SciFi and Fantasy Book Club discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
What Else Are You Reading?
>
What Else Are You Reading in 2018?
message 1651:
by
Sarah
(new)
Jul 03, 2018 11:50PM

reply
|
flag

Who knows where my next reading adventure will lead me. To the stars or back to Sweden or to the US again. I do know that I’m off to the Pub right now for dinner. That’s enough of an adventure for me tonight.

Don't neglect Cannery Row's sequel,





Walkaway by Cory Doctorow, Autonomous by Annalee Newitz, and Trail of Lightning by Rebecca Roanhorse.



movie?
wow


movie?
wow"
Yeah, with John C. Reilly which is, just... weird.


Maybe....I've been keeping an eye out for a used copy but I'm trying to prioritize books I already own (before I die under an avalanche of unread books).


My review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...



Please post your thoughts in the buddy read thread when you're done!


I recommend taking a breather first. Those books are heavy, and they take a lot from a reader. It would be a shame to commit to reading all three in a row and lose your tolerance part way.

I usually like to take a break, just so that the books stay separate in my mind. If I read a series back to back, later on it just all blends together and I can't remember where one ended and the next one started.

I was thinking about All the Birds in the Sky or Among Others or Uprooted or The Zero Stone or Swords and Deviltry so if anyone who’s read any of those has thoughts relative to what I was talking about, let me know...
I mean the funny thing about these inner debates I have is that I’m going to read all of these eventually...

I've also read The Zero Stone and it's sequel Uncharted Stars which was also fairly good

1Q84 by Haruki Murakami
This is an omnibus of a trilogy originally published in Japan. I really enjoyed the setting throughout the omnibus, and the writing style seemed unique to me. I enjoyed the first two books a lot, but my interest fizzled out on the third and I wasn’t all that satisfied by it in the end. My review.
Southern Reach trilogy by Jeff VanderMeer
I liked this quite a bit, with my main complaint being that there aren’t ever any solid answers to the main questions in the series and the ending is pretty ambiguous. I really enjoyed the first two books. The third was good but a little less interesting to me, and I wanted some things to be fleshed out better. My reviews:
Book 1 – Annihilation
Book 2 – Authority
Book 3 – Acceptance
For my next book, I’ve started Touch by Claire North. I’m only about 25 pages in, but so far I’m really interested in it.

I’ve been obsessed with finishing the Popsugar challenge (and to a lesser extent the Around the Year one as well) and I’ve been reading stuff I never would have gone near before. Eleanor Oliphant, Erotic Stories for Punjabi Widows, Simon....and all sorts of crying girl type books. Honestly it’s scary. What’s scarier is that I’m actually enjoying them all. I want to read a lot more SFF but I can’t fit it all into the prompts. It’s a bit hard to find a True Crime in a fantasy book...

Both would be excellent targets for screen adaptation, IMHO.


"
I loved those books when I read them while still at school ... will need to do a re-read one of these days.


I didn't love Zero Stone or Uprooted. I think after Jemisin the would have been disappointing for me. Among Others is literary, but you have to be willing just to lazy-river ride it through--it's not a roller coaster like Fifth Season. I haven't yet the other two but they seem to get a lot of strong reactions, Anthony!
YouKneeK, I'm gonna say I also loved Touch! I hope it keeps your interest. I really must read another by her. I've been leaning on The Sudden Appearance of Hope
YouKneeK, I'm gonna say I also loved Touch! I hope it keeps your interest. I really must read another by her. I've been leaning on The Sudden Appearance of Hope

Anthony wrote: "I wound up doing a little Twitter poll and All the Birds in the Sky won, and it’s turning out to be perfect. Uprooted got a lot of votes as well, I’m surprised to hear you didn’t enjoy it."
Not liking Uprooted is an unpopular opinion, but there it is. I think it was hurt by the fact I'd read two other popular Russian folk tale retellings in a short time, so I couldn't be as charmed with the setting.
Glad you're liking All the Birds!
Not liking Uprooted is an unpopular opinion, but there it is. I think it was hurt by the fact I'd read two other popular Russian folk tale retellings in a short time, so I couldn't be as charmed with the setting.
Glad you're liking All the Birds!

