A Court of Thorns and Roses (A Court of Thorns and Roses, #1) A Court of Thorns and Roses discussion


7612 views
What do we think about the ending with Rhysand? [Spoilers]

Comments Showing 1,201-1,250 of 1,663 (1663 new)    post a comment »

message 1201: by Kelly (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kelly Oh man, I'm going to have to be super careful over on the acomaf tags now if there are major spoilers going on... I usually spend a good amount of time on them since I write a bunch of meta and character analysis (I'm xnightwolfx over there) haha. Aqsa warned me about spoilers now, so I'm gonna have to keep my eyes half shut if I go through those tags lol


message 1202: by Echo (new) - rated it 5 stars

Echo  Yeah, I usually cave in depending on the book. For Frozen Tides--I caved in. I started rereading it after exams and I liked it a lot better. For AGOS--I waited and waited even after I didn't have to. So much better.

Here are some things you could do:

You should probably block tumblr out once the book is released. There are lots of apps that you can download or settings that you can change to do so. You could also block 'acomaf' and 'a court of mist and fury' in general. (or just Rhysand--it's a really strange name. I doubt it will come up in your history research.).

Also, making sure the book is really hard for you to access is a great idea. Ideally, give it to someone. You could also keep the book unopened, duct tape it shut, and throw it in a closet in a different part of the house. I'm sure kindles operate the same way. (The car of a friend/parent/sibling who travels all the time is great as well--though I would wrap it in gift wrapping paper to not seem to crazy. Sending your friends a package monster-wrapped in duct tape come off...a little sketchy. )

Also, try reading paranormals or urban fantasy. Those are addicting and can deter you from thinking about acomaf. I say urban fantasy because high fantasies and contemporaries are harder to get into. Though, I repeat that paranormals are super addicting. So, be careful.

Did you preorder your book on an iPhone? If you are one of those individuals who has an older version of the iPhone, you can go ahead and delete that app. Or you can just delete the book in general. If you bought it, it should be in your purchases when you return exam-free.

And last but not least, writing tips for other people about how to delay your book anxiety (while suffering yourself) may help.


Souffle98 "I didn't care one bit about what I was & who I was & where I'd been as I yielded fully to him..."

I've noticed the talk about testing season and whatnot going on when ACOMAF comes out, and I have to say that I'm with you there people (clash with timing between ACOMAF and finals is ridiculously frustrating). Welp, as I try to distract myself from my impending doom tomorrow on a physics EM test, I was looking through some of the quotes Sarah released and trying to figure out who says what, and the one quoted above in particular right, I'm pretty sure Feyre is speaking about Rhys. Feyre states that she doesn't care about who/what she is, so we can conclude that this is after Rhys helps Feyre out with her psychological injuries, and this is probably well into the book (and we know Feysand is happening) so maybe...? Idk, I guess it could be Tamlin with the whole hot and heavy thing she has going on with him from the previews we've seen, and the "yielded" part at the end does give indication of that. Any thoughts?


message 1204: by Alyana (new) - rated it 5 stars

Alyana Souffle98 wrote: ""I didn't care one bit about what I was & who I was & where I'd been as I yielded fully to him..."

I've noticed the talk about testing season and whatnot going on when ACOMAF comes out, and I hav..."


I'm leaning towards Tamlin, just because yeah I agree she only "forgets herself" when she's doing it with Tamlin. This also ties in with my personal headcanon of Rhys and Feyre ending up together because they build each other up and not because they or Feyre wants to forget/lose themselves.


message 1205: by Megan (new) - rated it 5 stars

Megan Cheang I am leaning toward the theory that Feyre will end up with Rhys, but i can't help feeling sorry for Tamlin and worrying about how this might cause a lot of discord, especially since that both the Night Court and the Spring Court are at the opposite ends of Prythian.


