Amazon exiles discussion

28 views
Sport > "BALL UP!" - Val's 2023 Aussie Rules Footy Tipping *Open to Everyone*

Comments Showing 601-650 of 687 (687 new)    post a comment »

message 601: by SussexWelsh (new)

SussexWelsh | 7447 comments Demons by 11
Giants by 13


message 602: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments Suzy's tips:

Blues x 7
Port x 7


message 603: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments Mine:

Dees x 13
Giants x 6


message 604: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments Tonight's result:

Melbourne Demons (on hiatus) v Carlton Blues (available)
3.3.21 (Q1) 2.2.14
4.7.31 (Q2) 5.3.33
7.11.53 (Q3) 7.5.47
9.17.71 (Q4) 11.7.73

A cracker of a final with momentum swinging from one end to the other, plus injuries, possible reports to the Tribunal and everything inbetween. Melbourne's inaccuracy cost them dearly. Well done Carlton for never giving up - they scored the winning goal with less than a minute on the clock.


message 605: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments Tonight's result:

Port Adelaide Power (available) v GWS Giants (Duke)
4.1.25 (Q1) 4.4.28
5.6.36 (Q2) 9.11.65
8.7.55 (Q3) 11.15.81
9.16.70 (Q4) 13.15.93

The Giants won it in the second quarter when they were unstoppable. After that, I thought they were going to emulate the Demons last night with their poor kicking. But then Port got stuck with the same goal yips. I really love the Giants' style of footy - commentator David King described it as "a tsunami". I think it's pure chaos with the aim of moving the ball forward by whatever means. Next week's game against Collingwood will certainly be interesting - can the Pies tame them?

All the players contributed but special note must be made of Stephen Coniglio - his game has turned around completely since relinquishing the captaincy; Callan Ward (be still my beating heart) has regained his form of 2016; and, of course Toby Greene and Tom Green, and not forgetting Lachie Whitfield either - from a star he seemed to lose interest in the game but now is back better than ever. Congrats to Adam Kingsley in his first year as coach.

And we have a winner - the only person to tip both winners - it's Duke! So he wins $15.00 for The Centre For Eye Research Australia. Well done!

The fall-out was like this:

Duke - 2 - 21 margin (3+18)
Sussex - 1 - 23 margin (13+10)
David - 1 - 27 margin (11+16)
Val - 1 - 32 margin (15+17)
Tim - 1 - 32 margin (17+15)
Suzy - 1 - 35 margin (5+30)
Anita - 1 - 41 margin (8+33)
Philip - 1 - 71 margin (13+58)
Steve - 0 - 55 margin (17+38)


message 606: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments Winners AND margins please:

AFL 2023 FINALS FIXTURE - WEEK 3

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Friday, 22 September
First Preliminary Final - Collingwood Magpies (on hiatus) v GWS Giants (TheDuke) - in Melbourne

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Saturday, 23 September
Second Preliminary Final - Brisbane Lions (David) v Carlton Blues (available) - in Brisbane

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

If punters could lodge their tips by midnight THURSDAY September 21 (your time) it would be a great help, although I can accept them up until 10.45am FRIDAY (your time) if absolutely necessary.


message 607: by theDuke (last edited Sep 17, 2023 01:48PM) (new)

theDuke | 6491 comments Yay...go me! Many thanks Val. :)

I forgot to add my congrats on your season win, Val, nicely done.

As for my Giants.....at the beginning of this season they were predicted to be a bottom 4 team! Instead they're a top 4 team!! :)
Adam Kingsley has done wonders for this ailing club...hats off to him. Orange Tsunami is pretty apt, their forward pressure tactic is working wonders for them. Collingwood will have their work cut out come Friday. Words going out that we could see a Brisbane v GWS final......when for a long time most were expecting a Pies v Port final!

