On The Same Page discussion
2025 Independent Challenge
>
**Michelle’s Any Way You Want It That’s The Way You Read It Independent Reading

― Amor Towles, The Lincoln Highway"
Nice to hear that you liked The Lincoln Highway so well. I did too!
I read it after reading Towles' A Gentleman in Moscow which is the only other book of his I have read. So . . . I wasn't exactly expecting what I saw in Lincoln. I'm not sure if two books could be any different than these. Shows was a talented writer he really is.

I read The Old Man and the Sea many, many years ago, I think I liked it, but I don't remember much. It's about and old man and the sea, right? 🤣



Looks like I'm in the minority opinion on Lincoln Highway, I loved A Gentleman in Moscow but I'm not sure why I didn't connect to the former. It may have to go on my "maybe I should reread" list.
Loved The Hate U Give. And will definitely have to read A Sorceress Comes to Call. I've only just started reading T. Kingfisher books and I've really enjoyed them.


― Craig Johnson, Daughter of the Morning Star
50 books
3178 pages
39 audiobooks
11 print
#46

#47

#48

#49

#50

Current:
Wild Dark Shore Popped up for me on Libby so I am joining the band wagon.
The Last Ranger Love Peter Heller's writing.
Selected Poems of Edna St. Vincent Millay: An Annotated Edition Isn't it poetry month?
“Tolkien and Lewis were attracted to the genres of myth and romance not because they sought to escape the world, but because for them the real world had a mythic and heroic quality.”
― Joseph Loconte, A Hobbit, a Wardrobe, and a Great War: How J.R.R. Tolkien and C.S. Lewis Rediscovered Faith, Friendship, and Heroism in the Cataclysm of 1914-
What's different now from 1804 or 1904 is that tuberculosis is curable, and has been since the mid-1950s. We know how to live in a world without tuberculosis. But we choose not to live in that world.”
― John Green, Everything Is Tuberculosis
We live in between what we choose and what is chosen for us.”
― John Green, Everything Is Tuberculosis: The History and Persistence of Our Deadliest Infection

― Peter Heller, The Last Ranger
53 books
4022 pages
41 audiobooks
12 print
#51

#52

#53

Currently:
The Selected Poetry of Edna St. Vincent Millay For poetry month. Hopefully it won't take me a month to get through it.
Throne of Glass For my banned book challenge. Really liked it at first but now I'm cooling off.
Wrong Place Wrong Time Time loop.
“But here is the nature of life. That we must love things with our whole selves, knowing they will die.”
― Charlotte McConaghy, Wild Dark Shore
“Contrary to the messaging many of us are getting today, a hearty steak as part of your diet is better for you than ultra-processed plant-based foods such as Twinkies, Lucky Charms, and Impossible Burgers.”
― Gabrielle Lyon, Forever Strong: A New, Science-Based Strategy for Aging Well

Isn’t it funny how books can hit us so differently? I agree with your review but, for whatever reason, I loved it.
On to the next book :) I’m interested to hear what you think of Edna St Vincent Millay.

I didn’t hate it Lillie. I just felt like it was trying too hard. I also felt like the characters’ motivations were a little off. I mean a strange woman washes ashore and suddenly everyone loves everyone else even though there’s that big secret we’re not talking about. I just couldn’t quite buy it. I’m glad to hear you loved it though. That’s why we need access to all types of books. Not every book speaks to every person.
Great update, Michelle.
I read Peter Hellers The River, and really enjoyed it.
The Old Man and the Sea was a better read for me this time around, than when I read it in high school. I love a good classic, especially when it's short. LOL
I read Peter Hellers The River, and really enjoyed it.
The Old Man and the Sea was a better read for me this time around, than when I read it in high school. I love a good classic, especially when it's short. LOL

