word) to have Piper (or Rey..."
You're right... but I still can't help but imagine it. XD
Watermelon (In side joke.) wrote: "No. I hope its not going to happen that way but , *bite lip*, I have thought about that:
Jason: Paris (Eww I hate Paris)
Piper: Helen
Frank: Odysseus
Leo: Achilles (Or Hector)
Hazel: Cassandra
Pe..."
so they all died?...thats kind of sad :(
:P
I don't believe Odysseus died in the Trojan war though...he went home to his wife Penelope...
Jason: Paris (Eww I hate Paris)
Piper: Helen
Frank: Odysseus
Leo: Achilles (Or Hector)
Hazel: Cassandra
Pe..."
so they all died?...thats kind of sad :(
:P
I don't believe Odysseus died in the Trojan war though...he went home to his wife Penelope...
Piper! She's had it hard, and Reyna's okay and all, but he was never interested in her even before he was memory-jacked.. so, yeah.
We do Odyssey at my school (it sucks -_-),so I really like everyone's ideas xD But I'm not sure Rick have thought of it this way, even if it is such a great idea. It is highly unlikely to happen, sadly :(
Josey wrote: "Piper! She's had it hard, and Reyna's okay and all, but he was never interested in her even before he was memory-jacked.. so, yeah."True! Though he has been showed to have feelings for Reyna, it just they aren't as strong as the ones he has for Piper. :D
Galini wrote: "Josey wrote: "Piper! She's had it hard, and Reyna's okay and all, but he was never interested in her even before he was memory-jacked.. so, yeah."True! Though he has been showed to have feelings ..."
YAys someone gets it!!!!!!!
no way! piper all the way
Josey wrote: "Galini wrote: "Josey wrote: "Piper! She's had it hard, and Reyna's okay and all, but he was never interested in her even before he was memory-jacked.. so, yeah."True! Though he has been showed to..."
Haha, yeah xD
Hannah wrote: "no way! piper all the way"I agree with your opinion for Piper, but Reyna is bloody awesome, so... I would never call either of them weird... they're both brilliant xD
Josey wrote: "Piper! She's had it hard, and Reyna's okay and all, but he was never interested in her even before he was memory-jacked.. so, yeah."
Reyna's had it hard, too. Being a daughter of Bellona, being captured by pirates, being tortured, being praetor, leading the forces during the Titan War, watching your friends die all around you, losing your sister, and on top of it all, dealing with Octavian has to be hard. And it's way harder than Piper's past. Also, your statement of Piper having it hard and deserving Jason more doesn't make sense. It's like, "Annabeth had a hard past so she deserves Percy more than Rachel." No. As for Jason not showing an interest in Reyna, well we know that there was some chemistry between them. After all, she "made him feel guilty about what he was doing with Piper."
-A very factual Scarlett Rose
Reyna's had it hard, too. Being a daughter of Bellona, being captured by pirates, being tortured, being praetor, leading the forces during the Titan War, watching your friends die all around you, losing your sister, and on top of it all, dealing with Octavian has to be hard. And it's way harder than Piper's past. Also, your statement of Piper having it hard and deserving Jason more doesn't make sense. It's like, "Annabeth had a hard past so she deserves Percy more than Rachel." No. As for Jason not showing an interest in Reyna, well we know that there was some chemistry between them. After all, she "made him feel guilty about what he was doing with Piper."
-A very factual Scarlett Rose
Galini wrote: "Josey wrote: "Piper! She's had it hard, and Reyna's okay and all, but he was never interested in her even before he was memory-jacked.. so, yeah."
True! Though he has been showed to have feelings ..."
But the thing is, we can't figure it out yet. We don't know what Jason and Reyna have been through. For all we know, they could have MORE chemistry than Jason and Piper. We have to wait until Jason gets all of his memories back. *shakes fist at the sky* CURSE YOU JUNO!!!!!!!!!! OR HERA!!!! (whatever)
-A very curse-y Scarlett Rose
True! Though he has been showed to have feelings ..."
But the thing is, we can't figure it out yet. We don't know what Jason and Reyna have been through. For all we know, they could have MORE chemistry than Jason and Piper. We have to wait until Jason gets all of his memories back. *shakes fist at the sky* CURSE YOU JUNO!!!!!!!!!! OR HERA!!!! (whatever)
-A very curse-y Scarlett Rose
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
The Son of Neptune (other topics)
Books mentioned in this topic
The House of Hades (other topics)The Son of Neptune (other topics)
Yeah Nico for sure but I don't know about Thalia. She always has like a foreboding sense about her(if that makes sense). She seems like shes on the verge of death in every book.