One down, one to go!!!


message 608: by Tim (new)

Tim Watts (redswatts) | 550 comments Agree completely on Giants and it is with hope I am tipping them again this week but not with too much conviction because I know the support the Magpies will have and the atmosphere is likely to be overwhelming for the Giants. However, they seem to thrive on this so good luck to them.
Giants by 9
Lions by 12
I know I will be crucified for predicting a non Victorian side in the final so Val, please do not pass on.


message 609: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments Pass on?? I hope you don't mean pass away!! No chance - I suspect my tips will be the same as yours and I think that would be a great Grand Final with a crowd that hopefully would choose a team to barrack for (if they were not already aligned). The only downside (of any combatants) is KISS - what's the appeal??


message 610: by Tim (new)

Tim Watts (redswatts) | 550 comments Val I feel we should have met years ago. Naturally I meant not to tell on me to fellow Victorians as I may be run out of the state. Must not be too vocal for fear of upsetting fellow contestants in our wonderful competition but the prospect of a Collingwood Carlton Final would fill me with dread. Certainly a Lions GWS would be a great spectacle.
Kiss..... I simply have nothing to add to your comment which says it all. In fact I have no idea why the AFL deem it necessary to have any live entertainment at half time. It is just not worth the effort for 10 minutes. I would rather watch the children playing their games as they have done all season. What a great feeling for them it would be to be on the pitch on Grand Final day.


message 611: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments At least if it was Carlton/Collingwood you might get a 50/50 split in the crowd to make it even but I'd still prefer Giants/Lions.

Re the entertainment, my theory is they should just rotate Aussie songs each year (perhaps with younger artists doing a cover) :
Paul Kelly - Leaps & Bounds
Hunters & Collectors - The Holy Grail
Mike Brady - Up There Cazaly and/or One Day In September
and I'm sure there's plenty of others.


message 612: by Tim (new)

Tim Watts (redswatts) | 550 comments Great idea


message 613: by Tim (new)

Tim Watts (redswatts) | 550 comments I think crowd allocation for a grand final is an even split of about 17000 per team with the rest going to members and AFL Reserve plus all the important people. I was shocked last year that was how many tickets the Swans were allocated which is ridiculous given our membership is well over 50000. I was guaranteed one having paid a $100 on top of my membership to be a Premiership member which ensures a ticket if we make the Grand Final.


message 614: by Sj (new)

Sj Brooke | 2518 comments Collingwood Magpies #12
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Brisbane Lions (David) #18


message 615: by theDuke (new)

theDuke | 6491 comments well, i've got to back my boys, so:

GWS - 6

Lions 15


message 616: by Philip (new)

Philip | 488 comments Collingwood x 20
Brisbane x 20


message 617: by SussexWelsh (new)

SussexWelsh | 7447 comments .
.
Magpies by 18
Lions by 11


message 618: by David (new)

David Endersby (davidendersby) | 480 comments Magpies 7
Lions 14


message 619: by Anita (new)

Anita Bailey | 3841 comments magpies by 14
lions by 14


message 620: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments Suzy's tips:

Giants x 7
Blues x 7


message 621: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments Mine:

Giants x 11
Lions x 23


message 622: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments Tonight's result:

Collingwood Magpies (on hiatus) v GWS Giants (Duke)
2.2.14 (Q1) 0.3.3
2.6.18 (Q2) 4.4.28
7.7.49 (Q3) 6.9.45
8.10.58 (Q4) 8.9.57

Well it doesn't get any closer than that. What a nail-biter!


message 623: by theDuke (new)

theDuke | 6491 comments Cracking game....the lead changed several times....but that last quarter was fantastic. GWS gave it their all.....the mighty Magpies just held on in the dying moments.


message 624: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments All aboard the Lions bandwagon now!

ABC - Anyone but Collingwood.


message 625: by theDuke (last edited Sep 23, 2023 03:03AM) (new)

theDuke | 6491 comments I can't believe what i'm hearing, Lions are getting smashed in the first quarter. And Blues fans massively out number the Brisbane fans at the Gabba.

Edit: Er..yeah, only in that first quarter though!


message 626: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments Tonight's result:

Brisbane Lions (David) v Carlton Blues (available)
1.2.8 (Q1) 5.1.31
6.6.42 (Q2) 6.3.39
9.9.63 (Q3) 6.7.43
11.13.79 (Q4) 9.9.63

Yes it took a quarter before the Lions hit their stride and once they got going it was hard for the Blues to peg them back. I know a lot of Melbourne people were hoping for a traditional stand-off between Collingwood and Carlton but I'm just hoping the Lions aren't overwhelmed by Grand Final atmosphere.

