Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince
discussion
Who would you save that died in Harry Potter?
message 301:
by
Fonni
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Oct 08, 2013 12:03PM
Sirius, Fred, Dumbledore, and if I had a fourth choice I would without a doubt choose Remus. Oh the responsibility of hypothetically saving fictional characters lives.
reply
|
flag
Fred. Dobby. Hedwig.I'd like Sirius to be alive too, but I think, he'd be much happier with his bestfriend James, and then Lupin too.
Fred has to be alive cause well, its supposed to be the TWINS! Not one! >.< And Dobby. Cause Dobby's got to get more socks on Christmas! Hedwig because she was his only connection to his real magical world, even when he was alone with the Dursleys. She was the most reliable =(
Snape and Dumbledore did their part (brilliantly), so I think they've already lived to their full extent =)
oh my god, Sirius!! I cried so much when he died :( also, I would save Dobby and Fred.
I would save Fred. His death was COMPLETELY uncalled for. But i think Cedric Diggory deserves to be saved too.
Tonks, Remus, Sirius
Hedwig, Dobby, and Fred. Harry should have been able to hold on to one thing he loved. Dobby and Fred, the story could have gone on without them dying. I understand the premise behind their deaths, but if I had to choose, it would be them.I get why Remus and Tonks had to die. It brings the story full circle. Teddy is Harry and Neville in one. Orphaned in a fight against Voldemort, to be raised by his grandmother, and now Harry is the Godfather. With Teddy, it will all be done right instead of terribly wrong like Harry's life.
As sad as I was for Sirius to go, would have liked Harry to have at least one parental type figure left, I agree Harry wouldn't have developed the way he needed to with him still alive. The rest were also necessary for his development as a character.
Sherry wrote: "Hedwig, Dobby, and Fred. Harry should have been able to hold on to one thing he loved. Dobby and Fred, the story could have gone on without them dying. I understand the premise behind their deaths,..."Thats true! Nice logic!
Fred, Snape and Sirius:'(
Snape, Dobby and Hedwig.
I would say Fred, Sirius, and Dobby. Sorry to Dumbledore, Snape, Lupin, Tonks, and everyone else.
Fred, Dobby, and and Snape
Fred , Sirius and Dobby
OH, Fred, Remus and Tonks, of course!
Star wrote: "Noone. lol I wouldnt save any of the characters. If i did it would change the story and I think that the people who died added so much to the series that if any of them were saved it would take awa..."I agree with you, more or less. I wouldn't want to change them from the way they were written. They died how and when they died for their own individual reasons, and though each pulled on my heartstrings, that was the entire point.
It seems like everyone has forgotton the most complex, humourous and bravest of all the charecters...Snape! In the end, he died saving everyone and lets face it, without his charecter, where would Harry be? Dead. Not to mention the other two fantastic charecters that sadly got killed by the wands of Voldemort. Hedwig and Mad Eye Moody.
I for one was more sad that Hedwig (an owl!!)sacraficed his life then Dobby the annoying elf.
Daisy009 wrote: "I would probably save Hagrid, Hermione, and Dobby"Hermione????? Hagrid????? They didn't die.
As much as I love DD, I would save Sirius. He had had a rough life and I think he deserved (and Harry) to have a normal life. He could have been such a good uncle figure to Harry. I wanted something happy to come out of Sirius' tragic life.
Definately Fred, and Dobby... but I so want to bring back Lupin and Sirus and Tonks too!! and also Bellatrix, just because she is awesome :)
Remus and Tonks, and Fred- definitely!!!
Fred, Dobby and Sirius!
Lily, James and Voldemort
^^I agree with Voldemort. I found him to be the most interesting character in the series.
I would save Lily and James Potter because they are Harry's parents and Harry would not have to struggle with his Aunt, Uncle, and Cousin. I would also save Sirius Black because he was Harry's only family that was left that was nice to him. Also Hedwig and Fred because they were both nice . . . including Hedwig
cedric, fred, tonks. Cedric was about the most innocent pure heart who died, Fred because oh god why did he die, and Tonks because Teddy needs at least one parent.
Emily wrote: "Remus and Tonks, and Fred- definitely!!!"Or maybe Colin Creevey?
I'd say Fred, Remus, and Tonks.As much as I really want to say Snape, Dumbledore and Sirius, the truth is that they had to. The story would not have progressed the way it did with out those deaths.
But those three,they didn't HAVE to happen. They were there only to show the horrors of war, not to motivate Harry along his path.
Fred, Sirius, Dobby, Remus and tonks
FRED, SIRIUS AND DOBBY ,,And yeah LUPIN
Aishwarya wrote: "FRED, SIRIUS AND DOBBY ,,And yeah Lipin"you mean LUPIN ('U' not 'I')
anyway.... I would save FRED, DOBBY, JAMES AND LILY, TONKS, LUPIN.... have i missed anyone?
Snape, lupin, tonks, dobby, regulus black
Emily wrote: "Aishwarya wrote: "FRED, SIRIUS AND DOBBY ,,And yeah Lipin"you mean LUPIN ('U' not 'I')
anyway.... I would save FRED, DOBBY, JAMES AND LILY, TONKS, LUPIN.... have i missed anyone?"
THANK YOU!
FRED! Sirius, Dumbledore
Psychotic101 wrote: "Fred. In fact, I'd trade Harry for Fred."Haha oh geez i might too..
Jeni wrote: "Laura wrote: "Yes i agree...What do you think about Dobby?"
Dobby is a favorite, but I tried to think of people that would make a huge difference for the survivors. Fred's death devastated Georg..."
I agree. I would save the characters that really would've made a difference (in a good way) and save their loved ones their despair.
Snape was meant to die, so was Dumbledore.Fred's death was kind of useless, maybe if there was a little more elaboration around his character it would have mattered. I am not saying that Fred didn't matter, only that his death didn't bring anything to the story except more drama and sadness for Harry.
Dobby died a martyr, that part was so beautiful and touching despite the sadness, with Harry burying him without using magic.
I think I would save Hedwig, as her death symbolized not only the loss of innocence for Harry but also the end of an era.
Fred. His death was the most shocking to me.
Lupin or Snape, definately!I would not save Sirius, to be honest. Because i don't understand the love for him and James. If i had people like that in my school/life, i'd probably hate them (or not like them at the very least...)
Bellatrix- the most awesome character of all time!
the first one would be Sirius because harry should have lived with him and so that they could be "a proper family."the second one would have to be Snape and i don't know why i chose him maybe the reason why is because of his sarcastic dry humour.
i think the last one would be Fred because he's part of the Weasley family and he was so funny.
Yeah maybe I would save Sirius (But I still love Bellatrix) because Harry's family members keep dying, and, like, even in the wizarding world that's so coincidental that it's HIS family
Snape, Remus, Tonks and Fred. Not in any particular order.
and sirius and dobby nearly everyone bad voldemort.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
