The Seasonal Reading Challenge discussion

note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
219 views
SUMMER CHALLENGE 2025 > Completed Tasks: PLEASE DO NOT DELETE ANY POST IN THIS THREAD!

Comments Showing 1,101-1,150 of 2,561 (2561 new)    post a comment »

message 1101: by Mrsgeo (new)

Mrsgeo | 301 comments SHEMAC

25.2 - Robin P's Task: Enjoying Summer - Not!

This is a two book task, choose two different options and read one book for each option.
Required: state the options - Option 3 and 4

Option 3 - Read a book whose author has first and last initials made up of these letters. That is, the author initials are AA, AB, AO, BA, BB, BO, OA, OB, or OO - BB

Omega's Teacher by Bella Bennet

Option 4 - Read a book from the first 25 pages of one of these lists.
Winter Books
Christmas Books
Required: State the list and the page - Christmas Books; page 5

The Geek Who Saved Christmas

This task points: 25
Total season points: 480


message 1102: by Elizabeth (new)

Elizabeth (ebpnd17) | 811 comments Elizabeth P

Task 5.9 - Sand Time
Word of 4+ letters in title can be made from GREAT SAND DUNES

Great Big Beautiful Life by Emily Henry
Word: Great
GREAT sand dunes


Points this Post: 5
Total Points: 90
Total Tasks: 7
GO: 0
BB: 0
IAF: 0
Total Books: 7


message 1103: by Robin P (new)

Robin P | 1609 comments ROBIN P

20.3 Shorter is Sweeter: Karen Michele's Task - I Wonder
Option 1: Book focuses on animals

Call of the Penguins

Points this post: 20
Total points: 480

BB:3 GO:0 IAF:5


message 1104: by Fly (last edited Jul 13, 2025 05:24PM) (new)

Fly (fly-me-to-the-moo) | 889 comments FLY

Task #15.6 Animals, Animals, Animals!
+IAF ticket


task: one of the listed words in the title
book: James Herriot's Animal Stories
(my version is audio, no MMPB or PB, first HC here)
how it fits: "Animal" in the title

other:
**Claiming IAF ticket for nonfiction memoir

Points this post: 15
Total points: 375
Tasks completed: 21/56

BB: 9 / GO: 5 / IAF: 1 + 1 = 2


message 1105: by Fly (new)

Fly (fly-me-to-the-moo) | 889 comments FLY

Task #15.7 Bright and Beautiful

task: cover at least 50% blue OR green OR Red
book: In an Absent Dream
(my version is audio, no MMPB, first PB here)
how it fits: In an Absent Dream (Wayward Children, #4) by Seanan McGuire
TinEye:
58.5 % #1c2f3a Blue
19.8 % #1a5b79 Blue
5.2 % #698695 Grey
4.2 % #695955 Grey
3.8 % #dde0e1 Grey
3.1 % #a49d9c Grey
2.8 % #542418 Brown
1.5 % #a04617 Brown
0.8 % #793415 Brown
0.4 % #169fba Blue


Points this post: 15
Total points: 390
Tasks completed: 22/56

BB: 9 / GO: 5 / IAF: 2


message 1106: by Fly (new)

Fly (fly-me-to-the-moo) | 889 comments FLY

Task #15.5 Land of Dragons

task: author initials in Komodo OR Dragon OR Lizard
book: Faceless
(my version is audio, no MMPB, first PB here)
how it fits: author Rob Ashman initials RA in d(RA)gon


Points this post: 15
Total points: 405
Tasks completed: 23/56

BB: 9 / GO: 5 / IAF: 2


message 1107: by Julia (new)

Julia (julia103) | 2719 comments Julia103

30.5 Delicious Dee 's Task: Classic Science-Fiction: HG Wells

Option 2: Read a book by a single author where ALL the authors initials can be found in H.G. Wells.
The Convenient Marriage by Georgette Heyer

Option 3: - H.G. Wells was born 21 September 1866 and died 13 August 1946. Read a book that was first published between those dates.
The Penguin Pool Murder
(first published January 1931)

The Convenient Marriage was first published in 1934.
The Penguin Pool Murder was first published in 1931.
Claiming two Golden Oldie tickets.

