Sign in with Facebook
64 Paranormal, Supernatural, and Magical Romances for Spooky Season
Adriana Herrera was born and raised in the Caribbean and now lives in New York City. When not at work as a trauma therapist, she writes stories with unapologetic happily-ever-afters about people who look and sound like her people. Her books, which The New York Times has called "sweet and thoughtful, but delightfully filthy too," include the contemporary Dreamers series as well as historical romances like her Las Leonas series.
For fall, we thought, "Who better than the author of The Hellmouth Guardian's Lover to recommend a reading list of supernatural and paranormal love stories for our audience?" Below, find Herrera's picks from her extensive mental Rolodex of romance titles!
For fall, we thought, "Who better than the author of The Hellmouth Guardian's Lover to recommend a reading list of supernatural and paranormal love stories for our audience?" Below, find Herrera's picks from her extensive mental Rolodex of romance titles!
Spooky Season is upon us, and we have you covered! The fall is the perfect time to dip your toe into spicy books with a bit more bite to them…see what I did there? If, like me, that knot in Ali Hazelwood’s Bride left you craving for more or if you are now a certified #MonsterLover, I have 60 books on this list to keep you reading well into the winter. We're talking sexy shifters, villainous vamps, wicked witches, delicious demons, and everything in between. What better way to start cuffing season than with a few horny heroes? (No, but really…they have horns.)
For this Spooky Romance extravaganza, I’ve rounded up a selection that will tempt anyone to take a little stroll into the dark side. Every book on the list is available to read now. Most have been published in the last few years, but there are a few classics I could not help to shout out. Now get that Pumpkin Spice Latte and reading blanket ready, because you will need them!
Ghouls in Schools: Dark Academia
Cozy Witches
Supernatural Anti-Heroes
Demons and Lovers
Horrormance
The OGs: Paranormal Masterpieces
Old-Timey Magical Vibes
Shifters Do It Better
OMG Omegaversing
Monster Smash
Why Choose: Monsters and Demons Edition
Ghost Love
Small-Town Magic
Vamps
A Little Fantasy, A Little Horror
The Vibe Is…Slasher
Your turn! Let us know YOUR favorite spooky-season romance reads in the comments below!
Comments Showing 1-50 of 56 (56 new)
message 1:
by
soni ୨୧ casual reader
(new)
Sep 26, 2024 01:39AM
might add a few to my PTR !!!
flag
Lots of great titles on this list! The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches and Starling House are some of my all time favorites! I also love the Stay a Spell series by Juliette Cross- and the whole series is on Kindle Unlimited too!Here are some more of my favorite Spooky Season Romances:
Mating the Huntress(werewolf & werewolf hunter on Halloween)
Throne in the Dark (glacially slow burn) (the whole series is amazing)
Young Adult:
House of Salt and Sorrows (gothic retelling of 12 dancing princesses)
Carry On (MM Harry Potter vibes)(series)
Serpent & Dove by Shelby Mahurin (witch and witch hunter)(series)
Athena wrote: "List feels obviously catered towards the romantasy booktok crowd."I mean, it is a romance list.
Kirby wrote: "Lots of great titles on this list! The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches and Starling House are some of my all time favorites! I also love the Stay a Spell series by Juliette Cross- and the ..."Just in case you didn't know, Juliette has the sequel series coming in February for Stay a Spell. The kids are grown up. The Rebel without Claws.
Was hoping for an actually spooky section on this list so kind of bummed.
Kirby wrote: "Lots of great titles on this list! The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches and Starling House are some of my all time favorites! I also love the Stay a Spell series by Juliette Cross- and the ..."Thanks for the recommendations! I will give Throne in the Dark a try.
From this list I’ve read The Magpie Lord and How to Bite Your Neighbor and Win a Wager. Both are excellent books that I highly recommend.
I refuse to believe there’s no book by Sarah Hawley in this list
Absolutely criminal that there's nothing by Jayne Krentz on here. You can't get more spooky paranormal romance than her.
I’ve read Darkfever, and The Ex Hex on this list. I recommend Ava Reid, Kim Harrison, Laurell K. Hamilton, B.B. Easton, Abigail Owen, and Holly Black.
