Red Queen (Red Queen, #1) Red Queen discussion


4910 views
Maven or Cal???

Comments Showing 1,151-1,200 of 1,247 (1247 new)    post a comment »

message 1151: by Abby (new) - rated it 5 stars

Abby Vikasini wrote: "Abby wrote: "Shaona wrote: "I love Maven. Even after his betrayal. I still love him."

BUUUT, do you think he should be Mare's significant other? Her lover? Her husband? Her true love?"
NOOOOOOOOOO..."


Lol good


shaona ♡ Abby wrote: "Shaona wrote: "I love Maven. Even after his betrayal. I still love him."

BUUUT, do you think he should be Mare's significant other? Her lover? Her husband? Her true love?"


I think he has the potential for a redemption arc as I think he's very broken, gentle and vulnerable inside and just wants to please his evil mother Elara since as a child he was always overlooked and placed in the shadow of Cal. I'm not sure if Mare and Maven will end up together but I still hope that Maven will have a happy ending and for some reason I think he will start to act the way Draco Malfoy did towards the end of the HP books xx


mi ♡ Ummm, once you finish the book you'll pretty much hate Maven. In the end, I didn't want her to be with anyone.


mi ♡ Ann wrote: "I disagree with you all. I don't really like either of them. Cal, to me, is a bit of an ass, while Maven…well, YOU know. Didn't like him when I started reading the book, still don't like him after...."

Sameee i didn't really like any of them


message 1155: by Natalie (new) - rated it 5 stars

Natalie Cal. While Maven understands Mare in some ways, he's just not a good person, that's the difference that decides it. Cal understands her pain completely, and more than that he knows what it is to go through what they have and hold on to who you are. He didn't lose himself to become a miserable person only trying to fix his life, no matter the cost. Maven did. Cal understands her and he helps her through it all.


message 1156: by Hannah (new)

Hannah I seriously cannot chose. Honestly if I had to chose out of the two which one I like better, it has to be Maven. Maven is such an intricate character. You cannot tell what he is thinking or what he's going to do which makes it so fun to read about him. He's so twisted I enjoy trying to unravel him.

On the other side, you have Cal who I personally think is a bit boring. maybe if I met him I would think differently, but he is way too indecisive. The fact that he can't chose, Mare or the Crown, get kind of tiring. Throughout all the books he can't decide who's side he is on or what he believes. Then again, if Mare likes him there must be some reason why.

However that's just me personally. But to ship with Mare, I honestly can't decide.


message 1157: by name (new) - rated it 4 stars

name deleted user wrote: "Who Do You Think Mare Should End Up With????

I Actually Feel SO Torn.

I Really Like Maven and Cal xD

I Usually Fall For The Mysterious,Dangerous Bad Boy"


It's hard to say since, I haven't finished the series, but like the nicer version of Maven, and if he stayed like that I would've preferred Maven over Cal.


message 1158: by Abby (new) - rated it 5 stars

Abby Nate wrote: "Cal. While Maven understands Mare in some ways, he's just not a good person, that's the difference that decides it. Cal understands her pain completely, and more than that he knows what it is to go..."

Bingo


message 1159: by Shelby (new) - added it

Shelby Maven. He was so...........untold. Though I am disappointed in him.


shaona ♡ Hannah wrote: "I seriously cannot chose. Honestly if I had to chose out of the two which one I like better, it has to be Maven. Maven is such an intricate character. You cannot tell what he is thinking or what he..."

Yessssssss


message 1161: by نغم (new) - rated it 2 stars

نغم Maven all the way


message 1162: by Abby (new) - rated it 5 stars

Abby I love this debate so much, even though the correct answer is obvious.


message 1163: by Lilly (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lilly Solomon I think I would choose cal, he's the kinder, funnier, and hotter brother. Plus he has no murderous feelings towards Mare lol


The Fifth Eliot neither! I think she should devote herself to something else rather than a person. id like it if she ends up exploring the other lands briefly mentioned. ive only read first two books.


message 1165: by Minglu (new) - rated it 1 star

Minglu Jiang I may not have liked the book, but I did have opinions on the love triangle.
Maven all the way - even after the twist.


message 1166: by Sarah (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sarah A Maven. Cal wasn't nearly as compelling as him. Plus he has a total Loki vibe they both have/are:
-dark black short sleek hair (Thor 1)
-pale skin
-lithe but athletic build
-blue eyes
-prince
-the second son with no chance of being king
-hate their older brother and the shadows they cast and father
-conspire to kill brother and father
-love their mother (sorta for Mavy)
-magic
-mental issues/identity crisis
-backstabbers
-killed innocents (Jotun genocide was bad move Loki)


message 1167: by Abby (new) - rated it 5 stars

Abby Cal. Fight meh.


message 1168: by Mia (new)

Mia Maven and mare all the way!


message 1169: by Mia (new)

Mia I really want maven and mare to work out!


message 1170: by Sarah (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sarah A Mia wrote: "Maven and mare all the way!"

Good luck with that...


The Fifth Eliot Mia. And they all need to call their mothers and say “you have failed me” 🤭


Paige⭑⭒ Leahest Leah wrote: "Cal, all the way. I was on Cal's team the first moment he entered the story. What really sold me though, was the dance lessons."

YES!!!!!


message 1173: by Chloe (new) - rated it 5 stars

Chloe Cal, definitely Cal!