This post: 30 points, 2 GO
Total points: 460
BB: 4
GO: 3
NF: 1
Tasks completed: 22
Books read: 32


message 1108: by Fly (new)

Fly (fly-me-to-the-moo) | 889 comments FLY

Task #10.3 500 Reads of Summer

task: from the first 25 pages of the Summer Books shelf
book: The Southern Book Club's Guide to Slaying Vampires
(my version is audio, first MMPB here)
how it fits: on page 15 of the list

Points this post: 10
Total points: 415
Tasks completed: 24/56

BB: 9 / GO: 5 / IAF: 2


message 1109: by Erica (new)

Erica | 154 comments Erica H.

15.7 Bright and Beautiful

Read a book that is at least 50% blue OR 50% green OR 50% Red according to Tineye.
Required: Post the cover

The Midnight Library is 82.6% blue per Tineye The Midnight Library by Matt Haig

Points: 15
Total points: 210
BB: 1
GO: 1
NF: 1


message 1110: by C (new)

C | 350 comments Lora
Task: 5.5 Summer Solstice
Read a book where the first letter of each word in the title from the phrase "Summer Solstice".
Book/Author: The Mistletoe Mystery / Nita Prose
How it fits: using TMM from suMMer solsTice

Points for this task: 5
Total points: 420
Big Book tickets for this task: 0
Big Book tickets total: 3
Golden Oldies tickets for this task: 0
Golden Oldies tickets total: 2
It's a Fact tickets for this task: 0
It's a Fact tickets total: 1


message 1111: by C (new)

C | 350 comments Lora
Task: 20.4 Golden Oldies: Kai's Task - London Adventure, using Option 5: Read a book with an MPG of Historical, Romance, or Historical Romance.
Book/Author: A Fellowship of Bakers & Magic / J. Penner
How it fits: MPG Romance

Points for this task: 20
Total points: 440
Big Book tickets for this task: 0
Big Book tickets total: 3
Golden Oldies tickets for this task: 0
Golden Oldies tickets total: 2
It's a Fact tickets for this task: 0
It's a Fact tickets total: 1


message 1112: by Tess (new)

Tess (tessavanessa) | 2114 comments TessaVanessa

Challenge 5.7 Summer Vacations

Read a book with at least one adult and two or more children on the book cover.

Pilgrim's Wilderness A True Story of Faith and Madness on the Alaska Frontier by Tom Kizzia by Tom Kizzia

Points this post: 5
Total points: 655/975
Task completed: 42/56


message 1113: by Tess (new)

Tess (tessavanessa) | 2114 comments TessaVanessa

Challenge 30.1 JennRenee's Task: The Great Yellowstone

Option 2: read a book with MPG Romance

Submerged by Dani Pettrey

This is Dani's debut book.

Option 3: Read a book with a cover featuring at least 5 different colors according to Tineye.

Girl Fifteen: Deceived by Molly Black

46.8 %#ad9979Brown
28.5 %#c2c9ceGrey
7.3 %#1f1149Violet
6.2 %#4e453dGrey
4.3 %#f61916Red
3.0 %#5c526fViolet
1.7 %#e86b59Red
1.4 %#db9478Pink
0.5 %#efcf80Yellow
0.4 %#dd979cPink

Points this post: 30
Total points: 685/975
Task completed: 43/56


message 1114: by Tess (new)

Tess (tessavanessa) | 2114 comments TessaVanessa

Challenge 30.7 Cat's Task: Books of Europe

Option 1:

Book 1: Read a book that is set (at least 70%) in one or more countries in Europe, or is about one or more countries in Europe (if Non-Fiction), but is NOT United Kingdom (i.e. England, Wales, Scotland, Northern Ireland).

A Woman in Berlin: Eight Weeks in the Conquered City: A Diary by Anonymous

Set in Germany.

Book 2: Read a book that is written by an author born in a country in Europe, excluding UK.

The Lost Daughter by Elena Ferrante

Elena was born in Italy.

Points this post: 30
Total points: 715/975
Task completed: 44/56


message 1115: by Nick (last edited Jul 14, 2025 05:28AM) (new)

Nick (doily) | 3392 comments Nick KY

15.4 Beauty in Words


National parks are all about Nature and preserving the beauty in our world.
For this task, use the website https://www.readpoetry.com/poems-that...
Option 2: One Book Task. Read a single book that satisfies both criteria:

1: Read a book whose title (subtitles are excluded) contains a 4 or more letter word from one of the poems on the website. Words must be stand alone and match exact.

