The Rory Gilmore Book Club discussion
Other Book Discussions
>
What else are you currently reading?
message 301:
by
Dottie
(last edited Dec 07, 2008 07:49PM)
(new)
Dec 07, 2008 07:45PM

reply
|
flag
I just read three books in a row that got top marks - that's unprecedented for me!!! They were:
The Tale of Despereaux
Miss Pettigrew Lives for a Day
The Big Sleep
Yes, in point of fact, all of them have been made into films. But I can't imagine the film can be near as good as the book when it comes to The Tale of Despereaux. It's so truly outstanding! I can't gush about it enough.
Miss Pettigrew Lives for a Day was just sheer, utter delight. I read the bulk of it, oddly enough, in the lines at Disneyland. It was so cool - the PERFECT book for such a place. It is full of wonder and discovery and even a little magic - I'm talking about the book here! It went straight to my über-short list of all-time favorites. Just delicious!
The Bogart film The Big Sleep is one of my top films. After reading the book The Big Sleep, I have to say that while the film is really wonderful and true to the book, it couldn't possibly do the writing justice. It's not just an interesting story of fascinating characters... his descriptions just ooze out, melting goodness everywhere. I took to underlining the really tantellizing bits. Absolutely tops.
The Tale of Despereaux
Miss Pettigrew Lives for a Day
The Big Sleep
Yes, in point of fact, all of them have been made into films. But I can't imagine the film can be near as good as the book when it comes to The Tale of Despereaux. It's so truly outstanding! I can't gush about it enough.
Miss Pettigrew Lives for a Day was just sheer, utter delight. I read the bulk of it, oddly enough, in the lines at Disneyland. It was so cool - the PERFECT book for such a place. It is full of wonder and discovery and even a little magic - I'm talking about the book here! It went straight to my über-short list of all-time favorites. Just delicious!
The Bogart film The Big Sleep is one of my top films. After reading the book The Big Sleep, I have to say that while the film is really wonderful and true to the book, it couldn't possibly do the writing justice. It's not just an interesting story of fascinating characters... his descriptions just ooze out, melting goodness everywhere. I took to underlining the really tantellizing bits. Absolutely tops.
Oh, it was too much pressure to follow that up with ANOTHER phenomenal find, so I went back to finish a book I was hating (which I did and it redeemed itself in the last little bit oddly enough) then decided to just indulge in some time with old friends. So I'm on to Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets. I spent some time getting reacquainted with them about a month and a half ago with the first adventure. This seemed a good time to venture out again. It's déjà vu, though, for the sixth time, I think!


Anyone have any suggestions? I feel like I private school kid when they have a break from wearing their uniforms. There is so much I want to read now that I have a month off from school and I'm having a hard time making up my mind.
Just finished A Left-Hand Turn Around the World: Chasing the Mystery and Meaning of All Things Southpaw. It was really very fascinating. Will have to write a review soon... but dang if it's not almost 5AM & I've yet to sleep! Oh, also topped off Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets tonight. I mean last night. Whatever.
GOOD night. LOL
GOOD night. LOL
Lori, Swann's Way sounds like long, heavy reading after Anna Karenina. You might want to take on something lighter? But then again I find that reading often depends on mood, so you should go with what you feel like reading. Just a suggestion :)
I'm currently reading Into the Wild and it's great so far, it really sucks you in and gives a lot of things to think about.
I'm currently reading Into the Wild and it's great so far, it really sucks you in and gives a lot of things to think about.

I was an English major too, and I do remember how it feels to have to read a ton of stuff for class. But it turned out that I read very little English lit outside of class reading. Throughout four years of college I've only read around two Shakespeares, no Jane Austens, and no Dickens. Gasp!

