Never too Late to Read Classics discussion
Archive 2022 Genre & Novelist
>
2022 Genre & Novelist Reads

Demian: The Story of Emil Sinclair's Youth by Hermann Hesse (not sure that this really meets the genre)
Hard Times by Charles Dickens
(If I'm limited to one, then in has to be Buddenbrooks: The Decline of a Family

Regarding Historical Fiction, usually something between the 18th to mid 20th centuries. Rarely anything earlier, though I also like current works.
I also like some Sci-Fi, though I'm very picky about that. Don't care at all for the Fantasy types but do like those that tend to involve dystopias and various social conditions.


Demian: The Story of Emil Sinclair's Youth by [auth..."
This is my choice of genre, and would like to read Buddebrooks.

So this year I am keeping a sharp eye on the proceedings lol. I voted for my most favourite genre Historical Fiction. If seconds are allowed I will second Family Sagas.
I chose Historical romance as the genre and I particularly recommend any of Jane Austen's books for that genre.

For family saga: The Good Earth by Pearl S.
Buck
Mystery: The Daughter of Time by Josephine Tey
Romance: The Awakening by Kate Chopin
Biography: The Story of My Life by Helen Keller
Action/Adventure:Uncle Tom's Cabin by Harriet Beecher Stowe
I voted for action/adventure having in mind Kidnapped and its sequel Catriona (sorry I couldn't find a link) by Robert Louis Stevenson. But I'm not sure whether the latter book is freely available.

2nd choice is Shroud for a Nightingale by P.D. James (1971)
Lesle wrote: "Piyangie hope this is the right one
Catriona by Robert Louis Stevenson"
It is the one, Lesle. Thank you.
Catriona by Robert Louis Stevenson"
It is the one, Lesle. Thank you.

I’m not sure if it has an “optimistic ending” though. Is it okay to suggest something we’ve not read before?
Supeng wrote: "Apologies, part of my comment got cut off.
I meant to ask if it is okay to suggest something we’ve not read before?"
Most definitely Supeng!
I meant to ask if it is okay to suggest something we’ve not read before?"
Most definitely Supeng!

I’ll keep a close eye on the final books chosen and hopefully join in when the announcements are out! :)
I too thought about voting for Romance and suggesting Madam Bovary since a reread of it is due. :) But the "optimistic ending" checked me. :) The only romances that come to my mind with an optimistic ending are Jane Austen's.
If a second is needed for Buddenbrooks: The Decline of a Family, please count me in. It's a book in my TBR for 2022.

Hooray!
@Piyangie--there are other optimistic classic romances, but of course it's easy to think of Jane Austen first and also of the Bronte sisters whose romances are not all so optimistic when they are romances (Jane Eyre certainly is, but not what one would call optimistic!)

I too would like to read Buddenbrooks: The Decline of a Family.


This is the June 2019 Archive discussion on Fathers and Sons: https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
This is the April 2018 Archive Discussion on German Authors with suggested reads Buddenbrooks and Effi Briest, although most of the discussion concerns Effi Briest: https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...

I posted these 4 old discussions for institutional memory purposes only.
However I was very pleased to see that 3 of the more experienced and reliable readers here, Kathy, Peter and Piyangie, want to read one of my all-time favorite novels, Buddenbrooks. Those 3, unlike the too many voters I've run into on Goodreads, can at least be counted on to read a book they asked or voted for.
Peter wrote: "Key classics that I want to read in 2022 are Max Havelaar, or the Coffee Auctions of the Dutch Trading Company by the Dutch author Multatuli and Fathers and Sons by Ivan ..."
Peter we can keep this in mind. We are considering re-reads as well.
Not everyone has time to fit it in their schedule when we originally read the classic.
Peter we can keep this in mind. We are considering re-reads as well.
Not everyone has time to fit it in their schedule when we originally read the classic.

This one could work for Comedy or Romance In fact there are two books (one is sort of a sequel) so I am going to put two down that could be either of those categories. I just love these.
Daddy-Long-Legs by Jean Webster
Dear Enemy
(it also comes as a 2 book volume). If we go with these, I strongly recommend getting Daddy Long Legs with the original drawings because it's even better than without, but still funny without.
If it were up to me, I'd plan it to read Daddy Long Legs for comedy and then in a later month read the sequel for Romance.