2: Read a book with an author that shares either a name or initials with one of the poets on this website.

I read Those We Thought We Knew by David Joy.

Title word “Thought” is in the poem by Emily Dickenson:

He glanced with rapid eyes,
That hurried all abroad –
They looked like frightened Beads, I thought,
He stirred his Velvet Head. (lines 9-12),

and the author shares the name “Joy” with poet Joy Harjo.

Points This Post: 15
Total Points So Far: 585


message 1116: by Nick (new)

Nick (doily) | 3392 comments Nick KY

10.7 Camp Rock.


Main character is a performance artist, in this case an actor.

I read The Parasites by Daphne du Maurier.

From Wiki. “ The novel follows the three children of the Delaney family - Maria, Niall, and Celia….Maria becomes a beautiful, successful actress.”

Points This Post: 10
Total Points So Far: 595


message 1117: by Kai (new)

Kai Coates (southernbohemian) | 403 comments Kai


15.3 Quantity or Size?
OPTION 2: Read a book set at least 75% in Australia AND read a book with title with 6+ words excluding subtitles

The Mystery of a Hansom Cab by Fergus W. Hume
Setting = Melbourne, Australia

**Claiming 1 Golden Oldie Ticket - First Published 1886**

New Points: 15
Tasks Completed: 18
Total Points: 295


BIG BOOK: 0
GOLDEN OLDIES: 2
IT'S A FACT: 1



message 1118: by Brigia (new)

Brigia | 451 comments 5.5 Summer Solstice

Book: Rogue
Task: Read a book where the first letter of each word in the title (subtitle words excluded) from the phrase "Summer Solstice"
How it fits: title word starts with R, in summeR

I read the kindle edition. The paperback edition has 312 pages.

Points this post: 5
Total points: 50


message 1119: by Lois (new)

Lois | 2632 comments 20.6 It's a Fact: Kristen IA's Task - Let’s Go to the Park!


Option 1, a book published in 2025: The Bright Years by Sarah Damoff

hard cover edition The Bright Years

Points this post: 20
Total points: 205


message 1120: by Robin P (new)

Robin P | 1609 comments ROBIN P

5.4 World Environment
Author initials in WORLD ENVIRONMENT DAY

Poseidon's Gold - Lindsey Davis

Points this post: 5
Total points: 485

BB:3 GO:0 IAF:5


message 1121: by Jecca (new)

Jecca | 735 comments 5.2 Civil War

Read a book with MPG War , Civil War, or Military Fiction.
MPG may be stand alone or embedded.

When We Had Wings by Ariel Lawhon, Kristina McMorris and Susan Meissner

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Points This Post: 5
Total Points: 435
Total Tasks Completed: 20
* * * * * * *
Big Books: 2
Golden Oldies:
It's a Fact: 1


World War II is the 3rd genre


message 1122: by Jecca (new)

Jecca | 735 comments 10.2 I Know What You Read Last Summer

Read a book that was claimed in the Summer 2024 Challenge Completed Task Thread

Post #64

Bad Summer People by Emma Rosenblum

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Points This Post: 10
Total Points: 445
Total Tasks Completed: 21
* * * * * * *
Big Books: 2
Golden Oldies:
It's a Fact: 1


message 1123: by Jecca (new)

Jecca | 735 comments 15.1 More or Less?

Book 1: Read the book with the most ratings on your TBR

Frankenstein: The 1818 Text by Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley


1,767,211 ratings

Claiming Golden Oldies - this was first published in 1818

Book 2: Read the book with the least ratings on your TBR

Last Twilight in Paris by Pam Jenoff

15,321 ratings

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Points This Post: 15
Total Points: 460
Total Tasks Completed: 22
* * * * * * *
Big Books: 2
Golden Oldies: 1
It's a Fact: 1


message 1124: by Jecca (new)

Jecca | 735 comments 15.9 Let's Go Camping

Read a book with a camper, tent, or RV on the cover.