Casket Case by Lauren Evans! Not everyone seems to like it, but I enjoyed it.
So many great books 💕 the Belladonna series is my current favorite paranormal !
I have dead romantics on my tbr but I haven't read it. So excited to read it. I wish I was into fantasy and lore but I am not. I am so sad but it's ok because I have many books that I will like.
Wish there was more queer stories on this list! If anyone has some LGBTQ+ recs for spooktober lmk :)
Nocticadia by Keri Lake needs to be on this list -- it's amazing! Dark romance and academia--- equal parts plot and romance. SO GOOD.
I mean, I Married a Lizardman by Regine Abel is not paranormal monster romance, it's a sci-fi alien romance.But it's great, so I'd still recommend!
Tannie wrote: "Was hoping for an actually spooky section on this list so kind of bummed."Read any Darcy Coates' books!
I'm so glad to see Minion by L.A. Banks on this list. The Vampire Huntress series does not get the love it deserves!
So many books on this list that I have added to my TBR! Can't wait to read them all.
read 14 on this list and DNFd an additional 2. not sure I fully agree with all the entries here, but would definitely add these to the list:
House of Roots and RuinA gothic romance with a ton of spooks and twists-- absolute banger that everyone should read (and a completely different book from House of Salt and Sorrows, which is also a decent spooky season romance)
PhantasmaPhantasma is another fun one that just recently released, if you like a competition and/or had a crush on Danny Phantom then this one's for you
BelladonnaAnother gothic romance, first in a trilogy, with a strong murder mystery element.
Absolutely shocked that The Nightmare Before Kissmas isn't on this list. Brand new and has the princes of Christmas and Halloween. So cute!
Some great recommendations added to this list. I'm honestly surprised that so many of the long-time great authors are missing too. Hamilton (previously mentioned), Krentz (previously mentioned), Annette Blair, Lynsay Sands, Saranna DeWylde, Virginia Nelson, Ashlyn Chase, Michelle Bardsley, Yasmine Galenorn, Bree Moore, etc. Those are some of my auto-buy authors.
Oh definetly a very interesting list! Loved it.
Me, My Shelf, & I wrote: "read 14 on this list and DNFd an additional 2. not sure I fully agree with all the entries here, but would definitely add these to the list:[book:House..."👀 Oooooh color me intrigued! Thanks! Adding to my TBR!
Read ZA, DNFed Butcher & Blackbird and want to read My Roomate is a vampire and some more
Angelika Frankenstein Makes Her Match by Sally Thorne belongs on this list. I am wildly disappointed in Goodreads for not including it. It's the absolute BEST.
Is someone paying someone to keep putting Mexican Gothic on these lists? It was terrible.
Nicholl wrote: "Angelika Frankenstein Makes Her Match by Sally Thorne belongs on this list. I am wildly disappointed in Goodreads for not including it. It's the absolute BEST."That book was so weird and campy! It seems like people either love or hate it, but I LOVED it! I heard an interview with the author and she was saying it was her quarantine Frankenstein fan fiction and isn't that amazing?!
Another good one -- Bloodshed by Molly Doyle, it's part of a series - that's the main book and there are 2 novellas that go with it (One of which is Scream For Us)!
Children of Fallen Gods has nothing to do with dark academia? There’s not a school?
DNFed A Soul to Keep, which is a shame bc I was excited to read a monster romance with an actual MONSTER, not “human with horns”.
All of these books sounds really interesting to me
Stephanie wrote: "Is someone paying someone to keep putting Mexican Gothic on these lists? It was terrible."I didn't care for it either.
ame ୨୧ wrote: "might add a few to my PTR !!!"I thought Mexican Gothic was awful. I agree with Stephanie - no clue how it keeps ending up on these lists.
The Carrow Haunting by Darcy Coates is really good, but not on this list
julianne wrote: "Wish there was more queer stories on this list! If anyone has some LGBTQ+ recs for spooktober lmk :)"Chuck Tingle: Camp Damascus and Bury Your Gays
julianne wrote: "Wish there was more queer stories on this list! If anyone has some LGBTQ+ recs for spooktober lmk :)"It was mentioned just before you posted - the Witches of Thistle Grove series by Lana Harper is predominantly queer, with the one straight book still having queer characters front and centre.
