Mark P. Shea's Blog, page 1367

New blog!

The Noble Bard writes:

I know you're a busy guy, so I guess i'll have to keep this brief. Both you and my aunt (Simcha Fischer: Creator of the blog "I have to Sit Down") have inspired me to start my own blog: the Noble Bard in an attempt to cheer up people's days like you so often seem to do.

P.S. I really have no idea if you remember this at all, but we were the people who sent you this clip that you posted on your blog quite a while back. It's called: "Hey There Obama"

And in case you're interested, they also recently came out with another which was quite good.

Looks like you are on your way to me. Write about what interests you and nothing else and you will be interesting to read. And, of course, tell the truth. Then you don't have to remember what you said. If you need a mentor you have a great one in your aunt, who is a fine writer.

Speaking of whom... Hey Simcha , Tito Edwards and Jen Fulweiler! Welcome to the Register blog! The world needs many more of youse!

A reader writes...

Greetings from Walla Walla. We had the privilege of hosting you here two years ago for the weekend mission you put on. I'm writing you this evening to bring to your attention a post on my daughter Amy's blog. Amy has a 3 year-old son, Matthew, who has Down Syndrome and she chronicles his life and the joys and trials of raising Matthew. What she's posted here regards another mom's efforts to raise funds to rescue children with Down's from hellish institutions all over the world. It's an expensive process as so many of these countries see these children as an exploitable commodity and charge very high fees. In a way, it's a blessing that these babies are at least brought to birth. Here in "advanced" America, if it's suspected that a preborn infant might have Down Syndrome, that child has a 95% chance of being killed within a month.

Wonderful work of mercy! And not surprising that your daughter would be involved in helping forward the mission since you guys are such wonderful parents! I have fond memories of my visit to Walla Walla (and still cherish the magnificent gift of the Acme Catalog ("Quality is our #1 Dream!). Blessings on you and your fambly and on this remarkable friend of your daughter's who is doing heroic work!

Prayer Request

A reader writes:

Please say a prayer for me that I can get a job at a good Catholic university soon after I graduate. I will keep you and your family in my prayers too.

Father, hear our pray that this man can put his gifts to work for you in academe. Smooth the way for him to get a good job and serve you and your people through Christ our Lord. Mother Mary and St. Thomas Aquinas, pray for him. Amen.

Debunking Sam Harris

A reader writes:

I am a PhD student in ethics at the Graduate Theological Union in Berkeley and I spend a lot time with the Dominicans at DSPT. I'm working on the relationship between contemporary science and Thomistic natural law.

I also used to be an atheist, so I try to debunk the new atheists whenever I can. As far as that goes, I have the first part of a review I am writing of Sam Harris' The Moral Landscape posted on the GTU ethics student blog here

Well done!

An Eastern Orthodox reader writes

Have you ever heard of Met. Hilarion Alfeyev? He's the No. 2 figure in the Russian Orthodox Church, the church's chief diplomat. He's only 44 years old. Super-brilliant guy, and startlingly open to the West. I heard him speak this past weekend in NYC, and let me tell you, this guy really gets it. He doesn't have that old-school closed-off approach, but he is not a religious liberalizer either. He's also a classical music composer, and was in NYC for the American premiere on Monday night of his "St. Matthew Passion." I've been listening to it on CD, and it's breathtaking. Take a look at the fragment below from a speech he gave in 2009, in which he posited a "Catholic-Orthodox Alliance."

Here's a link to the speech, and the relevant clip. God is doing great things! And notice, this man is of our generation.

In this missionary effort, I believe, the Orthodox Church needs allies, and its closest ally and partner is most likely to be the Catholic Church. There are well-known differences between Catholics and Orthodox on a certain number of doctrinal and ecclesiological points, notable on the understanding of the role of the Bishop of Rome. All these differences, however, appear to be rather minor in comparison to the fundamental elements of faith which are identical in both traditions. Both Churches have apostolic succession of hierarchy and de facto have mutual recognition of sacraments (while continuing not to have full Eucharistic communion). No less important is the solidarity between the Catholics and the Orthodox on major points of moral teaching, including questions of family ethics, human sexuality, bioethics etc.

It is against this background that I have repeatedly suggested that a Catholic-Orthodox Alliance should be formed. This alliance may enable Catholics and Orthodox to fight together for the preservation of traditional values and to combat against secularism, liberalism and relativism. Such alliance may help Orthodox and catholics to speak with one voice in addressing secular society, may provide for them an ample space where they will discuss modern issues and come to common positions. The two traditions can speak with one voice, and there can be a united Catholic-Orthodox response to the challenges of modern times.

The rationale behind my proposal is the following: our Churches are on their way to unity, but one has to be realistic and understand that it will probably take decades, if not centuries, before this unity is realized. In the meantime we desperately need to address the world with a united voice. Without being one Church, can we act as one Church, can we present ourselves to the outside world as a unified structure, as an alliance? I am convinced that we can, and that by doing so we may become much stronger.