All the Missing Pieces by Catherine Cowles by Catherine Cowles

This was approved on the help thread.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Points This Post: 15
Total Points: 475
Total Tasks Completed: 23
* * * * * * *
Big Books: 2
Golden Oldies: 1
It's a Fact: 1


message 1125: by Kim, Moderator (new)

Kim (kmyers) | 1043 comments Mod
XBM

25.1 - Ash's Task: Boss Level

Option 2-Animal Crossing
Read a book with Olive in the title.
Olive, Again. Elizabeth Strout

Option 3-Minecraft
For this option read a book with a 4 or more letter word in the title that can be made up of letters in "creepers have no respect". OVER
Glory Over Everything: Beyond The Kitchen House. Kathleen Grissom

Required: State the word.

Points this post: 25
Total Points: 285 /1000
Tasks Completed 21/57


message 1126: by Jecca (new)

Jecca | 735 comments 25.3 - Shemac's task: Celebrating the end of WW2

Option 1 - Read a book that is set (at least 50%) in any combination of Japan

Before the Coffee Gets Cold by Toshikazu Kawaguchi

From the synopsis "In a small back alley in Tokyo"

213 pages

Option 2 - Read a book that has MPG World War II

Code Name Hélène by Ariel Lawhon

451 pages

World War II is the 3rd genre

Total 664 pages

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Points This Post: 25
Total Points: 500
Total Tasks Completed: 24
* * * * * * *
Big Books: 2
Golden Oldies: 1
It's a Fact: 1


message 1127: by Tien (new)

Tien (tiensblurb) | 2304 comments 25.2 - Robin P's Task: Enjoying Summer - Not!
Option 1 - read a book whose title (Subtitles may be ignored) does not contain any of the letters SWEAT.
Cold Blood (Aidan Snow #1) by Alex Shaw

Option 4 - Read a book from the first 25 pages of one of these lists: Winter Books (page 7)
House of Earth and Blood (Crescent City #1) by Sarah J. Maas

Task total: 25
Season total: 460



message 1128: by Jecca (new)

Jecca | 735 comments 25.5 - Fly's Task - Celebrating Summertime

June - Option 2

Quicksilver by Callie Hart

Claiming a Big Book for 624 pages

August Option 2

Read a book by an author whose initials (first and last) are in one of the following words: SmORes

The Glass Hotel by Emily St. John Mandel

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Points This Post: 25
Total Points: 525
Total Tasks Completed: 25
* * * * * * *
Big Books: 3
Golden Oldies: 1
It's a Fact: 1


message 1129: by Chandni (new)

Chandni (chandnin31) | 507 comments CHANDNI

30.1 JennRenee's Task: The Great Yellowstone

Option 1: Water Water and More Water
Read a book with a title/subtitle that contains one of these words.
waterfall, lake, river, stream, pond, wetlands

Crow Lake by Mary Lawson

Option 2: Read a book with MPG Romance.

Gone With the Wind by Margaret Mitchell

Both of these books are debut novels.

Points this post: 30
Total points: 290


message 1130: by Kelly (new)

Kelly L (kelly29) | 282 comments Kelly L

20.10 Group Reads
Fiction: Modern Classics - The Poisonwood Bible
I just posted in the Group Discussion thread - what a great read!!

**Claiming a Big Book ticket -- 546 pages**

-----------------------------
This post: 20 points
Tickets: 1 BB
-----------------------------
Season total: 115 points
Season Tickets: 1 IAF, 1 BB


message 1131: by Ash, Moderator (new)

Ash (essentiallyash) | 336 comments Mod
ASH

30.1 JennRenee's Task: The Great Yellowstone
Option 1: Water Water and More Water
Read a book with a title/subtitle that contains one of these words. Plurals/Possessives accepted, no other variations
waterfall, lake, river, stream, pond, wetlands
The River Has Roots

Option 2
Get hot and steamy and read a book with MPG Romance, may be standalone or embedded
Voice of the Ocean- Debut novel

Points this Post: 30
Total Points: 525


message 1132: by Tien (new)

Tien (tiensblurb) | 2304 comments 20.8 Shorter is Sweeter: MEGSCL's Task
Option 1- read any book first published in March 2025 or later.
Daughters of Flood and Fury (Stormbringer #2) by Gabriella Buba
published 7/22/25 - I read eARC gifted by author

