Romance Readers Reading Challenges discussion
2021 Challenge Archive
>
2021 September Pick-it-for-me Challenge

Here are your picks! Happy reading!
September
TBR - Lord Holt Takes a Bride
New - Never Kiss a Duke
The Sapphire
TBR - Most Ardently
TBR - Not My Problem
September Equinox
TBR - A Mail-Order Heart
New - A Bride for Carlton
Vulcan
TBR -Dark Fae
New - Cruel Magic
Barley
TBR - The Summer Job
New - The Frequency of Us
September Birth Flowers
TBR - Sweet Montana Sky
New - Taming a Texas Bad Boy
Virgo
TBR - The Sister Surprise
New - The Lucky Escape
Fun Folklore
TR - The Heiress Hunt
New- West End Earl

















Here is your list. There are a couple of NewISH picks as they are on your To-Read shelf but not on your PFM shelf. But I tried my best to fit your taste, while going a LITTLE outside the box. Hope there's something you like.
1 Orange:
TBR: The Hidden Oracle ((mostly) orange cover)
NEW: November 9 (orange, 9 in the title)
2 Blue/Necklace:
TBR: The Lightning Thief (blue cover)
NEW: The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo (necklace)
3 Sky, Science:
TBR: The Darkest Hour (Sky)
NEWISH: The Kiss Quotient (Science)
NEW: The Soulmate Equation (Science)
4 Fiery/Fantasy:
TBR: The Rescue (fiery)
NEW: Dark Lover (Fantasy)
NEW: Things You Save in a Fire (fiery)
5 Food:
TBR: Blackberry Summer (food)
NEWISH: Garden Spells (food)
NEW: Nuts (food)
6 Flowers:
TBR: An Unlikely Amish Match (flowers)
NEW: Whitney, My Love (flowers)
7 Female MC:
TBR: Red Queen (Female MC)
NEWISH: The Unhoneymooners (Female MC)
8 Wedding
TBR: A Cowboy's Pride (Wedding)
NEW: The Invitation (Wedding)




















These are your September book recommendations, Hope you'll enjoy them and would find some new favorite books!📚
1)Book with any combination of the numbers 2, 6, 7 or 9 in the title, series or publication date, or with an orange cover, or with an Historical tag.
TBR= Bombshell - Historical
New= The Duchess Deal - Historical
(This book was recommended to me in August PIFM challange and I loved it hope you'll enjoy it too)
2)book with a necklace on the cover, or with a blue cover or with a character that is considered tough or strong
Tbr=Imagines- blue cover
Tbr=Big Jack- blue cover
3)book with a sky on the cover, or with a character who studies or is interested in Science or a book that is published in a ‘Fall’ month
Tbr=Right as Raine- sky on cover
Tbr=Sweet as Honey: An Aster Valley Novel-sky on cover
4)book with a ‘fiery’ cover or with a naturally occurring event in the story or with a Paranormal or Fantasy tag.
Tbr=A Wish Upon the Stars- fiery
New=The Cruel Prince- fantasy
5)book with food or beverages in the story or on the cover, with a yellow or brown cover or with a funny or humorous story or character
New=Life's Too Short- Yellow
New=The Bride Test-yellow
6)book with flowers on the cover or in the story, or with a couple you felt had an instant or powerful connection or with a purple cover.
New=All Your Perfects- purple
New=Eleanor & Grey- purple
7)book with a female main character, or with a symmetrical cover or with an even number in the page count or publication date.
Tbr=Fighting the Fire- even number in page count
New=It Ain't Me, Babe- even number
8)book with water or rain on the cover, or with a wedding or celebration in the story, or with a 1 in the page count or publication date.
Tbr=Fatal Chaos- 1 in publication date
New=The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo- 1 in publication date