I read Peter Hellers The River, and really enjoyed it.
The Old Man and the Sea was a better read for me this time around, than when I read it in high scho..."
The Old Man and the Sea definitely needs some life experience behind you to enjoy it. I wonder why we insist on making people read it in high school? I was not required to read it then. The Hemingway we were assigned in high school was A Farewell to Arms. I hated it and have not read it since even though I have read and enjoyed other Hemingway novels. Reading this one made me think maybe I should give that one a reread. Maybe there was more to it than I could comprehend at that time.
Peter Hellers is great and The River was one of his better ones. I think there is a sequel. The Guide???
Michelle wrote: "Alondra wrote: "Great update, Michelle.
I read Peter Hellers The River, and really enjoyed it.
The Old Man and the Sea was a better read for me this time around, than when I read..."
I really have no idea; but classics are deemed cultured and should be read to be a more well rounded human being.... I guess. LOL
We also read The Catcher in the Rye, which I actually enjoyed. I think I enjoyed the debating more than the books, but they were still enjoyable.
I did add the 2nd book to my list.
I read Peter Hellers The River, and really enjoyed it.
The Old Man and the Sea was a better read for me this time around, than when I read..."
I really have no idea; but classics are deemed cultured and should be read to be a more well rounded human being.... I guess. LOL
We also read The Catcher in the Rye, which I actually enjoyed. I think I enjoyed the debating more than the books, but they were still enjoyable.
I did add the 2nd book to my list.

― Gillian McAllister, Wrong Place Wrong Time
57 books
4902 pages
44 audiobooks
13 print
#54

#55

#56

#57

Current:
The Last Week: What the Gospels Really Teach About Jesus's Final Days in Jerusalem For Easter
Darius the Great Is Not Okay For the banned book challenge
Edna St. Vincent Millay: Selected Poems: For poetry month
“What I am is the Indian who can’t die. I’m the worst dream America ever had.”
― Stephen Graham Jones, The Buffalo Hunter Hunter
“Don't you ever do anything other than read?" said Chaol.”
― Sarah J. Maas, Throne of Glass

I have only read Rebecca and Jamaica Inn by duMaurier, and I have to say I greatly preferred Rebecca. I seem to remember not liking the ending at all and throwing the book at the wall.


Oh, I felt some hope at the end of Rebecca for the heroine, whereas at the end of Jamaica Inn, I was just left wondering why. I still thought Jamaica Inn was 3 stars, the atmosphere of the novel was incredible. I am pretending those last couple of chapters never happened. I do want to read more by her. I don't necessarily need a happy ending to a book, but if there's no character growth, I'm left wondering about the point of it all.

I agree on all points. Let me know if you find a du Maurier that tops Rebecca for you. I want to read it. I’ve also read The House on the Strand which was decent and My Cousin Rachel which I did not enjoy. In all of them though that gothic atmosphere was unforgettable.
Michelle wrote: "“#57 The Buffalo Hunter Hunter by Stephen Graham Jones The Buffalo Hunter Hunter I did not want to like this native american vampire tale as much as I did. It was too dark and, well, gross. It was layered. So many layers. I'm not even sure I got it all. BUT it was so well written, like any good horror story I could not look away in spite of the gore. Stephen Graham Jones is an excellent writer. 4 a dark and gory nightmare stars..."
Now I want to read this more than ever!!! Woot!
Now I want to read this more than ever!!! Woot!

I think you will like it Alondra. It was complicated and messy and very dark.

― Gillian McAllister, Wrong Place Wrong
#54

Think I need to move this one up on my list. I love a good time travel story


― Gillian McAllister, Wrong Place Wrong Time
57 books
4902 pages
44 audiobooks
13 print
#54

I REALLY liked Throne of Glass and am looking forward to continuing with the series. IDK what it says about me that you mentioned a really gross vampire story and I immediately added to my TBR haha

― Gillian McAllister, Wrong Place Wrong Time
57 books
4902 pages
44 audiobooks
13 print
#54 [bookcover:Wrong Place Wrong..."
LOL. Don't feel too bad. I listened to the vampire story on audiobook (double gross) and then at the end listened to an excerpt of another book by the same author and added that one to my TBR.
I'm looking forward to the next in the Throne of Glass series too. I don't know if the series lives up to the hype but I did enjoy it. I think in this case the hype may have been the reason I didn't read it.

― Deesha Philyaw, The Secret Lives of Church Ladies
61 books
4926 pages
48 audiobooks
13 print
#58

#59

#60

#61

Current:
Edna St. Vincent Millay: Selected Poems: This one went back to the library so my poetry month read may be an extended one.
The Last Week: What the Gospels Really Teach About Jesus's Final Days in Jerusalem Easter week reading.
The Secret History I'm in for the story at this point but the audio production is terrible and the characters are worse.
“This book examines crisis management in the modern presidency. During the Trump administration, the president was the crisis to be managed.”
― George Stephanopoulos, The Situation Room: The Inside Story of Presidents in Crisis

L.O.L. !!

