THE WORLD WAR TWO GROUP discussion
Introduction to the WW2 Site - Please Say Hi
message 1401:
by
Rebecca
(new)
Dec 29, 2013 08:31PM

reply
|
flag



I am turning green with envy. The weekend my brother and I spent in Normandy in one of my fondest memories!
message 1406:
by
Geevee, Assisting Moderator British & Commonwealth Forces
(new)

Rebecca, welcome.

Welcome to the group, Rebecca. It's wonderful to see a younger person so interested in history.

message 1410:
by
Geevee, Assisting Moderator British & Commonwealth Forces
(new)

Welcome. From the photo I guess Kansas not the other Manhattan.

Manray9 wrote: "Jerry wrote: "I belong to other Goodread groups but just now discovered this which is exactly my cup of tea (with a little bit of milk, please)."
Welcome. From the photo I guess Kansas not the ot..."

I just commented in another thread, so thought I should introduce myself. Been lurking for a bit, and following/friended a couple of the members, but hesitant to join in as I don't think my reading is as dedicated as most of you. I have picked up some very interesting tips though, already.
I'm a (US) Army brat with a German mother, so I do a bit of reading in German too. My grandparents and mother escaped from the DDR in 1953 (Erzgebirge zone), so I have some interests in that area. Spent most of my childhood in the Stuttgart area. I've lived in Arlington, outside of Washington, DC, for a long time now, and up until a few years ago generally worked for defense contractors directly, mostly in international programs, and at one point worked a few years for USAF. But now I've been away from the military for a while and my reading has shifted away some too...
I generally prefer to read the broader, survey books about the war, and social histories, not so much the individual campaigns which is why I feel a bit inadequate compared to your member's knowledge. I do want to get more serious again in 2014, so hopefully will be around a bit.



Rick, sadly it's a case of 'you should ask before it's too late' - although I do know the basics of what they went through, there are a lot of things I now realize I wish I knew more about.
Long story, but my brother and I are the only ones left from either side of the family; really wish we had talked about it more with my mother, but I always thought there would be time.



please feel free to add a much or as little as you like - we don't bite :)
message 1426:
by
Geevee, Assisting Moderator British & Commonwealth Forces
(new)

I just commented in another thread, so thought I should introduce myself. Been lurking for a bit, and following/friended a couple of the members, but hesitant to join in as I don't think my..."
Hi Miss M and nice to see you here and a very warm welcome to the group. No specialist knowledge is required as we all learn from each other's reading and experiences so please don't feel you can'y join in.
Having patrolled the DDR/GDR border in the 1980s and been based in West Berlin for a while living with the Wall and seeing the border's frontier "defences" of metal fences, watch towers, tripwire and mines, the ploughed strip, the dogs and barriers close up I find your family story very interesting. To younger people today - and happily so - it looks like a fictional world where a physical barrier ran from the Baltic to Czechoslovakia.
As Rick says many of us have missed talking about family history - mine with very elderly uncles when I was a young lad who had served in WWI.

I just commented in another thread, so thought I should introduce myself. Been lurking for a bit, and following/friended a couple of the members, but hesitant to join in as I don't think my..."
Miss M: Welcome. Please pitch in whenever you feel like it. We have a diverse and interesting group with knowledge in many areas.

Hope everybody has a wonderful time ushering in the New Year, whichever time zone you're in!

Lee wrote: "Greetings, all.
I'm from Columbus, Ohio, a longtime reader of WW2 stuff. I'm also a wargamer (as in hex-board and counters)..."
I have several favorites, but the series I keep coming back to is GDW's /Europa/, for European & East Front operational stuff.

I'm very pleased to have found this forum. I wrote a book that was published in 2009 about one of the most ardent POW escapers of the war, my father.
Escape, Evasion and Revenge

Here's a link to a recent academic review of same:
http://www.journal.forces.gc.ca/vol12...
Best wishes and Happy New Year to all,
Marc Stevens
Toronto


If you like you can post details about you book on our author's page:
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...

Welcome to the group. I am sure you will feel at home here.
I just bought your book. It is the kind of book I like to read. I am glad you set your father a monument by writing his story.

Lee wrote: "Dj wrote: "It may have been asked before, but what is your favorite game?
Lee wrote: "Greetings, all.
I'm from Columbus, Ohio, a longtime reader of WW2 stuff. I'm also a wargamer (as in hex-boar..."

I'm very pleased to have found this forum. I wrote a book that was published in 2009 about one of the most ardent POW escapers of the war, my father.
[book:Escape, ..."
Wow, what a story. Thanks for tipping us to it.

Marc wrote: "Hello to all WW2 enthusiasts,
I'm very pleased to have found this forum. I wrote a book that was published in 2009 about one of the most ardent POW escapers of the war, my father.
[book:Escape, ..."
message 1439:
by
Geevee, Assisting Moderator British & Commonwealth Forces
(new)


https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...

I picked up Harold R. Winton's Corps Commanders of the Bulge based on your recommendation. Thank you.
So far, about 50 pages in, and impressed at the way he analyzes the different lectures and courses covered during the time the generals attended the various war colleges. The description of the Lee lecture reminded me of Lost Triumph, Lee at Gettysburg, where that author also tried to surmise the influence of Lee's actions at Gettysburg based on the influences of Napoleonic study at West Point when he attended.
While I thought author stretched his point quite a bit, it does make sense that officers in training would study the most recent examples of warfare and be unduly influenced on many levels by the actions of the prior war--the ol' "Generals prepare for the last war".
Book also reminded me that when I was in high school I read several novels that "projected" the continuation of the Star Wars trilogy, and one mentioned an Empire starfleet commander/general who guessed how his opponent would react by the person's culture.
So does knowing which military theory is stressed in a country's schools really provide a keen insight into what the general of that army will do? Can we truly see that influence when analyzing a past battle like Bulge or Kursk or France or Gettysburg, or are we benefiting from 20/20 hindsight?
Well off to finish the book but just food for thought out there.
message 1446:
by
Geevee, Assisting Moderator British & Commonwealth Forces
(new)

I think your final point is an interesting one and something that is still done and considered highly important by governments and their militaries today; perhaps even more so today in modern asymmetric war both prior and during operations at command/strategy level but also importantly out on the ground once forces are deployed (psychological operations or PsyOps).
Let us know your thoughts once you finished too.
message 1447:
by
Geevee, Assisting Moderator British & Commonwealth Forces
(new)

Welcome Heather and pleased you found us. Please feel free to jump in on the threads.

Welcome to the best little group on GR, Heather.

You may like my book Occupation and Insurgency, which deals with the holocaust/war crimes in the field on the eastern front, and I interviewed SS officers and Soviet irregulars.
Books mentioned in this topic
The Battle of Britain: Five Months That Changed History, May-October 1940 (other topics)Afterbursts: Reliving World War II (other topics)
MacArthur's WWII Seaborne Communications: CP Fleet reports, brochures, memos from the scrapbooks of a Signal Corps Commanding Officer (other topics)
Last Citadel: A Novel of the Battle of Kursk (other topics)
The Ghost Tattoo (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Stephen Harding (other topics)Alex Kershaw (other topics)
James M. Fenelon (other topics)
Günter K. Koschorrek (other topics)
Rick Atkinson (other topics)
More...