So here are some recommendations, I hope you like them!
1) September:
TBR: Sweet Filthy Boy (orange cover)
NEW: Punk 57 (7 in the title)
2) The Sapphire:
TBR: Valencia and Valentine (blue cover)
NEW: Very Bad Things (blue cover)
3) The September Equinox:
TBR: The Fallen (published in October)
NEW: Paper Princess ( High School)
4) Vulcan:
TBR: Eidolon (Paranormal)
NEW:Into The Light (Paranormal)
5) Barley:
TBR: The Shadow Queen (Apple in the Cover)
NEW: Lessons Learned (MC is a Chef)
6) September’s Birth Flowers:
TBR: Half-Blood (Flowers on the Cover/ Purple Cover)
NEW: The Next Always (Flowers on the Cover)*
* I've read it a while back, the Greek translation sucks but the prototype was really nice.
7) Virgo:
TBR: The Chase (Even Number in the Publication Date)
NEW: Nightfall (Even Number in the Page Count)
8) Fun Folklore:
TBR: Murder in the South of France (Water on the Cover)
NEW: Captive of the Horde King (1 in the Publication Date)
P.S. Baby is awake, so I'll try to add the covers sometime soon.

These are my picks for this challenge :
1- Book with an orange cover by Samantha Shannon
new : The priory of the orange tree
2- Book with a blue cover
From tbr : The song of Achilles by Madeline Miller
3-Book published during a fall month
New : The invisible life of addie larue by V.E Schwab october)
This book is amazing 😍
4- Book with a fantasy tag
New : Mercurial by Naomi Hughes
Received an ARC of this book and enjoyed it ! It deserves to be more famous.
5- Book with a funny character :
From tbr : The last Olympian by Rick Riordan ( percy jackson)
Love this series !
6- Couple with a powerful connection
From tbr : A court of thorns and roses by SJM
( couple appears in second book tho)
7- Book with a female main character
From tbr :
Shadow and bone by Leigh Bardugo ( Alina)
8- book with a wedding
New : Serpent & dove by Shelby Mahurin
Hope u like these picks !

Thank u so much for your work on the list !
I think i’m going to go with “the hating game” because i’ve heard a lot of good things about it and the movie adaptation is going to come out in November ☺️
Thanks again !

Thank u so much for your work on the list !
I think i’m going to go with “the hating game” because i’ve heard a lot of g..."
Hi Alyssa!
You're welcome. My picks are some of the more popular romances. You may come across them again. Enjoy Hating Game...it's lots of fun!

1) September, or ”Septem”, meaning seven in Latin, based on the oldest known Roman calendars, was originally the seventh of ten months. Modern Julian and Georgian calendars place September as the ninth month of the year while September is the sixth month on the astrological calendar. September consisted of 29 days until the Julian reform, which added a day.
Recommend a book with any combination of the numbers 2, 6, 7 or 9 in the title, series or publication date, or with an orange cover, or with an Historical tag.
TBR - This Could Change Everything

NEW- Trial by Fire

2) The Sapphire is September’s birthstone, which was once thought to guard against evil and poisoning. They are also thought to encourage divine wisdom and protection. They symbolize purity, truth, trust and loyalty. The Sapphire, along with the related ruby, are the second-hardest natural gemstone after the diamond.
Recommend a book with a necklace on the cover, or with a blue cover or with a character that is considered tough or strong (your interpretation).
TBR -Bright Young Dead

New- Brutal Prince

3) The September Equinox occurs in September (DUH!). In the Northern Hemisphere this is called the Autumn Equinox, while in the Southern Hemisphere, it is referred to as the Vernal Equinox. This is the moment when the Sun appears to cross the celestial equator, heading south. At this point, the length of daytime is almost exactly equal to the length of nighttime.
Recommend a book with a sky on the cover, or with a character who studies or is interested in Science or a book that is published in a ‘Fall’ month (September, October or November).
TBR - I See You

NEW -Bestselling Bastard

4) September, the Romans believed, was looked after by the god, Vulcan. As the god of fire and forge, the Romans expected September to be associated with fires, volcanic eruptions and earthquakes.
Recommend a book with a ‘fiery’ cover (your interpretation), or with a naturally occurring event in the story (your interpretation) or with a Paranormal or Fantasy tag.
TBR - White Nights

NEW- Forged In Fire

5) The Anglo-Saxons called September Gerst Monath (Barley month) because it was the time when they would harvest their barley to make into their favorite drink – barley brew!
Recommend a book with food or beverages in the story or on the cover, with a yellow or brown cover or with a funny or humorous story or character (your interpretation).
TBR -Peaches and Scream

