Short list, huh? I've started this list because there is shockingly little fiction out there geared towards women that doesn't center around a girl falling in love, most commonly with a dude. And it needs to be a thing.
Not that I have a problem with romance novels or fiction that is about/involves love or has romantic subplots, but I'm frankly bored with books about women chasing love. Love is great, but is it our raison d'etre? Of course not. Can we have experiences that don't involve the pursuit or the management of love/marriage? Can we exist without a soulmate by our side? Hell yes!
I mean really, the boys have Kerouac and Hemmingway and an overflowing cup of introspective life lessons, coming of age stories, bromance and platonic partnerships, and political intrigue. C'mon, our turn! I would really like to find more fiction that explores women as the complex and multi-faceted people we are. so, I present to you a list, however depressingly meagre, of work that doesn't make women feel like our existences are only validated by being someone's wife/girlfriend/mistress. Enjoy, and please add!
Update: Umm... I've noticed some ( or, a lot) of the books people have added to this list are Romantic Fiction; as in, romance - whether successful or not- is important enough to the plot of the book to be mentioned in the plot description of the novel. Specifically: The Dressmaker, the COVE!!!, Elizabeth Gilbert novels (The Signature of All Things), The Bride's Farewell, Becoming Clementine, A Ring of Endless Light, etc are all guilty of having romantic elements that are important to the plot. Perhaps my explanation was vague, so hopefully this clarifies what I hope this list will include..
New Criteria: if the novel has anything to do with romance it doesn't count. Even if the protagonist ends up single, or goes on a journey of self-discovery that involves forsaking poisonous relationships, or even if the romantic relationship is some kind of social metaphor, or the central plot is not completely about love but the novel spends a lot of time talking about love interests, it still involves someone's love life. To qualify for this list, the plot must not involve woman+romantic interest (s) unless the romance is so negligible it isn't even mentioned in the book description/can be completely removed from the novel in such a way that it in no way changes the essence of the story.
In short, this list is meant to be of novels that are completely AROMANTIC and have female protagonists.
Not that I have a problem with romance novels or fiction that is about/involves love or has romantic subplots, but I'm frankly bored with books about women chasing love. Love is great, but is it our raison d'etre? Of course not. Can we have experiences that don't involve the pursuit or the management of love/marriage? Can we exist without a soulmate by our side? Hell yes!
I mean really, the boys have Kerouac and Hemmingway and an overflowing cup of introspective life lessons, coming of age stories, bromance and platonic partnerships, and political intrigue. C'mon, our turn! I would really like to find more fiction that explores women as the complex and multi-faceted people we are. so, I present to you a list, however depressingly meagre, of work that doesn't make women feel like our existences are only validated by being someone's wife/girlfriend/mistress. Enjoy, and please add!
Update: Umm... I've noticed some ( or, a lot) of the books people have added to this list are Romantic Fiction; as in, romance - whether successful or not- is important enough to the plot of the book to be mentioned in the plot description of the novel. Specifically: The Dressmaker, the COVE!!!, Elizabeth Gilbert novels (The Signature of All Things), The Bride's Farewell, Becoming Clementine, A Ring of Endless Light, etc are all guilty of having romantic elements that are important to the plot. Perhaps my explanation was vague, so hopefully this clarifies what I hope this list will include..
New Criteria: if the novel has anything to do with romance it doesn't count. Even if the protagonist ends up single, or goes on a journey of self-discovery that involves forsaking poisonous relationships, or even if the romantic relationship is some kind of social metaphor, or the central plot is not completely about love but the novel spends a lot of time talking about love interests, it still involves someone's love life. To qualify for this list, the plot must not involve woman+romantic interest (s) unless the romance is so negligible it isn't even mentioned in the book description/can be completely removed from the novel in such a way that it in no way changes the essence of the story.
In short, this list is meant to be of novels that are completely AROMANTIC and have female protagonists.
Kat
617 books
26 friends
26 friends
Marilee
1598 books
52 friends
52 friends
Jennifer
3518 books
991 friends
991 friends
Claire
5716 books
1048 friends
1048 friends
Nadosia Grey
281 books
10 friends
10 friends
Susan
2239 books
75 friends
75 friends
Saturday's
2255 books
67 friends
67 friends
Ellinor
6719 books
624 friends
624 friends
More voters…
Comments Showing 1-25 of 25 (25 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Susanna - Censored by GoodReads
(new)
Jul 19, 2014 04:36PM
A Girl of the Limberlost? The second half is all romance.
reply
|
flag
Excellent list. Thanks so much. I would add Pulse from political and military fiction writer Robert Cook. In fact anything from the series is pretty awesome.It features a great female protagonist called Dr. Caitlin. A physicist who won a MacArthur fellowship in her early 20s and is just a super intelligent and strong female character. Something that is all too rare in such a genre. Overall it is a brilliantly written book with excellent attention to detail and a really exciting, fast paced story.
http://robertcooknovels.com/
The Yellow Wallpaper is on there twice.
I would add Black Girl/White Girl by Joyce Carol Oates. It's been awhile, but I don't think that it had any romance.
I would add Black Girl/White Girl by Joyce Carol Oates. It's been awhile, but I don't think that it had any romance.
The female protagonist (i.e., the unnamed narrator) in Sarah Orne Jewett's The Country of the Pointed Firs would make this book qualify on this list, but I would be somewhat weary of actually including this book on this list because one of the most important subplots in it involves a woman named Joanna ("poor Joanna"), who ends up living the remainder of her life as a recluse on Shell-Heap Island because her fiance left her and married another woman. As Mrs. Fosdick states in the book, "All her hopes were built on marryin', an' havin' a real home and somebody to look to; she acted just like a bird when its nest is spoilt" (Chapter 13).
