Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince
discussion
Who would you save that died in Harry Potter?
message 551:
by
L. L.
(last edited Feb 14, 2014 06:33AM)
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Feb 14, 2014 06:32AM
Sirius, Fred, Hedwig, Dobby; if we saved Harry's parents the story wouldn't have been quite as adventerous, so sorry, Harry...that loss you have to endure.
reply
|
flag
Everybody except everybody that was evil.
Miriam wrote: "I'm torn between Sirius, Remus, Tonks, Dobby, Fred, Dumbledore, Snape, James, Lily, Hedwig...I agree. So much.
I wouldn't have saved Dumbledore, James, or Lily.
Harry has gotten used to living without his parents and Dumbledore seemed like a Jerk.
Dumbledore Lily James
Joey wrote: "Dumbledore Lily James"Agreed!! :)
Lupin and Tonks :(
Fred, Sirius, Colin Creevey, Lavender Brown, Cedric, Hedwig, Snape, Lily, James, Remus, Tonks.
No one ever seems to remember Colin but I will always remember his death. He was only thirteen!
James, Lily and Sirius. I cry for those three often. Ok, Maybe Snape and Lupin and Fred. Those are my other picks.
I would save Sirius, Dobby, and Lupin.
CedricSirius
Dumbledore
sirius. all the other are collateral damage( i think)
Lily, James, Dumbledore.
Sirius, Snape, Lupin, Tonks, Dobby
You can't save Lily. Her death was Harry's protection.
Sirius, Remus, Tonks and Fred, the twins are just not complete with only one half!
message 568:
by
Tana Lovegood of Dumbledore's Army✞~
(last edited Sep 02, 2014 05:55AM)
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
FRED,Hedwig, Sirius
Kate wrote: "Joey wrote: "Dumbledore Lily James"Agreed!! :)"
If they had not died, there would be no story.
Fred, Sirius, TonksI still firmly believe that Percy should've died instead of Fred, as his last redemption. Sirius should have lived, and someone else closer to Harry die. Bellatrix is a surprising character that actually was incredibly fascinating, but her death was epic and befitting to her dynamic character. I believe that death for Remus was peace at last, but Tonks should have lived in order to be there for Teddy, even if she was emotionally crippled by her husband's death.
SiriusRemus
Fred
Dobby
Snape
I can't pick 3. These 5 should have survived. They shouldn't be dead. I bawled so hard with Fred. Not 2 chapters later Snape and then directly after it when I was still bawling Remus and Tonks. And with Dobby I don't think my book was happy with me I threw it through my room. I've never cried so much reading a book. And Sirius... book5 was the first one I actually cried over in my life. after that many followed though xD
Star wrote: "Noone. lol I wouldnt save any of the characters. If i did it would change the story and I think that the people who died added so much to the series that if any of them were saved it would take awa..."Exactly. And for those who say Fred's death was needless, well, if you've got 7 kids from the same family fighting (although now I'm not sure if they were all there), it's a little implausible for not a single one to be killed, don't you think? We must have some semblance of realism, even in a magical world :)
message 573:
by
Tana Lovegood of Dumbledore's Army✞~
(last edited Sep 04, 2014 05:54AM)
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Rakel, you are right! But i wish Fred didn't die still...as mean as it is i would prefer Percy to die
SiriusSnape
Dumbledore
Sirius
Fred
Hedwig
Dobby
Dumbledore
Snape
Lupin & Tonks
Fred
Hedwig
Dobby
Dumbledore
Snape
Lupin & Tonks
Tana~ wrote: "Rakel, you are right! But i wish Fred didn't die still...as mean as it is i would prefer Percy to die"True, she could've killed off Percy, and it've had the 'oh no, but he'd just seen the light' angle :)
Star wrote: "Noone. lol I wouldnt save any of the characters. If i did it would change the story and I think that the people who died added so much to the series that if any of them were saved it would take awa..."I agree! I think everyone died for a reason, and there's a chance we wouldn't appreciate some of the characters that died as much if they were still alive.
If I have to pick just one it would be Sirius
Jeni wrote: "Laura wrote: "Yes i agree...What do you think about Dobby?"
Dobby is a favorite, but I tried to think of people that would make a huge difference for the survivors. Fred's death devastated Georg..."
Tonks, Lupin, Fred, Sirius, Dobby, Hedwig, Dumbledore...Can't pick just three
SNAPE, SNAPE, SNAPE!!!I loved Snape since the very first book. I used to reread all his scenes with Harry because I loved the witty dialogue between the two of them. I would love for Rowling to do a prequel with Snape as the main character, telling his time at Hogwarts and his unrequited love for Lily.
It's Fred. Because of George. I thought about Tonks, because of her baby, but it's just Fred. I would love to save Sirius, he had a horrible life and is my fav character, but, again, it's just Fred.
Hailey wrote: "VOLDEMORT!"What? Well, maybe so that the story would go on. HP FAN 4EVER!
Dumbledore, Sirius, Dobby
Λάουρα (Laura) wrote: "Hannah wrote: "No one ever seems to remember Colin but I will always remember his death. He was only thirteen!":("
He was 16 actually. He was in his 1st year in the "Chamber of Secrets". But I can relate, I do remember his death. And Denis' death too. Both hyper sad.
I can't choose three!!! Dobby, Siruis, Lupin, Tonks, Dubledore, Cedric, James, Lily, Fred, Snape and Hedwig. I know its not three - i just can't choose!!! xD
It's a tie between Sirius, Hedwig, and Fred.
Fred, Sirius and Tonks.
Kalina wrote: "Fred, Sirius and Tonks."Tonks died for a reason, so Harry could be the father to Teddy that he never had
I would have saved 1. Diggory because he HAD nothing to do with it, he died without trying and it was saddest thing
2. Sirius because he deserved a life where he could live in freedom without a defamed
3.Fred because....well you know....
Annabeth~Hermione wrote: "Kalina wrote: "Fred, Sirius and Tonks."Tonks died for a reason, so Harry could be the father to Teddy that he never had"
Harry was too young to be a father and he could never take the place of Teddy's mum aka Tonks.
Fred, Snape & lily
I don't think any of us can just choose one XD most of us save like 3 people
If I can just pick 3: Sirius, Lupin and Dobby, because I really liked them.
The only death I'm truly bitter about is Sirius. So I would save just him.
Falling though the veil was a cheat, and unlike the movie it wasn't preceded by the killing curse.
I felt, and still feel, like it's unclear what really happened to him.
Have him still fall though so it wouldn't alter the story, but bring him back. Harry who had lost so much deserved one person just for him.
Remus Lupin would be pretty much the only one I'd save. The rest I could live without. But Remus Lupin went through too much of a garbage life treating him like garbage for way too long. Remus Lupin deserved to live. Greatest injustice in all the books.
Dobby, Hedwig, and Sirius. Dobby and Hedwig because they were so innocent and did so much good and so little bad - if anyone deserved to live, they did.
Sirius was the only family Harry had, really. It seemed so cruel to rip him away from Harry after he has lost SO much and endured so much pain :(
DumbledoreHedwig
and Harry's parents
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