Gone with the Wind
East of Eden or The Forsyte Saga


Both threads are still open for discussion. I've been posting in The Forsyte Saga discussion thread during this month.
Shrouk, as Brian said, both threads are still open for discussion, and will remain so.
All of our book discussion threads remain open, no matter how long ago we read the book.
All of our book discussion threads remain open, no matter how long ago we read the book.
Thank you Shrouk!
It just reminds me even though we have read a Classic as a group at the time we may not have had time to read it. A re-read or get to finally off my TBR pile never hurts to revisit some of our past reads.
I myself know, I always have high hopes of reading every one of our Monthly Group Read up for the month that I am interested in but the month passes me up before I get to the next read!
It just reminds me even though we have read a Classic as a group at the time we may not have had time to read it. A re-read or get to finally off my TBR pile never hurts to revisit some of our past reads.
I myself know, I always have high hopes of reading every one of our Monthly Group Read up for the month that I am interested in but the month passes me up before I get to the next read!
Looking for suggestions for next year under each category. It can be a re-read for the group or a new read.
You can suggest a book for each genre or just a few. Please copy and past if you like. Taking suggestions for FWC (Frontier Western Classics for the Western Category like O Pioneers!, Smoky the Cowhorse or even Little Big Man.
You can support a suggestion as well.
Historical Fiction/Romance: 35 votes
Family Saga: 34 votes
Mystery: 30 votes
Romance: 22 votes
Action/Adventure: 15 votes
Thriller: 13 votes
Spy/Detective: 8 votes
Comedy: 8 votes
Biography: 7 votes
Nautical/Sea: 7 votes
Western: 0 votes
Just a reminder: Most Classics need to be 50 years or older written 1972 or older. YA is 40 years 1981 or older. FWC and Plays are written 1991 or older.
You can suggest a book for each genre or just a few. Please copy and past if you like. Taking suggestions for FWC (Frontier Western Classics for the Western Category like O Pioneers!, Smoky the Cowhorse or even Little Big Man.
You can support a suggestion as well.
Historical Fiction/Romance: 35 votes
Family Saga: 34 votes
Mystery: 30 votes
Romance: 22 votes
Action/Adventure: 15 votes
Thriller: 13 votes
Spy/Detective: 8 votes
Comedy: 8 votes
Biography: 7 votes
Nautical/Sea: 7 votes
Western: 0 votes
Just a reminder: Most Classics need to be 50 years or older written 1972 or older. YA is 40 years 1981 or older. FWC and Plays are written 1991 or older.

I think Catriona is sufficiently available. When I read it 3 years ago, I bought a Kindle version on Amazon. There is also a paperback edition: https://www.amazon.com/Catriona-Rober...
Presumably Amazon UK will have some version of Catriona available.

Historical Fiction/Romance - Ivanhoe by Walter Scott
Family Saga - Buddenbrooks: The Decline of a Family by Thomas Mann
Mystery - The Big Sleep by Raymond Chandler
Action/Adventure - Kidnapped by Robert Louis Stevenson
Thriller - Rebecca by Daphne du Maurier
Spy/Detective - Our Man in Havana by Graham Greene
Comedy - Thank You, Jeeves by P.G. Wodehouse
Biography - The Life of Charlotte Brontë by Elizabeth Gaskell
Nautical/Sea - Captain Blood by Rafael Sabatini
Western - Shane by Jack Schaefer
(Irrespective of the results - aren't these lists a great way of enthusing yourself to read/re-read some great books?)