message 1206: by Sammy (last edited Apr 11, 2016 02:21AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sammy I really do think what Tamlin and Feyre have is only lust, definitely not love. Remember in ACOTAR during a party that Feyre was taken to by Rhys and Tamlin touched Feyre's hand and lead her into a room away from all the people which they both end up kissing? That's definitely lust. I mean come on, Feyre had just done a very hard challenge by Amarantha and she's staying on a cell, shouldn't Tamlin should have checked if she was alright first and how she was doing? and shouldn't Feyre should've done the same too? but no, once they went into that room, they just start sticking their tounge down each other's throats. I say that's lust.
Plus I've read the first four chapters in ACOMAF, and it seems to me Tamlin is getting to be a dickhead. Instead of calming her and talking to her about it, he just flat out ignoring her when she was having nightmares and vomiting up. Both of them just went through a very haunting experience, they should help each other out and talk to each other and opening up their true feelings, instead their just either ignoring each other or having sex all the time. Of course I've only read a little starter of the 2nd book so I don't know what might happen later on, they might start to open to each other but if they don't and this is going to continue on then I'm out of that ship. #TeamRhysand


message 1207: by Megan (new) - rated it 5 stars

Megan Cheang While i think their relationship is mostly sensual in ACOMAF, you can't deny that at ACOTAR Feyre definitely loved Tamlin. Why else go through Amarantha's three painful tasks?


message 1208: by Sammy (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sammy Megan wrote: "While i think their relationship is mostly sensual in ACOMAF, you can't deny that at ACOTAR Feyre definitely loved Tamlin. Why else go through Amarantha's three painful tasks?"

True, and they might've loved each other then, but in my opinion, I think the love was a bit too fast and a bit forceful as well, and they also didn't have any spare time to really think what they actually felt then about that time. Feyre also hesitated to say 'I love you' to Tamlin when he said it to her, that's why she was sent home when she didn't said it and then everything happened. If she really did truly love him at that time, she would've said it. But she HESITATED. And now after everything they've been through and what happened, it seems like their relationship is going downhill, especially if they won't talk to each other about what they are really feeling. I don't think they really and truly love each other, I think they just want to force themselves to believe in an illusion of them living happily ever after rather than actually admitting the truth. Also, I don't think Feyre (now that she is a high fae) and Tamlin will not be the same person as they were in ACOTAR, because after having to experience that haunted experience, who wouldn't come back as a change person.


message 1209: by Richard (new) - rated it 5 stars

Richard Renee Potential major *spoiler alert*, but did anyone see what the-german-bookworm posted? Are these legit? Thoughts?

http://the-german-bookworm.tumblr.com...

http://the-german-bookworm.tumblr.com...


message 1210: by Aartee (new) - rated it 5 stars

Aartee Samantha wrote: "Guys, I have just started re-reading 'A Court of Thorns and Roses' and I came across this;
This is when Feyre and Rhysand were talking to each other.

"Your court fell, too."
Sadness flickered in ..."


Oh God thats a hell of a clue .......They have to mates. And now i am kinda sure of it.lol;-)


message 1211: by Sammy (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sammy OMG OMG OMG HOW DID YOU GET THIS? IS THIS REAL??? AND IS THIS RHYSAND TALKING? I'M GETTING SO EXCITED!!!


message 1212: by Fatima (new) - rated it 5 stars

Fatima Bayram Ommfg noooo i am scared af now wtf is this IS IT REAL!!


message 1213: by Fatima (new) - rated it 5 stars

Fatima Bayram I REGRET ALL MY LIFE DECISIONS NOW
WHY DID I READ THESE WHHHHHY *sits in corner and cries*


message 1214: by Sammy (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sammy Aartee wrote: "Samantha wrote: "Guys, I have just started re-reading 'A Court of Thorns and Roses' and I came across this;
This is when Feyre and Rhysand were talking to each other.

"Your court fell, too."
Sadn..."


I know right! Aaaah getting so hyper now


message 1215: by Sammy (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sammy Richard wrote: "Potential major *spoiler alert*, but did anyone see what the-german-bookworm posted? Are these legit? Thoughts?

http://the-german-bookworm.tumblr.com...-..."


I HOPE TO GOD THIS IS REAL. I WANT THIS TO HAPPEN. NEED A ACOMAF NOW!!!


message 1216: by Sasa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sasa OMGGGGGGGGGG

If those are for real, we're in for the best book everrrrrrr. *faints*


message 1217: by Fatima (new) - rated it 5 stars

Fatima Bayram Can you tell me how sure you are that this isn't real??
Idk they just seem pretty legit to me.
Also tell how to get over these MAJOR spoilers posted only three weeks before the release date?


message 1218: by Alyana (new) - rated it 5 stars

Alyana Lol, yall have opened Pandora's box.

But seriously if you don't want to be spoiled just don't open the links. FOR REAL.