Seems to me some of those books DO have romance. They may have powerful female protagonists that do things other than just fall in love but not all of the ones I see on this list are completely aromantic (just saying)
Removed for being explicitly mentioned in the list description as novels that do NOT qualify:The Signature of All Things
The Cove
The Bride's Farewell
Becoming Clementine
I like "Mistborn: The Final Empire" (#84), but it includes a fairly significant romance plot so I'm not sure it belongs here.
I just wanted to let you all know that you're using the word "aromantic" incorrectly. Aromantic is a romantic orientation that means someone experiences little or no romantic attraction to other people. It's an orientation not a choice. The way you're using aromantic to mean "a lack of romance plot" is incorrect and hurtful to aromantic people. This is the first list that pops up for "aromantic" and doesn't fit the orientation's criteria, so anyone looking for representation will be mislead. Please update your description.For more info: http://wiki.asexuality.org/Aromantic
Valley of the Dolls, page 2, is about romance as much as it's about addiction. One character chooses to die of breast cancer because her man adores her for her breasts, and without them, she feels she has no value. Do you want me to pull it down?
All of my novels analyze some aspect of love stories, but they are not romances: THE PROVIDER (2012), THE WAY THEY SEE (2013),CONCERNING GEORGIA STEKKER (2014), THE ROMANTIC IMPERATIVE ebook (2017), and coming in October AN INCIDENT IN THE FAMILY. Visit my website: EvelynMarshall.com
Evelyn wrote: "All of my novels analyze some aspect of love stories, but they are not romances: THE PROVIDER (2012), THE WAY THEY SEE (2013),CONCERNING GEORGIA STEKKER (2014), THE ROMANTIC IMPERATIVE ebook (2017..."
This is a clear and flagrant violation of Goodreads authors' policy. I have flagged your comment.
Good reads librarians are volunteers, and anytime a list that we are responsible for editing gets a comment, one of us is alerted to go to the thread in question. So you're basically setting off an auto-alarm to tell us that you're spamming the thread that exists for technical issues.
Karen Azinger has a wonderful series with a great heroine called The Silk and Steel Saga, starting with The Steel Queen. In addition to the heroine, there are several other very strong female characters, including one female antagonist who is excellent! https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1...
Miss Pettigrew Lives for a Day is definitely a romance - the whole book is about Miss Pettigrew spending a day with a woman who has three boyfriends and has to decide which she loves, with Miss Pettigrew's help.The Snow Child also has a romance which is a big part of the second half of the book, even if it's not the protagonist's romance. It certainly has a big impact on the ending and the plot itself.
Some other books you might consider for your list though:
How Saints Die by Carmen Marcus
Call of the Undertow by Linda Cracknell
The Good People by Hannah Kent
Akata Witch by Nnedi Okorafor
All the Light We Cannot See by Anthony Doerr
El Deafo by Cece Bell
Dreaming the Bear by Mimi Thebo
The Vanishing Act by Mette Jakobsen
The Quality of Silence by Rosamund Lupton
The Earth Hums in B Flat by Mari Strachan
Northern Lights by Philip Pullman (Will doesn't appear until the second book so this one's clear of romance)
Also possibly:
The Unseen World by Liz Moore (there is a vague kind of romantic suggestion right at the end, but it's of the negligible/easily removed kind that has no influence on the plot, so I think you'd be cool with it?)
Most of my favorite books have no romance in them or if they do, it's just incidental. I'm not aromatic but do get tired of a plot being pushed along with just a love interest. The characters are richer when not bogged down with the romance.
Lily wrote: "Miss Pettigrew Lives for a Day is definitely a romance - the whole book is about Miss Pettigrew spending a day with a woman who has three boyfriends and has to decide which she loves, with Miss Pet..."I'm not the maker of this list, but I would think that if a character is married or has a partner or even a love interest but it was a very small part and if the part about romance could be taken out and doesn't effect the book, I'd say sure. Like "her marriage was good" done. Like in the book "The Help" Skeeter had a love interest but he was used to make the character choose between love and her beliefs. But he is just incidental to the book and the plot doesn't rely on him. Also it is only a small part of the book and really isn't "romantic" at all.
Another example is in The Secret Life of Bees" one of the characters has a love interest but it's purely incidental and is a very small part. I think those are fine for this list.
Just my thought on this.
There are some books that I could just skip all the romance and it didn't change the plot at all. As if the author said "I better put some romance in this." It really bogs a book down.
Something I've noticed about many of these is that they focus on young women (of an age prior to when romantic relationships will become a consideration). Why aren't there more stories about adult women whose lives are not somehow defined by love and relationships? Is it because that is truly the central focus of our lives, or is it because that's what we've been told is the central focus of our lives?
...*looks through the list of books I've read in the last 5 years*
...
ok my list tops out at less than 20 =(
Removed because they don't fit the theme of the list:The Scarlet Letter
The Hunger Games
A Girl of the Limberlost
I also question, but didn't feel confident enough to remove:
The Hero of Ages
The Well of Ascension
Little Women
A Doll's House
The Hiding Place: The Triumphant True Story of Corrie Ten Boom
Related News
Here at Goodreads World Headquarters, we sort through a lot of books each month. Our monthly Readers' Most Anticipated Books feature is...
Anyone can add books to this list.