Task total: 20
Season total: 480



message 1133: by Tien (new)

Tien (tiensblurb) | 2304 comments 20.5 Bigger is Better: Kathy KS's Task - Light Up My World, Scarlett!
Option 3 - Read a book with an author born or living in one of these states: Mississippi
Sartoris by William Faulkner
author born in Mississippi as per GR profile

Task total: 20
Season total: 500



message 1134: by Jayne, Moderator Emeritus (new)

Jayne (littlemissskittles) | 1399 comments Mod
JAYNE

15.8 - Shipwrecked and Stranded

Read a book where a shipwreck or someone who stranded in the ocean or on an island is essential to the story.

The Island of Doctor Moreau

MC is stranded on the titular island following a shipwreck.

This book was first published in 1896. One Golden Oldies ticket please!

Points this task: 15

Season total: 135
BB Tickets: 5
GO Tickets: 1
IAF Tickets: 2


message 1135: by KSMary (last edited Jul 15, 2025 05:58AM) (new)

KSMary | 1181 comments 10.6 Theater Camp - Read a book first published either in July of any year or any month for the year 2022.
They Called Us Enemy
Pub. July 16, 2019

*Claiming It's a Fact Ticket for NF

Points: 10
Total/challenge: 10
IAF ticket: 1


message 1136: by KSMary (last edited Jul 15, 2025 05:58AM) (new)

KSMary | 1181 comments 15.5 Land of Dragons
Read a book with a single author with all initials found in Komodo OR Dragon OR Lizard.
Dopamine Nation: Finding Balance in the Age of Indulgence by Anna Lembke
A,L in LizArd

*Claiming It's a Fact Ticket for NF

Points: 15
Total/challenge: 25
IAF: 1/2


message 1137: by KSMary (new)

KSMary | 1181 comments 15.9 Let's Go Camping - camper, RV or tent on cover
Deserts, Driving, & Derelicts (Camper & Criminals #2) by Tonya Kappes

Points: 15
Total: 40


message 1138: by KSMary (new)

KSMary | 1181 comments 20.5 Light Up my World, Scarlett
Opt 4 Suspense: standalone or embedded, Thriller(s): standalone, or Fantasy: standalone MPG

The Tenant - Thriller

Points: 20
Total/challenge: 60


message 1139: by KSMary (new)

KSMary | 1181 comments 20.6 Let's Go to the Park
Pub in 2008, 2014, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024, and 2025.

The First Ladies
Pub June 27, 2023

Points: 20
Total/challenge: 80


message 1140: by KSMary (new)

KSMary | 1181 comments 20.8 2025 Goals
Option 2- Read award shortlists. Read a book that has been longlisted, shortlisted, or won any of these prizes in any year.
Required: The award must be listed on the GR book page

Stella Prize
Women's Prize for Fiction
Miles Franklin
Booker Prize

James
Booker Prize shortlist 2024

Points: 20
Total/challenge: 100


message 1141: by KSMary (new)

KSMary | 1181 comments 25.1 Boss Level
Opt 1 Pick a book from list
Oona Out of Order
Time Loops list - page 1

Opt 3 - For this option read a book with a 4 or more letter word in the title that can be made up of letters in "creepers have no respect".
The Longest Race: Inside the Secret World of Abuse, Doping, and Deception on Nike's Elite Running Team
RACE
R,C,E - CREepers
A - hAve

*Claiming IAF ticket for NF

Points: 25
Total: 125
IAF: 1/3


message 1142: by Nick (new)

Nick (doily) | 3392 comments Nick KY

15.7 Bright and Beautiful
50+% Blue -- I read The Deluge by Stephen Markley. 81.4% blue The Deluge by Stephen Markley

I listened to the audiobook. No Mass Market Paperback. The most popular paperback is The Deluge.

CLAIM TWO BIG BOOKS for The Deluge at 836 pp.

https://labs.tineye.com/color/9d06d2a...

