From the Bookshelf of Nothing But Reading Challenges…

Heartless

Marissa Meyer

Start date: December 22, 2016

Finish date: December 31, 2016

Discussion: Books of the Month

Why we're reading this: December Young Adult Book of the Month
[close] December Young Adult Book of the Month

Find A Copy At

Libraries

Group Discussions About This Book

Showing 2 of 163 topics — 23,363 comments total

Books of the Month

* The Names by Florence Knapp - Sep 25 Adult / Non-Fiction BOM (starts 16 Sep)
By Moderators of… , Challenger-in-Chief · 11 posts · 68 views

last updated Sep 05, 2025 04:38PM

* The Covenant of Water by Abraham Verghese - Sep 25 Theme BOM - South and South East Asia (Starts 5 September)
By Moderators of… , Challenger-in-Chief · 31 posts · 66 views

last updated 7 hours, 19 min ago

showing 10 of 93 topics view all »

What Members Thought

Dec 09, 2016 Yzabel Ginsberg rated it it was ok · review of another edition

Shelves: arc-netgalley, fantasy, young-adult, romance, retellings, annoying-characters, good-ideas-but, tales, insta-love

[I received a copy of this book through NetGalley.]

Hm. I liked the premise (telling the story of the Queen of Hearts before Alice came to Wonderland), however there were parts when I was a little... bored?

Catherine Pinkerton, daughter of a Marchess, loves nothing more than to bake, and dreams of opening a bakery with her maid and best friend Mary Ann, rather than just marrying some rich nobility son that she won't even love. Of course, her plans get thwarted when she catches the attention of the [I received a copy of this book through NetGalley.]

Hm. I liked the premise (telling the story of the Queen of Hearts before Alice came to Wonderland), however there were parts when I was a little... bored?

Catherine Pinkerton, daughter of a Marchess, loves nothing more than to bake, and dreams of opening a bakery with her maid and best friend Mary Ann, rather than just marrying some rich nobility son that she won't even love. Of course, her plans get thwarted when she catches the attention of the King... or are they? When the new Court's joker waltzes into the play, things change again, and this time, Cath may have a chance at true love. Except... We all know how the Queen of Hearts behaves in Carroll's story, so we also know that whatever Fate has in store for those characters, it's not a happy ending.

It's not so easy to write a (re)telling of something whose end is already well-known, and while it was problematic, some aspects I really liked. The beginning had a certain vibrancy, what's with the cake/bakery imagery and Catherine's dreams, not to mention Jest's first appearance during the ball, and the darker parts, including the meeting with the three sisters, were creepy in their own ways.

The main problem I had with this novel were its characters, and I think that had a lot to do with how I knew (or at least suspected) it would end. This time, it's not even a case of insta-love—Cath's and Jest's relationship progresses quickly, but frankly, I've also seen much, much worse in that regard—more a case of characters trying to let their own personality develop and shine through, only to be put back on rails in order for the story to end up where it should. I found this too bad for them, to be honest; I suspect they would've been more interesting had they been able to live their own tale fully. As a result, Catherine especially ended up rather passive and unappealing, stuck between a sort of Regency-like society where noble girls marry noble men and must remain silent and pretty in their corsets, a holier-than-thou attitude (ironically mirroring Margaret's without never realising it), and twists meant to turn her into the Queen of Hearts, yet too predictable to really hit home. The courtship period was infuriating, what's with all her refusing the King but never telling it to his face, letting things happen, then worrying that she'll have to marry him and not be with the man she actually loves, but still not doing anything, until it was too late and whatever she'd do would just end up badly (also it's the others' fault, never hers... great).

Other problems were the writing (not bad, but nothing exceptional either), and the pacing: especially in the second third, the story dragged and felt padded out—that was when I started struggling to keep on reading, before getting to the last/darker part. While the kingdom of Hearts had a 'cutesy' and colourful side that I quite liked, it didn't enthrall me (Chess with its warring Queens seemed more exciting?), perhaps because half the book at least was devoted to parties and balls and a more traditional "arranged marriage" plot, instead of playing on a more Wonderland-like atmosphere.

Conclusion: Well, I expected more, and this is clearly a case of a story whose characters would have been better left to their own devices. ...more

2 likes · Like · see review

Apr 27, 2020 Avigail rated it liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: audiobook, audible, physical-book, 2020

The truth is that Alice in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glass aren't book that I am a font of due to the darkness of the story. I am happy that I gave "Heartless" a chance because I was intrigued to find what the author did with the back story of the Queen of Hearts.
I have this edition of "Heartless" from the Owlcrate book subscription since November 2016. I knew that I would not read it as soon as it came out because I wanted to read it when the hype for the book, and especially the audio ...more

2 likes · Like · see review

Aug 28, 2020 Marla rated it liked it

Shelves: audiobook, young-adult, mystery, fantasy, award-winner, romance, magic, retelling, barely-finished, library-audiobook

..Catherine is a beautiful lady, daughter of a Marquess, and admired by the King of Hearts. Catherine just wants to open a bakery with her maid, not be queen. But then she meets the King's new joker, Jest, and she may want to fall in love after all.

I am not a fan of Alice in Wonderland, so that may taint my review of this book. So many secrets and though I wish I could taste Cath's lemon tarts, rose macarons, and pumpkin cake, I didn't really like her or anyone besides Jest, Cheshire and Hatter ...more

Like · see review

Mar 01, 2018 Angie Taylor rated it it was amazing

I seriously hated this book as much as I loved it. Since the story is about the Queen of Hearts I knew from the beginning it would have a tragic ending, so I could have chosen not to read. But reading about an imagined background Meyer created for the Queen was so magical and enchanting. But I totally ugly cried at the end. Because my heart was broken. So good! Yet so dang frustrating!

Like · see review