Silvia Moreno-Garcia: Horror Picks to Take Your Reading Beyond Stephenkingitis

Posted by Cybil on October 4, 2021
 
Silvia Moreno-Garcia is the New York Times–bestselling author of critically acclaimed speculative novels including Mexican Gothic (which won the 2020 Goodreads Choice Award for best horror novel), Gods of Jade and Shadow, and Certain Dark Things; the crime novel Untamed Shore; and the noir Velvet Was the Night. She has edited several anthologies, including the World Fantasy Award–winning She Walks in Shadows (a.k.a. Cthulhu's Daughters). 


The horror genre has a condition that I like to call Stephenkingitis. Now, I think King is a wonderful writer, and not only have I enjoyed his novels and collections of short stories, but On Writing: A Memoir of the Craft offers some of the best insights into the profession that I have ever read.

Unfortunately, for several decades now, it has been pretty standard that when I walk into a bookstore, the horror section—if there is one—is reduced to the two big Ks: King, maybe some Koontz. Sometimes there’s a Lovecraft collection thrown in for good measure.

Titles like Rosemary’s Baby, The Exorcist, and The Other catapulted horror into the bestseller lists in the 1970s, and what followed was a rapidly expanding category. In the 1980s, horror paperbacks were hitting the shelves at an astonishing pace. But everything that goes up must come down, and in the early 1990s, the horror bubble burst. The swan song of this era was the Abyss line, which launched with Kathe Koja’s The Cipher.
 
After the ’90s, most imprints turned away from horror. Since it was no longer a commercially viable category, the shelf space for horror was drastically reduced and we ended up with bookstores that only stocked a few horror titles and limited themselves to the heavy hitters that had managed to survive the upheaval.
 
Horror aficionados continued to operate and consume the books put out by small presses, but for the general public, horror seemed to vanish.
 
The erroneous perception that horror only constitutes a limited number of authors and titles obscures the breadth and history of horror fiction. Although some people think horror books need to give you a heart attack in order to be horror, or that horror only means violent murders, horror encompasses everything from Peter Straub’s elegant, slow-paced Ghost Story to Guy N. Smith’s pulpy Crabs: The Human Sacrifice (featuring my favorite book cover of the 1980s).
 
Recently, we have witnessed a resurgence of horror fiction in stores and libraries. We can thank books such as Stephen Graham JonesThe Only Good Indians, Grady Hendrix’s The Final Girl Support Group, or Alma Katsu’s The Hunger for showing publishers and booksellers that horror has some life left in it. Truth be told, horror is like a poltergeist that keeps rattling the dishes and won’t be exorcised. 
 
But despite these successes, there’s still a fair amount of Stephenkingitis, which is the reason I’m penning this list of lesser-known horror titles. So no, Stephen King does not appear on this list, and neither does Clive Barker of the iconic Books of Blood, nor the queen of the undead, Anne Rice. But I hope we can dig up the coffins and unearth some hidden gems—or skeletons—for you.

 
 
The tale of a young woman raised in Jamaica who may or may not be a supernatural predator. Its discussion of race and gender makes this an interesting title, especially when positioned next to Dracula, which was published the same year. The Valancourt edition comes with a handy introduction by Brenda Hammack.


 
Quiroga, who would go on to inspire iconic authors such as Julio Cortázar, has been called the Latin America Poe, and it is easy to see why in this collection of short stories that swirls around themes of madness, obsession, and death.


 
Fans of Dark Academia should get a kick out of this novel about an occultist from turn-of-the-century San Francisco who may have left a dangerous legacy behind embedded in the very architecture of the city.


 
Lush. That is the only way to describe Tanith Lee’s four Paradys books, which are set in a decadent, French-inspired city where scholars are infected with demonic curses, journalists encounter ancient sorcerers, and a labyrinth of ice connects parallel universes.


 
If Quiroga has been called the Latin American Poe, then Dávila would be the Mexican Shirley Jackson. Dávila’s fiction is subtle and disquieting, painting portraits in which the home can be more horrifying than any supernatural entity.