English Major here! I read LOADS of Shakespeare... but a course in strictly him was required at all of my schools (I transferred a few times, LOL). Thing is, I ended up having to take it THREE times... so there wasn't much Shakespeare I missed. However, I never read Austen, Dickens, Woolf, Steinbeck, Rand (though the last two are not REALLY classics comparatively) for course study. But somehow I was still overloaded with reading! Thing is, I know a appreciate them far more because I was reading them for pleasure and not for a deadline.
Oh, and Lori, I'm far more into the classics than the modern to the point that until this group, my modern novel reading was exceedingly limited. I still prefer classics (so great and I have so many yet to get to), but am pleased for Rory's list because I've found it trustworthy for very good modern fiction.
P.S. I thought is was hilarious, Lori, that you listed "sex" and "gender" separately. I'm still trying to figure that one out.
Oh, and Lori, I'm far more into the classics than the modern to the point that until this group, my modern novel reading was exceedingly limited. I still prefer classics (so great and I have so many yet to get to), but am pleased for Rory's list because I've found it trustworthy for very good modern fiction.
P.S. I thought is was hilarious, Lori, that you listed "sex" and "gender" separately. I'm still trying to figure that one out.

I know a appreciate them far more because I was reading them for pleasure and not for a deadline.
Michele, I agree that reading for pleasure is far more meaningful and enjoyable. But sometimes after reading something I wish I was back in class, having a lively discussion/debate about the book -- especially when there's some points I don't understand. Sometimes I can't find many people to do that... luckily I found Goodreads and this group :)
Michele, I agree that reading for pleasure is far more meaningful and enjoyable. But sometimes after reading something I wish I was back in class, having a lively discussion/debate about the book -- especially when there's some points I don't understand. Sometimes I can't find many people to do that... luckily I found Goodreads and this group :)

There's a course you can take where you read 4 Austen novels over the semester. But I think taking a course on it might limit my ability to enjoy them. After taking a course on Mark Twain, I don't think I'll be able to read one of his novels for quite some time. I always toss Steinbeck and Rand in with the classics because they're new classics, in my opinion. I think a lot of people (or maybe just me) have their own standard for what makes a classic. I am ridiculously overloaded. I have to intentionally not study for one of my classes in order to get in much reading time. But it's worth it because it feels like such a forbidden pleasure. I think having to read even my favorite novels for a deadline would suck all of the fun out of them. Most of the time, I read (for class) just to get the book finished because I don't have the time to ponder each and every word.
This group does have some pretty good modern stuff. Right now I'm more concerned with getting through the classics because I own so so many of them. By the time I'm done with the classics, the modern stuff will probably be considered classics (or not).
The whole sex and gender thing was totally an oversight. I think I meant to say sexual orientation. It's finals week--give me a break. :)

I can't wait until winter break, too. I'm counting down the days. I have one paper and two finals to go. This semester was a killer for me. Eighteen physical/biological science credits was too many. I won't make that mistake again.

I have one final tomorrow over French grammar (my minor) and I'm worried about it, but I'm just too exhausted and spread thin to do much about it. 18 credits is a lot. But I'll bet you're glad you got them out of the way.


Dini wrote: "Michele, I agree that reading for pleasure is far more meaningful and enjoyable. But sometimes after reading something I wish I was back in class, having a lively discussion/debate about the book -- especially when there's some points I don't understand. Sometimes I can't find many people to do that... luckily I found Goodreads and this group :)"
Dini, I wholeheartedly agree!!!
Dini, I wholeheartedly agree!!!
Lori, I think I said this before, but were it not for this group for the most part I wouldn't read much modern at all except what might strike my fancy as I'm looking for more classics at the bookstores! In fact, until this group I didn't own and had never read a single "modern" book on Rory's list! (The other side was a whole different story!)
I have recently decided to go back to reading whatever book on my list of to-reads I'm in the mood for the moment I finish a tome. I usually hop from one genre to another but generally have a classic every other or every third book. (Interspersing children's lit, histories, biographies/memoirs, sociologically based books, occasionally a chick lit sneaks in there, self-help - especially in regards to my sport, faith-based reading... and then the rare modern novel.)
Right now I'm reading a memoir, but that's because I heard an interview with the author the other day and it struck such a deep chord with what I'm dealing with right now, that it's more like therapy reading it! (So far it's a really interesting story, too.) But I had been reaching for a classic before the interview!
I have recently decided to go back to reading whatever book on my list of to-reads I'm in the mood for the moment I finish a tome. I usually hop from one genre to another but generally have a classic every other or every third book. (Interspersing children's lit, histories, biographies/memoirs, sociologically based books, occasionally a chick lit sneaks in there, self-help - especially in regards to my sport, faith-based reading... and then the rare modern novel.)
Right now I'm reading a memoir, but that's because I heard an interview with the author the other day and it struck such a deep chord with what I'm dealing with right now, that it's more like therapy reading it! (So far it's a really interesting story, too.) But I had been reaching for a classic before the interview!



