Catching up on Classics (and lots more!) discussion

269 views
Buddy Reads > Buddy Read Requests

Comments Showing 251-300 of 400 (400 new)    post a comment »

message 251: by Greg (new)

Greg | 1043 comments Connie wrote: "Greg, I'm going to try to fit in The English Patient in March too.."

Great Connie!


message 252: by Cynda (new)

Cynda | 5266 comments Thanks Savita. I will have three surgeries total scheduled to improve my mobility. One down. Two to go.


message 253: by Terry (new)

Terry | 2542 comments Good luck with your surgeries, Cynda!


message 254: by Terry (new)

Terry | 2542 comments Greg. I’m excited that so many people are joining our Buddy Read for The English Patient in March!


message 255: by Greg (new)

Greg | 1043 comments Terry wrote: "Greg. I’m excited that so many people are joining our Buddy Read for The English Patient in March!"

Me too!


message 256: by Kathleen (new)

Kathleen | 5508 comments Cynda wrote: "Thanks Savita. I will have three surgeries total scheduled to improve my mobility. One down. Two to go."

Sending strength and healing as you go through all of this, Cynda. And I'm sure some great books will help!


message 257: by Cynda (new)

Cynda | 5266 comments Thank you Terry and Kathleen. I will go to the same rehab facility afterwards that I did last time. They did a fine job. I wish they had better food 😄


message 258: by Sara, New School Classics (new)

Sara (phantomswife) | 9753 comments Mod
I sincerely hope the food is the only complaint you have, Cynda!


message 259: by Shawn (new)

Shawn | 233 comments I’m going to jump in on The English Patient in March also.


message 260: by Greg (new)

Greg | 1043 comments Shawn wrote: "I’m going to jump in on The English Patient in March also."

Glad to have you join us Shawn. Everyone is very welcome!


message 261: by Sara, New School Classics (new)

Sara (phantomswife) | 9753 comments Mod
With this much interest, I will nominate this for the March group read. If this many group members are reading, it would be nice to have it added to the bookshelf. Everyone please remember to vote. Of course, if it does not win, I will set up the thread for a buddy read.


message 262: by Sam (new)

Sam | 1163 comments Sara wrote: "With this much interest, I will nominate this for the March group read. If this many group members are reading, it would be nice to have it added to the bookshelf. Everyone please remember to vote...."

Great idea!


message 263: by Sam (new)

Sam | 1163 comments Daryl wrote: "Ascanio wrote: "Daryl wrote: "Hello, would anyone be interested in reading The Nun by Denis Diderot."

Just to remind, so that it doesn't get lost among the many message..."


Can we get an update on whether this buddy read is still on, when and if any other members are joining?


message 264: by Greg (new)

Greg | 1043 comments Sara wrote: "With this much interest, I will nominate this for the March group read. If this many group members are reading, it would be nice to have it added to the bookshelf. Everyone please remember to vote...."

That sounds great Sara! It would be nice to have a very active group read! And if it doesn't win, we can still do the buddy read as you say.


message 265: by Sara, New School Classics (new)

Sara (phantomswife) | 9753 comments Mod
I have read it already, but as you guys were talking I thought what a good discussion it would make and I would be in for a re-read. Thank you for putting it out there, Greg.


message 266: by Greg (new)

Greg | 1043 comments Sara wrote: "I have read it already, but as you guys were talking I thought what a good discussion it would make and I would be in for a re-read. Thank you for putting it out there, Greg."

Fantastic to have another shared read with you Sara, and my pleasure! I think it was Terry who first had the idea after I mentioned not having read it yet. I'm looking forward to it!


message 267: by Sam (new)

Sam | 1163 comments Ascanio wrote: "I noticed that several people have added Satantango to their bookshelves. If anyone is interested in discussing it, I will be reading it between late October and early November (alr..."

There was a decent interest in Satantango for a group read in December, probably more than we'll ever see for Krasznahorkai nomination ever again. . Ascanio was suggesting a buddy read from now through November. I suggest if there is sufficient interest, to making Satantango a buddy read for November/December. With the intent of encouraging participation, I am asking whether there is an easy way to notify members who voted for the book for December that a buddy read is potentially scheduled? I had been wondering this for some of the other books that have done well in the polls but seem of limited interest when it comes to buddy reads, like Diderot's Nun for example. But I do not wish to incur a lot of work for anyone. Mods have access to notifying lists of members which seems to reach people that are getting spotty notifications. Is it doable to just target members that voted in the poll?


message 268: by Ascanio (last edited Oct 28, 2025 09:12AM) (new)

Ascanio Sam wrote: "Ascanio wrote: "...like Diderot's Nun for example"

Thanks for your interest, Sam. I read Satantango last week, but I could still take part in a discussion. I'm just popping in to remind that a buddy read of Diderot's The Nun is scheduled for December (two participants).


message 269: by Greg (new)

Greg | 1043 comments Sam wrote: "I suggest if there is sufficient interest, to making Satantango a buddy read for November/December.."

