The Mark of Athena (The Heroes of Olympus, #3) The Mark of Athena discussion


168 views
What do you think will happen in The Mark of Athena?

Comments Showing 51-100 of 291 (291 new)    post a comment »

Yuman !!!


Yuman still recovering from SHOCK exposure


Yuman hey, that's a really cute picture!!


message 54: by Ellie (new) - added it

Ellie Gratzi! I haven't been ones goodreads for a while either lol. I just got done reading the whole twilight saga in 3days......I'm so sad haha


message 55: by Ellie (new) - added it

Ellie Make sure your table doesn't get sticky from orange juice. :D


Yuman Ellie wrote: "Gratzi! I haven't been ones goodreads for a while either lol. I just got done reading the whole twilight saga in 3days......I'm so sad haha"

was it good? (Say no, please--for my sake)


Yuman Ellie wrote: "Make sure your table doesn't get sticky from orange juice. :D"

also lolling


message 58: by Ellie (new) - added it

Ellie Yumn♣(as in Yumna) wrote: "Ellie wrote: "Gratzi! I haven't been ones goodreads for a while either lol. I just got done reading the whole twilight saga in 3days......I'm so sad haha"

was it good? (Say no, please--for my sake)"


Oh....you probably don't want to hear my answer then XP


Microbat Annabeth won't die. I'm sure of that. She's one of the seven and I think they'll all make it to the last book. In The Son of Neptune and The Lost Hero I think Rick's trying to say that someone's going to die and wants us to guess who it is because he said that 1.) Hazel's already dead and shouldn't have been brought back, 2.) Frank's got a stick that will one day burn and he will die and 3.) Percy shouldn't trust Annabeth and that something bad will happen to her. He hasn't gave any hints to any of the other 4 dying but I'm sure he will soon...

Don't you think Leo and Frank are connected in a lot of ways? They both fell for Hazel, Leo's got fire powers and Frank may die by fire, and they're both the "3rd" characters (Percy - Hazel - Frank, and Jason - Piper - Leo).

Now if you'll excuse me I'm going to read through the "Percy Jackson and the Olympians" books and the "Heroes of Olympus" books again :)


message 60: by Ellie (last edited Dec 30, 2011 09:39PM) (new) - added it

Ellie Ooooooooooooo Microbat has an EXCELENT point about Frank and Leo. Do you think that Leo could be the cause of Franks death? I mean Leo could very much set Franks life into flames. And why do you think Leo cant remember Hazel, if he is supposedly Sammy. GAWD! What is with Riordan! Its like he enjoys my pain. So now, just to put it out I am worried about the following
1) Anabeth dying
2)A love triangle between Jason Piper and Reynaa
3) A love triangle between Hazel Frank and Leo
4)Leo killing Frank by accident and/or purposely
5) Why cant Leo remember Hazel, and what's the deal with that?!?!?!?
6) How the outcome of the Battle in Greece is going to turn out. And how will the Romans fight for Rome if they are in Greece and vice versa
7) How is Anabeth going to play a part in this whole thing
8) If Luke is going to come back......oh gosh cant even think about that without going in to hysterics
9) Whether Zeus is going to come to his senses and STOP BEING SO FREAKING STUBBORN!!!!!!!(no offense, I love Zeus just as much as I love any other God)
I'm pretty sure there is more to ky rant, but I fear that I'm borring you guys -sigh- oh well. I think I'm gonna go cry in a corner now. -mutters to myself- I really am crazy aren't I


Microbat I don't think Leo's forgot Hazel, I think he just wants to forget about it like everything else in his life. He been kicked out of a lot of places and lost lots of friends. And how can you say he's not FROM the past? There were workshops and zoos in the past, so maybe he just moved to the furture somehow. Hazel, Nico and Bianca managed it...


Rachel Lee Well, if someone has to die.. I hoped its Frank. I think his character is not as interesting as the others and his powers and bloodline is a little too much don't u think? I always wonder, since he's connected to Poseidon, will he have any water powers?


message 63: by Ellie (last edited Dec 31, 2011 10:46AM) (new) - added it

Ellie Well the only reason Nicol and Bianca managed is because they were in the Lotus hotel. And I think Hazel came back because the doors of death were opened. So unless Hephaestus preserved Leo than how did he come to the future than? And wouldn't his name still be Sammy if he did remember Hazel, his name is Leo now so wouldn't that give some kind of hint that he doesn't remember?????