I really do want to finish Anna K and start Swann's Way though by the end of break. I keep starting and stopping and starting at the beginning with Anna K, so I want to see it through this time. And I've wanted to read Swann's Way for quite some time.
I'm generally reading 3 or 4 books at once. I just take days and weeks off.
What thoughts, if any, do you have on Anna K? I don't know anyone that's read and understood it from a literary point of view to discuss it with.

I would love having a class that gets loud with the discussing and disagreeing amongst the students and professor. Then again, such a class requires that people do the reading, which I've found rare in my English classes (people majoring in English are included in this group!).
Luckily most of my professors back in college were quite open-minded, they were willing to listen to our opinions as long as our arguments were sound. I can also remember one occasion where a classmate and I disagreed in interpreting a drama. He was saying "Prove it", and I said "You prove it", and he said back, "Why don't you prove your point first?" And all the while the professor just sat back watching us with amusement, LOL.


Lori, your English class sounds really bad.. Especially with people not doing any work.
I hope I won't have anything like that in College as my High School is already like that and that annoys me enough.
I hope I won't have anything like that in College as my High School is already like that and that annoys me enough.

Marion, In my experience, college has been like high school except there's little busywork out of the freshman level courses. In my class, we had some non-majors and some lazy people. What makes me angry is they got the syllabus the first day and could have (and should have) dropped the course when they saw they weren't doing the work. Because then the professor took it out on those who had done the reading. This professor does have high expectations and is demanding, but that's not an excuse to just give up.


Mondays-Pride and Prejudice
Tuesdays-Lolita
Wednesdays and Sundays-Anna Karenina
Thursdays-Grace and Power: The Private World of the Kennedy White House
Fridays-Swann's Way: In Search of Lost Time, Vol. 1
Saturdays-His Dark Materials Trilogy
I thought this seemed like a good idea because I have a bunch of books I want to read and some days, I just don't want to read whatever book I'm reading. So if I trade off each day, then (theoretically) I'll get more done because I can tell myself, "OK, just get through today and then you won't pick it up for a week." It helps build anticipation. And it's similar to the way a lot of old books were published, which was serially, so people would have to wait a week or a month before getting to read the next installment.
That's a pretty cool idea, Lori : )
I guess I'll try that out, too.
I have got so many books I want to read next to the ones I have to read for my paper, so that sound's like a really good idea.
I guess I'll try that out, too.
I have got so many books I want to read next to the ones I have to read for my paper, so that sound's like a really good idea.

In response to the point of this thread, I just started Omensetter's Luck by William H. Gass.

This morning, I read 2 more chapters of A people's history of the United States. I find it very interesting, but I really have to be "there" when reading, otherwise I'll start missing things, so it's really a slow read.
I just started The Three Stigmata of Palmer Eldritch after I finished my re-read of Ubik. It's the second source I am writing my thesis on.
I just started The Three Stigmata of Palmer Eldritch after I finished my re-read of Ubik. It's the second source I am writing my thesis on.

