It seems that the "Cats vs. Dogs in Middle Earth" was cast aside after the first draft. However, Tolkien stubbornly keeps to the term "gnomes" for the Noldor, insisting that it comes from the term "gnomic", "to be knowing" (in Greek, see "agnostic").
This keeps bringing up the image of garden gnomes fighting Orcs in the early days of Middle Earth.
    
    
      — Aug 15, 2023 11:24PM
    
      Add a comment