I voted for it, and I would join one if we have it Sam


message 270: by Sam (new)

Sam | 1163 comments Greg wrote: "Sam wrote: "I suggest if there is sufficient interest, to making Satantango a buddy read for November/December.."

I voted for it, and I would join one if we have it Sam"


The discussion aspect is what I had in mind. As Ascanio I hope will agree, the novel is worth discussing.


message 271: by Ascanio (last edited Oct 28, 2025 09:56AM) (new)

Ascanio Sam wrote: "...the novel is worth discussing."

I can easily see several points of interest. For my part, I would take advantage of the opportunity to read a second novel by the same author.


message 272: by Savita (new)

Savita Singh | 1096 comments Cynda wrote: "Thanks Savita. I will have three surgeries total scheduled to improve my mobility. One down. Two to go."

Soon all 3 surgeries will be done and over with , Cynda , and may kind angels be with you in an uneventful pathway to good recovery . God bless


message 273: by Savita (new)

Savita Singh | 1096 comments Sara wrote: "I have read it already, but as you guys were talking I thought what a good discussion it would make and I would be in for a re-read. Thank you for putting it out there, Greg."

How very nice , Sara , that you're joining the read of The English Patient 😊 . It's a re-read for Connie , too , so it must be a really good book !


message 274: by Cynda (new)

Cynda | 5266 comments Namaste Savita.


message 275: by Sara, New School Classics (new)

Sara (phantomswife) | 9753 comments Mod
Sam, as far as I know, there is no provision for mods to reach a group of individuals beyond what another member can do. A mod can send a message to the entire group or to an individual alone.

Perhaps a comment in the poll comments section at the end of voting, to say you are doing a buddy read of a losing nomination, would reach interested voters.


message 276: by Sam (new)

Sam | 1163 comments Sara wrote: "Sam, as far as I know, there is no provision for mods to reach a group of individuals beyond what another member can do. A mod can send a message to the entire group or to an individual alone.

Pe..."



I will try to remember that before the poll ends. Thanks Sara.


message 277: by Klowey (new)

Klowey | 834 comments Sam wrote: "Ascanio wrote: "I noticed that several people have added Satantango to their bookshelves. If anyone is interested in discussing it, I will be reading it between late October and ear..."

I already bought it, but honestly, I am so booked for this year that I was hoping for a buddy read in in 2026.

In any case, I would welcome a discussion on it, but I won't be starting reading it until January.


message 278: by Darren (new)

Darren (dazburns) | 2057 comments it hasn't lost the poll yet ;o)


message 279: by Kimberly (new)

Kimberly | 358 comments Sam wrote: "Daryl wrote: "Ascanio wrote: "Daryl wrote: "Hello, would anyone be interested in reading The Nun by Denis Diderot."

Just to remind, so that it doesn't get lost among th..."


I just finished reading it this week.


message 280: by April (new)

April | 475 comments Wishing everyone successful procedures and speedy recoveries!

Now, back to the thread. I might be interested in a couple, but we will see. I'm trying to slow down still these days. But I wanted to say about The English Patient. Sounds a lot like A Farewell to Arms?


message 281: by Savita (last edited Oct 29, 2025 04:58AM) (new)

Savita Singh | 1096 comments Cynda wrote: "Namaste Savita."

Oh , Cynda , I am absolutely taken by surprise and deeply touched by your response in my own language ! Such an amazingly sweet way of responding.... 💖 !

[ 🙏 ... this is the accompanying gesture for namaste .. when two people greet each other ; or when one wishes to say thank you ; and, also , as in the West.. when we bow down in
prayers before the Almighty. ]


message 282: by Savita (new)

Savita Singh | 1096 comments April wrote: "Wishing everyone successful procedures and speedy recoveries!

Now, back to the thread. I might be interested in a couple, but we will see. I'm trying to slow down still these days. But I wanted to..."


It'll be lovely if you could join The English Patient read , April ! ... though , from your previous comments , you seem to be a bit hard pressed for time .
Though I haven't read any of the two books you've mentioned, I have read the blurb of The English Patient, and the latter title seems to have a sad , a painful, even a ? proud ( depending on the context and story of A Farewell to Arms )resonance with the former title 🤔 . Maybe the other members will be able to clarify.


message 283: by Terry (new)

Terry | 2542 comments Having seen the movie, I can say, without giving anything away, that the English Patient has a singular and complicated plot. After we read the book, I recommend watching the movie, but not before.


message 284: by Savita (new)

Savita Singh | 1096 comments Thanks for the info , Terry !


message 285: by Ascanio (new)

Ascanio In December, we will read Samuel Beckett's fourth novel: Mercier et Camier, 120 pages. In the discussion already underway, you can find introductory notes on the author and his early works. I hope to see you there!


message 286: by Luffy Sempai (new)

Luffy Sempai (luffy79) | 776 comments Ascanio wrote: "In December, we will read Samuel Beckett's fourth novel: Mercier et Camier, 120 pages. In the discussion already underway, you can find introductory notes on the author and his early works. I hope ..."