David is our top tipster so another $15.00 goes to The Song Room. Nice work!


message 627: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments The breakdown was:

David - 2 - 8 margin (6+2)
Steve - 2 - 13 margin (11+2)
Anita - 2 - 15 margin (13+2)
Sussex - 2 - 22 margin (17+5)
Philip - 2 - 23 margin (19+4)
Duke - 1 - 8 margin (7+1)
Tim - 1 - 13 margin (9+4)
Val - 1 - 19 margin (12+7)
Suzy - 0 - 31 margin (8+23)


message 628: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments AFL 2023 GRAND FINAL

Saturday, 30 September

Collingwood Magpies (on hiatus) v Brisbane Lions (David)

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

If punters could lodge their tips (winner and margin) by midnight FRIDAY September 29 (your time) it would be a great help, although I can accept them up until 5.30am SATURDAY (your time) if absolutely necessary.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


message 629: by Tim (new)

Tim Watts (redswatts) | 550 comments Just going with my heart with no expectation. Just hope for a better final than last season.
Lions by 15


message 630: by David (new)

David Endersby (davidendersby) | 480 comments Great to see the Lions in the final. Obviously I'm going to tip them - but by how many?

Lions by 9

Thanks Val


message 631: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments And you earned another $15.00 last night David when Lions player Lachie Neale took out the Brownlow Medal (Best & Fairest) for the second time (he won it in 2020).


message 632: by David (new)

David Endersby (davidendersby) | 480 comments Val wrote: "And you earned another $15.00 last night David when Lions player Lachie Neale took out the Brownlow Medal (Best & Fairest) for the second time (he won it in 2020)."

Even better news - thanks once again Val


message 633: by Anita (new)

Anita Bailey | 3841 comments lions by 16


message 634: by Sj (new)

Sj Brooke | 2518 comments Pies +9


message 635: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments Suzy's tip:

Lions x 7


message 636: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments Mine:

The head says the Pies will win by a landslide but I'm going with the heart:

Lions x 4


message 637: by Philip (new)

Philip | 488 comments Brisbane x 20


message 638: by SussexWelsh (new)

SussexWelsh | 7447 comments Magpies by 21


message 639: by theDuke (last edited Sep 29, 2023 11:49AM) (new)

theDuke | 6491 comments Tough one to call this.....the MGC doesn't favour the Lions, but i gather it's going to a hot one in Melbourne tomorrow, with temps up to 30 degrees, which will suit the Lions just fine. Brisbane is no stranger to the swalty temps up there! On paper, this should be a Pies win, but the Lions have beaten them consistently at different venues.....so, i'm going with....

Lions - 12 points


message 640: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments The bounce is less than 3 minutes away, just waiting on the national anthem. It's 29 degrees here with a bit of a swirly wind. KISS were okay - the make-up covers a multitude of sins and looks very theatrical so worthy of the occasion. Go Lions!!!


message 641: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments Lions win the toss but, as expected, Collingwood are wanting a fierce first quarter. First goal to Nick Daicos from a genuine free kick decision. Second goal to Bobby Hill.


message 642: by Val (last edited Sep 29, 2023 10:14PM) (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments That was a beautiful goal by Hill (I will say it for the 100th time this season, he should have landed at Essendon!). Three great goals on the run from the Lions - Zac Bailey (2) and Lincoln McCarthy, followed by another two great goals for the Pies from Brodie Mihocek and Jordan De Goey (after the siren).

Quarter time score:

4.4.28 (Q1) 3.0.18


message 643: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments Goals to the Lions: Charlie Cameron and Hugh McCluggage.


message 644: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments Pies back in front. Another goal to Bobby Hill.


message 645: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments Goal to Charlie. Lions lead.


message 646: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments Goal Daniher. Brisbane lead by a goal.


message 647: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments Goal McCarthy - Lions by 13.


message 648: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments Goal Collingwood via Jack Crisp - Lions by 7.


message 649: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments Miraculous mark and goal by Bobby Hill - scores tied up, 50 apiece.


message 650: by Val (new)

Val H. | 22140 comments Another miraculous goal to Bobby Hill - Pies by a goal.

Norm Smith medal for Bobby Hill??? Did I mention he should have landed at Essendon!


back to top