The One (The Selection, #3) The One discussion


1594 views
Team Maxon or Aspen

Comments Showing 101-150 of 500 (500 new)    post a comment »

message 101: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Gabriella wrote: "Night wrote: Sorry are you for real? Maxon may not have the best track record ok. But to say that ASPEN is with out fault is unfair, Aspen let his ego get in the way. America was willing to live a ..."

The king may be pulling strings remember he said he had eyes everywhere?


Patrice Lavandero MAXOOOOOOOOOOOON


message 103: by Alyssa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Alyssa B. America can't handle being princess-her actions at the end of The Elite obviously prove that. TEAM ASPEN!!


message 104: by Sophia (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sophia Team MAXON!!!!!!! America just need to realize that she really do have feelings for him...and I don't hate Aspen because he was her firdt love snd all that but people change and so she deserves Maxon than Aspen


message 105: by Riya (last edited Nov 09, 2013 09:15AM) (new) - added it

Riya Team Maxon!!! I will absolutely die if she is not with Maxon at the end of the book The One. Ughh! Now I have to wait less than a year to find out. Maxon is the one for her. Aspen on the other hand is not. He dumped her because he let his ego get in the way of their relationship. I mean everyone agrees with that, right? You guys can clearly see that I hope that America choses Maxon over Aspen because he will take care of her and look after her. Not that Aspen will not but I think that Maxon will do a better than Aspen. *sighs I really want America to chose Maxon. SO TEAM MAXON loud and proud.


message 106: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Riya wrote: "Team Maxon!!! I will absolutely die if she is not with Maxon at the end of the book The One. Ughh! Now I have to wait less than a year to find out. Maxon is the one for her. Aspen on the other hand..."
LAP indeed I hope she loves Maxon enough to see how perfect she is for him and Ilea


message 107: by Jasmine (new) - rated it 1 star

Jasmine too predictable and boring if America ends up with the prince in the end..............................

So i hope she either ends up with neither one of them or with aspen as a twist.


message 108: by Vic (new) - rated it 5 stars

Vic Team Maxon.
I feel as if I don't need a reason but if Aspen was who she really wanted she could already have him. America wants and loves Maxon more.


message 109: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Vic wrote: "Team Maxon.
I feel as if I don't need a reason but if Aspen was who she really wanted she could already have him. America wants and loves Maxon more."


Not many aspen fans agree. I do agree with you though


message 110: by Riya (new) - added it

Riya Night wrote: "Riya wrote: "Team Maxon!!! I will absolutely die if she is not with Maxon at the end of the book The One. Ughh! Now I have to wait less than a year to find out. Maxon is the one for her. Aspen on t..."

Thanks. She deserves to be with Maxon... I can't wait for the book to come out!


message 111: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Riya wrote: "Night wrote: "Riya wrote: "Team Maxon!!! I will absolutely die if she is not with Maxon at the end of the book The One. Ughh! Now I have to wait less than a year to find out. Maxon is the one for h..."

Who can?


message 112: by Cherry (new) - rated it 5 stars

Cherry C. team maxon or team aspen?

BOTH! because I split America's heart in half!

the half for Prince Maxon and the other half for her first love Aspen.

AND THEY LIVE HAPPILY EVER AFTER!


message 113: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Cherry wrote: "team maxon or team aspen?

BOTH! because I split America's heart in half!

the half for Prince Maxon and the other half for her first love Aspen.

AND THEY LIVE HAPPILY EVER AFTER!"


Great idea!


message 114: by Cherry (new) - rated it 5 stars

Cherry C. Well the problem is America. And this love triangle story.
another idea :>
America and Maxon? No
America and Aspen? No
hmmm...
Maxon and Aspen? sure! (just kidding~) ;)

-looking forward for The One


message 115: by Jessica (last edited Nov 13, 2013 05:44PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jessica Grace Kelley I think America has changed so much that if she ends up with Aspen, she will be taking a hundred steps backwards. Aspen was her first love, her first heartbreak, her first everything. He is comfortable and the easy choice for America in so many ways. However, how often is your first love your true love? Not often! In order to fall in love with someone after you have already been in love and been hurt is scary. However, when you do learn to love again you love that person even more than your first love, you love them so much your willing to risk having your broken again! Maxon is America's second love, but I also think she loves him more. I am TEAM MAXON all the way. I don't hate Aspen. In fact, I think Aspen was and will always be an important part of America and who she has become. I actually like many things about him! His determination is admirable, and he does love her. However he isn't the best choice for her. She needs to be with the person who makes her better, drives he
r to grow, and challenges her. That is Maxon, hands down.


message 116: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Jessica wrote: "I think America has changed so much that if she ends up with Aspen, she will be taking a hundred steps backwards. Aspen was her first love, her first heartbreak, her first everything. He is comfo..."