NEW - Sweet Talk

6) September’s birth flowers are the Forget-Me-Not, Aster and Morning Glory. All have varying shades of blues, indigos and violets. The aster signifies powerful love and the morning glory symbolizes affection. The forget-me-not symbolizes true love.
Recommend a book with flowers on the cover or in the story, or with a couple you felt had an instant or powerful connection or with a purple cover.
TBR - It All Comes Back To You

NEW -Beauty

7) Virgo is the primary Zodiac sign for September, until the 22nd when Libra takes over. Virgos are an earth sign, represented by the goddess of wheat and agriculture. They are logical, practical and systematic in their approach to life. Libra is an air sign that is represented by scales. Libras are obsessed with symmetry and strive to create equilibrium in all areas of life.
Recommend a book with a female main character, or with a symmetrical cover (your interpretation), or with an even number in the page count or publication date.
TBR - Cold Truth

NEW -Bitten

8) September has some fun folklore. Here are just a few:
”Heavy September rains bring drought.”
“Married in September’s golden glow, smooth and serene your life will go.”
“If the storms of September clear off warm, the storms of the following winter will be warm>”
“Fair on September 1st, fair for the month.”
Recommend a book with water or rain on the cover, or with a wedding or celebration in the story, or with a 1 in the page count or publication date.
TBR - Bookseller

NEW - Repeat Offender

If you need any repicks just let me know :). Happy Reading!

These are my picks for this challenge :
1- Book with an orange cover by Samantha Shannon
new : The priory of the orange tree
2- Book with a blue cover
From tbr : The song o..."
Thanks Alyssa I'm not sure if I have songs of Achilles anymore I might have unhauled it when I moved but I will most likely read either Percy Jackson , merciual or shadow and bone. I might
also might read Sarah j Maas although will use the series rule and go with throne of glass as I understand the series are connected. Thanks for the picks 🙂

These are all great reads i hope you’ll enjoy them !
Actually, throne of glass and acotar are both set in the same universe but not the same worlds (all the posts about them being connected are theories)
So it’s totally fine to start off with ACOTAR.
That’s what i did and i rlly enjoyed them both !

Thank you for the great picks! There are several that I want to start with....oh, who am I kidding? I want to read them ALL!
Have a great reading month yourself!
Romanticbookworm wrote: "Hi Nancy here are your picks for this month :).
1) September, or ”Septem”, meaning seven in Latin, based on the oldest known Roman calendars, was originally the seventh of ten months. Modern Jul..."

Here is your list. Happy reading!
1)
NEW - The Bourbon Kings (Orange Cover)
TBR - Sacred Evil (Orange Cover)
2)
NEW- Hard Curves (Necklace on the cover)
TBR- Undeniable (Tough looking character)
3)
NEW- This Time Next Door (Super Smart and Genious Male Character)
TBR- Voyeur (Male character is a professor and female character is a student.)
4)
NEW- Reaper (Fiery cover and Paranormal)
TBR- The Darkest King (Fiery and Paranormal)
5)
NEW- He Loves Lucy (Food on cover and funny story)
TBR- Can't Text This (funny blurb)
6)
NEW- Brown-Eyed Girl (Flowers on cover)
TBR- Inevitable (purple letters on the cover)
7)
NEW- Kiss an Angel (Female main character)
TBR- Boss of Me (Female main character)
8)
NEW- The Taming of the Billionaire (Weeding)
TBR- Begin Again (Number 1)

Hi Fran, thanks for the picks; they all look super interesting, and I can’t wait to get started! 😊

I hope you enjoy them Adi!
Darkness, I can't wait to see what you've got for me!
Sonja, I can help with repicks if needed- it will be 1 am my time when the picking time ends, so I will be able to do it later in the morning if you need me :)

Hi Fran, thanks for the p..."
No worries at all Adi! Honestly, I only get to about half or a third of the books I'm given anyway so don't overthink it! I'm happy for whatever you've got! :)

I hope you enjoy them Adi!
Darkness, I can't wait to see what you've g..."
Thank you Fran! I'm sending reminder messages now so hopefully we get everyone else in on time and you don't have to be up that late! ;)

I have Fran as a repicker, but may need one or two others if anyone is available tomorrow for repicking? LMK!
Thanks all!

I have Fran as a repicker, but may n..."
I can do that too Sonja

I have Fran as a repic..."
Thank you Mony!

