Fantasy Book Club discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Group business and info
>
Introductions - tell us a little about yourself


I just found the site this weekend via Brandon Sanderson's blog, and am glad I did. I have long been looking for a place to be able to discuss ..."
I enjoy all the flavors, but not equally. A Song of Ice and Fire and the Malazan books are by far my two favorite series. I will add your suggestions to my reading pile immediately! Thank you for your help.

Bear in mind that many of those are among the 'Top 40' of fantasy fiction, which are continuously recommended every time anyone asks for something new to read. There are hundreds of fantasy novels out there that are as good, possibly better, and get no mentions because they aren't big names or in the bookstores. (This includes mine, although I think it's crass to constantly be jumping up and down saying 'Read me! Read Me! every time this question gets asked.) Kfir Luzzatto, Regan Black, Jacquelyn Sylvan, and J.R. Turner come to mind, but also Joel Rosenberg, Janet Kagan, A.C. Crispin, Diane Carey, Diane Duane, L.E. Modesitt, and John M. Ford. Tanya Huff, Nina Kiriki Hoffman, Dave Duncan, Lois McMaster Bujold, and Lawrence Watt-Evans are pretty heavy hitters and they also get few mentions on these threads. (If you like Jim Butcher try Huff's The Enchantment Emporium or Summon the Keeper.) I'm a big fan of character-driven fantasy, and a lot of these epic, plot-driven things leave me stone cold.



Some of my favourite fantasy books are the Tamir triad, Harry Potter, Lord of the Rings, the Name of the Wind and His Dark Materials (I love how almost every fantasy novel is part of a series). When I'm not reading, I'm interning at the hospital, which takes up a lot of my time and energy, but is what I want to be doing :)

I have been fascinated by books my entire life, and have always been drawn to fantasy. As a child I started off with the Redwall series by Brian Jacques, and devoured each new installment with unending enthusiasm. From there I moved onto Piers Anthony, and eventually stepped up to The Wheel of Time series. I will always hold the WoT books dear to my heart.
Some of my favorite authors include - Anne Bishop, Jim Butcher (Codex of Alera), Jacqueline Carey, C. S. Friedman, Robert Jordan, Katherine Kerr, Charles de Lint, George R. R. Martin, Melanie Rawn, J.R.R. Tolkien, and many, many more. I tried to keep the list short!
I'm here to meet like-minded readers, enjoy some literary discussions, and see what everyone else is reading!
Hi everyone, I'm Laurel and am new to Goodreads. I am relatively new to fantasy too, but have fallen in love with it. My family are big fantasy fans and for years have been encouraging me to give it a go.
I started with the Robin Hobb Assassin and Tawny Man trilogies, which are still my favourites. Other authors I have been reading are GRRM, Raymond E Feist, Robert Jordan, and I have just started with Sara Douglass. I attempted Cecilia Dart Thornton, but could not get into it.
I really love finding a well established fantasy series where i know there are lots of books just waiting for me to read. I am very impatient waiting for new books to be written, so I prefer work that's a bit older and already completed! Any suggestions would be great.
I started with the Robin Hobb Assassin and Tawny Man trilogies, which are still my favourites. Other authors I have been reading are GRRM, Raymond E Feist, Robert Jordan, and I have just started with Sara Douglass. I attempted Cecilia Dart Thornton, but could not get into it.
I really love finding a well established fantasy series where i know there are lots of books just waiting for me to read. I am very impatient waiting for new books to be written, so I prefer work that's a bit older and already completed! Any suggestions would be great.



Been lurking around for almost week so I thought I might as well introduce myself :)
My name is Lucia, I come from Slovakia and presently live in Switzerland where I work on crazy particle physics theory stuff.
I was a sci-fi fan long before I knew what sci-fi was, could name all the planets in the solar system in any order when I was seven and when I saw my first star wars movie I couldn't sleep from excitement. Over the years I grew up into a regular geek, loving every good movie/tv series/comic book and occasional game that crossed my path.
But it is books I love the most. In the spirit of Lemony Snicket's 'Never trust anyone who has not brought a book with them' I carry one with me wherever I go and tend to open it in the most unlikely places (in the elevators, while brushing my teeth - you name it). Recently I drifted more towards fantasy, not sure why, possibly because it seems to offer more space for character development and interactions which is what I love most about my books.
My favourites include many of the new(ish) names - Patrick Rothfuss, Scott Lynch, Brandon Sanderson, Scott Bakker, Carol Berg, .... But I'm always on the hunt for some new fantasy goodness! :)

You may also enjoy (in no particular order) Sarah Zettel, Lois McMaster Bujold, Guy Gavriel Kay, and Barbara Hambly whose characters are as well developed and whose plots are just as airtight as Berg's, and as moving. Juliet Marillier should be on this list too (she styles her work in first person) - her stories center around womens' issues, with a beauty and sensitivity, which may make her work of less interest to male readers.