 
A weather official assigned to a distant island near the Antarctic discovers that his outpost is under attack from reptilian creatures and his predecessor has gone a little mad. Strange, bleak, and claustrophobic.


 
A private detective in 1950s New York is hired to find an elusive singer. The attention to period detail in this book is astounding, and it probably served as the predecessor of more than one urban fantasy that decided to marry a hard-boiled detective story with the supernatural.


 
Files has written several novels, but I first discovered her through her short stories and I’m recommending her first collection here. Disturbing and velvety, it’s like eating a poisoned box of chocolates.


 
A man is haunted by the death of his grandmother, who saved him from drowning as a child, and experiences recurring nightmares and episodes of déjà vu as a result. Is it psychological trauma or are sinister forces at work? 


 
A mosaic novel constructed via a series of creepy, interconnected stories about two peculiar Japanese students who share a fascination with murder and death. There's no supernatural element here, just the dark corners of the human mind. It was also adapted into a manga of the same name.


 
When police find a mutilated body, they attribute the death to an animal attack. But the locals who know Creek stories realize a mythical beast is stalking the area. This is a throwback to creature features that will delight readers who don’t mind their gore.


 
The autobiography of one of the undead, laced with angst. No, it’s not Interview with the Vampire. Farrington’s prose evokes Le Fanu rather than Rice, even though it was first published in 1983. Perfect for fans of lush, baroque language.  


Do you have a hidden-gem horror novel recommendation? Share it with your fellow readers in the comments below!

 

Comments Showing 1-50 of 52 (52 new)


message 1: by Christina (new)

Christina Thank you! Have added several of these to my To Read list!


message 2: by Andy (new)

Andy Raptis Check out something titled Selina's Gift


message 3: by Ana (new)

Ana Even though I'm a fan of the King, I am very thankful of this remedy to our communal stephenkingitis (loving the concept so far).
Thank you for including very diverse authors. I was shocked and very pleased to see Amparo Dávila and Horacio Quiroga here. I'll give the rest a go.


message 4: by Bookfan (last edited Oct 04, 2021 09:28AM) (new)

Bookfan The Ruins by Scott Smith
Anything by Adam Nevill, starting with The Ritual but the one I really loved was No One Gets Out Alive.

And I can't agree with the author more about Stephen Kingitis. His books are basically repeats of themselves for a long, long time.


message 5: by M (new)

M Scott Hrm... Octavia Butler & Margaret Atwood are hardly hidden gems; same for Kelly Link. Is Michael Bishop's Brittle Innings Horror? Maybe Jane Yolen's Briar Rose or Karen Russel's Swamplandia. Devil in the White City is probably History & Perdido St. Station probably SFF. Let's end, then, with Daryl Gregory's We are all Completely Fine


message 6: by Tina (new)

Tina Thank you so much for this. I agree completely and it doesn't mean that I dislike any of these authors. As a matter of fact, I have several Barker, Rice and King novels in my collections. I just want some more variety. Adding all these to my list lol


message 7: by Aran (new)

Aran This year I am somehow truly attracted to horror, mostly classics and some movies & tv shows for the nostalgia. Glad I can keep it up with my next reads, thanks for the recs!


message 8: by Kelsie (new)

Kelsie Chiles (To the above comments )She is not slandering King in any way. He is a brilliant writer, and has inspired a countless number of writers. It’s the book stores and websites that suffer from this. It has proven to be borderline difficult to find proper horror outside the King family without a deep dive. A big part of that comes through the fact that everybody absorbs horror differently, and it gets categorized improperly. I’ve read some pretty mortifying “thrillers”, and some pretty vanilla “horrors”.

I’m thankful for these Goodreads articles that come out every October. I literally save every authors name, and every recommended book title just so I can go through them them later and find what works for me!
I love when writers credit writers other than Jackson and King as their inspiration, it really helps me find new books.


message 9: by Juushika (new)

Juushika Not to be That Guy, but Otsuichi's Goth does have a supernatural element! It's discussed in the author's afterwords in the edition linked above: "So the killers that appear in GOTH are not human, but youkai. And the male protagonist is also a youkai, with the same power as the enemies, whereas the female lead has a powerful psychic gift that attracts youkai. As I didn’t use any items or jargon to suggest that this was not our world, people tend to believe the book is set in reality; but in my mind, it absolutely is not." I love how this riffs on the suspension of disbelief required for serialized murder-mysteries and their parade of local murderers; it also contextualizes the female lead's hilarious bad luck and obliviousness.

