Comfort Reads discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Chit Chat
>
Daily Chat
message 501:
by
[deleted user]
(new)
Feb 07, 2010 06:54AM
Haha! That would be fun, a book/football party with me in a germ mask.
reply
|
flag
Christine wrote: "Haha! That would be fun, a book/football party with me in a germ mask."
That's an interesting image!
That's an interesting image!
Lisa,
It was Shackleton's Stowaway
It's a YA book I grabbed for him to take on the plane. The author has created a novel based on published accounts, interviews and journals. My husband said it gave a bit more insight into Shackleton and his crew, but nothing new in the way of details. My husband prefers non-fiction -- he says it's better than anything anyone could make up.
It was Shackleton's Stowaway
It's a YA book I grabbed for him to take on the plane. The author has created a novel based on published accounts, interviews and journals. My husband said it gave a bit more insight into Shackleton and his crew, but nothing new in the way of details. My husband prefers non-fiction -- he says it's better than anything anyone could make up.

Lisa wrote: "Thanks Jeannette. I've never heard of that one. I know that there are a few of them. There are many good non-fiction polar exploration books!"
I will look through my shelves and post them on the appropriate thread and in the bookshelves. We went through a polar exploration phase a while back. I'll also check out what other members have posted. Always looking for books for my husband.
I will look through my shelves and post them on the appropriate thread and in the bookshelves. We went through a polar exploration phase a while back. I'll also check out what other members have posted. Always looking for books for my husband.

Lisa wrote: "Jeannette, I've actually read quite a few but haven't posted/shelved them here because for me they're not exactly comfort reads."
I don't consider a lot of the topics here as comfort reads, either (my definition is probably too narrow). I just thought I would add them to the thread for other members who might enjoy them.
I don't consider a lot of the topics here as comfort reads, either (my definition is probably too narrow). I just thought I would add them to the thread for other members who might enjoy them.

ETA: Meaning: I am adding my own cr books, which might be very different from others' cr books.
If I added all my faves, this group wouldn't have much meaning, in my opinion. Even though many of my cr books won't be cr books for others at least they're mine.

Most of my favorites aren't comfort books because they are usually quite depressing. I'm a misery reader for the most part.

I'm putting just my comfort reads here, and I hope other members will do the same.
Many of my favorite books are not comfort reads.
However, many of my comfort read books are favorites and are also quite depressing. I find comfort in depressing books - sometimes.
I think my comfort books are usually lighter books, which I read only every once in a while. It is interesting how our definitions of comfort vary.
Now I have to go smear that black stuff under my eyes and get my football attitude on.
Now I have to go smear that black stuff under my eyes and get my football attitude on.

Just to add, too, my fiance isn't much of a reader at all. He has countless stories of reading only the first few chapters of books, then acing the exam. I don't know how many times I've told him, "think about how much more rich and rewarding it would be for you, though, to actually read the whole thing!" Alas, I will settle for him encouraging my habits at least. It is interesting, though, that more often lately he tries to get me to talk about what I'm reading. Since I'm usually reading about 10 books at the same time, though, I think it gets a little confusing.
Lisa wrote: "Jeannette and Christine,
I'm putting just my comfort reads here, and I hope other members will do the same.
Many of my favorite books are not comfort reads.
However, many of my comfort read book..."
I've always been a little confused about what this group is really about. It seems to me that people get onto a topic and suggest their favorites to each other.
I agree with Gundula, most times "favorite" equals "comfort". Would you like the members to limit what they add to the bookshelves or what they discuss or both? I thought if I mentioned a book, it was hoped (by the moderators) that I would add it to the bookshelf. (for example, several people have asked for manga recommendations, but I don't know if they are comfort(ing) or that I just enjoy them).
I'm putting just my comfort reads here, and I hope other members will do the same.
Many of my favorite books are not comfort reads.
However, many of my comfort read book..."
I've always been a little confused about what this group is really about. It seems to me that people get onto a topic and suggest their favorites to each other.
I agree with Gundula, most times "favorite" equals "comfort". Would you like the members to limit what they add to the bookshelves or what they discuss or both? I thought if I mentioned a book, it was hoped (by the moderators) that I would add it to the bookshelf. (for example, several people have asked for manga recommendations, but I don't know if they are comfort(ing) or that I just enjoy them).



I would hope that the books people mention are comfort reads to them, favorites or not favorites.
If we start listing favorite books when they're NOT AT ALL comfort reads, then I think this group does get confusing.
Most of my comfort books are in my favorites, but I know people who have comfort reads that aren't their favorites at all. Also, I suspect most of us have favorite books that aren't at all comfort reads - I do - and I won't mention them in this group.
Just my take on things.
I think for the purposes of this group we are encouraging members to post and discuss their own personal comfort reads. What I've learned since we started is that many people have quite varied types of comfort reads and I would like this group to continue to be inclusive.
If you know of books that may interest someone else because we have a thread on the topic then I think it's a great idea to share them even if they are not personally comforting to you. I hope I'm making sense!
I'm very happy to hear that you guys like to hang out here. My intention was to create a warm and friendly group where we could share ideas.
If you know of books that may interest someone else because we have a thread on the topic then I think it's a great idea to share them even if they are not personally comforting to you. I hope I'm making sense!
I'm very happy to hear that you guys like to hang out here. My intention was to create a warm and friendly group where we could share ideas.