I've heard this that you should marry your bestfriend as America and Maxon are frends


message 117: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night I'm not really sure.


message 118: by Alyssa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Alyssa B. I think Kriss should be with Maxon!!


message 119: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Larissa wrote: "I think Kriss should be with Maxon!!"

Do you know the beatles song "somebody" or in the way she moves try that out I don't know any more


message 120: by Helen (new)

Helen Johnson Olivia wrote: "Nobody really likes Aspen, do they? Don't get me wrong: I don't like the annoying ass either. Every time he shows up in the book, I feel like screaming at America, "Why?! Why are you doing this to ..."
I couldn't have said it better myself... that is exactly how I reacted every time! TEAM MAXON ALL THE WAY!!!!


message 121: by Helen (new)

Helen Johnson Denzblueangel wrote: "TRUST matters! BIG TIME! and in my opinion, that is something Maxon had broken a couple of times. America sometimes doubt him(I know she just misunderstands him but still, she finds it hard to actu..."
Maxon told her about him getting hit by his father while he's never told anyone but his doctor I think that's pretty trustworthy to me....


message 122: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Helen wrote: "Denzblueangel wrote: "TRUST matters! BIG TIME! and in my opinion, that is something Maxon had broken a couple of times. America sometimes doubt him(I know she just misunderstands him but still, she..."

You are right it is a BIG THING TO TRUST HER WITH. HOW COULD WE FORGET THE FACT HE GAVE HER BOOKS THAT WERE HIDDEN BY THE PALACE AND SHE SHOWS IT TO EVERY TOM DICK AND HARRY SHE COMES ACROSS. America came across as very selfish in the Elite in the beginning and the way she reacted to the kiss between Celeste and Maxon! I loved how she forgot she was/is doing the exact same thing to maxon. I feel at this point that America is going to take herself out of the competition. I'm team Maxon by the way.


Jessica Grace Kelley I have to agree America is bieng a hypocrite, and she broke Maxons trust before he ever broke hers.


message 124: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Jessica wrote: "I have to agree America is bieng a hypocrite, and she broke Maxons trust before he ever broke hers."

Thanks Jessica for agreeing with me.


message 125: by Niamh (new) - rated it 5 stars

Niamh TEAM MAXON!! I just feel like if America ends up with Aspen nothing will have changed and there would have been no point to the books really. What would America and aspen have learned from their experiences if they just go right back to where they started from and end up marrying each other?! But if she marries Maxon she will be able to change the system of the castes and help be a great princess. Isn't that the point of most dystopian stories? To fix the society? Illea definitely needs help being fixed! I think in my opinion America not only loves Maxon more, but she also would be a lot more useful as a person if she became princess and then queen rather then just marrying aspen and being a guards wife.


message 126: by Mel (new) - rated it 3 stars

Mel Campbell I kinda like Aspen. Right now i'm in the middle. He broke up with her initially because he didnt think he could provide for her they way he believes she deserves. He loves her, but didn't think he was good enough for her. It wasn't ego or pride that lead him to leave her, it was fear of not being able to give her the life she deserved. Plus, he was waiting to make sure he didn't make her a young widow.

I like Maxon, but i'm on the fence. I haven't finished Elite yet though so i have yet to place my feelings


message 127: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Mel wrote: "I kinda like Aspen. Right now i'm in the middle. He broke up with her initially because he didnt think he could provide for her they way he believes she deserves. He loves her, but didn't think he ..."

What did you think of America in the Elite?


message 128: by [deleted user] (new)

Team Maxon:)


message 129: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Team whoever I'm not so sure


message 130: by Neenah (new) - rated it 5 stars

Neenah Maxon all the way


message 131: by Ria (new) - added it

Ria Puri The one as in Maxons rank, number one in the caste system


message 132: by Shivani (new) - added it

Shivani Team Maxon!
If she doesn't end up with Maxon than I am done with life, like not even kidding! I am going to be so mad if America ends up with Aspen, or if Maxon chooses Kriss! It's not that I don't like them, it's just I've always thought that America and Maxon are meant to be you know? They connect better than America and Aspen. America will probably always have some sort of feelings for Aspen, but when she's with Maxon, it's like true love! It's just so adorable!


message 133: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Shivani wrote: "Team Maxon!
If she doesn't end up with Maxon than I am done with life, like not even kidding! I am going to be so mad if America ends up with Aspen, or if Maxon chooses Kriss! It's not that I don't..."