Anyway it's a great narrative, I love it so much; very much encourage folks to check it out!


message 10: by Razzle (new)

Razzle Oh, what a fantastic list. Thank you!


message 11: by J.D. (new)

J.D. Reynoso Added most of these to my read list!


message 12: by Mary (new)

Mary Welcome Home by Adam Sydney Welcome Home
Penpal by Dathan Auerbach Penpal
The Push by Ashley Audrain The Push

These are three of my all time favorites!


message 13: by Joe (new)

Joe M The Dangers of Smoking in Bed: Stories by Mariana Enríquez is also incredibly creepy, and a perfect October read! º-°


message 14: by mamabrauner (new)

mamabrauner *Adding all to TBR*


message 15: by Dean (new)

Dean Stephen Graham Jones.
Phillip Fracassi.
Chuck Wendig.


message 16: by Andy (last edited Oct 07, 2021 12:31PM) (new)

Andy Weston Night Theatreby Vikram Paralkar
The Vampire of Ropraz by Jacques Chessex
Ankomst by Gohril Gabrielsen
The Route of Ice and Salt by Jose Louis Zarate
Hadriana in All My Dreams by Rene Depestre
Into Bones like Oil by Kaaron Warren
Children of The Caveby Verve Sammalkorpi
Perfect Days by Raphael Montes

Thanks for all the recommendations..


message 17: by Wanda (new)

Wanda Maynard I have added quiet a few of these books to my reading list; and I am currently reading CHASING THE BOOGEYMAN by Richard Chizmar.


message 18: by Rachel (new)

Rachel Beauchamp-Ferrero Tananarive Due's The Good House is also excellent


message 19: by Lady (new)

Lady Dazy An interesting selection of books.


message 20: by Paul (new)

Paul O’Neill Like I didn't have enough to read already. Humph...


message 21: by dan epstein (new)

dan epstein Gotta check few of the titles here for sure. I’m a sucker for the short mystery stories by Mariana Enriquez at the moment.


message 22: by Geoff (new)

Geoff I think it's tacky to namedrop in a negative fashion like this, if only because it encourages less "professional" people in the comments to be rude about his work and the people who read it. That being said, there were a few things I added to my to-read from this list... But I'm staying far away from unnecessarily fluffy baroque language. Makes reading a chore rather than fun for me.


message 23: by Andy (new)

Andy Ohm Love this list! I didn’t realise how much horror I’d been missing out on. Added more than a few to my list. Thank you!


message 24: by Kerry (new)

Kerry Thanks for the list, but don't "King" shame me.


message 25: by Nicholas (new)

Nicholas Perez Yes! Tanith Lee's Books of Paradys series!


message 26: by Emmett (new)

Emmett Great list! Added many to my to-read.


message 27: by Tra-Kay (new)

Tra-Kay The Black Spider is an awesome 18th century slim horror novel with truly creepy scenes.


Erin *Proud Book Hoarder* I've read Crota, which I liked well enough (3/5 stars), and I loved Falling Angel. Haven't read the others suggested yet.


message 29: by Poetniknowit (new)

Poetniknowit Another way to find great horror novels is simply by looking through the listopia lists on Goodreads, or the horrorlit subreddit. I've broadened my horror horizons way past Kingitis thanks to Reddit and a ton of great recommendations there.


message 30: by Mary (new)

Mary Great list, but you forgot the wonderful book by Muriel Grey, THE TRICKSTER.


message 31: by Russell (new)

Russell Johnson Mexican Gothic belongs here too.


message 32: by Alison (new)

Alison Lee Thank you for sharing! 🖤🦇🎃👻


message 33: by Claudia (new)

Claudia I'm from Argentina, so I love that you have Horacio Quiroga in this list, as he was my introduction to horror. Yes, they got us reading it in primary (elementary?) school :P

