Fans of British Writers discussion
Group news and business
>
Currently reading anything by a British writer?
message 651:
by
Werner
(new)
Apr 05, 2017 06:28AM

reply
|
flag

https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
Currently reading Beneath Sunless Waves by Stephen Makk which is excellent and hard to put down. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/2....

Surely, you have to read C&P first to be interested in the series. If you venture in the long run. But mind you that these novels contian still gorier scenes, including detailed descriptions of body dismemberment by a forensic doctor. But you're not junior anymore:))

True! But with 399 books on my to-read shelf already, I think I'll pass on Morris' series. :-)


True! But with 399 books on my to-read shelf already, I think I'll pass on Morris' series. :-)"
Great! But remember: C&P first, оtherwise it will not be so interesting.


Kierkegaard Between Traffic & Travel
I read this great comic novel recently that was recommended by a friend. He said the..."
I just started this. Enjoying it immensely.




https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/2....
This will be the fifth one I've read by this author - a favourite!





Rosemarie, I read that one as a kid of 10 ore 11, and really liked it! It was one of the first mysteries I read (although The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes might have been my very first).


That's quite a common device in the Poirot novels!

When I step outside to a 100 degree heat index, all I want to do is lay inside in the AC and read about somewhere that isn't so hot! Does anyone else share this experience? Also any suggestions for someone that wants to feel cold?


https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1...

A., I'm not familiar with that Austen title, and I thought I knew about all of her writings (though I haven't read all of them). Can you link to the book you just finished?


I loved his earlier book, 'A Spy's Life', but this one wasn't as good. Here's my review:
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show....
Now reading: 'Double Cross: The True Story of the D-Day Spies'
by Ben Macintyre, one of my favourite authors.





I don't usually read that many British authors at once, it has just worked out that way.

The thread extends from Ireland (an IRA operative is sent over) to India and Pakistan as the tension and military build-up increases between the two countries.
I'm also reading Harry Drinkwater's, Harry's War - his diary and vivid description of his experience in the trenches in the Great War.
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1...



I have a bundle on Kindle ( lol) of all Austen's work, fragments, juvenilia and all and am enjoying re-reading them all . Just finished Emma and was cross all over again at Mr Woodhouse . I never understood why he is considered endearing. Selfish old codger, to my mind even if he is scrupulously polite about it !


Even though some of them are very mannered, I always love sinking in to the world she creates, and getting the only available information about the sons of Peter and Harriet.
Very soothing when I'm having writing breaks.



Agnes Grey by Anne Bronte is on my to-read soon list.
Happy New Year everyone!



I think they'd be great audio for a car trip, too.

I think I liked Chesterton's way of writing, which is completely lost in the TV version. Word choice is particularly notable to me, as a writer.
Good questions.

Alicia, I think you're right that which is "better" can only be decided on a case by case basis (though I also think it can be something like comparing apples and oranges). You're also right that an author's distinctive prose style is usually lost in a filmed adaptation. That can take away a dimension of pleasure if you've read and liked his/her prose style. But if an author's prose style is often on the overly verbose, dry and ponderous side, like Henry James or James Fenimore Cooper, the excision of the written narration can actually make the work come across more favorably.


Many a bad story has been improved by filming - and many a good book has been ruined by the movie. I've known both kinds - as we all have. And it may even depend on the individual reader/viewer.
I, for example, don't like anyone but the original author writing stories in their universe, and consider the Sherlock Holmes adaptations as abominations, all of them. Won't look at them, won't read them. I want my memory of Conan Doyle's stories to be exactly what I get when I pick up my copy of The Complete Sherlock Holmes from next to my bed. It's my opinion - others obviously have different ones.
Scarlett was widely disdained - and probably also made a lot of money for Alexandra Ripley. I won't read it, and will never look at Go Set a Watchman. I'm a purist. I like writing novels and possibly plays because whatever I choose to make them, no one will get a chance to interfere.
It also makes me responsible for anything that goes wrong - I hope I do a good job of it.
Other writers can't wait to send their latest file to their editor.
The one thing I won't do is tell other people what to do!


Alicia wrote: "I, for example, don't like anyone but the original author writing stories in their universe, and consider the Sherlock Holmes adaptations as abominations, all of them. Won't look at them, won't read them. I want my memory of Conan Doyle's stories to be exactly what I get when I pick up my copy of The Complete Sherlock Holmes from next to my bed. It's my opinion - others obviously have different ones."
Alicia, although I see your point, I personally can enjoy a good pastiche of an older writer, a new adventure of a character that I like, or another writer's exploration of a concept or world created by someone else, provided that they're faithful to the original author's vision. (Sometimes they're not, and I have a problem with that. Since you mentioned Sherlock Holmes, I gave Laurie R. King's The Beekeeper's Apprentice, set in Holmes' not-really-"retired" years, five stars; but since the subsequent novels of her spin-off series feature a married Holmes, I'm not interested in reading them --that strays too far from the canon for me! And while Fred Saberhagen stays true to Doyle's vision in The Holmes-Dracula File, he's very unfaithful to Stoker's, and that cost the book stars when I rated it.) Some authors have a problem with their work being used this way; but it's been said that "imitation is the sincerest form of flattery," and some take it that way. For instance, H. P. Lovecraft's many author friends sometimes worked his Cthulhu Mythos concepts into their own tales during his lifetime, and he seems to have enjoyed the imitative fun as much as they did. :-)
Alicia wrote: "The one thing I won't do is tell other people what to do!" Well said, Alicia; that's the credo of most of us here! Much of the fun of Goodreads comes from comparing and contrasting our different tastes and opinions. It'd be a dull world, and our discussion boards would be pretty boring, if we all thought alike and liked/disliked the same things.

However, since so far today I've been free of fever (crosses fingers and knocks on wood!), I've now started on a nonfiction read about paranormal phenomena,

Books mentioned in this topic
Elia and the Last Essays of Elia (other topics)Martin Chuzzlewit (other topics)
The Stones of Muncaster Cathedral (other topics)
Favorite Ghost Stories (other topics)
The Feast (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Charles Lamb (other topics)Charles Dickens (other topics)
Robert Westall (other topics)
Margaret Kennedy (other topics)
William Wordsworth (other topics)
More...