Such an alliance, whatever it shape may be, may well include those representatives of Protestant and Anglican communities who associate themselves with a traditional rather than liberal "wing" of Christianity and who share the essential points of traditional Christian morality. I also believe that the Oriental Orthodox Churches should from the very beginning be a part of the alliance on behalf of the Orthodox family. There is no Eucharistic communion between the Eastern and the Oriental Orthodox Churches, but their spirituality and ethos, as well as their social and moral teachings are quite identical. Moreover, in an ecumenical context the Eastern and Oriental Orthodox Churches have already proved to be able to act as one Orthodox family.

The modern battle between traditional Christianity on the one hand and secularism, liberalism and relativism on the other is primarily centred round the question of values. It is not a theological argument, because it is not the existence of God that is debated: it is the existence of an absolute moral norm, on which human life should be founded, that is put into question. The contest has an anthropological character, and it is the present and future of humanity that is at stake. By defending life, marriage and procreation, by struggling against legalization of contraception, abortion and euthanasia, against recognition of homosexual unions as equal to marital ones, against libertinage in all forms, the traditional Christians are engaged in a battle for survival of the Christian civilization and of those peoples who until recently identified themselves with Christianity.

The rediscovery of traditional Christian values is essential in the epoch which is marked by a deep demographic crisis, which in the course of the 21st century is likely to turn into an unprecedented catcstrophe for many countries of the so-called "Western civilization". More and more people are coming to the understanding that the roots of the current demographic crisis are spiritual rathern than economic. It is loss of the traditional understanding of marriage and family, based on religious values, that led to a radical transformation of etical norms related to human sexuality in the second half of the 20th century. This conviction is shared today not only by religious leaders, but also by many social activists and politicians – first and foremost by those with conservative convictions. In his book with the characteristic title The Death of the West, American politician Patrick Buchanan calls the homo occidentalis an "endangered species." He writes:

As a growing population has long been a mark of healthy nations and rising civilizations, falling populations have been a sign of nations and civilizations in decline. If that holds true, Western civilization, power and wealth aside, is in critical condition… As late as 1960, European people, including Americans, Australians and Canadians, numbered 750 million, one-fourth of the 3 billion people alive… In 1960, people of European ancestry were one-fourth of the world's population; in 2000, they were one-sixth; in 2050, they will be one-tenth. These are the statistics of a vanishing race… If the present fertility rates hold, Europe's population will decline to 207 million by the end of the twenty-first century, less than 30 percent of today's. The cradle of Western civilization will have become its grave.

"Irony of ironies," exclaims Buchanan. "Today, an aging, dying Christian West is pressing the Third World and the Islamic world to accept contraception, abortion, and sterilization as the West has done. But why should they enter a suicide pact with us when they stand to inherit the earth when we are gone?"

In his book Buchanan shows that the collapse of the institution of marriage and marital fertility, the triumph of promiscuity, the sharply rising number of divorces, the legalization of abortion, the widespread use of contraception and the liberalization of sexual ethics are all very closely linked with the West's rejection of traditional moral norms formulated by the religious world-view. The "cultural revolution" of the second half of the twentieth century, which undermined the foundations of traditional morality, directed the Western mind away from Christian values – self-sacrifice, altruism and faithfulness – and toward militant secular individualism, which has brought Western civilization to the brink of destruction. Buchanan concludes: "Only a social counterrevolution or a religious awakening can turn the West around before a falling birthrate closes off the last exit ramp and brings down the curtain on Western Man's long-running play."

The Orthodox Church can play a significant role in this religious awakening, which is perhaps the only thing that can save Western civilization from an irrecoverable collapse.

Sounds like a sensible guy who gets the whole "breathing with both lungs" thing. May he live a hundred years.

Prayer Request

A reader asks prayer:

For a special intention.
For the Blessed Virgin Mary's intentions.

Father, hear our prayer through your Son Jesus Christ.

Augustine vs. the Priscillianists

In which we trace the curious thread of connections between Augustine, Peter Kreeft, St. Thomas, Rod Serling, Dr. Faustus, Live Action and all the hurly burly about Lying for Jesus.

Mary's Perpetual Virginity

Why Does it Matter?

Prayer Request

A reader writes:

Please pray for the Elliot family. Their "matriarch", if you will, is in her last days. She's truly a saint -- you could tell because she would become visibly upset if anyone even implied as much in her presence --and I suspect she'll will bypass purgatory entirely, but her large and adoring family and circle of friends will miss her sorely (me included!).

Father, hear our prayer for the Elliot family and especially for Mom. Grant her the grace of a happy death through Christ our Lord and entry into the Regions of Light in the company of Mary and all the saints. Grant grace, peace, strenghth and consolation to her family and skill and compassion to her caregivers. We ask this through Christ our Lord. Mother Mary, pray for the Elliots and all who love them. Pray for us sinners now and at the hour of our death. Amen.

The great Lying for Jesus Debate Continues

in which I discuss Faustian Bargains, argue with people whose sandals I am not worthy to untie, and plead for calm in the factional world of St. Blogs. I would urge those who love babies, Jesus and the Faith to remember that this includes everybody on both sides the debate and to pray for each other and for peace, love and truth to prevail.

Still grinding away and am on deadline this week, so still not much blogging. However, the argument at the Register should keep everybody content for days with grist for conversation.