And I found some books that seem very interesting in this list. Oh, well! Who needs a manageable to-read list? *laughs*


message 34: by Lori Michutka (new)

Lori Michutka Russell wrote: "Mexican Gothic belongs here too." Agree!


message 35: by Lori Michutka (new)

Lori Michutka Like I don't have enough books to read as it is. Thanks for this list, Silvia! On your mark, get set, READ!!


message 36: by Trike (new)

Trike The real horror is the increased size of my TBR. 😈🎃


message 37: by Betty-Anne (new)

Betty-Anne Wow thanks. I have added several of these to my want to read list.


message 38: by Ursula (new)

Ursula Pflug Carlos Fuentes' Aura. Read it decades ago and never forgot it.


message 39: by Robert (last edited Oct 27, 2021 03:09PM) (new)

Robert Herold Great suggestions!!
There's another Fritz Leiber book I love, The Conjure Wife.
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
I also loved your book!
(I guess it would be tacky to recommend my own!)


message 40: by Cecil (new)

Cecil Huston Thanks for some great suggestions for my spooky season TBR list! Penpal, by Auerbach Dathan, was short but very creepy, and Night Film by Marisha Pessl was very different, but unsettling enough to be considered horror. Dan Simmons has a good series, starting with Summer of Night.


message 41: by Kimberly (new)

Kimberly Adding most of these to my list! I have to admit that any book that Stephen King likes is an instant TBR for me. His recommendation brought your book into my hands and I am so glad it did. I loved your book.


message 42: by Fiona (new)

Fiona Great list - thank you


message 43: by Rebel (new)

Rebel Reads What a fantastic list of books. Thanks!


message 44: by Berenice (new)

Berenice Muchas gracias to Silvia for adding a Mexican author, Amparo Dávila, her stories are brilliant and strange. And the wonderful Horacio Quiroga from Uruguay, he is a staple of the Magic Realism in Latin-American and really master of the obscure states of mind. I highly recommend to all American readers to explore authors from other countries.


message 45: by Erin (new)

Erin My to be read list has gotten longer, but what fascinating books have been added! As much as I enjoy what I've read of Stephen King, his works are definitely prolific to the point that lesser known authors are harder to find (so much King, Poe, and Lovecraft- all of which are fascinating to read, but I already know of their work). From other comments on here, I see that several of these authors aren't obscure, but I certainly had never heard of them.

I loved Mexican Gothic. It wasn't at all what I expected and I will have to read more of her work, too. I did notice how classy she was to not list any of her own books, even though it would have been understandable!


message 46: by Marisa (new)

Marisa This is awesome!! Thanks for sharing!


message 47: by Kristine (new)

Kristine I ordered Crota today! I had seen it in a list before & forgot about it.
Btw…I would be very interested in a sequel to Gods of Jade & Shadow!


message 48: by Keith (new)

Keith CARTER The Haunting of Hill House has to be on any list.


message 49: by JoyReaderGirl1 (new)

JoyReaderGirl1 Adore the list and added them all to " be read." Thank you.

Another fantastic one for the season, if anyone hasn't already read and enjoyed is "The Historian," by Elizabeth Kostova. My Goodreads's review follows.
====

“The Historian,” by Elizabeth Kostova is a darkly chilling and profoundly intelligent tale like none other of it’s genre. It is a remarkably compelling, comprehensive and compulsively readable fictionalized history of the vampire origins of Vlad Tepes (Count Dracula).

Narrated by an unnamed Dutch girl who finds a mysterious antique vellum-bound book with a center woodcut of a dragon hidden in her father’s study, this frightening, eerie saga emerges.

Readers with an appreciation for prosaic epistolary literature; grand Gothics; historical European travelogues; thrilling mysteries; as well as sensual allegorical and metaphorical imagery will feast on this treasure.

Read and become entranced… Perhaps Dracula is still alive and listening?


message 50: by Natasha (new)

Natasha Here to recommend Jonathan Aycliffe, particularly 'Naomi's Room' , which creeps me out at every single re read!


« previous 1
back to top