Emma (M)’s
Comments
(group member since Dec 02, 2014)
Emma (M)’s
comments
from the Nothing But Reading Challenges group.
Showing 641-660 of 1,777

No too much, just having some family stay for a few days over Christmas and the rest of the time we'll be relaxing. How about you?



Rightio, I'll go switch the editions. I thought it was based on what we posted to the Books Read page, but I'm guessing the update is automatic when I post to my shelf?


Pages: 544
Finished:25/11/15
BOM yes
DQs yes
Goal:No
Points:60 + 40 + 20
Nov 25, 2015 11:43AM

I wasn't particularly surprised, although it was pretty horrible to find out Huckabee was so involved in Julia's death. There wasn't anyone that wasn't involved that I thought would be.
39. Chapters 22 and 23 had me on the edge of my seat. What did you think of Claire’s rescue plan? Would you have done the same thing knowing you couldn’t trust local law enforcement and authorities that could come to the rescue are too far away? Keep in mind that all this happened in the space of two days. I would have been more inclined to let Nolan know and less likely to go in by myself. To me fire is too hard to control to be something I would have used to bring Paul out of the house. As it was it nearly killed Lydia and Claire.
40. What do you think of chapter 24, do you need some sort of happy ever after or would you have been fine with how chapter 23 ended? By the way, what do you think of Claire dating Nolan? I don't mind a wrap up of where characters are in the future and I loved the fact Claire was dating Nolan, what an unexpected turn around on her part.
41. I liked that the last word was given to Sam. It had me almost in tears by the last sentence (I have to admit I’m a bit of a daddy’s girl). What did you think of his dream, walking his eldest daughter down the aisle? I found Sam's parts of the story heartbreaking and probably an accurate assessment about parents would feel in that situation. When you look at parents whose children go missing they fight for years to try and find them, like Julia's father did. A good example of that in Australia was the parents of Daniel Morcombe.
42. Did you watch the video posted on the group page? This is an interview with Karin Slaughter about her book and what inspired her to write this story. Do you think she described the effects of the disappearance of a loved one on the remaining family members well? I wonder what her dreams are like if you can get a story line like that from one of your dreams. What about you?
I think she shows the long lasting effects on families well. That sort of thing would haunt families for a long time. Karin Slaughters books are all pretty gruesome so I'm not surprised that one of her dreams turned into the events in this book.
43. This is a standalone novel and written from the victims’ point of view. Most of Karin Slaughter’s other books are part of series (The Grand county series and the Will Trent/Atlanta series) written from an investigators point of view. Do you think you would have experienced this book differently if it was written from the pov of an investigator? I think there would be more distance to the horrible things that happened? Would you read other novels by Karin Slaughter? I think it's more of an emotional read when from the POV of the victims so the reader gets more involved in the storyline. I really like her Grant County series and will be continuing with that as the opportunity arises.



Pages: 236
Finished:24/11/15
Goal:Yes, someone talks with a God
Points:20 + 5

Books published pre-2015




For books published in 2015




My favourites were a mix of genres and I could have added more but I tried to narrow it down to the best of the best for me this year.
Nov 18, 2015 02:11AM

13) Now that we're almost a third into the story, how are you enjoying it? I'm really enjoying this book. I love the mystery and trying to piece together what's happening and whose in on it.
14) Why do you think Adam is pushing so much for the files Paul had? Do you think it has anything to do with the embezzling or the videos Claire found? This part is a complete mystery to me - I hoping it's just the embezzling.
15) What do think of Captain Mayhew? Did you think his asking about all the possible places copies of the videos could be was suspicious? He's totally dodgy. I'll be shocked if he's completely innocent in all this.
16) Why do you think Paul had Lydia under surveillance every year? Do you think he was obsessing after the one that escaped from him or that he felt guilty for what he tried to do? I think he is just a sicko who likes to see how his crime has affected his victims over time.
17) Do you think the videos that Claire found are real? If so, who do you think is the man in them (since Claire ruled out Paul)? I think they are realand I reckon the guy in the them is Captain Mayhew.