I have also been lurking for a bit. My name is Wil and I have been reading fantasy and sci-fi as long as I can remember. My introduction to fantasy/sci-fi was my mother reading The Crystal Cave and The White Dragon to me when I was little boy.
As I begin branching out on my own I begin reading
J.R.R. Tolkien, C.S. Lewis, and Lloyd Alexander.
High school, college, marriage and two children later, I am still reading fantasy with no intentions of ever stopping.
I am looking forward to speaking with you guys. wb

Welcome to the club Willian! I am pretty new myself, but had to chime in because of your above statement!
I don't think I could ever stop reading fantasy! Who says we ever have to give up what we enjoy!? More power to you.


My love for fantasy came from reading Anne McCaffrey's Dragonriders series in High School, and I haven't looked back! My favorite series is A Song of Ice and Fire by GRRM, and of course the Dragonriders. Some new authors I have enjoyed are Patrick Rothfuss and Scott Lynch (although I've only read the first book by each).
I look forward to having some discussions with you all soon!

My name is Ashley. I'm a reading specialist at an elementary school in Washington. I've enjoyed fantasy ever since I was introduced to the Grimm's fairy tales as a child. I look forward to being introduced to new books and discussing them.
Welcome to the group Nymeria and Ashley and we look forward to you both being part of the discussions.
Nymeria we are currently reading A Game of Thrones so you may wish to join that discussion next month. Patrick Rothfuss is a member of the group and will be doing a discussion of his second novel, which has no fixed release date yet.
Ashley, it would be interesting to do a group discussion of those old fairy tales.
Nymeria we are currently reading A Game of Thrones so you may wish to join that discussion next month. Patrick Rothfuss is a member of the group and will be doing a discussion of his second novel, which has no fixed release date yet.
Ashley, it would be interesting to do a group discussion of those old fairy tales.


I can't really narrow down my favourites any more because I have a tendency to get caught up with current obsessions, but in the past I've salivated over Eddison, Vance, Wolfe, Howard, Tolkien, Donaldson and errr Weis and Hickman (shhhhhh now, their talents are just different from everyone else's) I tend to like my fantasy on the more literary side but honestly, I'm not that fussy... if there's a big sword and a dragon somewhere within it'll probably keep me quiet for a bit...
...actually, it won't keep me quiet because I tend to be more than a little forthright and outspoken.



My current fantasy faves also include Sharon Shinn and newcomer Lynn Kurland. I also love historicals, which, really are pretty much fantasy with some extra work in the research department. I'm published in Regency and am about to be published in fantasy, a book I wrote about 20 year ago and about 20 million revisions ago ;-) I just picked up a book by Robin Hobb and am looking forward to discovering her books.





Welcome to the group Eden and keep up with the writing.

Thanks for putting my reading list in for me, Janny! LOL. I haven't read Berg or Zettel before and I haven't read Bujold or Hambly in a few years, but Kay and Marillier are favorites, so I'll make sure to check out Berg and Zettel soon.
I'm not big into sequels anymore, but I've enjoyed The Riftwar series, Narnia Chronicles, LOTR, The Pern and Deryni novels, the first Shannara Trilogy and the Belgariad. Right now, I'm privileged to be reading a galley of Kay's "Under Heaven" which is due out in April. I will hopefully post my review this week.

Thanks for putting my reading list in for me, Janny! LOL. I haven't read Berg or Zettel bef..."
Victoria: Carol Berg is Phenominal - it doesn't matter if she's writing a series or a one-off, she builds, deepens, startles and the payoff is amazing. I will NEVER recommend a book that does not deliver a crack stunner for an ending. Start Berg with either her standalone, her first trilogy, or her Lighthouse duology (not the four book series done between)...expect everything to change as she grows the story, you'll revise your opinions and even volte face, on the way. I have not read her new one yet (but only due to work/deadline pressure, it's high on the list once I'm free)
Zettel is way too under appreciated. Both her SF and her Fantasy are topflight.
Both of these writers characterize as well as Hambly, Kay, and Bujold. And Marillier - though unlike Marillier, whose issues are oriented to women, I've found male readers may enjoy Berg and Zettel.
You may also like Jennifer Roberson - her Karavans duology is great, and also, her Tiger and Del series - light, fun reading, on the latter, fast adventure and again, great characters/plausible plots.
I hate carelessly crafted books with either research or plot holes you could drive a truck through....



