Breaking Dawn
discussion
Which Vampire in this series has the best 'Gift'?
message 1:
by
Kristen
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Dec 18, 2011 11:38PM
I think Zafrina's was pretty cool.
reply
|
flag
that's really the direction I was headed in my thoughts...I might would like the mind reading, but only in aro's form- I wouldn't want to have to hear it all the time...but, I don't know- I could maybe see even that one making you miserable. maybe it would be better to just be able to tell if someone's lying w/o having to learn what they really think about. I might would want to know the future, but she can't turn it off, can she? don't know if I'd like that...I might would like being able to soothe people like jasper can.
Kristen wrote: "I think Zafrina's was pretty cool."I was thinking hers was cool too, but could she only do it to other people, or could she see whatever she wanted?
Kirby wrote: "that's really the direction I was headed in my thoughts...I might would like the mind reading, but only in aro's form- I wouldn't want to have to hear it all the time...but, I don't know- I could ..."No, Alice can't turn off her visions. In BD, she needed a werewolf to give her a break :)
Jasper can't turn it off, either. It'd be nice to be able to do what he can, but it'd be horrible to have to feel everything all the time. Especially other people's pain. Having to deal with our own is bad enough. Multiply it by every single person you meet.... :/
Kirby wrote: "Kristen wrote: "I think Zafrina's was pretty cool."I was thinking hers was cool too, but could she only do it to other people, or could she see whatever she wanted?"
I don't really remember...but I think she could see it too.
I have always wanted to read minds like Edward. But Alec's and Zafrina and Jasper and Benjamin's "gifts" are AWESOME!how cool would it be to have all of them.
Jaye wrote: "We've all read the series, now tell me, which vampire has the best "extra" ability? Is it Edward, Alice's, Aro, Jane, Alec, Benjamin, another? What are your thoughts?"i like Edwards because you would be able to tell if somebody really liked you as a friend or as something else<3 and i would want to know when people where lying to me
Edwards definatly!!! And not cuz I'm team edward or anything. I'm always wondering what people are thinking. Especially todlers, guys, and people I'm arguing with. I would love to read minds (even though that wasn't exactly what the question was).
LOL how bout just emmetts funnyness/ buffness and his laughable jokes and his awesome speed including the strongest of all cullens ♥
I liked Alice's gift and Edwards gifts the best. I liked the fact that Alice could see the future and Edward could read it from her mind before she could even say a word. Now that is cool.
Jennifer wrote: "I liked Alice's gift and Edwards gifts the best. I liked the fact that Alice could see the future and Edward could read it from her mind before she could even say a word. Now that is cool."yes i love them both!
Alice has the best gift!!!! Because she can see the future!!! and I think that is awesome !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Zafrina!! I think its so cool that she can make illusions or take away thier eye sight. I also like Chelsea's power which is sensing and breaking bonds.
Curlygirly wrote: "Zafrina!! I think its so cool that she can make illusions or take away thier eye sight. I also like Chelsea's power which is sensing and breaking bonds."
I think I need to read this again... I don't remember Zafrina or Chelsea!!!
i personally think Edward. Cuz it would be purdy freakinepic to read minds plus it'll be superduper usefull in real life~
Jane or Jean, did is say it right. Well, it's been a while since I've read the books. The 15 yr old vampire that can use her mind to HURT PEOPLE. SHE HAS THE BEST GIFTS.
Brooke wrote: "Alice has the best gift!!!! Because she can see the future!!! and I think that is awesome !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"Yeah, but it can be pretty confusing. Besides, half the things she see don't even happen so it would be very confusing to see 5 different versions of something and then not be able to see anything at all when werewolves become involved.
Thee is a fanfic book (I wrote) where the girls power is that if she tuched a vampire, she gets their gift.
Emmalilly wrote: "Edwards definatly!!! And not cuz I'm team edward or anything. I'm always wondering what people are thinking. Especially todlers, guys, and people I'm arguing with. I would love to read minds (even ..."Thanks!
it has to be Edward!!!!!!!!but Bella turns out to be pretty cul too!!!!
love alice ,ale and jane toooo!!!!!!!!!!
Jaye wrote: "Weird wrote: "I was going to say Edwards, but his could get a bit irratating. So, I think I have to say Nessie."Nessie's is cool—in theory. I'm a bit of a germ-a-phobe, so I don't see myself ru..."
Lol! Good point!
Including the Bree Tanner book? I like Fred's power of repugnance and forgetfulness... I think it would be great for people to be able to forget about you, especially with the case of the Volturi. In the actual series I like Jane's power. Period.
Jaye wrote: "Sandra wrote: "Jasper, by far!"Oh wow, I nearly forgot about Jasper. Yes, his gift is quite remarkable. Although it must be hard to feel everyone's emotions, all of the time. It would be better..."
Wow, I almost forgot that he feels their emotions too! LOL. Well, I think he could just surround himself with Alice and she's almost always content and happy!
i think that Nessie has the best gift because she has both Edward's and Bella's gift. Bella who is an shield and nobody can get in. But Edwards abilites to read minds is super complex. now Nessie gifts sre unique because she can tell a whole paragraph with just a touch of her finger. Nessie is doing the opposite of what her parents do. So Nessie has the best gift
I wouldn't want Edwards gift. I'm sure it would be cool to know if people were being honest with you. but think about the number of times you've thought something negative a bout a person, even if you never say it out loud. With Edward's gift you'd hear that along with whatever pain and tragedy they were dealing with. No way!I'll take Kate's! Zap the hell outta anyone who got too close to me! Great defensive weapon!
Kristen wrote: "I think Zafrina's was pretty cool."I think so too but it's creepy she can make you see creepy things
Katniss990 wrote: "Including the Bree Tanner book? I like Fred's power of repugnance and forgetfulness... I think it would be great for people to be able to forget about you, especially with the case of the Volturi. ..."Yes, inflicting pain on others is always fun
SPOILER (if you haven't read the books)While I like everyone's ability, I have to say that I like Bella's the best. She has the ability to protect people from the danger of other vampires, and their powers. I like that, and it fits her personality. I also kind of like Renesmee's gift, it was cool too.
Lee Anne wrote: "I wouldn't want Edwards gift. I'm sure it would be cool to know if people were being honest with you. but think about the number of times you've thought something negative a bout a person, even i..."yea i wish i could zap the hell out of my english 5 teacher
why are we discussing this? Its Alice, always Alice. Her gift contributed to the plotline alot more than Ed's did.
that would be a tough one cauz all the vampires have really good gifts. but alice probaly had the best gift cauz she can see the future and then edward cauz he can read minds
Zanaiaj wrote: "i think that Nessie has the best gift because she has both Edward's and Bella's gift. Bella who is an shield and nobody can get in. But Edwards abilites to read minds is super complex. now Nessie g..."actaully yeah come to think of it, nessi actually has pretty cool gifts cauz their mixed from edward and bella.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
Twilight: The Complete Illustrated Movie Companion (other topics)
Breaking Dawn (other topics)
Eclipse: The Complete Illustrated Movie Companion (other topics)
Twilight: The Graphic Novel, Vol. 2 (other topics)
More...
Books mentioned in this topic
New Moon: The Complete Illustrated Movie Companion (other topics)Twilight: The Complete Illustrated Movie Companion (other topics)
Breaking Dawn (other topics)
Eclipse: The Complete Illustrated Movie Companion (other topics)
Twilight: The Graphic Novel, Vol. 2 (other topics)
More...