Lee, I think you've done that. Yay!



Lee wrote: "I think for the purposes of this group we are encouraging members to post and discuss their own personal comfort reads. What I've learned since we started is that many people have quite varied typ..."
Thanks, Lee, that's exactly how I feel. I love the discussions and the relationships that are developing between members. I think that is the most comforting part about this group.
Thanks, Lee, that's exactly how I feel. I love the discussions and the relationships that are developing between members. I think that is the most comforting part about this group.
I also think of comfort reads as books that make me laugh, feel nostalgic, happy or uplifted. But I also love the spy/thriller/adventure type of book as a comfort read too and those don't usually inspire those types of feelings. It's like seeing a good action movie, you forget yourself in a completely foreign world for a while.

Lisa wrote: "Lee wrote: "My intention was to create a warm and friendly group where we could share ideas."
Lee, I think you've done that. Yay!
"
You've done that for me...I love this group, it's my favorite.
Lee, I think you've done that. Yay!
"
You've done that for me...I love this group, it's my favorite.
Well, Christine -- I'm eating my words, my hat and one article of clothing of your choice! stunning!
Jeannette wrote: "Well, Christine -- I'm eating my words, my hat and one article of clothing of your choice! stunning!"
Hahaha!! You're too funny! And it should be noted that my first impulse was to get on here and post so we must be getting tight. :)
Hahaha!! You're too funny! And it should be noted that my first impulse was to get on here and post so we must be getting tight. :)
You mean tight as in close, I assume, even though I need another glass of wine after that mess. :(
Christine wrote: "Very Off topic...Jeannette, Does the pic that I put up on Dixie's blog look like dancing? I can't tell."
I'll have to check it out later tonight. We have to go pick up the kid from a SB party. (I'll check it out cuz I'm curious now)
I'll have to check it out later tonight. We have to go pick up the kid from a SB party. (I'll check it out cuz I'm curious now)
Jeannette wrote: "You mean tight as in close, I assume, even though I need another glass of wine after that mess. :( "
awww!!! Well, I'll try not to Woot too loudly.
awww!!! Well, I'll try not to Woot too loudly.
I left Dixie a post on her blog. Even she is celebrating!! Tell her I said Happy Birthday. :)

However, I do get that there are certain books or types of books that are more "comforting" than others.
For example, my husband, while a book lover, is a far more intellectual reader than I am. We do read *some* of the same books, but most of the time he wouldn't stoop to my level of fluff, LOL. The latest book he read is A Mind for Murder: The Education of the Unabomber and the Origins of Modern Terrorism by Alston Chase. Heavy stuff!
I don't think I would put that on my comfort list, either! :)
Yikes! I have too much of a freak-me-out factor to read a lot of stuff, and I think that might qualify.
Christine wrote: "Yikes! I have too much of a freak-me-out factor to read a lot of stuff, and I think that might qualify."
I'm the same way......
I'm the same way......
Hello Paula!
You haven't checked in since before the big game. Did your fiance' get home alright?
You haven't checked in since before the big game. Did your fiance' get home alright?
I was wondering too...I hope everything is okay.
Yikes, who felt that earthquake (midwest US)? We've been awake since 4:00 since my son can't relax now...he can't put this into perspective after what has happened in the world with earthquakes.
On top of that I was up late finishing Mudbound (awesome) and watching Lost (confusing). Need. Coffee.
On top of that I was up late finishing Mudbound (awesome) and watching Lost (confusing). Need. Coffee.
I haven't heard anything about an earthquake! Certainly not in Iowa. It actually woke you up?? I experienced a quake in Seattle, but it was day time. Off to check the news...
Everybody okay by you?
Everybody okay by you?
Wow, magnitude 4.3, just north of Chicago. Too far away for me. How close are you to Chicago? I bet that Paula noticed it, too.

And now earthquakes as well!


I feel for all those in the blizzard zone.
If I see one more snowflake, I might scream. We have no place to put the stuff we have shoveled off the drive and sidewalks anymore. The kids have missed 6 days of school, too. I feel sorry for the folks in DC -- at least here in Iowa we are used to the snow and cold.
Last report I read, the earthquake was pretty mild, so I don't think anyone was injured.
Last report I read, the earthquake was pretty mild, so I don't think anyone was injured.

Well, they won't be loving it in June! The Governor is considering letting the schools skip Spring Break, or go on Saturdays.


I had to go to school on Saturdays (in the mornings) when I was a child in Germany. I hated it. I think it would be better if they cancelled Spring Break. Also, for any family who is Jewish, sending the kids to school on Saturday would not be an option. I know one thing. If I had children, I would not force them to go to school on Saturdays, no matter what the governor etc. decreed.
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
No Angel (other topics)The False Prince (other topics)
Para Handy Tales (other topics)
Para Handy Tales (other topics)
Olivia Bean, Trivia Queen (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Jane Austen (other topics)Rebecca Stead (other topics)
Ken Jennings (other topics)
Neal D. Barnard (other topics)
Nigel Tranter (other topics)
More...