Yes LOL! I truly did not expect that. Maybe I should have done my homework better.

― Donna Tartt, The Secret History
65 books
5200 pages
51 audiobooks
14 print
#62

#63

#64

#65

Current:
Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell Not much headway so far.
Among the Bros: A Fraternity Crime Story Frat boy true crime
The Wild Robot Escapes to read and discuss with my grandson
“The word felt dangerous, and also powerful, as if uttering it would summon someone or something”
― Malinda Lo, Last Night at the Telegraph Club
“Her life was a tissue of vanity and deceit.”
― Virginia Woolf, Mrs. Dalloway
“Still, life had a way of adding day to day”
― virginia woolf, Mrs. Dalloway
Michelle wrote: "“It is is better to know one book intimately than a hundred superficially.”
― Donna Tartt, The Secret History
65 books
5200 pages
51 audiobooks
14 print
#62
[..."
I can't say that I like Virginia Woolf but I'm glad that I've read a couple of her stories. Her style of story - telling is quite unique. The Wild Robot Escapes.. ahhhhh... I have the final book awaiting me..
― Donna Tartt, The Secret History
65 books
5200 pages
51 audiobooks
14 print
#62

I can't say that I like Virginia Woolf but I'm glad that I've read a couple of her stories. Her style of story - telling is quite unique. The Wild Robot Escapes.. ahhhhh... I have the final book awaiting me..

Roz is my grandson's current favorite character. I'm trying to keep up.
Michelle wrote: "“It is is better to know one book intimately than a hundred superficially.”
― Donna Tartt, The Secret History
65 books
5200 pages
51 audiobooks
14 print
#62
[..."
Folks either love or hate The Secret History. I have a copy, but the reviews are so mixed. Ugh
― Donna Tartt, The Secret History
65 books
5200 pages
51 audiobooks
14 print
#62

Folks either love or hate The Secret History. I have a copy, but the reviews are so mixed. Ugh

― Donna Tartt, The Secret History
65 books
5200 pages
51 audiobooks
14 print
#62 [bookcover:The Secre..."
People do seem to have strong feelings about it Alondra. I was taken to task on another thread for saying it wasn't a good audiobook. I'm standing by that though. The story was well written but weird with very unlikeable characters. Not horrible but not great IMO. The audiobook was a different story. It was bad. The author should never have been the reader for this book. The main POV was a young male. The author was not male and did not have a good male reading voice. Many of the characters supposedly had an affected way of speaking but this was poorly done by the author. A good reader with some vocal acting skills or even better a cast of readers would have made this an audiobook to remember. Instead, I am trying to forget it. This book is too long to suffer through a tortured audiobook. If you decide to go ahead with this one, definitely do not listen to the audiobook. That's all I'm sayin'.

Yup! Never understood the love. For me, I loathed it and I read the physical book. I don't actively hate a lot of books but this one I do (the other one for me is Normal People *shudder*). I liked The Goldfinch by Donna Tartt though 🤷🏻♀️
How are you liking Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell? I tried reading it years and years ago but never finished it. Weirdly enough, I enjoyed Piranesi. Maybe because it was shorter?

I'm liking Jonathan Strange but it's sort of meandering along. I'm hoping we get somewhere soon.

I'm liking Jonathan Strange but it's sort of meandering along. I'm hoping we get somewhere soon."
Not sure you'd like The Goldfinch. A lot of people didn't like it at all but I was an art history major in school and I enjoyed those bits. From what I saw from those who didn't like it, it was too long and boring.

― Victoria Kann, Pinkalicious
68 books
5232 pages
54 audiobooks
14 print
#66.

#67.

#68.