I have Fr..."
Welcome! if no other volunteers, I can help with two. :)

You ROCK!!! I'm sure most, if not everyone, will finish their picks on time! And I'll probably let it slide until later in the evening anyway. Know we're all busy! Thanks again, Mony!

1) September, or ”Septem”
TBR: An Earl, the Girl, and a Toddler — historical — this looks so cute! 🥰
New: Untamed — historical, orange cover, and set in historical Scotland.
2) The Sapphire
TBR: The Wisteria Society of Lady Scoundrels — blue on the cover
New: Know My Name — the cover is teal, but more importantly, this is the memoir of one of the strongest people I’ve ever heard about. TW: Sexual assault, depression, mental health issues. Not sure if this is something you’d read, but I do think you’d be able to relate it to real life events seeing as you live in the same American state. (Not mentioning the place to respect your privacy 🙈🙈) interesting fact: the cover art depicts kintsugi, a Japanese art where broken pottery is made stronger by melding it together with gold.
3) The September Equinox
TBR: Rocket Science — MC is an aerospace engineer.
New: Searching for Perfect — I absolutely loved this book when I read it a few years ago, I still think of the book very fondly. 😭 MC is a rocket scientist.
4) Vulcan
TBR: Vanessa Yu's Magical Paris Tea Shop — fantasy
New: Master of Salt & Bones — fantasy — haven’t read it myself, but it comes highly recommended to me by a goodreads friend.
5) The Anglo-Saxons
TBR: Love & Gelato — icecream is food, right? 😋
New: The Opposite of You — the two MCs are chefs, so there’s always food in the conversation. 😎 I hope you love this book as much as I did.
6) September’s birth flowers
TBR: Hang the Moon — the cover looks purple to me
New: The Scarlet Pimpernel — again, a book that comes highly recommended by real life friends. They even got me a copy for my birthday. It’s historical, I think you’ll like it. 🥰 (flowers on the cover and in the title!)
7) Virgo
TBR: The Lady Travelers Guide to Scoundrels & Other Gentlemen — looks like the MC identifies as a female, from the blurb!
New: We Are Family — female MC — I enjoyed this book and I think you will too; it focuses on the sisterly bond more than the romance.
8) September has some fun folklore.
TBR: Happy Ever After — weddings!! 😄
New: First Comes Marriage — I see that you’ve liked other Mary Balogh books in the past — this is the first HR novel I ever read, and though I gave it 3 stars, I loved the world and the series and got addicted to it! Read the first three books of the quintet in four days. 😄

happy to help!

I think I have a problem with goodreads because a lot of my posts are not posted so here are the picks I picked for you.
1) September, or ”Septem”
TBR: The Charm Offensive
New: The Darkness Outside Us
2) The Sapphire
TBR: Daniel & Erik’s Super Fab Ultimate Wedding Checklist
New: Starfish
3) The September Equinox
TBR: Crash Plus Expenses
New: Meant to Be
4) Vulcan
TBR: Immersed
New: Moon Called
5) The Anglo-Saxons
TBR:The Bookworm's Guide to Faking It
New: The Soulmate Equation
6) September’s birth flowers
TBR:Keep Me
New: Stealing Home
7) Virgo
TBR: The Beast
New: By a Thread
8) September has some fun folklore.
TBR: Go Deep
New: Neon Gods

















Hope you find something yummy!
1) September, or ”Septem”
TBR: In Bed with a Highlander - historical
NEW: Much Ado About You - orange cover


2) The Sapphire is September’s birthstone
TBR: Arrogant Devil - blue cover
NEW: Fighting Silence - tough and strong


3) The September Equinox occurs in September
TBR: America's Geekheart - interested in Science
NEW: A Discovery of Witches - interested in Science


4) September, the Romans believed, was looked after by the god, Vulcan
TBR: Dark Prince - fantasy/pnr
NEW: On the Edge - fantasy/pnr


5) The Anglo-Saxons called September Gerst Monath (Barley month)
TBR: The Hooker and the Hermit - humorous
NEW: Faking Ms. Right - humorous


6) September’s birth flowers are the Forget-Me-Not, Aster and Morning Glory
TBR: Truly - purple cover
NEW: Whiskey Dick - instant connection