Ok this is for yall who have read the spoilers (ya sinners)
(view spoiler)


message 1219: by Sasa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sasa Alyana wrote: "Lol, yall have opened Pandora's box.

But seriously if you don't want to be spoiled just don't open the links. FOR REAL.

Ok this is for yall who have read the spoilers (ya sinners)
OH GOD but eve..."


(view spoiler)


message 1220: by Vinnie (new) - rated it 3 stars

Vinnie Tears of joy T-T they won't stop T-T


message 1221: by Echo (new) - rated it 5 stars

Echo  Yeah, the AGOS showed up in Google books as well. It's like reading the real boon but much more unfulfilling.

Not going to read them!!!! I get reading previews but anything more is going to make me loose my no-acomaf-until-exams resolve.


message 1222: by Kristin (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kristin Ciullo GKLJGLGHFJGLDFJGS;LDJFGDF;GHDKFNCVUGHOFJ

OHMYGOD!!!!!!!!!

(view spoiler)


message 1223: by Mirou (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mirou Oh man, I see your comments and I'm trying so HARD not read the spoilers.

SO DIFFICULT.


message 1224: by Melanie (new) - rated it 5 stars

Melanie (view spoiler)


message 1225: by Echo (new) - rated it 5 stars

Echo  Mirou wrote: "Oh man, I see your comments and I'm trying so HARD not read the spoilers.

SO DIFFICULT."


SAME. Same...

btw--For those who are hiding the spoilers: Thanks for spoiler tagging the google books spoilers! I would have been so mad if I had ruined the book for myself.


message 1227: by Kelly (last edited Apr 11, 2016 05:03PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kelly Samantha wrote: "Kelly wrote: "I....am DEAD. DEAD, I TELL YOU. I finally broke down and read the spoilers last night at 3am (and then was wired for the rest of the night from sheer excitement. Hence why I was exhau..."

I....am DEAD. DEAD, I TELL YOU. I finally broke down and read the spoilers last night at 3am (and then was wired for the rest of the night from sheer excitement. Hence why I was exhausted at work today but still running on the biggest emotional high lol)

(view spoiler)


message 1228: by Sammy (last edited Apr 11, 2016 04:58PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sammy Kelly wrote: "I....am DEAD. DEAD, I TELL YOU. I finally broke down and read the spoilers last night at 3am (and then was wired for the rest of the night from sheer excitement. Hence why I was exhausted at work t..."

Whooo! I need a break after staring at that picture for a long time. Thats so hot lol
Who is it though? He doesn't look like Rhysand...


message 1229: by Alyana (new) - rated it 5 stars

Alyana Kelly wrote: "I....am DEAD. DEAD, I TELL YOU. I finally broke down and read the spoilers last night at 3am (and then was wired for the rest of the night from sheer excitement. Hence why I was exhausted at work t..."

Haha, everything will commence under spoiler tags now.
(view spoiler)


message 1230: by Kelly (last edited Apr 11, 2016 05:11PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kelly (view spoiler)


message 1231: by Mirou (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mirou I broke. I read the whole thing haha. I'm so weak.

SO BEAUTIFUL. I was crying in the subway, I swear.


message 1232: by WinterRose (last edited Apr 11, 2016 07:23PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

WinterRose Let me just say this.

(view spoiler)


message 1233: by Olya (new) - rated it 4 stars

Olya Holly wrote: "Honestly, I'm not sure that those are real.... At first I thought they were but the more I read them, the less it sounds like SJM's writing and more like a fanfiction. Never know though."

Agreed. The characters sound off. This sounds very like her ToG books which, for me, isn't a good thing. I know that people complained about her first book and I hope she didn't change anything to please. :( I'll definitely still want to read this but I think I'm going to hold out for reviews first and not buy it. It's all too rushed for me!


Souffle98 Ok, just throwing this out there but to continue the talk as to when Rhys figured out about the mate bond, could it have been before he bet on her with the first trial? Why would he bet on her like that? He seemed to have actual confidence in her (on par with his cunning and skill?=he knows they're mates) He didn't seem to have the highest regard for humans last time he met with her, and when Amarantha gave Feyre the riddle, he did this half smile thing? Idk, but this seems to be kind of a pivotal change in his behavior around her...maybe something happened when he went to Feyre's village and brought Claire back for Amarantha...?


message 1235: by Olya (new) - rated it 4 stars

Olya Laura wrote: "Maybe they sound off because this is an improvised cut off from the middle-end of the book. PRETTY SURE a lot of character development will go down before those things happen. And these scenes are ..."

