The Rory Gilmore Book Club discussion
Other Book Discussions
>
What else are you currently reading?
message 201:
by
Dini, the master of meaning
(new)
Sep 29, 2008 02:36AM

reply
|
flag

I have just put that book on my Amazon wishlist.
I hope I'll get it for Christmas.
Do you know Reading Lolita in Tehran: A Memoir in Books? I actually put the Three Cups of Tea on there because I thought it might be similar as Reading Lolita.
I hope I'll get it for Christmas.
Do you know Reading Lolita in Tehran: A Memoir in Books? I actually put the Three Cups of Tea on there because I thought it might be similar as Reading Lolita.

but I found it really interesting--quite different than most children's books I've read (and I do love children's books!) "Alcatraz and the Evil Librarians." My husband is reading it now and also finds it interesting. I don't think it'd be for everyone (unusual writing style) but here's my review if you're interested:
Alcatraz Versus the Evil Librarians
FOUR STARS
What a wacky, wise book! I really don't know how to describe it. It's not exactly the sort of book you cozy down with and I'm not sure how attached I really felt to the characters (One chapter begins with Alcatraz asking the reader, "Are you annoyed with me yet?" and he constantly asserts that he is not as heroic or as nice as the Free Kingdomers have made him out to be.)
AND YET, I was completely absorbed in it! Despite all the goofy, fantastical sorts of things going on, Sanderson makes some philosophical and political forays (Plato's allegory of the cave is even mentioned!) Consider these quotes, "People go along with what they're told. Even intelligent people believe what they read and hear, assuming they're given no reason to question."
I think the best way to give any sort of description of the book is to include a few quotes to give you a sense of the writing style--which could be maddeningly annoying to son:
"Hushlanders [that's us:], I'd like to take this opportunity to commend you for reading this book. I realize the difficulty you must have gone through to obtain it--after all, no Librarian is likely to recommend it, considering the secrets it exposes about their kind.
Actually, my experience has been that people generally don't recommend this kind of book at all. It is far too interesting. Perhaps you have had other kinds of books recommended to you. Perhaps, even, you have been given books by friends, parents or teachers, then told that these books are the type you 'have to read.' Those books are invariably described as 'important' -- which, in my experience, pretty much means that they're boring. (Words like 'meaningful' and 'thoughtful' are other good clues.)"
There are so many little gems of hilarious-wiseness in the book; so many "Ah, well, that is because the Librarians rule the Hushlands and so things are this way." (Consider, for example, why we use PAPER for our currency; what else would Librarians choose!?) But, finding them is the whole fun of the book so I'll keep quiet!
:->
Alcatraz Versus the Evil Librarians

I started Flyte a few days ago. A slightly shorter fantasy book to bite off for the time being ;>





Diana, I only know reviews of both books, I have not read either of them, so I can only guess. I thought the theme was going to be rather similar, as they are both about women's education in the Middle East.

And I've gone in a very different direction with my current choice: A Great Deliverance. Since so many of you cheered for the Lynley Mysteries, I thought it would be a good place to start reading Elizabeth George's stories.

(Great picture, by the way!:D)

I finished A Great Deliverance late last night. Was compelled to read to the end to see if my guess was right about how the mystery is solved - it was, but I wasn't proud of my investigative skills as I usually am in that case. The unveiling of the murderer and their motives revealed such a horrible situation - worse even to see it come alive on the page, than to jump ahead with my imagination. But even while I struggled to read about something so ugly, I was still so interested in the main characters - the character development is fascinating (even though their own lives are pretty grim). I suppose my horror at it all wrapping up the way it does is proof of Elizabeth George's skill in creating a realistic world in the pages of her mystery.... Can someone tell me if all her mysteries are this dark?


(oh, which actually made me just remember a book I read at the start of this year. It was really sweet for any animal lovers out there called Enslaved by Ducks. It wouldn't be for everyone, but I found it quite funny and touching).
ANYWAY, back on topic here, I, too, would be very interested to know if all Elizabeth George's mysteries are dark. I'm always up for a good, well-written mystery, but I tend to like them on the lighter side.
I'm not familiar with "Fear of Flying", Sarah... too bad it wasn't better. I think I tend to be harder on books and movies when it seems like the premise is great and it's not executed... it's like the author had everything and their disposal and didn't use it! Argh! ;>
Erin & Ann, you know I don't remember the whole story of A Great Deliverance and my copy is in storage so I can't glance through it and remember. However, I remember many of the other stories that I've read so far in the series. I don't know that Elizabeth George's works are all so "dark," but I will say they are all very involved stories. They aren't simple or straightforward ever. I like that about them.
I will say that while the mysteries themselves are compelling, the best part is in fact the continual character development throughout all the stories. One of my favorites is when it involves Simon St.James and Deborah as the main characters. I just really liked getting to know their stories as well.
But, and I'm only just over half way through them all, one of the best for me was when Barbara went to possibly help/protect her neighbors and ended up embroiled in something big. It was fascinating because you got a glimpse into a culture-within-a-culture.
The book before that one was pretty great, too. I'm purposely not saying the titles of these books because I'm hoping you will be compelled to just keep reading the series and discover for yourselves!
But I'm sorry you didn't like The Song Reader. It's a wonderful story. It wasn't always easy to get through, but so worth it in the end. And Rory liked it! LOL
Kristi, The Thin Man - brilliant! Genius! You'll love it!! I was HOOKED, I tell you!
I will say that while the mysteries themselves are compelling, the best part is in fact the continual character development throughout all the stories. One of my favorites is when it involves Simon St.James and Deborah as the main characters. I just really liked getting to know their stories as well.
But, and I'm only just over half way through them all, one of the best for me was when Barbara went to possibly help/protect her neighbors and ended up embroiled in something big. It was fascinating because you got a glimpse into a culture-within-a-culture.
The book before that one was pretty great, too. I'm purposely not saying the titles of these books because I'm hoping you will be compelled to just keep reading the series and discover for yourselves!
But I'm sorry you didn't like The Song Reader. It's a wonderful story. It wasn't always easy to get through, but so worth it in the end. And Rory liked it! LOL
Kristi, The Thin Man - brilliant! Genius! You'll love it!! I was HOOKED, I tell you!
I'm currently reading The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe by C.S. Lewis. I picked up a copy of The Magician's Nephew for two bucks when on my trip, and ended up reading it on the flight home. I was compelled to continue the Narnia series, I enjoyed it so much. I've been mooching all the other books in the series as a result! It's pushed aside my Frankenstein reading (for now) as a result.