Lejla wrote: "Mystery, ''The name of rose'', Umberto Eco"
Glad to see you were able to post this Lejla! Thank you :)
Glad to see you were able to post this Lejla! Thank you :)
John wrote: "(Irrespective of the results - aren't these lists a great way of enthusing yourself to read/re-read some great books?)..."
Just never know what is going on in my head John! But I totally agree.
Just never know what is going on in my head John! But I totally agree.
Helen wrote: "I find it very hard to nominate particular books, because there are so many I want to read, but I also like being surprised by books I haven't come across before. That said, I would happily second ..."
Thank you Helen!
Thank you Helen!
Shrouk wrote: "Thank you Brian, Rosemarie, and Lesle for your comments. I didn't know that threads remain open. Hopefully I will be able to read these books soon."
Your more than welcome Shrouk!
Your more than welcome Shrouk!
Brian wrote: "Piyangie wrote: " Kidnapped and its sequel Catriona (sorry I couldn't find a link) by Robert Louis Stevenson. But I'm not sure whether the latter book is freely available."
I think [book:Catriona|..."
Ah, thats good news, Brian. Thank you.
I think [book:Catriona|..."
Ah, thats good news, Brian. Thank you.
Lesle - my original suggestion for Kidnapped and Catriona stands under action/adventure category. And I will support the Buddenbrooks under family saga.

Family Saga: I support Buddenbrooks: The Decline of a Family
Mystery: Armadale by Wilkie Collins
Romance: Sense and Sensibility (re-read for me)
Action/Adventure:
Thriller:
Spy/Detective: I support Our Man in Havana
Comedy: I support Thank You, Jeeves
Biography: I support The Life of Charlotte Brontë
Nautical/Sea:
Western:

I have already named a Family Saga above (Mary Stewart's Crystal Cave).
Mystery: A Pocket Full of Rye by Agatha Christie
Romance:
Action/Adventure:
Thriller:
Spy/Detective:
Comedy:
Biography:
It has been a long time since I read this Western but I suggest No Life for a Lady by Agnes Morley Cleaveland.
And for Nautical/Sea: I suggest Master and Commander by Patrick O'Brian
I will return to name a book for the blank categories.
Looks like I've completely misunderstood this process. So, let me get myself cleared. Can I recommend/support one book in more than one category?

Piyangie wrote: "Looks like I've completely misunderstood this process. So, let me get myself cleared. Can I recommend/support one book in more than one category? "
Yes you can. You are right at first I was just taking one, but I have changed my mind wanting more diversity in choices.
All prior suggestions will remain and be part of this whole process. Thank you for the reminder and wanting clarification :)
Yes you can. You are right at first I was just taking one, but I have changed my mind wanting more diversity in choices.
All prior suggestions will remain and be part of this whole process. Thank you for the reminder and wanting clarification :)
Annette wrote: "It has been a long time since I read this Western but I suggest No Life for a Lady by Agnes Morley Cleaveland...."
Annette what a great suggestion, I did not know about this. Seems to be very interesting about the female role!
Annette what a great suggestion, I did not know about this. Seems to be very interesting about the female role!
Books mentioned in this topic
Shane (other topics)The Ox-Bow Incident (other topics)
Catriona (other topics)
Oliver Twist (other topics)
Very Good, Jeeves! (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Walter Van Tilburg Clark (other topics)Herman Melville (other topics)
Ernest Hemingway (other topics)
Wilkie Collins (other topics)
Agatha Christie (other topics)
More...
January: Thomas Hardy
February: Historical Fiction/Romance
Madame Bovary by Gustave Flaubert
Silas Marner by George Eliot
March: Jane Austen
Suggested read: Persuasion
April: Action/Adventure
Kidnapped and Catriona by Robert Louis Stevenson
Robinson Crusoe by Daniel Defoe
May: W. Somerset Maugham or Charles Dickens
Suggested read for Dickens: Oliver Twist
June: Family Saga
Buddenbrooks: The Decline of a Family by Thomas Mann
July: Daphne du Maurier
Suggested read: Frenchman's Creek
August: Mystery: Thriller/Spy:
The Daughter of Time by Josephine Tey
Our Man in Havana by Graham Greene
The Magus by John Fowles
September: Agatha Christie
October: Nautical/Sea
Moby-Dick or, the Whale by Herman Melville
The Old Man and the Sea by Ernest Hemingway
November: Wilkie Collins
Suggested read: Armadale
December: Comedy
Very Good, Jeeves! by P.G. Wodehouse
Scoop by Evelyn Waugh
FWC: Quarterly Reads
Jan-Mar The Ox-Bow Incident by Walter Van Tilburg Clark
Apr-Jun Shane by Jack Schaefer
Jul-Sep Llano River by Elmer Kelton
Oct-Dec Riders of the Purple Sage by Zane Grey