Currently:
Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell A meandering fantasy so far.
The Wild Robot Escapes Moving slowly but still fun.
Edna St. Vincent Millay: Selected Poems: Back from the library so I can finish poetry month. Better late than never.
The SpellshopLoving this one.
By 2013, the fraternity lifestyle website Total Frat Move wrote, “Greek life today makes Animal House look like a Pixar movie.”
― Max Marshall, Among the Bros: A Fraternity Crime Story
Loving him is poetry, and she thinks she’ll try her hand at that too”
― Yulin Kuang, How to End a Love Story
Michelle wrote: "People do seem to have strong feelings about it Alondra. I was taken to task on another thread for saying it wasn't a good audiobook. I'm standing by that though. The story was well written but weird with very unlikeable characters...."
Okay; well, I don't do audiobooks and I have a physical copy already. The worst that could happen is that it bites and I have to read something else. Poor book. LOL
Okay; well, I don't do audiobooks and I have a physical copy already. The worst that could happen is that it bites and I have to read something else. Poor book. LOL

I hope you have an entirely different experience with it than I did Alondra. I'm looking forward to hearing what you think.

I've enjoyed this one too, and I agree about Rebecca, which is actually my only book by Daphne du Maurier, and a big favorite. I hope to read more by her...which one should I pick?


I'm not sure this will help, but to me, Rebecca is the best of these four. I also liked The House on the Strand a lot, although of the four it creeped me out the most. And I found My Cousin Rachel quite intriguing.
The only one I really did not care for was Jamaica Inn.

Thanks Karol! I have actually read the same four du Maurier books and mostly agree with your assessment. Although, I found Jamaica Inn to be good but I did not like My Cousin Rachel much at all. I think we both agree that Rebecca is by far the best. Unfortunately that really doesn’t help Ioana at all. They all had great writing and great atmosphere. If you are looking for a moody gothic read, I don’t think you could go wrong with any of them. Again not very helpful we’re going to need more Goodread friends to help us settle this one.

― Sarah Beth Durst, The Spellshop
“I can’t lose books; I’d lose me.”
― Sarah Beth Durst, The Spellshop
71 books
5269 pages
57 audiobooks
14 print
#69.

#70.

#71.

Who should be held accountable for a shared history of violence? It was a question that was dogging Northern Ireland as a whole.”
― Patrick Radden Keefe, Say Nothing: A True Story of Murder and Memory in Northern Ireland
rubble and broken glass, what one poet would memorably describe as “Belfast confetti.”
― Patrick Radden Keefe, Say Nothing: A True Story of Murder and Memory in Northern Ireland
Words are important, no matter what the language—they are perhaps one of the most powerful things we have. Words can preserve life or invoke death and should be handled with the same care as any deadly weapon.”
― Craig Johnson, Hell and Back

I have this one on my list. May have to push it up and get to it sooner rather than later
Michelle wrote: "“It wasn’t that she didn’t like people. It was only that she liked books more.”
― Sarah Beth Durst, The Spellshop
“I can’t lose books; I’d lose me.”
― Sarah Beth Durst, The Spellshop
71 books
526..."
I need to finally read The Spellshop. I've had it for awhile now.
― Sarah Beth Durst, The Spellshop
“I can’t lose books; I’d lose me.”
― Sarah Beth Durst, The Spellshop
71 books
526..."
I need to finally read The Spellshop. I've had it for awhile now.

― Sarah Beth Durst, The Spellshop
“I can’t lose books; I’d lose me.”
― Sarah Beth Durst, The Spells..."
I hope you enjoy it Bill. It's not high adventure fantasy just good cozy fantasy. Hope you like books, plants and baking.

Thank you both. I'm still not sure which one I'll pick up next, but because I'v been planning another one for a while, I think it will be fairly soon.
"They all had great writing and great atmosphere" - this is good enough for me!
Books mentioned in this topic
Murder on the Marlow Belle (other topics)Silver Elite (other topics)
The Breakaway (other topics)
Shunning Sarah (other topics)
Moon Tiger (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Jennifer Weiner (other topics)Sarah Beth Durst (other topics)
Kara Swisher (other topics)
Nate Bargatze (other topics)
SA Cosby (other topics)
More...
― Amor Towles, The Lincoln Highway
45 books
3570 pages
35 audiobooks
10 print
#42
#43
#44
#45
Currently:
The Old Man and the Sea A short book but I'm dawdling. Time to wrap it up.
The Last Ranger Need more time to read.
Daughter of the Morning Star My old friend Longmire
“Words could always be said, but could rarely be unsaid.”
― T. Kingfisher, A Sorceress Comes to Call
“Intentions always look better on paper than in reality.”
― Angie Thomas, The Hate U Give