Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince
discussion
Who would you save that died in Harry Potter?
message 501:
by
E
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jan 06, 2014 07:31AM
Remus and Tonks, Sirius
reply
|
flag
fred, dobby and sirius
RemusTonks because I kind of felt pity for was about to have a child
Makaylia wrote: "...three? How can I pick three? I would save..Fred
Dobby
Sirius
Lupin and his wife who's name just eluded me I think it starts with a T
DUMBLEDORE
Diggory
Harry's parents (come on. he deserves it..."
Tonks...that was Lupin' wife. But I agree with Hedwig....that was so sad!
Nobody... Part of what made the series great were its sad moments, and the deaths that felt unfair and pointless.
Fred, Tonks and Lupin.
Fred, Sirius, Lupin and Hedwig. I was upset at all of the deaths of the main characters really but I love the marauders (except Peter Pettigrew)
Sirius, Dobby, Fred, Dumbledore, and Hedwig (couldn't pick just three!)
cedric dumbledore hedwig
definitely either remus or tonks just cause they had a kid...a kid need to know their parents. as much as i love everyone else and i would prefer no one at all to die...
Sirius, Fred and Dobby
The only person I would save is Hedwig, Cause anyone else and it would have changed the story completely. I know it seems Tonks, Lupin, and Fred's death was unnecessary but it was a war and in war people die. Although I cry my eyes out whenever I read those pages.
THAT'S SOOOO HARD!!! I would DEFINITELY choose Fred and Dobby as two. But the last would be either Sirius, Snape, Remus, or Dumbledore. Actually I would choose Voldemort. JK I WOULD NEVER CHOOSE HIM ;)
fred,dobby,tonks,remus
the death of Hedwig was hard to accept
Seriously? THREE? no way.Fred
Dobby
Sirius
Lupin & Tonks
Hedwig
(not in order)
There are other people whose deaths I would have saved, but I felt their deaths were necessary for the plot to continue in the way it did. For example, if Snape had not died, Harry would not have gotten first-hand experience on what Snape felt throughout his life.
1. Sirius 2. Fred 3. Cedric (4. Snape, 5. Remus)
Snape Fred Lupin Tonks Sirius Hedwig Bellatrix.... and everyone else besides the other Death Eaters and Voldy... they should all come back (including Harrys parents) and say that they were just hiding to see what Harry did....
Just three?? It`s hard, but I will save: Sirius, James and Remus
Fred, Sirius, Dobby:'(
SIRIUS. DUMBLEDORE. DOBBY. And please let me save HEDWIG too.
Fred, Lupin + Tonks (They're a package),Snape. :(
Remus, Tonks, Bellatrix
It's between Dumbledore, Dobby, and Snape. I cried more when Snape died than with any of the other characters and I never thought I would've.
Ella wrote: "Julie, totally agree! Hedwig's death didn't make ANY sense. Harry didn't grow stronger as a character. JK Rowling picked some random deaths I think. I mean really? George, Dobby, Colin Creevey, and..."I'm glad someone else agrees. It felt so unnecessary, what did Hedwig's death prove? It seemed Harry forgot about her, as the book went on.
Fred, Dobby, and Dumbledore.
Cassie wrote: "It's between Dumbledore, Dobby, and Snape. I cried more when Snape died than with any of the other characters and I never thought I would've."I know. He is one I wouldn't save tho. He missed Lily and was never happy without her. He accomplished his mission. Let us just give him some peace.
Sirius, Dumbledore, Snape.Sirius was actually my favorite character, and the father Harry never had.
Sirius, Remus, and Dobby
Antigoni wrote: "Sirius, Dumbledore, Snape.Sirius was actually my favorite character, and the father Harry never had."
Sirius is my favorite too :D
sirius, fred, and snape.This was a hard decision because I want Harry to have parents, but that's what Sirius and Snape are for, to look out for Harry. And Fred needs to be alive because, well, he's Fred and there can be no Weasley Twins without him.
I can't believe I'm saying this, but as much as I would love to save someone I actually wouldn't change anything. It was because of these characters' deaths that made me even more invested into the books and completely emotionally attached to the story and the characters. But I have to say, Fred, Lupin's and Sirius's deaths were really horrible to read about ;(
But Harry potter wouldn't be Harry potter without their deaths :)
I wouldn't have saved dumbledore 'cause i think we all knew damn well that dumbledore was gonna die anyways so yeah
Abey, are you a death eater or something?
Sirius Black, Fred Weasley, DobbyBut then I am forgetting Albus Dumbledore, Severus Snape, Nymphadora Tonks, Remus Lupin, Alaster Moody, Cedric Diggory, Hedwig, Lavender Brown, and Colin Creevy
( do not mind the spelling )
Three?? How about 5!! If I had to pick it would be...
Fred Weasley,Sirius Black,Remus Lupin,Hedwig and Dobby!!
I would love to save everybody else {not Voldemort or any other death eaters}
But these deaths were the saddest for me...
Snape!!!!!Oh and Lupin, Tonks, Fred and Sirius
SIRIUS of course! He was the last family Harry ever had!
I would save Fred. I can see why the others died. Harry had to be left alone so that he had no one to lean on and had to do it all by himself. But Fred...Fred didn't have to die. Plus I still to this day worry about how George is coping.
And Tonks and Sirius!
I would save Fred, I hated that he died. I also would have saved Dobby because he was a true friend of all of them, and mostly because he had such a big heart. I understand why Sirius had to die, and as well as Severus, but if I had to pick, it would be Sirius. god, i'd save them all. haha if i could
I would save snaps two I liked him:)
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