My favorite authors change over time but currently they are Brandon Sanderson, Robin Hobb, Patrcik Rothfuss and Terry Pratchett. I am currently reading John Milton's Paradise Lost and since I always read Pratchett I'm also reading The Last Continent for the third time (I've read all his books at least twice)


I grew up reading fantasy and historical fiction:
JRR Tolkien
Lloyd Alexander
David Eddings
Robert E. Howard
Gary Gygax
Robert Aspirin's Thieves World
Weis and Hickman
Paul S. Kemp
David Gemmell, and
Michael Curtis Ford (historical fiction).
Lately, I've been reading heroic fantasy and sword & sorcery, specifically Joe Abercrombie's The First Law trilogy.
I like protagonists that start out with little or no magical ability. They can develop abilities, but I like to see them struggle with it.
In addition to Goodreads, I support Boysread.org.




I don't really know how to describe what type of fantasy I like other than to say I'm not a big fan of the usuals such as Tolkien, Brooks, Jordan, Goodkind, etc. But I love magic, elves, fairies, and characters that I remember after the book is closed.

Hey Donna, I am also from North Carolina. You live in Cove City? I am outside of Seven Springs, we are practically neighbors.

Anyway, about me. I'm 24, I currently live in Mississippi, and I'm trying to re-ignite a reading obsession that's been partially displaced by movies and video games. My favorite fantasy writers are Robert Jordan, George R.R. Martin, and David Eddings.



I have been on Goodreads for a few months and just HAD to join this group when I got my Brightweavings e-newsletter (Guy Gavriel Kay fan site) and learned that he was here to discuss A Song for Arbonne, which is one of my favorite books.
Kay is one of my favorite authors, along with Neil Gaiman, Terry Pratchett, Tad Williams, Robin Hobb, and for light reading, Mercedes Lackey, among many others.
About me, I'm a middle school science teacher (I know, I'm nuts!), I live in Boston with my husband, and I have been a fantasy fan all my life. I read some science fiction as well but tend to like fantasy better. I also have been getting into historical fiction more recently and am absolutely in love with Dorothy Dunnett - and there seems to be some fairly significant overlap between Dunnett fans and fantasy fans, so that's why I mention it :)
Anyway, nice to meet you all, I look forward to participating in your discussions!

Anyhow, happy to find so many other avid fantasy fans and looking forward to joining the discussions.

I have been on Goodreads for a few months and just HAD to join this group when I got my Brightweavings e-newsletter (Guy Gavriel Kay fan site) and learned that he was here to discuss ..."
Hi Shel, interesting that you enjoy Dorothy Dunnett. That marks you for an intelligent reader, quite willing to wait for an amazing plot to unwind. (With this author, nobody gets it all on the first read - that I ever heard of, anyway.)
Did you know that there are a few fantasy authors who also share your appreciation for this wonderful historical writer? You may want to look up the fantasy by Ellen Kushner, for one. I see you've already fallen for Kay. Good choice!
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
The Name of the Wind (other topics)The Fault in Our Stars (other topics)
Prince of Fools (other topics)
The Whitefire Crossing (other topics)
To Ride Hell’s Chasm (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Michael J. Sullivan (other topics)Robin Hobb (other topics)
Patrick Rothfuss (other topics)
Daniel Abraham (other topics)
George R.R. Martin (other topics)
More...
I just found the site this weekend via Brandon Sanderson's blog, and am glad I did. I have long been looking for a place to be able to discuss fantasy novel..."
I ran through your shelves - there are a lot of interesting books, and even more interesting gaps.
The question I'd pose: are you wanting more depth and complexity (aka Martin/Malazan books) or do you prefer the middle road tradition of easy to grasp action adventure epic - like Feist, Lackey, and Tad Williams?
Notably absent are the rich, character driven works by Guy Gavriel Kay, Martha Wells, Carol Berg, Barbara Hambly, etc.
You don't list anything by Patricia McKillip, though her work is more poetic and faery tale like.
If action is your take, do try Jennifer Roberson's Tiger and Del books, Dennis McKiernan, Michael Sullivan.
If dark and complex, C. S. Friedman, and darker still, Joe Abercrombie.
You also might enjoy Patrick Rothfuss, which rolls a lot of themes into one. And maybe Acacia: The War with the Mein.