Microbat Like I said, he's moved on a few times so he may have changed his name in a couple of places, and there's got to be other ways to skip time. Anything could have happened, but I just believe that's the case...


message 65: by Ellie (new) - added it

Ellie I don't know... it doesn't seem like that would really fit...


Microbat Maybe Hazel and Frank die together.


message 67: by Ellie (new) - added it

Ellie That would be a really bad ending though...... it just doesnt seem like Riordans style to create that.


Rachel Lee Microbat wrote: "Maybe Hazel and Frank die together."

Just like Beckendorf and Silena?


Microbat I find it a little wierd that Hazel's the only 13 year old in the seven heroes. AND that Leo and Frank are both 3 years older than her...


message 70: by Savannah (new)

Savannah AHHHHH! how did i find this place????? okay well this is crazy. Hazel is only 13 and everytime I read that I was like, "But she acts so mature." Humph. I don't know about Leo. Maybe he did skip time- but I doubt it. In the other discussions, Isabelle thought maybe Leo was Sammy come back to life...?


Microbat I'm 13 and I think I'm more mature than a lot of 16 year olds...


message 72: by Savannah (new)

Savannah yeah- but you know... sigh. I just felt like she was 16. I'm sorry if I offended you- I wasn't trying. :)


Microbat I just realised that there is a high chance Annabeth will die! Percy is going to feel pain and misery beyond relief, Hera said he shouldn't trust Annabeth, and Nothing's indicated that Annabeth is one of the 7! She hasn't had a POV and no one's told her she's one of the 7. She just said she wanted to go with them. Knowing me I'm probably wrong, but it does sound logical.


message 74: by Ellie (new) - added it

Ellie Microbat!!!!!!! Annabeth can't die!!!!!!! True, she might not be on of the 7, and I know Hera might not trust her; but she is still good. This goes back to one of my earlier comments but I think that she just has to make a big decision about the battle. It will REALLY big though. and to Savannah it feel to me that she is 16 too, it's cause she came from time so she kind of aged a lil in ya know hell. HAHAHA! So anyways, I think from reading Riordans books and knowing how upset his fans would be, I think Annabeth will most likely not die.....and if she did well.....I have a pitchfork and a shotgun waitin :)


message 75: by Haley (last edited Jan 17, 2012 07:22AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Haley sorry to drop in, but i think that leo didnt come back just that he is a grandson to sammy, like hazel said "he looks LIKE sammy" that dosent mean he is. like i said he might be a desendent of sammy. that is just my guess.


message 76: by Ellie (new) - added it

Ellie @Haley
Eh who knows...


Haley I dont even know, im just guessing...but if he did come back from the past how did he do it, or did he go through the doors of death


message 78: by Aaron (new)

Aaron Sorry for coming in.. but I like to read speculation and the possibilities are blowing my mind
Anyways, Didn't Daedalus have some sort of Mark of Anthea for murder or whatever? I think they are going to Rome in the upcoming book as well. That is all I can think of for now...


message 79: by Ellie (last edited Jan 21, 2012 03:55PM) (new) - added it

Ellie hmph.....stupid book needs to come out faster. And so help me Riordan, if Mark of Athena ends in another cliff I'm going to court for pre-meditated murder(well I heard the charges are more if its pre-meditated so maybe I'll just do it, ya know heat of the moment xD)!!!!!!!!!!!


Sabina Gora You know what I just realized?! In SoN the last line is "Let me introduce you to my other family."
That means not only Annabeth, Piper, Leo, and Jason are on the ship! Cuz Percy doesn't know J, L, And P. He only knows Annabeth, So that means others are on the ship!! I bet it's people like Grover.. idk who else! But it can't be Thalia. CUz im almost 100% percent sure she was kidnapped like Nico. but OMG. GAHH I NEED TO KNOW.


message 81: by Laura (last edited Jan 22, 2012 12:29PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Laura About Sammy being Leo. I think that Sammy is Leo's grandfather... It knida fits because in Alaska when Hazel went down in the mud to get Percy, Gaia told Hazel that Sammy had married and every thing so it would only make sense that Leo is his grand son...

Also has any one thought about the possibility of Reyna and Leo hooking up? Because Leo always likes girls that are way out of his league and he has moved crushes like with the snow goddess to Thalia.


