Score

removed The Circus of Dr. Lao for having more than 1000 ratings.

graduated The Silver Key and The Knight of the Swords and Lord Darcy and The Queen of the Swords and The King of the Swords and The Bull and the Spear and The Oak and the Ram and The Sword and the Stallion and The Anvil of Ice and The Heart of Myrial and Portrait of Jennie and Aurian for having more than 1000 ratings

Graduated for having more than 1000 ratings: Azathoth
The Master and Margarita
Bloodstone
Harp of Winds
Sword of Flame
Dhiammara
The Silver Branch
A Taste of Blood Wine
Darker Than You Think
Death's Master
The Haunter of the Dark
Carson of Venus
The Flood
The Temple
Tarzan and the Leopard Men
In the Vault
Tarzan and the Lion Man
The White Ship
Behind the Walls of Terra
The Other Gods

Over 1k:
Conan the Invincible
Conan the Triumphant
Conan the Victorious
Conan the Destroyer
Conan the Defender

The Little Grey Men and Jirel of Joiry and The Dragon Waiting and Time and the Gods and Too Many Magicians graduated

The Dunwich Horror: Seven Stories has more than 10k ratings and looks like it was placed on this list by mistake

Night Winds and A Voyage to Arcturus and The Strange High House in the Mist and The Night Land and The Whispering Mountain and The Candle in the Wind and Conan the Unconquered and The One Kingdom and The Isle of Battle and The Unnamable and Imprisoned with the Pharaohs and Delusion's Master and Conan the Magnificent graduated

❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] Through the Gates of the Silver Key by H.P. Lovecraft (Ratings: 1,187, Avg: 3.67, Pos: 9)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] The Wolves of Willoughby Chase (The Wolves Chronicles, #1) by Joan Aiken (Ratings: 22,692, Avg: 4.06, Pos: 36)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] The Book of Wonder by Lord Dunsany (Ratings: 1,045, Avg: 3.93, Pos: 36)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] The Evil Clergyman by H.P. Lovecraft (Ratings: 1,049, Avg: 3.00, Pos: 56)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] Black Easter (After Such Knowledge, #2) by James Blish (Ratings: 1,162, Avg: 3.83, Pos: 63)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] The Uninvited by Dorothy Macardle (Ratings: 1,733, Avg: 3.96, Pos: 82)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] The Copper Crown (The Tales of Aeron, #1) by Patricia Kennealy-Morrison (Ratings: 1,613, Avg: 4.03, Pos: 86)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] The Stone and the Flute by Hans Bemmann (Ratings: 1,170, Avg: 4.06, Pos: 102)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] The Misplaced Legion (The Videssos Cycle, #1) by Harry Turtledove (Ratings: 1,937, Avg: 3.90, Pos: 102)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] An Emperor for the Legion (The Videssos Cycle, #2) by Harry Turtledove (Ratings: 1,218, Avg: 3.93, Pos: 102)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] Duffy and the Devil by Harve Zemach (Ratings: 1,142, Avg: 3.42, Pos: 106)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] Dr. Rat by William Kotzwinkle (Ratings: 1,102, Avg: 3.71, Pos: 112)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] The Gates of Creation (World of Tiers, #2) by Philip José Farmer (Ratings: 1,121, Avg: 3.84, Pos: 112)

❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] The Conan Chronicles: Volume 1 (Conan, #1-3) by Robert Jordan (Ratings: 1,427, Avg: 3.85, Pos: 91)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] The Drive-In by Joe R. Lansdale (Ratings: 1,238, Avg: 3.74, Pos: 111)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] The Levee (Blackwater, #2) by Michael McDowell (Ratings: 62,694, Avg: 3.76, Pos: 136)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] Rain (Blackwater, #6) by Michael McDowell (Ratings: 41,961, Avg: 4.08, Pos: 136)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] The House (Blackwater, #3) by Michael McDowell (Ratings: 53,555, Avg: 4.14, Pos: 136)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] The Fortune (Blackwater, #5) by Michael McDowell (Ratings: 44,727, Avg: 3.98, Pos: 136)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] The War (Blackwater, #4) by Michael McDowell (Ratings: 47,978, Avg: 4.00, Pos: 136)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] Higglety Pigglety Pop! or There Must Be More to Life by Maurice Sendak (Ratings: 1,887, Avg: 4.19, Pos: 150)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] The Doll Who Ate His Mother by Ramsey Campbell (Ratings: 1,291, Avg: 3.36, Pos: 150)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] A Private Cosmos (World of Tiers, #3) by Philip José Farmer (Ratings: 1,166, Avg: 3.91, Pos: 150)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] The Animal Family by Randall Jarrell (Ratings: 1,559, Avg: 4.19, Pos: 157)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] Dark Crusade by Karl Edward Wagner (Ratings: 1,392, Avg: 4.15, Pos: 157)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] The Maker of Universes (World of Tiers, #1) by Philip José Farmer (Ratings: 2,202, Avg: 3.81, Pos: 157)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] The Infinity Concerto by Greg Bear (Ratings: 1,311, Avg: 3.87, Pos: 165)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] The Chronicles of Corum (Corum, #4-6) by Michael Moorcock (Ratings: 1,782, Avg: 4.05, Pos: 165)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] The Swords Trilogy (Corum, #1-3) by Michael Moorcock (Ratings: 3,034, Avg: 4.07, Pos: 165)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] The Cuckoo Tree (The Wolves Chronicles, #6) by Joan Aiken (Ratings: 1,109, Avg: 4.03, Pos: 165)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] The Stolen Lake (The Wolves Chronicles, #4) by Joan Aiken (Ratings: 1,014, Avg: 3.90, Pos: 165)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] All Heads Turn When the Hunt Goes By by John Farris (Ratings: 1,263, Avg: 3.59, Pos: 175)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] Swords of the Legion (The Videssos Cycle, #4) by Harry Turtledove (Ratings: 1,160, Avg: 4.00, Pos: 183)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] The Legion of Videssos (The Videssos Cycle, #3) by Harry Turtledove (Ratings: 1,102, Avg: 3.94, Pos: 210)
❌ OUTLIER: [TOO MANY RATINGS] Black Hearts in Battersea (The Wolves Chronicles, #2) by Joan Aiken (Ratings: 4,623, Avg: 4.14, Pos: 229)