Having unpopular opinions about celebrated works can be a strange thing. Years ago I started Dave Eggers’ book A Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius, which topped many critics’ lists and won all sorts of awards and I wanted to punch that book in the face. And I’m not typically a violent person. I still can’t imagine why people thought that book was so great. I never finished it.

Is the other one Deathless? I liked Uprooted, and should have loved Deathless (because I loved the stories about Koschei as a child), but it was a slog. Since I like Uprooted, it's hard to explain what it is that some people absolutely hate about it. There's weird pacing in the middle, which I get, and I don't think it's flawless, but I don't quite get why some people loathe it.
Anna wrote: "Allison wrote: "Not liking Uprooted is an unpopular opinion, but there it is. I think it was hurt by the fact I'd read two other popular Russian folk tale retellings in a short time, so I couldn't ..."
Deathless (which I absolutely adored! haha! Maybe it's where you start? You love the Koschei you find first? Maybe it's a curse!! Damn Baba Yaga, you are extremely petty to curse these books) and Bear and the Nightingale.
I love lush writing and complicated characters, which Valente does well for me. Bear was atmospheric and had complex characters but was way slower, and Uprooted had neither complexity nor the atmosphere I wanted/expected at this point.
Deathless (which I absolutely adored! haha! Maybe it's where you start? You love the Koschei you find first? Maybe it's a curse!! Damn Baba Yaga, you are extremely petty to curse these books) and Bear and the Nightingale.
I love lush writing and complicated characters, which Valente does well for me. Bear was atmospheric and had complex characters but was way slower, and Uprooted had neither complexity nor the atmosphere I wanted/expected at this point.

edit: I feel like I have to add, I'm talking about personal enjoyment, not the quality of the books. As a book, Deathless was pretty great, which is why I rated it higher than I otherwise would. With Uprooted, I can see it has flaws, but I enjoyed the story, I had fun, so I rated it higher. Bear... something must be wrong with me, everyone else loves it.
Probably to no one's surprise, there are a few tropes that I do not do well with. Uprooted had several. Bear was gorgeous but one of those "the first book is the prologue" things that...idk. Sometimes works really well for me (Night Circus!) and sometimes less so.
Rachel wrote: "I loved uprooted the most - it was the 5 star read for me - the others had flaws 😊"
Did you read it first? I must know now, for science!
Did you read it first? I must know now, for science!

I get that. Since May of 1980 I have hated — with a capital HATED — The Empire Strikes Back, which seems almost universally beloved and is by far the most popular Star Wars movie. I just don’t get the love. There are only two good things about that movie: John Williams’ score and Mark Hamill’s acting... and I seem to be the only person who appreciates the latter.

I have to come back to this. I first encountered Koschei in Alas taikavirtaa, which is a Russian children's book. Unfortunately there's no English translation, but it's an adventure story where you meet pretty much all the traditional Russian fairytale characters. I read my copy ragged, and I still loved it when I reread it for the first time as an adult a few years ago. Seeing my childhood fave in Deathless having pretty creepy sexytimes wasn't very pleasant. Same goes for Baba Yaga's mortar and pestle, that was so uncomfortable!

I really liked Uprooted, which I read first, a few years ago. I recently read The Bear and the Nightingale, which I liked ok, but less. Afraid to try Deathless now.

Anyway, I don't think Uprooted and Deathless have anything in common, except that they pull inspiration from Slavic folklore. Not all King Arthur stories are for everyone, so just because it draws from the same giant pool of inspo doesn't mean you'll like both. They're so completely different, and I think it does Deathless a great disservice to rec it to someone who asks for something similar to Uprooted. Had I known Deathless was a depressing slog through war ravaged Leningrad, I would not have started it when I wanted something light and fairytale-ish, like Uprooted. Of course same is true if you read Deathless first, you won't like Uprooted if you're looking for something similar.
edit: Changed Russian to Slavic.

In Uprooted even the horrific parts are written in gorgeous language whereas in Deathless it’s all grim and dark
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Working for the Devil (other topics)Where Late the Sweet Birds Sang (other topics)
Fool's Assassin (other topics)
Exo (other topics)
2018 on Goodreads (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Samuel R. Delany (other topics)Samuel R. Delany (other topics)
Samuel R. Delany (other topics)
Aliette de Bodard (other topics)
George Mazurek (other topics)
More...