LOL I was just talking about this question!


message 1174: by mimi (new) - rated it 5 stars

mimi Jen wrote: "I haven't finished the book yet. I am just about half trough but I would still like to say what I am thinking right know. I pretty much like both of them. Cal is the typical more badass guy and Mav..."

I bet you are regretting that now XD


message 1175: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Nicole Jam wrote: "I'm the only one who really loves Maven. Even if he doesn't end up with Mare I want him to have a great ending in the trilogy."

I really love Maven too! I was so sad at the end when he betrayed Mare ;(


message 1176: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Nicole Deena Beena wrote: "this probably makes me a really twisted person but i honestly want her to be with Maven still haahahaahahahahahaha"

Same Girl! #MavenGirl


Sarah.H.L No matter what he did, Maven will always be my sweet, little, messed up baby. Always Maven, Cal is to self-centered.


message 1178: by Kianna (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kianna I was absolutely Mareven before Elara messed with his mind but he is never going to go back to the person he was before, the person mare loved and wanted. I am all for Milorin because mare even said, if things hadn't turned out this way she would absolutely enjoy a life with the fish boy.


Goldilocks Well I think it's pretty obvious that Mare is going to end up with Cal. But personally I totally love Maven! I mean when I first started reading the book I totally fell in love with Maven and then at the end I was like 'oh I should have known' since all my favorite characters either start out evil or end up evil. *shrug*


message 1180: by tabby (new) - rated it 3 stars

tabby Leahest Leah wrote: "Cal, all the way. I was on Cal's team the first moment he entered the story. What really sold me though, was the dance lessons."

No, hun! Maven all the WAY! I’ve started the third book in the trilogy, and I’m commenting this like 3 yrs later, but still MAVEN! I CANNOT STAND CAL


message 1181: by Abby (new) - rated it 5 stars

Abby itzdianax wrote: "Leahest Leah wrote: "Cal, all the way. I was on Cal's team the first moment he entered the story. What really sold me though, was the dance lessons."

No, hun! Maven all the WAY! I’ve started the t..."


Just wait until the last book...u just wait...


message 1182: by elodie (new)

elodie Okay I don't think that Mareven could be a good relation ship. It will be so abusive and toxic. But I can't stop myself to shipp them. Actually I can't stop to love Maven since the first book ooh Maven is so broken by everyone is so a interesting character and I love him. I can't wait to read War Storm.
-E


message 1183: by elodie (new)

elodie Nashalee wrote: "Did you know that her inspiration for Maven was Joffrey from Game of Thrones?

I was at a book-club and we talked with her about it~!"


Ooh I didn't know!


message 1184: by Liv (new) - rated it 5 stars

Liv TEAM CAL!!!!!!!!


message 1185: by Celena (new) - rated it 4 stars

Celena Maven all the way. Cal seems like a plain boring prince :/


message 1186: by name (new) - rated it 4 stars

name Celena wrote: "Maven all the way. Cal seems like a plain boring prince :/" Agreed! Cal just seems so stereotypical, and Maven has such an interesting arc in my opinion.


message 1187: by Critter (new) - rated it 3 stars

Critter I really liked Maven in the beginning. But, by the end I didn't like either of them. Cal just wasn't that interesting to me.


|SHELBY| Okay, I understand that Maven is evil and all but that boy is able to use his words. Like in red queen, just like Mare, I fell in love with Maven's words and the person he acted as. And then even through the rest of the books Maven's words made me fall, even as the evil king. He was just so compelling. Where as Cal is completely pure strength and force and sometimes even closed off, where as Maven especially as the story goes on, wears his heart on his sleeve.


Stefania Pues, realmente leyendo el primer libro me enamore perdidamente de Maven, pero después su traicion me destrozo por completo; aunque debo aclarar su también me encanta Cal, pero que lo que le hizo a Mare en el 3 libro fue terrible... de verdad hubieran sido una linda e imperfecta pareja.


message 1190: by Ariella (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ariella cal!I do not care how many think maven okay. He is a sadist and evil


message 1191: by Abby (new) - rated it 5 stars

Abby Ariella wrote: "cal!I do not care how many think maven okay. He is a sadist and evil"

lol MARECAL


message 1192: by Sarah (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sarah A Ariella wrote: "cal!I do not care how many think maven okay. He is a sadist and evil"

We don't think Maven is "okay". We see him as a tormented, manipulated, confused, and lost teenage boy. We pity him and have compassion, empathy, and understanding of what he had done.


Vaughnfilbystmcatholic.Org come on, maven! You have to love the bad boys, if he is trying to kill you! ;)


message 1194: by Katherine (last edited Nov 20, 2018 11:29PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Katherine whats fucked up is that even now both of them are still possible, victoria cant even make up her own mind!


message 1195: by Chloe (new) - rated it 5 stars

Chloe Victoria? Her name's Mare!


message 1196: by Lindsey (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lindsey Uhhh I think she was talking about the author... Victoria Aveyard


Katherine @ linsdsey, indeed


message 1198: by Laura (new) - rated it 1 star

Laura I feel like the love triangle was really predictable and neither had any chemistry. I wish she'd had time to actually TALK to them because they have very few actual conversations getting to know each other. Both were pretty forced if you ask me. Just my opinion thought. Don't attack me!!


Isabelle Maven....even after the ending.


Isabelle Diane wrote: "Still, (spoiler) when someone revels in a gleeful method to kill me in gruesome manner (with a gleam in his eye, and a cruel twisted smile), it is sort of a turnoff. I think Maven is more likely to..."

Lmao.


back to top