So many books in French, so little time to improve on it.


message 287: by Daryl (new)

Daryl | 14 comments Sam wrote: "Daryl wrote: "Ascanio wrote: "Daryl wrote: "Hello, would anyone be interested in reading The Nun by Denis Diderot."

Just to remind, so that it doesn't get lost among th..."


Sam, will you join us for The Nun? Because me and Ascanio was going to private message since there were only going to be two of us but if you want to join then we can schedule the thread for December? :)


message 288: by Terry (new)

Terry | 2542 comments Did someone mention reading Our Mutual Friend next year? If so, I would join that.


message 289: by Luffy Sempai (new)

Luffy Sempai (luffy79) | 776 comments Terry wrote: "Did someone mention reading Our Mutual Friend next year? If so, I would join that."

Dickens last complete novel and his best? Sign me up.


message 290: by Klowey (new)

Klowey | 834 comments Luffy Sempai wrote: "Terry wrote: "Did someone mention reading Our Mutual Friend next year? If so, I would join that."

Dickens last complete novel and his best? Sign me up."


I might join in for Our Mutual Friend. Depends on timing. I want to reread it with my partner because I think he'd like it. Apparently it's a little different from Dickens other work, but I wouldn't know since the only other Dickens I read was his A Christmas Carol. I thought Our Mutual Friend had a lot of very modern elements and I thoroughly enjoyed it.


message 291: by Luffy Sempai (new)

Luffy Sempai (luffy79) | 776 comments Klowey wrote: "Luffy Sempai wrote: "Terry wrote: "Did someone mention reading Our Mutual Friend next year? If so, I would join that."

Dickens last complete novel and his best? Sign me up."

I might join in for [..."


It's great you will be joining. Looking forward to the BR. I haven't read this one so far.


message 292: by Terry (new)

Terry | 2542 comments Luffy and Klowey, what timing works for reading Our Mutual Friend? How about April or May? It’s a long book and could take me more than a month to get through it.


message 293: by Luffy Sempai (new)

Luffy Sempai (luffy79) | 776 comments Terry wrote: "Luffy and Klowey, what timing works for reading Our Mutual Friend? How about April or May? It’s a long book and could take me more than a month to get through it."

Either month is okay with me, Terry.


message 294: by Terris (new)

Terris | 4415 comments Terry wrote: "Did someone mention reading Our Mutual Friend next year? If so, I would join that."

Yes, Terry, I was talking to Sara about reading it. I would be happy to do a buddy read together & it looks like some others might be interested also! April or May would be fine with me :)


message 295: by Klowey (new)

Klowey | 834 comments Terry wrote: "Luffy and Klowey, what timing works for reading Our Mutual Friend? How about April or May? It’s a long book and could take me more than a month to get through it."

Yes, that timing would work well.


message 296: by Terry (new)

Terry | 2542 comments Sara, Terris, Luffy and Klowey will be joining me to read Our Mutual Friend by Charles Dickens next year. Can you please put us on the Buddy Read schedule for April?


message 297: by Terry (new)

Terry | 2542 comments My previous post was directed to Sara, but I didn’t mean to imply that she was joining us. However, I do invite others to join in. 😊


message 298: by Sara, New School Classics (new)

Sara (phantomswife) | 9753 comments Mod
Positively Dickens at his best! Added to the schedule.


message 299: by Terris (new)

Terris | 4415 comments Thank you, Sara! It's on my April list now! :)


message 300: by Savita (new)

Savita Singh | 1096 comments Terris wrote: "Thank you, Sara! It's on my April list now! :)"

Hmm .... well, my loss , really 😟😕🤔 😥 ... so many great reads happening close to each other , I will not be able to join for this Charles Dickens read ( not read Charles Dickens for quite sometime , and Sara has just mentioned Positively Dickens at his best ! What can I say except that it's my unfortunate loss ! Actually, My Brother Michael is probably being scheduled in April , and that , too , I don't want to miss ( I've become an absolute fan of M. Stewart ) . Our Mutual Friend is quite a long book .. 600 pages kindle book , and 880 pages paperback. Terry said she'll take a month to finish it , but , if I were to read it , it would take me three months , I suppose. Incidentally , Our Mutual Friend is free on Amazon kindle .


back to top