I'm a little more than halfway through Valley of the Dolls and I'm just loving it.

Ooh! Now I'm even more curious to reach Magician's Nephew since you liked it so much!! It's the only one I have left to read aside from Horse and His Boy, which it seems from what I've heard is a fan favorite...:)
At the moment I am reading Oscar and Lucinda, can't read too much of it at once, though because it is a veeeery slow story. Other reads are A people's history of the United States, it is actually really well-written and enjoyable (I know I am a geek, reading history books for fun) and I finally started The Catcher in the Rye because I was in such a Holden-Caulfield-mood today. I have to admit, I like it very much so far, actually a lot more than I thought I would, but that's probably because of my rebellious mood and Holden suiting that pretty well.
Heather! I'm so thrilled! Isn't it so delightful - and thought provoking - and imagination inspiring??? Hooray for Einstein's Dreams!!


I'm currently reading Selected Journals of L.M. Montgomery : Volume I: 1889-1910. L.M. Montgomery is one of my favourite writers, and I adore reading published journals, and I love her journal-writing style, so I'm very much enjoying it!
I'm actually always reading a few books at a time, but that's what has my main attention now...
Katri, I'm always reading several books at a time, but one does eventually take precedence. Okay, really one generally ends up taking over. Right now, however, cleaning needs to take over. LOL

Revoltingly Young: The Journals of Nick Twisp's Younger Brother - C.D. Payne
Slut! Growing Up Female with a Bad Reputation- Leora Tanenbaum
and
The Portable Dorothy Parker.
Revoltingly Young is good but I've been consistently disappointed with all the Twispian books post-Youth In Revolt.
The other two are great. I'm kinda dipping in and out of Dorothy Parker and I'm almost finished Slut! I am on a huge reading buzz at the moment..I love when that happens.





A sweet, charming and beautiful story about friendship, humanity, heart-full-ness and courage. And I have such a special place in my heart for letters-between-friends; and have made some good friends through letter-writing, so the premise of the story is just too-too perfect! The historical aspect was also very interesting; the island of Guernsey was the only place on British soil occupied by the Germans during WWII. Mercifully (to me, anyway) only a few of the letters dealt with some of the more dreadful details of the occupation, and most of them are delivered in a fairly gentle way, though I was still sickened by some of it--and of course the whole premise is horribly depressing and heartbreaking--but the book is all about the brave souls who strove to keep their kindness and strength through it all (not just the Guernsey residents but even a few of the German soldiers sent to occupy it) and how good books helped them to do it. And the story takes place during the brighter times after the Allied victory. Yet the story is more than a "just sunshine after the rain" tale, it shows how so many were able to find the rainbows while it was still pouring. Also, so much of it is based on the present; on sharing a love of literature, of Guernsey--there's some romance, too. The characters are all so interesting and I feel that I have become friends with them through all their dear letters.

Anyhoo, "Alcatraz" is proving to be highly amusing so far and I'm already intrigued!! :)

I am, however, reading New Moon and fully intend to finish the series. I like them. It's just not what I thought it would be, considering all the hype.

I confess, I never finished that book. It was chosen for my live book club several year ago. Definitely not my genre. Others in the club thought it was great, though.



A bit earlier I also started American Gods by Neil Gaiman and The No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency by Alexander McCall Smith, and found both wonderful, but I've had to put them on hold because I just can't concentrate. But I'll return to them later.
Books mentioned in this topic
The Last Girl (other topics)One Breath Away (other topics)
The Pursuit of Cool (other topics)
Visions of Sugar Plums (other topics)
The Girl Who Chased the Moon (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Jane Casey (other topics)Heather Gudenkauf (other topics)
Haruki Murakami (other topics)
John Updike (other topics)
Robb Skidmore (other topics)
More...