Nothing But Reading Challenges discussion
The Floor is Lava
>
Does this book work for the task....?
date
newest »

message 351:
by
Lexi
(new)
Sep 21, 2019 03:51PM

reply
|
flag



Task 3: Read a book with a natural setting on the cover and that contains the word ANIMAL in the text

I would say the first two books for sure she's a grumpy character.

Or should it be an author who was not only born in a Mediterranean country, but also grew up/lived there?

Would you accept


I would say that if he's from Italy it's ok !

I consider from more than just born since he grew up with his grandparents in England but let others have an opinion. Moving later in life is fine but I can't find how long he actually lived in Italy. Again, I may be too picky.


Virtual high five, I am usually in my own corner

I vote yes. To be honest, when looking for authors from a country I just look at the birth location. I don't look at their life story part. And in this case it just says that he was exposed to many languages at an early age. It doesn't say anywhere that he didn't live in Italy. And it sounds as if he didn't learn English until he was around 17.


I keep second guessing myself"
Sorry, Mollie. I would vote no for your book. Bees are actually quite fuzzy, so it would be the opposite of prickly. If their stingers were showing, that would be different... ;)

Thanks Cinthia. That's exactly why I kept second guessing myself. I do think a couple stingers are showing but I don't know enough bee anatomy to be sure and I'm not super keen to read this book anyway. I was just trying to kill two challenges with one book so I'll keep hunting.

It really depends on if you count from as born or grew up so hard to say, but from Wiki "Rafael Sabatini was born in Iesi, Italy, to an English mother, Anna Trafford, and Italian father, Vincenzo Sabatini. His parents were opera singers who then became teachers. At a young age, Sabatini was exposed to many languages, living with his grandfather in England, attending school in Portugal, and, as a teenager, in Switzerland. " He moved a lot but not really Italy.

Burn"
To me, no.
There is a lot of variation among Romani people, and who am I to categorize people by race anyway.
But I think you should wait for a few more opinions.

Fantastic. That's exactly what they're doing with them, selling the fruit and harvesting essential oils too.
Thanks.

Burn"
I have no idea so I Googled it and here we go: "Romani people ... are a migratory group originating from Northwestern India. Their exodus from India occurred approximately 1000–1500 years ago. The migration route of the Romani people was reconstructed with the help of cultural anthropology, linguistics and historical records. Their migration made them through Central Asia, Middle East and the Caucasus region, prior to the arriving into Europe." So yes and no, they are from N India originally, but their DNA is primarily S India, Europe and the Caucasus region, which means 2 out of three are Caucasian so it might be easier to find another book. (the Caucasus are where the word Caucasian originates I am pretty sure).

I also vote yes. Born in Italy is from Italy.

Burn"
I have no idea so I Googled it and here we go: "Romani people ... are a migratory group originating from Northw..."
On top of this info, I would ask what the other half is?

But with 2 votes as probably not, I'll look for something else.

But with 2 votes as probably not, I'll look for somet..."
I compared our books and we have quite a few in common, so if you haven't read these already try Skinwalker a UF or Kindred a time travel fantasy, the MCs are Cherokee and African-American respectively.

"I compared our books and we have quite a few in common, so if you haven't read these already...
Thanks for the suggestions, they both look great.
Books mentioned in this topic
Unconventional (other topics)Unconventional (other topics)
Unconventional (other topics)
Kindred (other topics)
Skinwalker (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Rafael Sabatini (other topics)Rafael Sabatini (other topics)
Rafael Sabatini (other topics)
Rafael Sabatini (other topics)
Rafael Sabatini (other topics)
More...