Alcatraz Versus the Evil Librarians, by Brandon Sanderson. I found it to be a fast-paced, easy-to-read, book. It's the first person account of Alcatraz Smedry, a foster kid who has a knack for breaking things. But we soon learn that this "knack" is really a Talent - a Smedry Talent - and a powerful one at that!
Alcatraz's world is turned upside down (or maybe right-side up) when he learns that the world we live in (the world of the Hushlanders) is actually run by evil librarians from the Free Kingdoms (where they know the truth...). Alcatraz must help retrieve his stolen inheritance, the Sands of Rashid, from the evil Dark Oculator. And yet, there's so much more to this book! It's full of witty narrative and clever plot twists (yup, still trying to wrap my head around the last few!). The author pokes fun at numerous things, (jobs, etc.), and while this could offend some people, I don't think it's meant to, as he even pokes fun at authors! More so, I took it as pretty insightful commentary on society (but in a fun, non-snobby way). Also, some readers might find the author's constant "interruptions" annoying - but I found them hilarious and delightful! Moreover, (despite his efforts ;> ), you find yourself caring about the characters and pulling for them.
This is a very different style, and a very unique take on a classic plot. I highly recommend it!!
The other book I finished was Mothstorm by Philip Reeve. I agree with Kathryn's post - they are some of the most enjoyable books I've come across, and do help to fill the HP void. Really, if you can get your hands on a few pages (either from the library or Amazon) check out Larklight: A Rousing Tale of Dauntless Pluck in the Farthest Reaches of Space, the first book in the series. Too wonderful!
I know that a couple of you - most of you, actually - have already read the sisterhood of the traveling pants. Accidentally I have stumbled across the DVD on Amazon when looking for Real Women have Curves (America Ferrara plays in both movies) and clicked on it because it had Alexis Bledel in it. I then realized that it was The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants movie and after some cross-reading on wikipedia, I became really interested in the books.
I had the impression that you liked them overall - could someone tell me a bit more about them?
I had the impression that you liked them overall - could someone tell me a bit more about them?
Marion, the Traveling Pants series are young adult books about four teenage girls who are best friends. Each have to deal with her own coming-of-age problems: boys, parents, college. There are four books in the series. I think the author does a good job in describing the thoughts and emotions of the girls although they have different personalities. I don't read much YA but I think these books are unusual in that they always have a hint of sadness. Bittersweet, that's how I'd describe it.
Thanks, Dini : )
I read the synopsis on wikipedia and thought it sounded pretty interesting. Anyway, I moved it up on my amazon wishlist... Maybe someone wants to get me a last minute Christmas present ; )
I read the synopsis on wikipedia and thought it sounded pretty interesting. Anyway, I moved it up on my amazon wishlist... Maybe someone wants to get me a last minute Christmas present ; )




It's a beautiful series of letters between Helene - a NY scriptwriter whose hunger for obscure used books connects her with Frank, the chief buyer for a London book shop that frequently comes in to possession of libraries from old British estates. Yes, the epistolary format leaves a lot out (in fact, I got the sense that some letters are actually missing from the series), but I think it's just leaving a lot to your imagination!
Their correspondence begins in the late 1950s when post-war England is on severe rations. The letters give a sense of what that scarcity might have been like, as well as what a thrill could be found in a care package of eggs, biscuits and meat, sent courtesy of Helene. But mostly, the series of letters tells the story of a beautiful friendship that gets its start from a shared love of books.
I adored the language and Helene's turns of phrase, as well as the idea of the familiarity and comaraderie that could be found between pen pals who never meet face-to-face.
I was startled at the end of this short book to realize that Helene and Frank were real as was their 20-year friendship! The cover teaser talks about a love affair between Helene and Frank, but I think her real affair is with the books he sends. Her loving, sensual descriptions of the books make me want my own copy of Pride and Prejudice to arrive in my mailbox, sent from overseas looking exactly as Jane ought to look, soft leather, slim and impeccable. (p. 58)
Has anyone else read this lovely little book?
Books mentioned in this topic
The Last Girl (other topics)One Breath Away (other topics)
The Pursuit of Cool (other topics)
Visions of Sugar Plums (other topics)
The Girl Who Chased the Moon (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Jane Casey (other topics)Heather Gudenkauf (other topics)
Haruki Murakami (other topics)
John Updike (other topics)
Robb Skidmore (other topics)
More...