It's just me. Honestly none of the snippets wowed me. Starting from the I am my own master quote. Maybe my expectations were insanely high after the first book. It sounds more ToG to me no matter what spoiler and whenever I judged books by snippets I was right. But. I hope I'm really wrong on this! I'll wait to see what you guys think.


message 1236: by Megan (new) - rated it 5 stars

Megan Cheang Agh, i want an excerpt about the wedding! I want to see the reactions of Lucien, Tamlin and Ianthe when Rhys arrives. I'm pretty sure Feyre will be stunned and maybe somewhat relieved she doesn't have to say the word no, or yes.


message 1237: by WinterRose (last edited Apr 11, 2016 09:39PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

WinterRose (view spoiler)


message 1238: by Megan (new) - rated it 5 stars

Megan Cheang Holly wrote: "Also, going back to the theory that Feyre is descended from an ancient fae.... I was rereading Acotar, and after Feyre finds out Tamlin is the last person she has to kill, Amarantha tells her that ..."

I think it more likely that Feyre isn't related to Jurian or his human lover - they hate Fae too much for that - rather Feyre is descended from the Fae that fought for humans.


message 1239: by Kristin (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kristin Ciullo (view spoiler)


message 1240: by Olya (new) - rated it 4 stars

Olya Holly wrote: "Olya wrote: "Laura wrote: "Maybe they sound off because this is an improvised cut off from the middle-end of the book. PRETTY SURE a lot of character development will go down before those things ha..."

I forgot about those! You are absolutely right. Maybe they now sound different because both of us expected things to go slower. I think perhaps it would be difficult to write Rhysand's character romantically. But I agree. It's not the characters so much as the plot. I thought only a part would be predictable but it's all a bit bland.


message 1241: by Megan (new) - rated it 5 stars

Megan Cheang If Rhys did know that Feyre was his mate and had said how everything he loved was taken, did that mean he was letting her go?


message 1243: by Fatima (new) - rated it 5 stars

Fatima Bayram http://the-german-bookworm.tumblr.com...
GUYS THERES MOOORE FEYSAND
YOU MUST CHECK IT DONT CLICK IF YOU DONT WANT SPOILERS FOR FEYSAND.


message 1244: by Alyana (last edited Apr 12, 2016 07:19AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Alyana Fatima wrote: "http://the-german-bookworm.tumblr.com...
GUYS THERES MOOORE FEYSAND
YOU MUST CHECK IT DONT CLICK IF YOU DONT WANT SPOILERS FOR FEYSAND."


Is this happening right now? THREE WEEKS BEFORE THE RELEASE DATE?!


message 1245: by Fatima (new) - rated it 5 stars

Fatima Bayram I KNOW RIGHT!! i couldn't help myself after i accidentally read the first spoiler post, really though i wish I didn't. *cries a bit more*


message 1246: by Kelly (last edited Apr 12, 2016 07:38AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kelly Megan wrote: "If Rhys did know that Feyre was his mate and had said how everything he loved was taken, did that mean he was letting her go?"

(view spoiler)


message 1247: by Kelly (last edited Apr 12, 2016 07:47AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kelly (view spoiler)


message 1248: by Alyana (new) - rated it 5 stars

Alyana (view spoiler)


message 1249: by Fatima (new) - rated it 5 stars

Fatima Bayram SPOILERS!!!!
FEYSAND SPOILERS!!








"the answer to a question he'd asked for centuries"
This is a quote from qos when aelin kissed rowan and the new leaks had something too similar to that quote.
SHOULD I FREAK OUT RIGHT NOW OR WHAT??


message 1250: by Kristin (last edited Apr 12, 2016 08:35AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kristin Ciullo Fatima wrote: "SPOILERS!!!!
FEYSAND SPOILERS!!


Are you referring to the leaks being possibly fake? I'm still trying to take everything with a grain of salt just in case but I will say that I know plenty of authors, including my favorites, use certain lines multiple times in different books. One saying that I'm particularly tired of, and that I've seen used by multiple authors, is "let out a they didn't know they were holding" or variations thereof. I roll my eyes a little now every time I see it written in a book.


back to top