Sorry to say this. I'm Maxemerica just to let you know. I feel that like the hunger games like someone said here that she will choose the "bad boy" which in this case is Aspen. The one may mean that America has FINALLY made a decision.


message 134: by Casey (new) - added it

Casey @night what do u mean in hunger games? Peeta was the good guy- he was amazing from the first scene!


message 135: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Casey wrote: "@night what do u mean in hunger games? Peeta was the good guy- he was amazing from the first scene!"

I'm sorry. I haven't read them. But I heard he was a bad boy. I'm sorry.


message 136: by Kait (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kait Spangler Definitely Team Maxon!


message 137: by Meghan (new) - rated it 4 stars

Meghan MAXON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Roxanne Gan I'd choose Team Maxon in a heartbeat. I wish that Aspen would start to see reason and stop harassing America anymore. Isn't it really obvious that even if America actually chooses him over Aspen, they would have no future? So what if she becomes a Two? Her heart is already wavering. And if Aspen really wants to blame it on anyone, he has no one but himself to blame. You, Aspen, should back down before any of this gets exposed and you endanger every single person involved.

(view spoiler)


message 139: by Winnie (new)

Winnie I swear if America actually ends up with Aspen I will literally burn the books and throw them into an ocean!! TEAM MAXON!! HER KNIGHT I SHINNING ARMOR!!!


message 140: by Winnie (new)

Winnie THEN SEND BURNT BOOK EATING SHARKS TO EAT THE BOOKS THEN FIND THE SHARKS AND BURN THEM THROW THEM INTO LAVA. I feel soo much better.


message 141: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Winnie wrote: "THEN SEND BURNT BOOK EATING SHARKS TO EAT THE BOOKS THEN FIND THE SHARKS AND BURN THEM THROW THEM INTO LAVA. I feel soo much better."

That's a bit drastic guys!


message 142: by Ria (new) - added it

Ria Puri TEAM MAXON!! America already burned the bridge with Aspen when she practically said she didn't love him any more in the elite. Aspen anyway messed things up with him and America so he needs to deal with it. Maxon has been nothing but amazing all throughout this series while Aspen screws up. And may i need remind you who signed America up for the selection, ya that's right ASPEN so he let her go so deal with it. Also if Kierra Cass chooses Aspen or someone else I WILL DIE!! ONE MORE YEAR


message 143: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Ria wrote: "TEAM MAXON!! America already burned the bridge with Aspen when she practically said she didn't love him any more in the elite. Aspen anyway messed things up with him and America so he needs to deal..."

Actually only 4 or 5 months


Rhondav I am Team Maxon all the way. Maybe the title "The One" will be that America chooses herself...to be alone and chooses neither of them...but I really just want a happy ending love story...so I hope it is Maxon!!!


message 145: by Ccl8989 (last edited Dec 30, 2013 04:40AM) (new)

Ccl8989 I feel like everybody is choosing Maxon and just a small majority is rooting for Aspen (which includes me). I like Maxon's character a lot but I really love Aspen. http://www.kieracass.com/journal/2013... If you read this entry that Kiera made about Aspen and Americas ship - Asperica you can kind of see why I like Aspen. Aspen sacrificed everything for America if you don't recall he gave her pennies when he needed it much more than she did. Also Maxon's dad really dislikes America, and in my view you want to have the families approval before marrying them. America is always on Aspens mind so remember that you have to take in account for what other characters feel.


message 146: by Vic (new) - rated it 5 stars

Vic @Rhondav Yeah. I want America to be happy too. But I will be beyond pissed if she doesn't at least pick one of them.


message 147: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Vic wrote: "@Rhondav Yeah. I want America to be happy too. But I will be beyond pissed if she doesn't at least pick one of them."

But she could pick herself and realise it's almost too late.


message 148: by yoongi (new) - rated it 5 stars

yoongi Team Maxon. [I do know, he was a dirtbag when he was with Celeste, and Aspen was her first, but Maxon, even though its not okay, she belongs with him.] Americas hold choose already. Maxon is sweet, kind and he lets her be free, and be herself when its just her and Maxon. He trusts her, and showed her the little library. Aspen broke up with her when he hot embarrassed, and now he's trying (and failing) to get her back. I feel like she knows, deep dow, that she loves Maxon. Not silly, childish puppy love, but real, strange yet strong, love.


message 149: by yoongi (new) - rated it 5 stars

yoongi Also, Aspen is repeatedly holding her back, telling her was isn't good enough, no, you can't do that. You would suck. Maxon is slightly encouraging her. He isn't telling her she can't do this or that. He is letting her do anything she wants.


message 150: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night GeekReader wrote: "Team Maxon. [I do know, he was a dirtbag when he was with Celeste, and Aspen was her first, but Maxon, even though its not okay, she belongs with him.] Americas hold choose already. Maxon is sweet,..."

It's loves pure form.


back to top