7) Virgo is the primary Zodiac sign for September
TBR: Dirty Little Secrets - female mc/symmetrical
NEW: Saturdays at Noon - symmetrical


8) September has some fun folklore
TBR: The Aristocrat - water on cover
NEW: Riskier Business - 116 pp



Here is your list. Happy reading!
1)
NEW - The Bourbon Kings (Orange Cover)
TBR - Sacred Evil (Orange Cover)
2)
NEW- Hard Curves (Neckl..."
Thanks Mina! =)

I think I have a problem with goodreads because a lot of my posts are not posted so here are the picks I picked for you.
1) September, or ”Septem”
TBR: The Charm Offensive..."
Thank you so much for the great picks Darkness! I can’t wait to get started 😊

We're looking for volunteers to host the Pick It For Me Challenge for the next several months. If you would like to help out and have been a member of the group for at least 6 months and have participated in the PIFM at least twice, please contact me (~KarenH~) via PM and we'll get things set up. Thanks!

I’m still waiting on Carmen the Bootyshaker Temptress and Mayte as well.
Fran and Mony, if they haven’t posted by 10pm my time, I’ll PM you to do picks tomorrow. Thank you for offering to repick! ❤️
And Adi, thank you for my picks!! I’ve already reserved several and am holding myself back (barely) from starting! One more day… I can make it! So thank you! 😁❤️

I’m still waiting on Carmen th..."
sounds good

No worries Carmen. This is supposed to be a fun exercise and I’m absolutely certain your picks will be magnificent! 🥰🥰🥰

1) September, or Septem
TBR - Good Girl Complex (orange cover)
New - Duke of Knight (historical tag)


2)The Sapphire is September’s birthstone
TBR - The Secret Bridesmaid (blue cover)
New - Radiance (tough female character)


3) The September Equinox occurs in September
TBR - Hopeless (sky)
New - Love at First Fight (Published in Sept)


4) September, the Romans believed, was looked after by the god, Vulcan
TBR - Caraval (fantasy tag)
New - Honey Queen (fantasy tag)


5) The Anglo-Saxons called September Gerst Monath (Barley month)
TBR - The Soulmate Equation (yellow cover)
New - Fluffy (humor)


6) September’s birth flowers are the Forget-Me-Not, Aster and Morning Glory
TBR - The Dating Plan (purple/violet cover)
New - Not So Nice Guy (powerful connection)


7) Virgo is the primary Zodiac sign for September
TBR - Listen to Me (even page count)
New - Mr. President (even page count)


8) September has some fun folklore
TBR - The Fall of Legend (rain on the cover)
New - Chase ( in the page count)



1) September, or Septem
TBR - Good Girl Complex (orange cover)
New - Duke of Knight (historical tag)..."
Girl don’t you DARE apologize! Lol. Life comes first and your list is PERFECT! Two of the TBRs are ones my friends suggested to me. And most of your NEWS are books I totally never heard of. The mystery excites me! Pretty damned good for last minute 😉.
September is going to be a good month for us all! I totally adore the picks! ❤️❤️❤️

1) September, or Septem
TBR - Good Girl Complex (orange cover)
New - ..."
Life did get away from me. I was busy with both my boys, one got married and the other had a birthday and then everything in between but I do hope you have a great September :-)

I’m closing the picking down, though I can’t update the 4th message from my phone. I’ve emailed Fran and Mony for picking.
Mony is picking for LaurLa and Fran is picking for Hinal.
If either of you ends up unable to pick, PM me and I’ll do the picks!
Thank you again!

Here are your picks for September....I hope you find a goodie or two here!
1) September, or ”Septem”- Historical
TBR: The Duke and I
New: The Governess Affair
2) The Sapphire- blue covers
TBR: The Wife Upstairs
New: Rebel Heir
3) The September Equinox- sky on cover
TBR: The House in the Cerulean Sea
New: The Favor
4) Vulcan- fiery covers
TBR: Dark Lover-PNR, love this series!
New: The Sinful King
5) The Anglo-Saxons- funny
TBR:To Sir, with Love
New: Work in Progress
6) September’s birth flowers
TBR: Hearts in Darkness- insta-love and so good!
New: Forever Mine: Hayden & Savannah- purple on cover
7) Virgo- even number in page count- I really enjoyed both of these!
TBR: Beautiful Bastard
New: Heart Signs
8) September has some fun folklore.
TBR: People We Meet on Vacation
TBR: Wife- 1 in page count
Happy Reading!