Points This Post: 15
Total Points So Far: 610

Big Books So Far: 750+ (2) = 4 BB Tickets


message 1143: by KSMary (new)

KSMary | 1181 comments 25.3 Celebrating the End of WWII >500 pgs

Opt 1 - set in Japan
The Travelling Cat Chronicles - 277 pgs

Opt 2 - MPG World War II
Mrs. Roosevelt’s Confidante- 337 pgs
277+337=614 pgs

Points: 25
Total/challenge: 150


message 1144: by KSMary (new)

KSMary | 1181 comments 30.2 Wrapped in Plastic
Opt 2 - sword or conifer on cover
Once Dishonored (Rogues Redeemed, #5) by Mary Jo Putney - sword

Opt 3 Read a book from the first 20 pages of this
Good Vs Evil list
Witch & Wizard
Page 1 of list

Points: 30
Total/challenge: 180


message 1145: by KSMary (new)

KSMary | 1181 comments 30.6 Catching up on Series
Opt B Choose a book from my Series-SRCSummer shelf. Read that book or one in the same series.
State of the Onion

Opt 3 - Read a book that is #3 or above but not the last published book in the series
Once a Spy - Rogues Redeemed #4

Points: 30
Total/challenge: 210


message 1146: by Jessica (new)

Jessica (bookwrm526) | 2106 comments Bookwrm526

Task #20.2 - Favorite things about Books

Option 2: Read a book with a word of at least four letters in the title/subtitle spelled from the phrase BIRTHDAY CELEBRATIONS. I made the word BONES (b in birthday, ONES in celebrations) and read Bury Our Bones in the Midnight Soil by V.E. Schwab.

Total points so far: 330


message 1147: by KSMary (last edited Jul 15, 2025 06:31AM) (new)

KSMary | 1181 comments 30.7 Books of Europe - 1 book option >500 pgs
Read a book that is set (at least 70%) in one or more countries in Europe, or is about one or more countries in Europe (if Non-Fiction), but is NOT United Kingdom and
Read a book that is written by an author born in a country in Europe, excluding UK. Multiple authors are allowed, provided that ALL are born within Europe.

The Hypnotist by Lars Kepler - 503 pages
Book set in Sweden and author is Lars Kepler writing duo of Alexander Ahndoril and Alexandra Coelho Ahndoril who were both born in Sweden

Points: 30
Total/challenge: 240


message 1148: by KSMary (new)

KSMary | 1181 comments 30.8 Gregorian Games - each book >250 pgs
Opt 1 Read a book with a variant of the number 6,7, or 8 in the TITLE ONLY.
The Power of Six 406 pgs

Opt 2 Read a book where the name of the Month (June, July OR August ) is found intact in the title
The Unmaking of June Farrow 320 pgs

Points: 30
Total/challenge: 270


message 1149: by KSMary (new)

KSMary | 1181 comments 30.10 Return of a Favorite
Opt 1: Read a book with one of these words from the series in the title (subtitle excluded). Rules, Shadow, Eyes, Silent, Winter, Night, Mind, Sudden, Secret, Certain, Easy, Chosen, Mortal, Naked, Hidden, Broken, Invisible, Phantom, Wicked, Storm, Buried, Stolen, Silken, Field, Gathering, Extreme, Golden, Twisted, Neon, Masked, Ocean, Righteous, Judgment, Toxic, Lethal
The Secret History - 559 pages
Secret is the word used from the list

Opt 4 Read a book by an author who shares a first or last name with one of the recurring characters. Lucas Davenport, Jennifer Carey, Weather Karkinnen, Virgil Flowers, Del Capslock, Harrison Sloan, Letty Davenport, Rose Marie Roux (Rose or Marie work), Marcy Sherrill, Elle Kruger

Champion by Marie Lu

Marie matches Rose Marie Roux (Rose or Marie work)

Points: 30
Total/challenge: 300


message 1150: by Karen Michele (last edited Jul 15, 2025 07:39AM) (new)

Karen Michele Burns (klibrary) | 2062 comments 10.7 Camp Rock

Read a book where the MC is a performance artist or performing arts is central to the story.
For the purpose of this task performance artist is someone who performs in front of an audience for entertainment.

From GR description:

"students at a highly competitive performing arts high school struggle and thrive in a rarified bubble, ambitiously pursuing music, movement, Shakespeare, and, particularly, their acting classes. "

Trust Exercise by Susan Choi

Task Total: 10
Season Total: 155


back to top
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.