Breaking Dawn (The Twilight Saga, #4) Breaking Dawn discussion


284 views
Which Vampire in this series has the best 'Gift'?

Comments Showing 51-93 of 93 (93 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 2 next »
dateUp arrow    newest »

Sarah This is hard for me because I really like Bella's gift, but I'm not sure it's the gift I would want for myself. I guess if I had to choose one for myself I would choose Edward's just because I sometimes really want to know what others are thinking. It might get annoying, but I'm sure after hundreds of years you would learn how to tune some of it out. ;)


Allison Jaye wrote: "Benjamin's Gift is pretty cool too."

I love his. I'd probably pick this one to have. I like Bella's too and it's be cool to see what the acual extent of her power was.


message 53: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Nor Alice without a doubt >.<


Victoria Parker Well bella and rennessme(spelled wrong) have gifts to but i would pick either bellas,alices or edwards i would want to know if someone is lying or what there thinking about but i would want to see the future to know what would happen and then what if ur thinking about something and u dont want them to know or see u could block them out( like bellas power)? i cant decide


Sarah yeah thats why edwards would be good cauz sometimes i really just want 2 know what people are thinking just out of curiosity. and it would be even better if you could control it. especially after like over 100 yrs:)


Lucille My favorite was Alec and Jane's. :)


Zanaija hunter Sarah wrote: "Zanaiaj wrote: "i think that Nessie has the best gift because she has both Edward's and Bella's gift. Bella who is an shield and nobody can get in. But Edwards abilites to read minds is super compl..."

yea i agree


Nicole Zanaiaj wrote: "i think that Nessie has the best gift because she has both Edward's and Bella's gift. Bella who is an shield and nobody can get in. But Edwards abilites to read minds is super complex. now Nessie g..."

I agree.


Haley I really would want to have Renesmee's gift. being able to show people what you think is cool!


message 60: by [deleted user] (new)

alice all the way


Sam VioletEmerald wrote: "I liked Bella's."

Totally with you on this, when Bella was turned I was team Bella all the way! :)


Sarah Sam wrote: "VioletEmerald wrote: "I liked Bella's."

Totally with you on this, when Bella was turned I was team Bella all the way! :)"

yeah bellas is pretty good. its probaly the most original out of all of them, then it would have to be nessie and alice


Radikal i cant remember her name but that chick who can tell if your lying and i like that other girl who could put pictures into your mind and of coarse mini bella/edward has the best gift of all!!!


message 65: by Allison (last edited Jan 11, 2012 09:23AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Allison Tayla wrote: "i cant remember her name but that chick who can tell if your lying and i like that other girl who could put pictures into your mind and of coarse mini bella/edward has the best gift of all!!!"

ya maggie and zafrina or how ever you spell it...
lol mini bella/edward lamo thats funny


Zanaija hunter Tayla wrote: "i cant remember her name but that chick who can tell if your lying and i like that other girl who could put pictures into your mind and of coarse mini bella/edward has the best gift of all!!!"

yea those are some pretty cool gifts!


Valerie I love Alice's. I want to be able to see the future! Besides, Alice is so bubbly! I love her personality!


message 68: by Nae (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nae Zafriana, Nessie, and Jasper have the best gifts in my opinion


Zanaija hunter Alleyaah wrote: "Zafriana, Nessie, and Jasper have the best gifts in my opinion"

what about bella?


message 70: by brooke1994 (new)

brooke1994 While I'm completely against the Jacob/Renesmee thing, I love Renesmee's power. Showing people your dreams would be awesome.


Allison animaldisneyreaderfan4lyfe7 wrote: "While I'm completely against the Jacob/Renesmee thing, I love Renesmee's power. Showing people your dreams would be awesome."

i agree. I'm not so sure about the whole wolf imprinting thing but i guess things could have been worse.


message 72: by brooke1994 (new)

brooke1994 Allison wrote: "animaldisneyreaderfan4lyfe7 wrote: "While I'm completely against the Jacob/Renesmee thing, I love Renesmee's power. Showing people your dreams would be awesome."

i agree. I'm not so sure about t..."


I really thought it was going to be him and Leah. Meyer is good but not as "up there" as some other authors.


message 73: by [deleted user] (new)

Kristen wrote: "I think Zafrina's was pretty cool."
yup... i liked zafrina's talent too...


message 74: by brooke1994 (new)

brooke1994 Well I'm not totally against it, as long as Jacobs happy with it


message 75: by [deleted user] (new)

i liked edward's talent the best.. not beacuse i want to intrude in someone's life or thoughts.. and always be an evasdropper.. but because we see life from our perspective only, not from others'. I believe, we'll be much, much wiser if we are able to see the things from many perspectives.. may be that's why edward so wise and always chose to do the right thing..


message 76: by Anna (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anna I like the knowing the truth and I like Benjamin's gift of the water and fire the elements


message 77: by brooke1994 (new)

brooke1994 The Denali Vampire's powers are awesome too


message 78: by [deleted user] (new)

btw whoz talent was "to know the truth"???


Kadie D♥ I like Alice's gift best, then Benjamin's.

The gift from Alice is as I think the most useful one, cause it can make you prevent things from happening, use it in tests and get you rich ofcouse ;p

But it's also one of the biggest burdens just as the one from Edward, always seeing visions or bad or unpreventable things happen. If I wa her I would surely have a big headache all day I think......

Benjamin's gift is solemly way to cool!
Musn't forget it's handy and superpowerfull ;p


Zanaija hunter Doris wrote: "I like Alice's gift best, then Benjamin's.

The gift from Alice is as I think the most useful one, cause it can make you prevent things from happening, use it in tests and get you rich ofcouse ;p

..."


i totally agree wit you doris


Casey Caldwell definitely edwards! but i guess thats because im a people pleaser, so i want to know exactly what people are thinking so i can know what they want to do. but alice's is really cool to! i would love to be able to see my future!


message 82: by [deleted user] (new)

Jaye wrote: "aarjavi005 wrote: "btw whoz talent was "to know the truth"???"


Maggie and Charles had the gift of telling when someone was lying to them."

oh.. thank u. i just didn't remember dat.


message 83: by [deleted user] (new)

I agree


message 84: by Sharmaine (last edited Jan 14, 2012 03:43PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Sharmaine Isidro i like Renesmee's


Kirby Nya wrote: "i like jane's and aro's"

yeah, aro's might would be better to have than edward's b/c he doesn't have to listen to everyone's thoughts all of the time...or were you thinking more along the lines of how aro knows all thoughts rather than just current ones?


Nya Tomlinson-Horan-Malik-Payne-Styles Kirby wrote: "Nya wrote: "i like jane's and aro's"

yeah, aro's might would be better to have than edward's b/c he doesn't have to listen to everyone's thoughts all of the time...or were you thinking more along ..."


no. you just wrote exactly what i was thinking.


message 88: by Angel (new)

Angel im torn between edward (who I don't like and Alice (I Love her personality!!!)


message 89: by Raya (new) - rated it 5 stars

Raya reenesme is so coooollll


message 90: by Rula (new) - rated it 5 stars

Rula Alice, hands down. i would love to see the future one day. that is an exceptional gift to be able to have.


message 91: by Jenn (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jenn I pick Alice or Edward. All are unique and useful in their own way!


message 92: by [deleted user] (new)

Jasper!


Allison Rula wrote: "Alice, hands down. i would love to see the future one day. that is an exceptional gift to be able to have."

i think seeing the future would be cool, but with Alice's being the possible future i think id get irritated. i think id just want to know what the for-sure future is going to be.


« previous 1 2 next »
back to top