Sabina Gora Sabina Gora wrote: "You know what I just realized?! In SoN the last line is "Let me introduce you to my other family."
That means not only Annabeth, Piper, Leo, and Jason are on the ship! Cuz Percy doesn't know J, L, ..."

Interesting theory. I was kinda thinking that Sammy decided to be reborn into another life, kinda like Bianca (Nico's sis) and it's Leo. :D


message 83: by Ellie (last edited Jan 24, 2012 12:16PM) (new) - added it

Ellie Laura wrote: "About Sammy being Leo. I think that Sammy is Leo's grandfather... It knida fits because in Alaska when Hazel went down in the mud to get Percy, Gaia told Hazel that Sammy had married and every thin..."

HOLY CRAP!!!!!!!!!!!!!(About the Leo and Reyna thing!)


message 84: by Ellie (new) - added it

Ellie I'm going to kill someone. Legit, someone is going to die soon. I just heard that Riordan is going to make a fourth book in 2013.......I don't know maybe you guys heard that but I DIDN'T!!!!! And watch it end in a cliff hanger! Gosh why!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I hate this, really I do. Riordan I'm coming for you! D;


Laura How many books are there going to be in the Heros of Olympus series???... just wondering because then it'll be like 2015 before the end of the series...?


message 86: by Laura (last edited Jan 24, 2012 04:26PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Laura Boo!kworm wrote: "I think that there are going to be five total."

WOW COOL!!!!!!!! I wish he'd hurry up writing them though... :D


Laura Boo!kworm wrote: "Laura wrote: "Boo!kworm wrote: "I think that there are going to be five total."

WOW COOL!!!!!!!! I wish he'd hurry up writing them though... :D"

I know. But maybe with his other series ending he ..."


Yeah that would be great!!! :DDD


message 88: by Ellie (new) - added it

Ellie ...no comment


Haley im think that he already has written all the books, but he is waiting to relese them so more poeple get excited about reading them then he will get more money...


message 90: by Ellie (new) - added it

Ellie Grrr, if he is doing that then he shall pay. I'm seriously considering ransacking his house.......Haley, wanna come with :D


Haley Im all in, like all i do is think about this book try to figure out what will happen in it. It needs to come out now.


message 92: by Ellie (new) - added it

Ellie My point exactly....erg. What I don't understand is why he chose to write 2 series at the same time, I mean I'm pretty sure he knows how deranged his fans are (Cough* Me Cough*). And the Kane Chronicles weren't even good, my note to Riordan would be stick to the Greek stuff homie!


Haley true! I heard from so many poeple the kane chronicles sucked... he should just stick with greek.


message 94: by Laura (last edited Jan 27, 2012 09:36PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Laura I liked the Kane Chronicles well enough but I think his greek books are better. I think that it is because that greek mythology is so popular and more well known than the egyptian... What I'm mean is that if we knew more about the egyptian gods then we might like the books more. I hope when he does the Norse myths that it will make more sense than the Kane Chronicles did.


Nya Tomlinson-Horan-Malik-Payne-Styles Haley wrote: "true! I heard from so many poeple the kane chronicles sucked... he should just stick with greek."

the kane chronicles are amazing! i loved them because they are so complicated and Egyptian mythology is soooo intriguing.


message 96: by Ellie (new) - added it

Ellie I still think he should just stick to Greek. The Kane Chronicles didn't get him anywhere. If it weren't for Heroes of Olympus, I think Riordon would be in a jam. Also, since he did so well with the Percy Jackson Series people expect a lot of him through the Greek stuff. Its better to stick with whet your good at.


Nya Tomlinson-Horan-Malik-Payne-Styles i think he is good at all mythology. personally, the kane chronicles go into wayyy more details than his greek books


message 98: by Ellie (new) - added it

Ellie sure sure....


Haley Ellie wrote: "I still think he should just stick to Greek. The Kane Chronicles didn't get him anywhere. If it weren't for Heroes of Olympus, I think Riordon would be in a jam. Also, since he did so well with the..."

Im with 100%... but Im getting so upset with Rick right now. He needs to get those fricken books read to sell i need to read them. now.


message 100: by Ellie (new) - added it

Ellie Ikr!!!!! He doesn't have as many fans for Kane as he does for Heroes of Olympus. Cant he just...idk quit the Kane chronicles till he is done with HO


back to top