Here are your picks for September....I hope you find a goodie or two here!
1) September, or ”Septem”- Historical
TBR: The Duke and I
New: [book:The Governess Affair|1319059..."
I am so excited to read these book! The picks are literally perfect because It has 2 books that were already on my tbr for this month for other challenge and I have audiobooks for 5 of these books... I can’t wait to start reading!

Sorry for the delay. RL. Hope you find a book here for your September reading!
1) Book with number 2, 9 in pub. date, or Historical tag.
NEW- The Maddest Obsession- quirkiest FMC in great mafia story. 4.4 GR
TNR- Devil in Winter- yay!


2) Book with a character who is considered strong
NEW- Lord Ruin- a fave HR book- controversial
TBR- Leverage in Death (In Death, #47)


3) Book published in a ‘Fall’ month
NEW- The Prenup- a hidden gem
TBR- The Corinthian- love Heyer, yay!


Book with Paranormal or Fantasy tag
NEW- The Headmaster*
TBR- Dark Debt (Chicagoland Vampires, #11)


5) Book with a yellow or brown cover
NEW-Teardrop Shot by Tijan - a beautiful very different sport romance
TBR- The Wall of Winnipeg and Me


6) Book with a couple who have a powerful connection
NEW-The Sex Surrogate- lovely sexy read
TBR- Fractured (Not Quite a Billionaire, #2)


7) Book with an even number in page count or pub date.
NEW-F*ck Marriage- disregard title; IMO, Tarryn Fisher's best book
TBR- Scandal Never Sleeps (The Perfect Gentlemen, #1)


8) Book with a celebration in the story
TBR- The Takeover- yay!
NEW-Knight in Shining Suit- amazing book boyfriend


*Another hidden gem. Blown away by this story. Reads quickly - a short powerful novella. Plus well written. (PNR - not erotica)

1) September, or Septem
TBR - Good Girl Complex (orange cover)
New - Duke of Knight (historical tag)..."
Yes! Finished my first book in one day!

The Dating Plan was everything I love in a romance. Witty banter, twists and turns, and the occasional hot love scene 😉. Thanks for your impeccable picks. On to the next one!

I finished your pick for me, This Could Change Everything

P.S. The cover of the edition I had is different than the cover on the one you recommended, in case you don't remember seeing this cover - lol.

1) September, or Septem
TBR - Good Girl Complex (orange cover)
New - Duke of Knight (historical tag)..."

Mr. President is next.

1) September, or Septem
TBR - Good Girl Complex (orange cover)
New - ..."
Go Courtney!!! 😊

Sorry for the delay. RL. Hope you find a book here for your September reading!
1) Book with number 2, 9 in pub. date, or Historical tag.
NEW- The Maddest Obsession- qui..."
Thanks, Mony!!! Looks like some great picks :-)
Books mentioned in this topic
The Wisteria Society of Lady Scoundrels (other topics)Happy Ever After (other topics)
Searching for Perfect (other topics)
Imagines (other topics)
Right as Raine (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Lisa Kleypas (other topics)T.J. Klune (other topics)
Lisa Kleypas (other topics)
Eloisa James (other topics)
K. Webster (other topics)
More...
Here are your picks for September- I hope you find something you love here!
1. September
TBR: In Her Shoes- pub 2005
NEW: Happiness for Beginners- orange cover
2. Sapphire- blue covers
TBR: Dear Dwayne, With Love
NEW: Field Notes on Love
3. Equinox- science
TBR: Flirtasaurus
NEW: Imperfect Chemistry
4. Vulcan
TBR: Angels' Blood- PNR
NEW: Daughter of the Pirate King- Fantasy
5. Barley Month
TBR: Wait With Me- humor
TBR: Dragon Bound- yellow cover
6. Flowers
TBR: Bitter Spirits- purple dress on cover
NEW: Charming Sir Charles- purple dress on cover
7. Virgo
TBR: We Were Liars
NEW: Rush
8. Folklore
TBR: The Bride- celebration
NEW:Isn't She Lovely
Happy Reading!