Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince
discussion
Who would you save that died in Harry Potter?
message 251:
by
Annika
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Sep 18, 2013 05:57AM
Fred, Dobby, Lupin
reply
|
flag
Brooke wrote: "Iris wrote: "Tonks. Everyone else I could live with not being there. But second place would go to Fred because who doesn't love the twins? And lastly Hedwig. Poor Owl didn't know what hit him."Hed..."
Really? Wow, I need to reread those books
I'd save Lupin and Tonks most of all, because they just had a kid. Their deaths really hurt me. I'd also save Fred because he was so young and deserved more time to live. Him and all the other children lost.
At least one of the Lupin/Tonks couple.
None- although I loved them all without them dying it wouldn't be HP
Remus Lupin. The guy make Defense Against Dark Arts some real deal. I want to never stop reading about him... He's my second favorite, after Albus Dumbledore.
Fred,Snape and Tonks - also Dobby!
Dumbledore, Snape and Dobby.
In order:Sirus, Hedwig, Lupin.
SO SAD NOW.
Spa wrote: Ok ill agree with u on tht but wat about azkaban for her"You know, Azkaban might have been okay as well. No one but Sirius had ever truly escaped and only a few people knew how he did it.
Maritza wrote: "I would have saved Severus Snape and Sirius Black...and Hedwig!" hry i agree with that why the poor and defenseles hedwig
Fred, remus/tonks and snape...mostly fred.
No one. How could I? the deaths were brilliant. Snape died a hero. Remus and Tonks died in love. Hedwig died helping his owner. Dobby died the way he'd want to. It's cathartic. Deaths were part of the story and I wouldn't change anything about it. No one died without a reason or meaning.
Cedric, Sirius and Fred. I cried a lot when Cedric died and Harry carried him out of the maze!
Sirius. Dobby and Fred!!
DOBBY!!!!!!! And Remus/Tonks (They count as one shh...) and Fred.
Mary ellen wrote: "Cedric, Sirius and Fred. I cried a lot when Cedric died and Harry carried him out of the maze!"
I would probably save cedric too, he was always the strange character. ike in the 3rd book when cedric wanted a rematch even when he won already, I was like "CEDRIC UR SO STRANGE"
I would probably save cedric too, he was always the strange character. ike in the 3rd book when cedric wanted a rematch even when he won already, I was like "CEDRIC UR SO STRANGE"
Dobby...pure and simple.
Fred, Remus and Tonks
lILY jAMES AND FRED. THE WEASLYS NEEDED FRED AND HARRY NEEDED HIS PARENTS. IF HARRY HAD HIS PARENTS THEN MOST LIKLY TEDDY WOULD HAVE HIS OR LILY AND JAMES COULD ADOPT TEDDY.
sorry i forgot i had caps lock on.
Fred, Sirius, Lupin
Sirius- cause he's just awesomeFred- cause I'm a twin and I can't imagine a life without my brother, no seriously I can't and I'm not being all emotional
Dobby- IT'S DOBBY
in order: remus, sirius, Snape and Hedwig.
Fred, Sirius and Hedwig
Harry's Parents!!I think it would save everyone a lt oftrouble.
:P
snape, sirius and cedric
Only 3??? Definitely Fred, Remus and Tonks, and if I could save one more it'd be Sirius!
Sirius, Fred, Remus, and Tonks
Sirius, Fred and Remus :(
Sirius, Fred and Dobby
Sirius, Remus and Fred.Sirius' death was the saddest death I have ever read :(
FRED! FRED! FRED! did I mention Fred. Ohmigod, he's my favorite character and he didn't deserve to die ok. Like I love him so much. George was never able to produce a potronus again because all his happy memories were with Fred. I know it's part of the stotry, but he could've been saved and for that reason, he should've lived. Along with him, I would've liked Sirius, Lupin, Tonks, and lastly, BELLATRIX, no hate, she has been my favorite villain for ages, not all villains need to die.
Noone... saving characters would change the story. even though Harry lost all of his family he still made friends along the way.. and a new family (Hogwarts).Also I find it wierd that noone would have saved Harrys parents...?
I would definitely save Dumbledore in the series. He's such a cool character, it's hard to have him die!
Nickisha wrote: "EVERY BODY!!!! lolzzz... okay let me lower my numbers. Dumbledore, Lupin, Snape, Fred, Mad eye, Hedwig, Dobby, Tonks, Sirius......."I totally agree with saving Dumbledore. He's my favorite character in the series!
Fred, Diggory and Snape.
Sirius, Snape, and Remus.
Remus,Tonks and Severus Snape
fred, dobby*sniffle*, and sirius.(oh, no, here come the freaking tears...)
FRED FRED FRED FRED FRED FRED, Dobby, Snape, Remus, Tonks... and did I mention FRED???
Fred, Tonks, and Lupin
Anshita wrote: "Sirius Black.
I still can't get over his death."
Me neither. :(
I still can't get over his death."
Me neither. :(
Sirius, Dumbledore, Dobby, and Hedwig needed to die for plot and progression. Fred, Tonks and Lupin died to show the horror of war and that it would leave no family untouched. I really cannot work out one meaningful death that could be undone without altering the story quite a bit. Had she gone through killing Mr. Weasley he probably would have been my choice.
Someone should've saved the audience. Saved us from this incompetently-written, thinly-conceived, and just plain pointless concept in the first place. Brain cells and personalities are the real victims in all this.
Feliks wrote: "Someone should've saved the audience. Saved us from this incompetently-written, thinly-conceived, and just plain pointless concept in the first place. Brain cells and personalities are the real vic..."
It's nice to know I'm not the only one who doesn't blindly worship Harry Potter. I admit it's good, but not THAT good.
It's nice to know I'm not the only one who doesn't blindly worship Harry Potter. I admit it's good, but not THAT good.
Shouldn't visit a thread to something you don't like. Obvious troll is obvious.
Fred & Dumbledore
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
